Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2021-11-01 City Council Minutes PUBLIC MEETING INFORMATION CITY OF CALDWELL Due to the COVID-19 pandemic,we invite interested parties to participate in public hearings either electronically or in person. If you have a cough, fever, or are not feeling well, please contact Planning& Zoning staff to arrange participation remotely. The City of Caldwell follows the CDC guidelines to allow for distancing in the public meeting area and provide masks/hand sanitizer on site. Virtual Participation Option:Register in advance to provide public comments electronically or by telephone. During the registration process,you will be asked what item on the agenda you wish to speak about. Please use the case number as listed within the written notice. On-line registration must be submitted at least 24 hours in advance of the meeting. Click on the green"public meetings"button on the center of the page. After registration, you will receive a confirmation email containing information about joining the virtual meeting. REGISTER HERE:https://www.cityofcaldwell.org Written comments must be received at least eight(8)days in advance of the meeting to the Planning&Zoning Department at P&Z@cityofcaldwell.org to be included within the staff report. All comments received after the staff report has been transmitted will be included in the case file and provided as late exhibits at the appropriate public hearing. Live Strewn Viewing: If you are not planning to speak,members of the public are encouraged to view the meeting via the live stream option: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCci7S1AOUJNK6asXxxugLGA REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING AGENDA Monday,November 1,2021 7:00 PM INVOCATION OFFERED BY PASTOR DAVID MOODY OF THE'CHRIST COMMUNITY CHURCH. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG. ROLL CALL. CONFLICT OF INTEREST DECLARATION. SPECIAL PRESENTATIONS. a. Proclamation: Extra Mile Day b. Proclamation: National Apprenticeship Week AUDIENCE PARTICIPATION. CONSENT CALENDAR: [ALL CONSENT CALENDAR ITEMS ARE ACTION ITEMS] 1) Approve acceptance of the minutes of the Regularly Scheduled City Council meeting held on October 18, 2021 and the minutes for the City of Caldwell Design Review Commission meeting held on September 28,2021. 2) Approve request for the appointment of Angela Lively and Robb MacDonald as City of Caldwell representatives for the COMPASS Regional Transportation Advisory Committee(RTAC); 3) Approve request for a new Alcohol Beverage License(Beer)for Paddles Up Ventures, LLC dba: Paddles Up Poke located at 712 Arthur Street; 4) Approve Resolution authorizing the execution of a Purchase & Sale Agreement and acceptance of a Warranty Deed for the Well No. 20 site; 5) Approve Resolution authorizing the execution of a Service Agreement with Republic Services for a recycling compactor in Downtown Caldwell; 6) Approve Resolution accept the quote from Idaho Power to bring three-phase power to the Milagro Sewer Lift Station and authorize payment to Idaho Power in the amount of$48,223.00; 7) Approve Resolution authorizing the purchase of eleven (11) outside security cameras in the amount of $4,000.00 from A-Gem Supply for use at the Nancolas Center/TVCC Building in Downtown Caldwell; 8) Approve Resolution ratifying the purchase of an Eltec HAWK System from Altitude Signal, LLC in the amount of$12,960.00 for use by the Caldwell Street Department; 9) Approve Resolution authorizing the purchase of a Thermo Plastic Applicator from Sherwin Williams in the amount of$20,734.00 for use by the Caldwell Street Department; 10) Approve Resolution authorizing the purchase of an animal control vehicle containment box in the amount of$40,920.00 for use by the Caldwell Police Department; 11) Approve Resolution authorizing the purchase of a Walker T 27-HP Kohler EFI Mower from Smiths Lawnmower Sales in the amount of$14,544.00 for use by the Caldwell Parks Department; 12)Approve Resolution authorizing the purchase of a 2022 Chevrolet Colorado 4WD Crew Cab from Mountain Home Auto Ranch in the amount of$26,522.00 for use by the Water Department; Page 1 of 2 OLD BUSINESS: 1) ACTION ITEM: Public Hearing (Legislative): [Continued from August 16, 2021 & September 7, 2021] for the creation of Local Improvement District No. 21-3 for asphalt paving improvements on Uvalde Street between Hird Avenue and North Montana Avenue at an estimated cost of $52,465.00 with approximately $42,465.00 being assessed to the property owners. [This request has been withdrawn by City Staff due the lack of 60%participation from the property owners within the boundaries of the proposed Local Improvement District.] 2) ACTION ITEM: Public Hearing(Legislative): [Continued from September 7, 2021 and October 4, 2021] Case Number OA-21-11 Ordinance Amendment: A request by the Planning and Zoning Department amending the Residential Land Use Schedule — Table 1, regarding the development of Multi-Family Housing in Commercial (C1, C2, C3, C4), Highway Corridor (HC), Traditional Neighborhood (TN) and College District(CD)zones. 3) ACTION ITEM: Consider Bill No. 52 Ordinance 3371 proposed amendments to Chapter 10 of the Caldwell City Code with a required to waive the rules, pass on the first reading, and approve the summary for publication. 4) ACTION ITEM: Public Hearing (Legislative): [Continued from September 7, 2021 & October 4, 2021] Case Number OA-21-09 (Public Safety Ordinance): An ordinance enacted by the City of Caldwell amending the Caldwell City Code Chapter 10, Article 1, Section 10-01-08 concerning Annexation Procedures; amending Chapter 10, Article 3, Section 10-03-04 concerning Special Use Permit Procedures; amending Chapter 10, Article 3, Section 10-01-07 concerning Planned Unit Developments; and amending Chapter 11, Article 1, Section 11-02-03 concerning Preliminary Plat Procedures. [This request has been withdrawn by City Staff. See New Business Item #4 below for consideration of Resolution No. 377-21] 5) ACTION ITEM: Public Hearing (Quasi-Judicial): Case Number ANN21-000007/SUB21-000012: [Continued from October 4, 2021] A request for an annexation of an approximate 48 acre portion of 54.11 acres with a zone designation of R-2 (Medium Density Residential). Concurrently, the applicant is requesting a preliminary plat for Sterling Ridge Subdivision, a 178 lot development, including 160 single- family residential lots and 18 common lots. The subject properties are located south and east of 20710 Ward Road and include parcel numbers R3408801000, R3408701200, R340880000, Caldwell, Idaho. The Hearing Examiner forwarded this case with a recommendation of approval as conditioned on August 24, 2021. NEW BUSINESS: 1) ACTION ITEM: Public Hearing (Quasi-Judicial): Case Number ANN21-000009: A request by Vallivue School District No. 139 to annex approximately 64 acres including parcels R32717 and R32718. The subject properties containing the Vallivue Middle School and proposed new elementary site are to be zoned "R-1" (Low Density Residential). The subject properties are located at 16412 S. 10th Ave. [10-3N- 3W-SW] in Caldwell, Idaho. The Hearing Examiner forwarded this case with a recommendation of approval on September 14,2021. 