Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2021-08-24 Hearing Examiner Minutes Regular Caldwell Hearing Examiner Minutes APPROVED Tuesday,August 24,2021,7:00 p.m. � 1)U,nel\. Community Room,Caldwell Police Department 110 South 5th Avenue,Caldwell,Idaho Date 1 V ( ' 12..1 Call to Order- Hearing Examiner, Mr. Bruce Eggleston opened the meeting for the public hearing at 7:00 p.m. II. Review of Proceedings- Mr. Bruce Eggleston outlined the procedures for the public hearing. Members Present: Robb MacDonald (City Engineer); Deb Root (Senior Planner); Cynthia Brogdon (Administrative Assistant) Members Absent:Jerome Mapp (Director P&Z); Katie Phillips (Associate Planner) III. Consent Calendar: 1) Mr. Eggleston approved the Minutes of the July 27, 2021 meeting. IV Old Business: 1) Case Number ANN21-000007/SUB21-0000112 (Continued from the July 27, 2021 Hearing Examiner Meeting): A request for an annexation of 54.11 acres with a zone designation of R-2 (Medium Density Residential). The Comprehensive Plan designation is Medium Density Residential.Concurrently,the applicant is requesting a preliminary plat for Sterling Ridge Subdivision,a 178 lot development,including 160 single-family residential lots and 18 common lots. There are currently two homes included in the annexation that are proposed to not be platted as a part of the subdivision development. The subject properties are located south and east of 20710 Ward Road and include parcel numbers R3408801000, R3408701200, R340880000, Caldwell, Idaho. Testimony: Ms. Root(Senior Planner) at 621 Cleveland Blvd, Caldwell, ID stated that the applicant wants to annex 3 properties totaling 47.82 acres.She has provided to the Hearing Examiner Exhibit A-18 a late exhibit from the Sterling Ridge developer.The county had recently approved a property boundary adjustment to remove the existing houses from the subject properties and separating them from the properties requesting to be annexed.The deeds still show those homes as part of the properties requesting to annex.The City believes that these homes should also be annexed into the city so as to not create enclave areas of property leaving services and jurisdictional challenges for the future. Enclave properties are not desired by the city.The property owners of those homes do not want to be annexed. This project is in compliance with code. It is zoned R-2.They have 8%open space.There are some concerns regarding Weymouth Lateral being pushed to the south side of Joplin Rd. and onto the Mandalay Ranch development. She is unsure if there is an agreement with that property owner. Bruce Eggleston, (Hearing Examiner) stated that he receive a late exhibit A-14 by email. He entered it into evidence. 1 Hearing Examiner Minutes 08/24/2021 Ms. Root stated that it would be A-14.1 a revised landscape plan. Mr. Eggleston asked if this late exhibit alters the proposal. Ms. Root responded that the Staff Report did not reflect these changes.This exhibit is to make things accurate. Mr. Eggleston ask if staff is satisfied that the subdivision complies with code. Ms. Root responded that it does with the exception of the lateral if Mandalay Ranch is not amiable to the lateral's move. If this happens,then they would need to make changes to the plat. Mr. Eggleston asked if the applicants have provided a reason that the property owners of the out-parcels asked to not be annexed and rezoned. Ms. Root responded that the applicants have not provided that information. Mr. Eggleston asked if there was a Development Agreement for this project. Ms. Root responded that there is a Development Agreement that goes along with the annexation and preliminary plat. Mr. Eggleston asked if there is a draft for the Development Agreement or is that something that the City Council will develop. Ms. Root responded that the conditions that are indicated within the staff report at the annexation decision and the Preliminary plat conditions of approval travel forward to the development agreement along with the engineering memorandum to the Council. Mr. Eggleston stated that Exhibit A-18 from the applicant Bonnie Layton. He asked if this exhibit changes the application or is it just for clarification. Ms. Root responded that it was for clarification in response to the staff report that they had received. Mr. Eggleston stated the county has recorded land divisions to make out parcels separate lots outside the site plan. Ms. Root stated that exhibit A-18 was the county doing property boundary adjustments. Two of the large agricultural parcel boundaries were shrunk to surround the residential parcels.The third boundary combined to make one large piece that they have proposed for annexation. Mr. Eggleston asked if those boundary adjustments affect the project. He asked if the changes affected the advertised legal notice. Ms. Root responded that it does not. Mr. Eggleston asked if the boundary adjustments would constitute a great enough change to require a new hearing or new notice of the affect parcels. 