2) ACTION ITEM: Consider Bill No. 35 (Ordinance No. 3354) for Case No. ANN21-000009 (Vallivue School District 10th Ave Annexation) with a request to waive the rules, pass on the first reading, and approve the summary for publication. 3) ACTION ITEM. Deliberation and decision on Request for Reconsideration of PUD20-000001 —Escalon Park submitted by Jane Suggs of Gem State Planning,LLC. 4) ACTION ITEM: Consider Resolution No. 377-21 directing that development applications resume normally within the City of Caldwell and determining that no additional code amendments are necessary at the present time to address the harms created by House Bill 389. 5) ACTION ITEM: Consider Resolution No. 378-21 authorizing the submission of the proposed North Urban Renewal Area Plan to the Caldwell Planning and Zoning Commission for said Commission's review of the proposed plan for its conformity with the Master Plan of the City of Caldwell. 6) ACTION ITEM Consider Resolution No. 379-21 authorizing the Mayor to enter into an intergovernmental agreement with Canyon County for the administration of the revenue allocation financing provisions of the proposed North Urban Renewal Area Plan in the areas outside of the municipal boundaries of the City of Caldwell. 7) ACTION ITEM: Consider Resolution No. 380-21 approving notice for a public hearing on the proposed North Urban Renewal Area Plan,as required by Idaho Code 50-2906. 8) ACTION ITEM: Consider Resolution No. 381-21 authorizing the use of General Fund Contingency for the addition of two(2)new police officer positions at Caldwell Police Department for FY-2022. 9) ACTION ITEM: Financial Report acceptance. 10) Council Reports. 11) Mayor's Comments. 12)Adjournment. Next Regular City Council Meeting is on Monday, November 15, 2021 at 7:00 p.m. in the Community Room at the Caldwell Police Station at 110 South Fifth. Any person needing special accommodations to participate in the meeting should contact the City Clerk at 411 Blaine Street or call #455-4656 prior to the meeting. The entire agenda packet and minutes can be viewed on the City of Caldwell's website: www.citvofcaldwell.com. Cualquier persona que necesita arreglos especiales para participar en la reunion debe comunicarse con el Secretario de la Ciudad en 411 Blaine Street o flame al # 455 a 4656 antes de la reunion. Page 2 of 2 BOOK 62 PAGE 177 REGULARLY SCHEDULED MEETING CALDWELL CITY COUNCIL November 1,2021 7:00 P.M. MINUTES Council President Allgood opened the meeting at 7:00 p.m. at the Caldwell Police Department Community Room. Pastor David Moody of the Christ Community Church provided the invocation. The Council President led in the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag. The Roll of the City Council was called by the City Clerk with the following members present: Allgood, Wagoner,Hopper,Callsen,Pollard(via Zoom),and McGee(via Zoom). Council President Allgood reported that he would be abstaining from voting on all agenda items tonight with the exception of the New Business Item#3 (Request for Reconsideration of PUD20-000001). SPECIAL PRESENTATIONS a. Proclamation: Extra Mile Day Council President Allgood read the proclamation into the record: WHEREAS, Caldwell, Idaho is a community which acknowledges that a special vibrancy exists within the entire community when its individual citizens collectively "go the extra mile"in personal effort, volunteerism, and service; and WHEREAS,Caldwell, Idaho is a community which encourages its citizens to maximize their personal contribution to the community by giving themselves wholeheartedly and with total effort, commitment, and conviction to their individual ambitions,family,friends, and community; and WHEREAS, Caldwell, Idaho is a community which chooses to shine a light on and celebrates individuals and organizations within its community who "go the extras mile"in order to make a difference and lift up fellow members of their community;and WHEREAS, Caldwell, Idaho acknowledges the mission of Extra Mile America to create 500 Extra Mile cities in American and is proud to support "Extra Mile Day"and November 1, 2021. NOW THEREFORE,I, Garret L. Nancolas, Mayor of Caldwell, Idaho, do hereby proclaim November 1, 2021 to be EXTRA MILE DAY. I urge each individual in the community to take time on this day to not only "go the extra mile"in his or her own life, but to also acknowledge all of those who are inspirational in their efforts and commitment to make their organization,families, community, country, or world a better place. b. Proclamation: National Apprenticeship Week: Council President Allgood read the proclamation into the record and presented the document to the presentative from Idaho Business for Education. WHEREAS, National Apprenticeship Week is celebrating its 7th anniversary of raising awareness of the vital role Registered Apprenticeships provide in creating opportunities by allowing apprentices to earn while they learn and preparing a pathway to well paying careers in Caldwell and across the nation; and WHEREAS, Registered Apprenticeship programs enable employers to develop and train their future workforce while offering career seekers affordable paths to secure high paying jobs, and WHEREAS, Caldwell recognizes the role of Registered Apprenticeship in expanding opportunities in our workforce that are inclusive of individuals who have been historically underserved, marginalized, and adversely affected by persistent poverty and inequality, thus providing a path for all qualified individuals, including