2 Hearing Examiner Minutes 08/24/2021 Ms. Root responded that she did not believe so. Staff would like those out parcels to be annexed along with the proposed properties to be annexed. However,that would be a City Council decision. City Council could annex without the property owner permission. Mr. Eggleston asked if staff had any other concerns. Ms. Root responded that there were no other concerns. Bonnie Layton (Applicant) at 690 S. Industry Way, Meridan, ID 83642 Clarified for the record a few discrepancies. She stated that her request is for 47.82 acres in R-2 zoning for 173 single-family residential lots. This application does not include two adjacent lots. She referred the Hearing Examiner to exhibit A-11 where she did address those properties as not being part of her application. It was in a letter dated July 14 that was sent to Ms. Root. She stated that her client does not own those properties and are not included in this project. She says that she sent the letter to staff this afternoon,which is exhibit A-18. Item 2.4 of that letter should clear up any misunderstanding about the properties involved in this project. She stated that they do have an approved PBA.There is also a recorded record of survey which was included with the letter. This project is on the northwest corner of Middleton Rd.and Joplin Rd.There is a future roundabout scheduled for Middleton Rd.and Joplin Rd.Joplin Rd.has not been built out as yet. Our project is on the NW corner of Middleton and Joplin Road. Future round about is scheduled for that intersection. Joplin Rd.has not been built out at this location. When it is built it will provide good east/west access and traffic flow. Designated ROW dedications will provide for traffic flow and safety. Water and sewer are being built there. There are going to be 14 common lots, 3.62 dwelling units per acre,with 8.2% qualified open space.There will be frontage improvements. Landscape buffers were designed per city code. She stated that they moved the entrance as per staff concerns. They worked with the engineer of the Mandalay project to put the entrance location in the proper space.She said that since Ware road is not going away that they have accommodated for that change.There is 3.92 acres of open space and it is dispersed throughout the project.They have modified the plan as per Staffs request. She said that they moved the linear pathways per Staff request.The ROW dedications and drainage storm ponds. She said that the have a phasing plan.Joplin Rd, frontage improvements are part of the first phase. This includes the piping of the Weymouth Lateral.They met with Pioneer Irrigation District. They are coordinating this work with Mandalay Ranch to have the Weymouth lateral run in a straight line. She stated that there would be 4 phases.48 lots in first phase and 42 lots in each remaining phase.There will be single and two story homes with some three car garages,some with RV bays. Mr. Eggleston asked what is the purpose for not annexing the out parcels. Ms. Layton responded that the owners wanted to remain county residence. They have no need of city services. Mr. Eggleston asked if they are still the owners of the project properties. Ms. Layton responded that she was not sure if they have signed the final paper work. 3 Hearing Examiner Minutes 08/24/2021 Brian Sinderhoff, (In Favor) at 611 S. 8th Street,Caldwell, ID 83702 has chosen not to speak. John Ogden (Neutral) at 12301 Arrow Point, Bainbridge Island,WA 98110 has chosen not to speak. Mr. Eggleston asked if Marble Front Rd. is dead-ended. Robb McDonald, (City Engineer) at 621 Cleveland Blvd stated that section of Marble Front Rd.is under Canyon Highway District#4. Until recently,it has connected with Middleton Rd.The Highway District wanted to remove that connection due to safety issues. It is a 1/4- mile road instead of a 1/2-mile or a mile road. It does not fit in the master plan. Mr. Eggleston asked if there are plans to complete that road on the northern most part. Mr. McDonald responded that the intent is for that road to remain as it still services properties.The other 3 streets will need to be improved.So curb,gutter and sidewalk frontage improvements will have to be done on Ware,Joplin and Middleton roads,but not Marble Front. Mr. Eggleston stated that State Statute Title 50-222 discusses the different type of annexations. He asked if this is rezoned as proposed could the out parcels be annexed without consent of the owners. Ms. Root stated that as she reads state Statute Title 50-222 (3)(a)(ii) and (4)(b)(i) that yes the city could on their own annex those enclave parcels.As those parcels would be surrounded by the city which does meet those conditions. Mr. Eggleston stated that there is a provision for services and regulating policies on those lands. State Statute 50-222 Item one, "The legislature hereby declares and determines that it is the policy of the state of Idaho that cities of the state should be able to annex lands which are reasonably necessary to assure the orderly development of Idaho's cities in order to allow efficient and economically viable provision of tax-supported and fee-supported municipal services,to enable the orderly development of private lands which benefit from the cost- effective availability of municipal services in urbanizing areas and to equitably allocate the costs of public services in management of development on the urban fringe." In reading this I would say that it speaks directly to this application for annexation and rezone, and the creation of enclaves through a legislative action. Ms. Root, would that be your impression that the city needs to look at that intent of the code the legislative intent in this case, and try to make that annexation for all the property. Ms. Root: From a planner's standpoint in reading that code, I would say yes. I don't know where City Council lies within this required annexation vs.not. From planning standpoint, from a future view of this city and its municipal services,and the overlap of police and fire city and county services, for a property that is not annexed,it is in the interest of the city to not have enclave parcels. Mr. Eggleston:The concern having not been in this position for a great length of time, is it policy or is it customary is the approach to annexation is to either a) create enclaves, or,b) avoid enclaves? 4 Hearing Examiner Minutes 08/24/2021 Ms. Root: Correct. I can't speak to what the policy was prior to my tenure here, I have been here approximately two years.They did have another application where that property was required to annex, even though it was not going to be a part of the plat.They were required to annex,which they did.A member of Council acknowledged that they were glad to see Staff including that piece of property as part of the annexation. I can't speak to what the overall policies of the City are,with regards to annexation. I have not had applications come forward with a lot of out-parcels that weren't going to be annexed. Mr. Eggleston:The effective part of the Idaho State Code, 50-522 item 2,states that"In any annexation proceeding, all portions of highways lying wholly or partially within an area to be annexed shall be included within the area annexed unless expressly agreed between the annexing city and the governing board of the highway agency providing road maintenance at the time of annexation." Now we have this Marble Front,again we would be annexing just a small portion of that. That seems to be creating a problem with the services provisions to that little strip of road that would be different with the other properties along that northern boundary of this overall portion that we are looking at.A question for Robb,would annexing just that small chunk of Marble Front present any challenges in providing services for that? Mr. McDonald responded that he does not see any problems. The City/County relationship and communication is good and there is no confusion with the County. Mr. Eggleston asked if it is currently a gravel road. Mr. McDonald responded that it is a gravel road. Ms. Layton responded that her project does not own the out parcels and they are not part of this project.She stated that they are trying to bring a large portion of this property into the city. There will be improvements to the roads.All positives. The out parcels are not controlled by our development.There are a lot more positives that this project brings to the City of Caldwell beyond the out parcels. Mr. Eggleston asked if the original owners were part of the original application. Ms. Layton: One of the owners was never a part of our application. She stated that they have worked with the property boundary adjustments for this project. They have also cleaned up some legacy issues with the properties.The property boundaries now reflect more accurately,how they are being used. Mr. Eggleston: Ms. Layton,to you knowledge,have any of those out-parcel land owners expressed any intent to develop or to join in to this development at any point? Ms. Layton responded not to her knowledge. Mr. Eggleston closed the public testimony Mr. Eggleston entered into the record late exhibits A14.1 and A18. Mr. Eggleston: In State Code with an annexation there is an accompanying that a rezone is typically is driven by the Comprehensive Plan land use designation. This case is request is 5 Hearing Examiner Minutes 08/24/2021 for an R-2 rezone and with that rezone,the city will typically seek and ask for a development agreement,that is a child of the rezone action.According to state code,it is allowable to address specific circumstances that do not occur in other parts,which would have that same zoning. He states that they need to address if this rezoning complies with the Comprehensive Plan. He states that the staff report does show some reservations about the configuration of the rezone and annexation. He stated that he is speaking lands that are not part of the application.When you look at the Comprehensive Plan designation,that essentially squares off the block that we are looking at.The similar kind of consideration would go with zoning, in some cases. He asks if this meets and fulfills the requirements of the Comprehensive Plan. Page 13 of 70 the Staff Report speaks of goals and policies of land use. In his analysis of the Goal 4,about creating communities that generate cost effective public services and infrastructure, I do not think we are quite there with this proposal. The concern I have is not annexing the larger piece of land,defined in whole as Marble Front on the north, Middleton Road on the east,Joplin Road on the south and Ward Lane on the West. In comprehensive planning you tend to look at the bigger picture,looking at chunks of land, not particularly in regards to the individual parcels. He referred to Idaho Statute 50-222 as it clearly lays out the intent of the annexation code. It speaks about annexation to ensure orderly development of Idaho cities in order to allow efficient and economically viable provision of tax-supported and fee-supported municipal services to enable orderly development of private lands,which benefit from the cost