women, youth, people of color, rural communities,justice-involved individuals and individuals with disabilities, to become apprentices and contribute to America's industries; and WHEREAS, Caldwell recognizes that Registered Apprenticeship, a proven and industry-driven training model,provides a critical talent pipeline that can train and build up our workforce to address our nation's pressing issues such as responding to climate change, modernizing our cybersecurity response, addressing public health issues, and rebuilding our country's infrastructure. NOW,;, THEREFORE, I, Garret L. Nancolas, Mayor of the City of Caldwell do hereby declare November 15, 2021, through November 21, 2021, as National Apprenticeship Week. BOOK 62 PAGE 178 AUDIENCE PARTICIPATION None. AMENDMENT TO THE AGENDA Moved by Callsen, Seconded by Wagoner to continue New Business Item #8 to the next City Council Meeting to be held on November 15,2021 per request of staff. MOTION CARRIED CONFLICT OF INTEREST DECLARATION Councilman Wagoner reported that he would recuse himself from action taken this evening on New Business Item#3 regarding the Request for Reconsideration of PUD20-000001. He noted that he was not present for the initial public hearing that was held concerning this matter. CONSENT CALENDAR: [All Consent Calendar items are considered action items! 1) Approve acceptance of the minutes of the Regularly Scheduled City Council meeting held on October 18,2021 and the minutes for the City of Caldwell Design Review Commission meeting held on September 28, 2021. 2) Approve request for the appointment of Angela Lively and Robb MacDonald as City of Caldwell representatives for the COMPASS Regional Transportation Advisory Committee(RTAC); 3) Approve request for a new Alcohol Beverage License (Beer) for Paddles Up Ventures, LLC dba: Paddles Up Poke located at 712 Arthur Street; 4) Approve Resolution No. 382-21 authorizing the execution of a Purchase & Sale Agreement and acceptance of a Warranty Deed for the Well No. 20 site; 5) Approve Resolution No. 383-21 authorizing the execution of a Service Agreement with Republic Services for a recycling compactor in Downtown Caldwell; 6) Approve Resolution No. 384-21 accept the quote from Idaho Power to bring three-phase power to the Milagro Sewer Lift Station and authorize payment to Idaho Power in the amount of$48,223.00; 7) Approve Resolution No. 385-21 authorizing the purchase of eleven (11) outside security cameras in the amount of $4,000.00 from A-Gem Supply for use at the Nancolas Center/TVCC Building in Downtown Caldwell; 8) Approve Resolution No. 386-21 ratifying the purchase of an Eltec HAWK System from Altitude Signal, LLC in the amount of $12,960.00 for use by the Caldwell Street Department; 9) Approve Resolution No. 387-21 authorizing the purchase of a Thermo Plastic Applicator from Sherwin Williams in the amount of $20,734.00 for use by the Caldwell Street Department; 10) Approve Resolution No. 388-21 authorizing the purchase of an animal control vehicle containment box in the amount of$40,920.00 for use by the Caldwell Police Department; 11) Approve Resolution No. 389-21 authorizing the purchase of a Walker T 27-HP Kohler EFI Mower from Smiths Lawnmower Sales in the amount of$14,544.00 for use by the Caldwell Parks Department; 12) Approve Resolution No. 390-21 authorizing the purchase of a 2022 Chevrolet Colorado 4WD Crew Cab from Mountain Home Auto Ranch in the amount of$26,522.00 for use by the Water Department. MOVED by Pollard,SECONDED by Hopper to approve the Consent Calendar as printed. Roll call vote: Those voting yes: Pollard, McGee, Allgood, Wagoner, Hopper, and Callsen. Those voting no:none. Absent and/or not voting: none. MOTION CARRIED OLD BUSINESS (ACTION ITEM: PUBLIC HEARING (LEGISLATIVE): [CONTINUED FROM AUGUST 16, 2021 & SEPTEMBER 7, 2021] FOR THE CREATION OF LOCAL IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT NO. 21-3 FOR ASPHALT PAVING IMPROVEMENTS ON UVALDE STREET BETWEEN HIRD AVENUE AND NORTH MONTANA AVENUE AT AN ESTIMATED COST OF $52,465.00 WITH APPROXIMATELY $42,465.00 BEING ASSESSED TO THE PROPERTY OWNERS) MOVED by Hopper, Seconded by Callsen to close the hearing and dissolve the LID NO. 21-3 pursuant to the request from staff for it to be withdrawn due the lack of 60% participation from the property owners within the boundaries of the proposed Local Improvement District. MOTION CARRIED BOOK 62 PAGE 179 (ACTION ITEM: PUBLIC HEARING(LEGISLATIVE):[CONTINUED FROM SEPTEMBER 7,2021 AND OCTOBER 4,2021] CASE NUMBER OA-21-11 ORDINANCE AMENDMENT: A REQUEST BY THE PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT AMENDING THE RESIDENTIAL LAND USE SCHEDULE — TABLE 1, REGARDING THE DEVELOPMENT OF MULTI-FAMILY HOUSING IN COMMERCIAL [C1, C2, C3, C4], HIGHWAY CORRIDOR [HC], TRADITIONAL NEIGHBORHOOD [TN] AND COLLEGE DISTRICT [CD] ZONES) Council President Allgood declared the public hearing open. Jerome Mapp, Planning&Zoning Director at 621 Cleveland Boulevard,presented the staff report and outlined the contents of the proposed ordinance. He noted that the current Zoning Ordinance allows multi-family housing within the Commercial and Industrial Zones as well as the Traditional Neighborhood and Highway Corridor Zone. The proposed ordinance specifically would not allow residential within the commercial zones. This change would allow multi-family zoning within the C-D Zone with approval of a special use permit. In response to questions from Councilman Wagoner, Mr. Mapp clarified that any request that includes a Planned Unit Developments along highway corridors would be considered by the Planning&Zoning Commission and City Council within a public hearing process. Councilman Wagoner expressed his concerns with the non-allowance provision of the ordinance within the Commercial Zone. He recommended that such requests be mandated to obtain a Special Use Permit. Councilman Callsen reported that there is a shortage of commercial zoning along highway corridors and therefore recommended that the highway frontage be reserved for commercial use. Councilman Hopper noted that there should be a balance with multi-family and commercial developments. Highway corridor parcels should be a combined use with commercial on the frontage portion and possibly R-3 multi-family zoning available behind the commercial zone. Councilman Callsen recommended that in-fill parcels within Caldwell be used