effective availability of municipal services. I think that that has to be addressed in the context of this.The City, in the long run,would benefit from not having these enclaves.You eventually have to deal with the enclaves, it is inevitable. It has to do with as development occurs densities increase the extension of public services become more difficult,that there is more intense developments,those enclaves eventual do become part of the city,and achieve urban zoning, and seek urban types of development. In reading Idaho State code 50-222, it is better to address those enclave property concerns at the point of annexation.Those properties that we are talking about are not specifically part of this application,but they are part of our Comprehensive Planning.part of the request is to annex an have zoning for this type of development. It is not too hard to perceive that the other parcels that are on this larger chunk of land might be developed at a later date, probably not that much later,given the kind of development pressures that we are looking at. The issue is always the provision of services, and who is eligible for service, and how the local government would provide those services.We just ended legislative session where House Bill 389 was passed,and that throws into doubt as to whether annexing properties like these will provide enough revenue, at least at the outset,to make those services happen.This is a real concern.The Mayor and Council have talked in terms of moratorium on development. But the inclusion of the other out-properties in this proposal might help sway the balance for the kind of services needed for this magnitude of a subdivision. We can say that the application does comply with and fulfill Goal 4 of the Comprehensive Plan,which is a necessary condition to make recommendation for the zone change and annexation.The goal is to create communities that generate cost effective public services 6 Hearing Examiner Minutes 08/24/2021 and infrastructure. I think in order to meet that goal that we would have to look at annexing and rezoning all of the parcels in this block. With that intent,to include as a condition of the Development Agreement. He added that these types of enclave properties could be annexed at the incentive solely of the city, in accordance with the State Statutes.These could be annexed at any time, if the city develops a plan for annexing these kinds of lands,that could happen without the consent of landowners. From that,this might preclude that kind of annexation in the future where this land is in the City,and would become prime real estate for this type of development. Comprehensive Plan Analysis for ANN21-000007 (Annexation):The Hearing Examiner accepted the comprehensive plan analysis as listed in the staff report. Findings of Fact for ANN21-000007 (Annexation):The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as outlined in the staff report, public testimony,and the evidence list. Conclusions of Law for ANN21-000007 (Annexation):The Hearing Examiner accepted the Conclusions of Law as outlined in the staff report. ORDER FOR ANN21-000007 (Annexation):The Hearing Examiner RECOMMENDED that Case Number ANN21-000007 BE APPROVED with the following conditions: 9.2 - 9.3 with the following amendment: 9.4 - Instead of 47.42 acres,the total acreage for the entire block is 58.64.This would include all the properties that are bound by Marble Front Road on north, Middleton Road on the east,Joplin road on the south,and Ware Lane on the west.The R-2 zoning would extend to the full block of land,as would the annexation actions.These boundaries of the annexation and rezone would become a clause in the development agreement accompanying the R-2 rezone. Comprehensive Plan Analysis for SUB21-000012 (Preliminary Plat): The Hearing Examiner accepted the comprehensive plan analysis as listed in the staff report. Findings of Fact for SUB21-000012 (Preliminary Plat): The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as outlined in the staff report, public testimony,and the evidence list. Conclusions of Law for SUB21-000012 (Preliminary Plat): The Hearing Examiner accepted the Conclusions of Law as outlined in the staff report. ORDER FOR SUB21-000012 (Preliminary Plat):The Hearing Examiner RECOMMENDED that Case Number SUB21-000012 BE APPROVED with the following conditions: 15.1 - 15.18 with the following amendments: Late exhibits A14.1 and A18 added which further amended the preliminary plat application.Additional condition is 15.19 The Weymouth Lateral in conjunction with its impact on the Mandalay Ranch Subdivision be resolved. The developer to be obligated to work with Pioneer Irrigation on the relocation of that drain and the exact ultimate alignment. Mr. Eggleston concluded the public hearing. 2) Case Number SUP21-000006 (Continued from the July 13,2021 Hearing Examiner Meeting): A request by Hannah Mitchell for a Special Use Permit for Timbergrass Apartments, a 274 unit multi-family residential complex on 16.57 acres in a C-2 (Community Commercial) zone. The property is located approximately 350 feet southwest from the intersection of 10th Avenue and Ustick Road. 7 Hearing Examiner Minutes 08/24/2021 Testimony: Mr.Eggleston has continued this case to the October 26, 2021 Hearing Examiner meeting. 