for R-3 developments. Councilman Wagoner noted that there is a small development on Hwy. 20/26 that has commercial to the front, which accommodates the residential housing units located behind the commercial development. He emphasized that there should be provisions within the development request mandating the commercial project to be completed before any residential units are constructed. Jane Suggs, 9839 Cable Car Street, Suite 101, Boise spoke as neutral to the request. She noted that many developers specialize either in commercial or residential projects. She recommended approval of Special Use Permit provisions within the proposed ordinance. MOVED by Callsen,SECONDED by Hopper to close the public hearing. MOTION CARRIED (ACTION ITEM: CONSIDER BILL NO. 52 [ORDINANCE NO. 3371] REGARDING PROPOSED AMENDMENTS TO CHAPTER 10 OF THE CALDWELL CITY CODE WITH A REQUIRED TO WAIVE THE RULES, PASS ON THE FIRST READING, AND APPROVE THE SUMMARY FOR PUBLICATION) The Council President read the ordinance by title only: AN ORDINANCE ENACTED BY THE CALDWELL CITY COUNCIL AMENDING CHAPTER 10, ARTICLE 2, CHAPTER 10-02-02, CONTAINING THE GENERAL LAND USE SCHEDULE FOR THE CITY OF CALDWELL; AMENDING CHAPTER 10, ARTICLE 13, SECTION 10-13-03 OF THE CALDWELL CITY CODE, CONTAINING THE LAND USE SCHEDULE FOR MIXED USE DISTRICTS WITHIN THE CITY OF CALDWELL; PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; AND REPEALING ALL ORDINANCES, RESOLUTIONS, ORDERS AND PARTS THEREOF,IN CONFLICT HEREWITH. Councilman Callsen spoke in favor of the proposed ordinance, which would secure the highway corridors for commercial development. Councilman Wagoner recommended that the ordinance be reviewed for potential changes and brought back for consideration. Councilman Hopper noted that there should be clear guidance to staff within the Zoning Ordinance regarding such developments. The Comprehensive Plan Map should be in agreement with the Zoning Ordinance. Councilman Wagoner recommended that the table indicate the allowance of special use permits and that they be considered directly by City Council. He inquired if there should be a specified amount of footage for commercial developments versus residential developments along highway corridors. BOOK 62 PAGE 180 MOVED by Hopper, SECONDED by Wagoner that consideration of Ordinance No. 3371 be continued until December 6, 2021 with provision that a City Council Workshop session be held prior to the date certain to review potential amendments to the document. MOTION CARRIED ACTION ITEM: PUBLIC HEARING (LEGISLATIVE): [CONTINUED FROM SEPTEMBER 7,2021 & OCTOBER 4, 2021] CASE NUMBER OA-21-09 (PUBLIC SAFETY ORDINANCE): AN ORDINANCE ENACTED BY THE CITY OF CALDWELL AMENDING THE CALDWELL CITY CODE CHAPTER 10, ARTICLE 1, SECTION 10-01-08 CONCERNING ANNEXATION PROCEDURES; AMENDING CHAPTER 10,ARTICLE 3,SECTION 10-03-04 CONCERNING SPECIAL USE PERMIT PROCEDURES; AMENDING CHAPTER 10, ARTICLE 3, SECTION 10-01-07 CONCERNING PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENTS; AND AMENDING CHAPTER 11, ARTICLE 1, SECTION 11-02-03 CONCERNING PRELIMINARY PLAT PROCEDURES. MOVED by Hopper, Seconded by Wagoner to withdraw the Safety Ordinance as requested by staff pursuant to consideration of Resolution No.377-21 on tonight's agenda under New Business. MOTION CARRIED (ACTION ITEM: PUBLIC HEARING [QUASI-JUDICIAL': CASE NUMBER ANN21- 000007/SUB21-000012: [CONTINUED FROM OCTOBER 4, 2021] A REQUEST FOR AN ANNEXATION OF AN APPROXIMATE 48 ACRE PORTION OF 54.11 ACRES WITH A ZONE DESIGNATION OF R-2 (MEDIUM DENSITY RESIDENTIAL). CONCURRENTLY, THE APPLICANT IS REQUESTING A PRELIMINARY PLAT FOR STERLING RIDGE SUBDIVISION, A 178 LOT DEVELOPMENT, INCLUDING 160 SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL LOTS AND 18 COMMON LOTS. THE SUBJECT PROPERTIES ARE LOCATED SOUTH AND EAST OF 20710 WARD ROAD AND INCLUDE PARCEL NUMBERS R3408801000,R3408701200,R340880000,CALDWELL, IDAHO. THE HEARING EXAMINER FORWARDED THIS CASE WITH A RECOMMENDATION OF APPROVAL AS CONDITIONED ON AUGUST 24,2021) The Council President explained the quasi-judicial process and asked the City Clerk to swear in those who would be providing testimony within the public hearing. The Council President declared the public hearing open. Debbie Root, Senior Planner at 621 Cleveland Boulevard, acknowledged being sworn in and outlined the contents of the staff report. She indicated that the Hearing Examiner recommended that the entire block of properties(approximately sixty acres)be annexed into the City Limits for the purpose of not causing enclave parcels. This would assist with the response of emergency services and jurisdictional challenges. The City Code allows for the outright annexation for enclave parcels or denial of the annexation request due to the enclave parcels. Steve Roedel, who owns the eastern two parcels, has requested not to annex his properties (seven acres)at this time. He is willing to annex the seven acres later when the properties to the north of his site actually start developing or when the remaining portion of the annexed parcels begin the residential development process. Mr.Roedel currently houses farm animals on his acreage,which may be restricted in the Caldwell City Limits. The northern parcels have already been annexed into the City of Caldwell. The subject parcels are surrounded by City Limits. She noted that it was her understanding that there are two additional parcels that the property owners have agreed to annex, if Council requires such action for the request to move forward. The applicant desires approval for only 48 acres to be annexed into the City of Caldwell. Approximately 12.5 acres would be considered as enclaved parcels. The annexation request is for an R-2 zoning classification (Medium Residential), which is in agreement with the Comprehensive Plan. The preliminary plat includes 178 total lots with 160 lots designated as residential usage. There is no major pathway connection within the development; however,there are ample sidewalks and micro-pathways included in the preliminary plat. There will be a minimum of eight percent (8%) open space and build out is in planned within four (4) phases. Roadway frontage is mandated along Middleton Road,Joplin Lane and Ware Road. Joplin Road build out would be completed within Phase I. The plan complies with City Code. In response to questions from Councilman Hopper, Ms. Root clarified that the original application addresses the annexation of only 48 acres. The Hearing Examiner's recommendation may be removed from the conditions of approval regarding the additional twelve (12) acres for a total of sixty (60) acres. Robb MacDonald, City Engineer at 621 Cleveland Boulevard confirmed that the development agreement only addresses the 48-acre application request. In response to questions from Councilman Hopper, Mr. MacDonald noted that the staff report does not include right-of-way improvements for the out parcels. BOOK 62 PAGE 181 Discussion followed regarding the potential of obtaining permission from the additional parcel owners to make such right-of-way improvements for the out parcels. Ms.Root reported that there are multiple parcels with separate owners beyond the Roedel family members. In response to questions from Councilman Callsen, Ms. Root reported that parcels annexed currently being used for agricultural purpose may continue such usages until they cease or change. Bonnie Layton,690 South Industrial Way, Suite 10,Meridian acknowledged being sworn in and spoke in favor of the request. She provided a PowerPoint outlining details of the development, noting that the lot line adjustments associated with the development were approved by Canyon County. She reported that the Idaho Statute provides the governing body to annex enclave parcels but expressed concern with any requirement for the developer to acquire approval from the additional parcel owners. The out parcels would continue to be served by Canyon County. She continued that Joplin Road would improve east/west traffic activity and the Middleton Road connection would address traffic by use of a new roundabout planned for the area. The average lot size will be 6,900 square feet, with fourteen (14) common lots, 3.62 dwelling units per acre, and 8.2 percentage of qualified open space. The plan is in compliance with requirements provided by the Canyon County Hwy.District No.4. Council President Allgood labeled the PowerPoint from Ms. Layton as CC-1000. Discussion followed concerning the construction of Ware Road. The City Engineer provided information regarding the plan from Canyon Highway District pertaining to Marble Front Road/Joplin Road/Ware Road. He noted that the Marble Front Road access to Middle Road has been closed by the Canyon County Highway District making Marble Front a dead-end street. Councilman Wagoner inquired of Ms. Layton if the developer would be amenable to right-of-way dedication and improvements on referenced parcels located on the corner of Ware Road/Middleton Road/Marble Front. There would not be a requirement for annexation of subject parcels, only for right-of-way improvements to be made. Ms. Layton expressed her concern with such a requirement since the developer does not have ownership of said parcels. She reported that Mr. Roedel is in possession of a License Agreement with Canyon County Highway District No. 4. The property to the north has been annexed but no development has occurred. The road has been grated and recommended that it function like a private drive to those parcels. Mr. MacDonald concurred that Marble Front has been closed off at Middleton Road. There is no requirement to pave the north portion of Marble Front Road since it will serve as a private drive to the residences. Steve Roedel, 11077 Marble Front Road, acknowledged being sworn in and spoke in favor of the request. He reported that in previous conversations with the Public Works Director Brent Orton, he was informed that he would not be forced to annex if his total acreage amounted to over five(5)acres in size. He acquired additional acreage for this purpose before the annexation and preliminary plat application was filed with the Planning& Zoning Department. He provided a copy of the letter from Canyon Highway District No.4 regarding the Marble Front Road—Cul-De-Sac License Agreement. Council President Allgood labeled the document as CC-1002. In response to questions from Councilman Wagoner, Mr. Roedel reported that he would be agreeable to annex his property at the time the parcel to the north begins development. He noted that would assist with connecting to city services. He would only be willing to dedicate additional right-of-way for future development if the connection fees were waived for city services for his residence. In response to question from Council President Allgood, Mr. Roedel confirmed that the other property owners are aware of the development request. Discussion followed concerning right-of-way improvements and traffic mitigation issues. In rebuttal, Bonnie Layton addressed concerns regarding prescriptive easement issues, annexation of additional parcels, and frontage improvements. She noted that the owner of the parcel located to the north of the site is currently dealing with severe illness of a family member. She requested that Brian Sinderhoff of Sterling Land Development be able to provide expert testimony regarding tonight's discussion dealing with parcel ownership. Brian Sinderhoff of Sterling Land Development and a member of the development team addressed questions regarding parcel ownership. He noted that contact by the development team had been made with the other parcel owners and their lack of interest to be involved with the annexation. Councilman Hopper expressed his concern with future frontage improvements associated with prescriptive easements. BOOK 62 PAGE 182 Mr. MacDonald referenced the current maintenance being conducted by Canyon County Highway District No.4 on the subject roadways. Long-term future maintenance plans by the Highway District is unknown at this time. In response to questions from Councilman Pollard, Council President Allgood confirmed that the current allowance of farm animals on the parcel owned by Mr. Roedel would be grandfathered as long as the existing use continues. MOVED by Hopper,SECONDED by Wagoner.to close the public testimony portion of the hearing. MOTION CARRIED EVIDENCE LIST FOR CASE NO.ANN21-000007/SUB21-000012: The Council President presented the Evidence List: staff report, sign-up sheets, CC-1000 (PowerPoint from Debbie Root), CC-1001 (PowerPoint from Bonnie Layton), and CC-1002 (License Agreement between Canyon Highway District No.4 and Steve Roedel). MOVED by Callsen, SECONDED by Hopper to accept the Evidence List as presented. MOTION CARRIED COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ANALYSIS FOR CASE NO.ANN2I-000007: MOVED by Callsen, SECONDED by Hopper to accept the Comprehensive Plan Analysis as presented in the staff report under roman number V. MOTION CARRIED FINDINGS OF FACT ON CASE NO.ANN21-000007: MOVED by Callsen,SECONDED by Hopper to accept the general facts as outlined in the staff report, the public testimony that was given in this matter,and the evidence list that was presented. MOTION CARRIED CONCLUSIONS OF LAW ON CASE NO.ANN21-000007: MOVED by Hopper, SECONDED by Callsen that the Caldwell City Council has the authority to hear this case and to make the decision to approve or deny; and the public hearing was noticed and heard within the guidelines of applicable state codes and local ordinances. MOTION CARRIED ORDER OF DECISION ON CASE NO.ANN-21-000007: MOVED by Wagoner,SECONDED by Pollard based on the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, the Mayor and City Council hereby order that Case Number ANN21-000007 a request by Sterling Land bevelopment to annex portions of parcels R3408801000, R3408701200, R340880000, 48 acres, more or less, with an R-2 (Medium Density Residential) zone designation for the properties located south and east of Marble Front and Ware Roads in Caldwell, Idaho, approved with the inclusion of the Conditions of Approval as identified within the staff report as Items 9.2 , 9.3, and 9.5 thereby providing the right-of-way for improvements along Middleton Road and thereby instructing the developer to work with Mr. Roedel regarding the completion of frontage improvements associated with his property. Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Wagoner, Pollard, and McGee. Those voting no: Callsen and Hopper. Absent and/or not voting:Allgood. MOTION CARRIED COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ANALYSIS FOR CASE NO. SUB21-000012 : MOVED by Wagoner, SECONDED by Pollard to accept the Comprehensive Plan Analysis as presented in the staff report under roman number X. MOTION CARRIED FINDINGS OF FACT ON CASE NO.SUB21-000012: MOVED by Wagoner, SECONDED by Callsen to accept the general facts as outlined in the staff report,the public testimony that was given in this matter,and the evidence list that was presented. MOTION CARRIED CONCLUSIONS OF LAW ON CASE NO. SUB21-000012: MOVED by Callsen, SECONDED by Hopper that the Caldwell City Council has the authority to hear this case and to make the decision to approve or deny; and the public hearing was noticed and heard within the guidelines of applicable state codes and local ordinances. MOTION CARRIED BOOK 62 PAGE 183 ORDER.OF DECISION ON CASE NO.SUB21-000012: MOVED by Wagoner, SECONDED by Pollard based on the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, the Mayor and City Council hereby order that Case Number SUB21-000012, a request by Sterling Land Development for Preliminary Plat approval of STERLING RIDGE SUBDIVISION, consisting of 47.82 acres, more or less, to be subdivided into 173 residential lots for the portions of properties, R3408801000, R3408701200, R340880000, located south and east of Marble Front and Ware Road in Caldwell, Idaho, is approved with two additional Conditions of Approval be included: 1) Frontage improvements at Middleton Road be continued along the entire east property line owned by Mr. Roedel to the intersection of Marble Front Road, 2)The Developer to work with the property owner at the NW corner of Ward Road and Marble Front Road to procure the proper right-of-way and provide those improvements. Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Wagoner, Hopper, Pollard, and McGee. Those voting no: Callsen. Absent and/or not voting:Allgood. MOTION CARRIED MOVED by Hopper, SECONDED by Wagoner to close the public hearing. MOTION CARRIED Council President Allgood called for a five-minute recess at 9:45 p.m. The meeting reconvened at 9:50 p.m. NEW BUSINESS (ACTION ITEM: PUBLIC HEARING (QUASI-JUDICIAL): CASE NUMBER ANN21-000009: A REQUEST BY VALLIVUE SCHOOL DISTRICT NO. 139 TO ANNEX APPROXIMATELY 64 ACRES INCLUDING PARCELS R32717 AND R32718. THE SUBJECT PROPERTIES CONTAINING THE VALLIVUE MIDDLE SCHOOL AND PROPOSED NEW ELEMENTARY SITE ARE TO BE ZONED "R-1" (LOW DENSITY RESIDENTIAL). THE SUBJECT PROPERTIES ARE LOCATED AT 16412 S. 1OT" AVE. [10-3N-3W-SW] IN CALDWELL, IDAHO. THE HEARING EXAMINER FORWARDED THIS CASE WITH A RECOMMENDATION OF APPROVAL ON SEPTEMBER 14,2021) The City Clerk sworn in those who would be providing public testimony. The City Council President declared the public hearing open. Debbie Root, Senior Planner at 621 Cleveland Boulevard acknowledged being sworn in and outlined the contents of the staff report. She noted that staff recommends approval of the annexation request. Councilman Wagoner asked for verification within the City Code that a public school is an allowed use on a collector roadway. Matthew Adams of The Land Group at 462 E. Shore Drive,Nampa,acknowledged being sworn in and spoke in support of the request. He reported that the applicant concurs with the Conditions of Approval as stipulated within the staff report. In response to questions from Councilman Callsen, Mr. Adams indicated that no date has been set for construction of the new elementary school at the site. A school bond will be required to move forward with the development. In response to questions from Councilman Hopper, Mr. Adams indicated that access would be provided to the facility from David Street/Montana Avenue. Necessary approval has already been obtained from the property owner for access (Seventh Day Adventist organization). City water and sewer services have previously been provided to the Vallivue Middle School site. Douglas Waterman,City Attorney at 1303 North 12th Road,Nampa, indicated that Section 10-02-14 of the Caldwell City Code provides for the allowance of a public school facility on a collector roadway without the need of obtaining a special use permit. MOVED by Hopper,SECONDED by Callsen to close the public testimony portion of the hearing. EVIDENCE LIST FOR CASE NO.ANN21-000009: MOTION CARRIED The Council President presented the Evidence List: staff report and sign-up sheets. MOVED by Hopper, SECONDED by Callsen to accept the Evidence List as presented. MOTION CARRIED BOOK 62 PAGE 184 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ANALYSIS FOR CASE NO.ANN21-000009: MOVED by Callsen, SECONDED by Hopper to accept the Comprehensive Plan Analysis as presented in the staff report under roman number V. MOTION CARRIED FINDINGS OF FACT ON CASE NO.ANN21-000009: MOVED by Callsen, SECONDED by Hopper to accept the general facts as outlined in the staff report, the public testimony that was given in this matter,and the evidence list that was presented MOTION CARRIED CONCLUSIONS OF LAW ON CASE NO.ANN21-000009: MOVED by Hopper, SECONDED by Callsen that the Caldwell City Council has the authority to hear this case and to make the decision to approve or deny; and the public hearing was noticed and heard within the guidelines of applicable state codes and local ordinances. MOTION CARRIED ORDER OF DECISION ON CASE NO.ANN21-000009: MOVED by Hopper, SECONDED by Callsen based on the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, the Mayor and City Council hereby order that Case Number ANN21-000009 a request by Vallivue School District No. 139 to annex parcels R32717 and R32718,64 acres more or less,with an R-1 (Low Density Residential) zone designation for the property located at 16412 S. 10th Ave and the adjacent parcel to the east in Caldwell, Idaho, be approved with the Conditions of Approval as outlined in Section 10 of the staff report. Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Hopper, Callsen, Pollard, McGee, and Wagoner. Those voting no: none. Absent and/or not voting:Allgood. MOTION CARRIED MOVED by Wagoner,SECONDED by Hopper to close the public hearing. MOTION CARRIED (ACTION ITEM: CONSIDER BILL NO. 35 {ORDINANCE NO. 3354] FOR CASE NO. ANN21-000009 (VALLIVUE SCHOOL DISTRICT 1OTE' AVE ANNEXATION) WITH A REQUEST TO WAIVE THE RULES, PASS ON THE FIRST READING, AND APPROVE THE SUMMARY FOR PUBLICATION) The Council President read the ordinance by title only: AN ORDINANCE DETERMINING THAT CERTAIN LAND LAYS CONTIGUOUS TO THE CITY LIMITS OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL, COUNTY OF CANYON, STATE OF IDAHO, AND THAT SAID LANDS SHOULD BE ANNEXED TO THE CITY OF CALDWELL, IDAHO, AS PART OF THE R-1 (LOW DENSITY RESIDENTIAL) ZONE; DECLARING SAID LANDS BY PROPER LEGAL DESCRIPTION AS DESCRIBED BELOW TO BE A PART OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL, CANYON COUNTY, IDAHO; DIRECTING THE CITY ENGINEER AND PLANNING AND ZONING DIRECTOR TO ADD SAID PROPERTY TO THE OFFICIAL MAPS OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL, IDAHO; REPEALING ALL ORDINANCES, RESOLUTIONS, ORDERS OR PARTS THEREOF IN CONFLICT HEREWITH;AND DIRECTING THE CLERK OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL TO FILE A CERTIFIED COPY OF THE ORDINANCE AND MAP OF THE AREA TO BE ANNEXED WITH CANYON COUNTY, STATE OF IDAHO AND THE IDAHO STATE TAX COMMISSION,PURSUANT TO IDAHO CODE,SECTION 63-215. MOVED by Hopper, SECONDED by Callsen to waive the three reading process and consider Bill No. 35(Ordinance No.3354)on its first reading by title only. Roll call vote: Those -voting yes: Hopper, Callsen, Pollard, McGee, and Wagoner. Those voting no: none. Absent and/or not voting:Allgood. MOTION CARRIED MOVED by Hopper, SECONDED by Callsen to sponsor Bill No. 35 (Ordinance No. 3354),move for its passage by title only,and approve the summary for publication. Roll call vote: Those voting yes: Hopper, Callsen, Pollard, McGee, and Wagoner. Those voting no: none. Absent and/or not voting:Allgood. MOTION CARRIED (ACTION ITEM: DELIBERATION AND DECISION ON REQUEST FOR RECONSIDERATION OF PUD20-000001 — ESCALON PARK SUBMITTED BY JANE SUGGS OF GEM STATE PLANNING,LLC) BOOK 62 PAGE 185 Councilman Wagoner excused himself from the council chambers. Douglas Waterman, City Attorney at 1303 12th Avenue Road, Nampa, provided the staff report. He reported that the applicant submitted a letter to the City Clerk indicating that the project complies with at least two of the City's Five PUD Instances and therefore requesting reconsideration of PUD20- 000001. Mr.Waterman referenced the content of the written request: The Project satisfies PUD Instance No. 1 because it offers a mix of housing and building types. The Project satisfies PUD Instance No. 3 because it is designed around existing topographic and geologic features. The Project satisfies PUD Instance No.4 because the property is constrained by irrigation features, waterways,and easement. Mr. Waterman responded to questions from Council President Allgood by clarifying the term "deficiency in the decision" as defined in the Idaho State Statute referring to the Request for Reconsideration procedure. He noted that the deficiency could be the result of applicant error or the applicant's lack of knowledge about a fact that they subsequently discovered. He clarified that a denial,based on the lack of information,is not deemed as a deficient decision. Councilman Hopper noted that the reason for the denial related to the fact that the PUD amenities were insufficient. No new information has been provided within the letter as submitted by the applicant. Mr. Waterman explained that Council must determine if the letter provides new information or an argument that would justify reopening the hearing on the Escalon Park PUD thereby identifying deficiencies in the initial decision made by the City Council Members. MOVED by Callsen SECONDED by Hopper that the Request for Reconsideration for the Escalon Park PUD decision be denied, and that the original decision on the request remain unaltered, in full force and effect. Roll call vote: Those voting yes: Callsen, Pollard, McGee, Allgood, and Hopper. Those voting no: none. Absent and/or not voting: Wagoner. MOTION CARRIED Councilman Wagoner re-joined the City Council meeting. (ACTION ITEM: CONSIDER RESOLUTION NO. 377-21 DIRECTING THAT DEVELOPMENT APPLICATIONS RESUME NORMALLY WITHIN THE CITY OF CALDWELL AND DETERMINING THAT NO ADDITIONAL CODE AMENDMENTS ARE NECESSARY AT THE PRESENT TIME TO ADDRESS THE HARMS CREATED BY HOUSE BILL 389) Douglas Waterman, City Attorney at 1303 12th Avenue Road, Nampa, provided an overview of Resolution 377-21. He noted that House Bill 389 was adopted by the Idaho Legislature in 2021,which has hampered the City's ability to require that new growth to pay for itself by removing the City's ability to include the total value of new residential construction and annexations in budget calculations. He noted that Caldwell continues to grow and a large portion of the growth is residential housing. Residential housing generates a much larger draw from life-safety personnel and resources than industrial and commercial development. The City adopted Resolution No. 154-21 and passed Bill No. 28, Ordinance No. 3348, placing a moratorium on certain applications for land use issues (preliminary plats/planned unit developments/special use permits/residential annexation). The moratorium was extended in August of 2021 and then expired in September of 2021. During this period, City staff reviewed this issue and determined that the total value of real property in the City of Caldwell has reached a point where it is unlikely that the City will be harmed by the eight percent(8%)cap as included in House Bill 389 in the future. Staff has determined that the appropriate action is to not amend City Code and allow development application processing to resume in full at this time. Discussion followed concerning the effects of HB 389 on smaller municipalities and potential amendments to the Statute by the Idaho Legislature. The Council President read the Resolution by title only: A RESOLUTION BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL, IDAHO, DIRECTING THAT DEVELOPMENT APPLICATIONS RESUME NORMALLY WITHIN THE CITY OF CALDWELL AND DETERMINING THAT NO ADDITIONAL CODE AMENDMENTS ARE NECESSARY AT THE PRESENT TIME TO ADDRESS THE HARMS CREATED BY HOUSE BILL 389. MOVED by Hopper,SECONDED by Callsen to adopt Resolution No. 377-21 as presented. Roll call vote: Those voting yes: Hopper, Callsen, Pollard, McGee, and Wagoner. Those voting no: none. Absent and/or not voting: Allgood. MOTION CARRIED BOOK 62 PAGE 186 (ACTION ITEM: CONSIDER RESOLUTION NO. 378-21 AUTHORIZING THE SUBMISSION OF THE PROPOSED NORTH URBAN RENEWAL AREA PLAN TO THE CALDWELL PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION FOR SAID COMMISSION'S REVIEW OF THE PROPOSED PLAN FOR ITS CONFORMITY WITH THE MASTER PLAN OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL) Douglas Waterman, City Attorney at 1303 12th Avenue Road, Nampa, provided an overview of Resolution 377-21. He explained that the documents to be considered by Council Members this evening pertain to the acceptance of The Urban Renewal Agency Plan, the execution of the Intergovernmental Agreement and setting of a public hearing date for final consideration of the URA Plan. ElJay Waite, Consultant for the URA Plan, outlined the contents of the URA Feasibility Study. He noted that the Canyon County property within the proposed URA Reallocation District does not come into focus with the Plan until 2033. Councilman Callsen expressed appreciation to Mr.Waite for his work to compile the feasibility study. Council President Allgood what is future development plan for the gravel pits in the area? Mr. Waite reported that the owner of the gravel pit area,the Rambo family, is mining the area with the intent of making it usable to industry. The Plan addresses potential future use of the gravel pit area. In response to questions from Councilman McGee, Mr. Waite City reported that The Plan will be presented to the Canyon County Commissioners with explanation of the value of the tax base and growth related to industry and economic development. In response to questions from Councilman McGee, Council President Allgood reported that The Plan would be presented to the Planning&Zoning Commission for review at their upcoming meeting. In response to questions from Councilman Pollard, Councilman Hopper explained the State Statute concerning the procedure to establish a new urban renewal agency re-allocation district versus establishing an initial new urban renewal agency. An initial urban renewal agency can only be created by public ballot. An urban renewal agency may have more than one district at any given time. MOVED by Callsen,SECONDED by Hopper to approve Resolution NO.378-21 as presented. Roll call vote: Those voting yes: Callsen, McGee, Wagoner, and Hopper. Those voting no: none. Absent and/or not voting:Pollard(abstained)and Allgood. MOTION CARRIED (ACTION ITEM: CONSIDER RESOLUTION NO. 379-21 AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO ENTER INTO AN INTERGOVERNMENTAL AGREEMENT WITH CANYON COUNTY FOR THE ADMINISTRATION OF THE- REVENUE ALLOCATION FINANCING PROVISIONS OF THE PROPOSED NORTH URBAN RENEWAL AREA PLAN IN THE AREAS OUTSIDE -OF THE MUNICIPAL BOUNDARIES OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL) MOVED by Callsen,SECONDED by Hopper to approve Resolution No.379-21 as presented. Roll call vote: Those voting yes: Callsen, McGee, Wagoner, and Hopper. Those voting no: none. Absent and/or not voting:Pollard(abstained)and Allgood. MOTION CARRIED (ACTION ITEM: CONSIDER RESOLUTION NO. 380-21 APPROVING NOTICE FOR A PUBLIC HEARING ON THE PROPOSED NORTH URBAN RENEWAL AREA PLAN,AS REQUIRED BY IDAHO CODE 50-2906) MOVED by Callsen, SECONDED by Wagoner to approve Resolution No.380-21. Roll call vote: Those voting yes: Callsen, McGee, Wagoner, and Hopper. Those voting no: none. Absent and/or not voting: Pollard(abstained)and Allgood. MOTION CARRIED (ACTION ITEM: CONSIDER RESOLUTION NO.381-21 AUTHORIZING THE USE OF GENERAL FUND CONTINGENCY FOR THE ADDITION OF TWO (2) NEW POLICE OFFICER POSITIONS AT CALDWELL POLICE DEPARTMENT FOR FY-2022) This item was continued to November 15,2021 by previous motion. BOOK 62 PAGE 187 (FINANCE AND HUMAN RESOURCE REPORTS) Councilman Allgood reported that the Finance Committee has reviewed current accounts payable in the amount of$4,237,073.53 for the period ending October 27,2021, a net payroll of$413,376.03 for the pay period ending October 9,2021. MOVED by Allgood, SECONDED by Hopper that accounts payable in the amount of$4,237,073.53 by check numbers 157163, 157313, through 15725 and payroll in the amount of $413,376.03 represented by check numbers 36624 through 36639 and direct deposits be accepted, payments approved and vouchers filed in the office of the City Clerk. MOTION CARRIED (COUNCIL COMMENTS) Councilman Callsen encouraged everyone to vote in the General Election on Tuesday,November 2,2021. (MAYOR'S COMMENTS) None. (ADJOURNMENT) MOVED by Hopper,SECONDED by Callsen to adjourn at 11:16 p.m. MOTION CARRIED APPROVED AS written THIS I5t DAY OF November ,2021. —;1—ef — . M Coun/p• son j un C• cilper : �� Councilperson c i�ilperson Councilpers C ATTEST: 0u111118884 ��.•• OF CA w%,i 000000 • City Clerk G. �(04./%1:•••,i = n ' JANIs �: : s