3) Case Number ANN21-000001/PUD21-000001 (Continued from the July 13,2021 Hearing Examiner Meeting): A request by T-0 Engineering, on behalf of Brady Lasher, for an Annexation, Planned Unit Development and a preliminary plat for Enclave Subdivision,a mixed use (single-family,multi-family and commercial) development with a zoning designation of H-C (Highway Corridor) zone on parcel's R32795 and R32795010 containing 46.76 acres. The proposed subdivision consists of 88 single-family lots, 204 multi-family units, 2 commercial lots and 13 common lots. The 2040 Comprehensive Plan designation is H-C (Highway Corridor). The subject properties are located 1,500 feet west of the intersection of HWY 55 and Midway Road, Caldwell, ID. Testimony: Mr. Eggleston has continued this case to the September 28, 2021 Hearing Examiner meeting. 4) Case Number PUD21-000002 (Continued from the July 27, 2021 Hearing Examiner Meeting): A request by Wilbur Group Inc. for a Planned Unit Development and Preliminary Plat for Mino'Aka Subdivision on parcel # R27438 located on the NE corner of Ustick Road and Florida Avenue,Caldwell, ID. The development is proposed for 27 townhomes on 4.56 acres with a density of 5.92 units per acre. Each residential lot is proposed to be 24'x66' with a square footage of 1584 square feet. The subject property is zoned"R-2" (Medium Density Residential). Testimony: Deb Root(Senior Planner) 621 Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell, ID 83605 states that this PUD request is for 4.67 acres.This property was previously zoned R-2 prior to this application being made. A PUD in the R-2 zone allows 12 units/acre. PUD's also require 10%qualified open space.The applicant also had to make accommodations for a roundabout that intersection at Ustick and Florida as well as having a 16'easement on both sides of the canal. The 16-foot easement is from the top of the bank for the Caldwell Low-Line canal on the properties northeast boundary.They are proposing a future bridge to their property on the other side of the canal. I cannot count that as open space but they will have to landscape and maintain that portion of their property. These will be individual town homes on individual lots. Ms. Root has concerns with unit 1 at the front of the development.The safety concerns have come from staff. Interior road is required to be a public road in a PUD. Current Comprehensive Plan has this property designated to be commercial on this corner. Applicant's current plan is unclear if there is 10%qualifying open space and if the development meets the requirement of amenities for the proposed development.They have proposed a small dog park.They have proposed a tot playground,but it is unclear where in the development they would be.There have been many changes while trying to meet code requirements to be a PUD. Staff have not received significant feedback or comments from surrounding property owners. Staff would like the roundabout to be completed before the townhomes go in due to heavy traffic in the area. Staff feels that there is more density on the property and the design and development lacks imagination.She is unsure if multi-family is the best use for the property. This development barely meets the code for an infill development 8 Hearing Examiner Minutes 08/24/2021 Mr. Eggleston stated that for a PUD to meet the criteria,which are two or more of the following instances under ordinance 2967. 1-Development offers a maximum choice of living environments by allowing a variety of housing and types.This application does not meet that criterion. 2-Development promotes mixed use projects are functionally integrated with the development and provide services primary use.This application does not meet that criterion. 3-Development provides layout,which preserves and properly utilizes natural topography,geologic features tree city.This does not meet that criterion.4-Land parcels constrained or otherwise limited by some obstacle feature geometry condition or easement that interferes with applying standard development process. Ms. Root stated that the parcel does have some restraints and constraints including the canal,the triangle shape of the parcel,and the parcel being divided by the canal.The application does meet the criteria for number four. 5-The development encourages infill development, it contributes to compatible design to the existing neighborhood.You note that it can be considered infill project and the subject property is zoned medium density residential.This may be compliant with item five giving the applicant the two required to meet the standard for application for a PUD. Mr. Eggleston stated that he received a project narrative email on 8/23/21. Ms. Root stated that the email narrative is part of the staff report. Mr. Eggleston stated that in that email transmission Ms. Root included an 11 page letter to the applicant describing requirements that have not been met as of 7/2/21. He asked if most of those items have been addressed in the current application. Ms. Root confirmed that was correct. Mr. Eggleston asked if the issue with lot 1 is the lot on the northwest and of the street closest to the main highway,and that it may be too close. Ms. Root confirmed that was correct. Mr. Eggleston asked what staff is trying to achieve, or where does it not comply with the ordinance. Ms. Root stated that in reality it does comply.The Planning Director and staff have consistently asked them to keep those units away from the entrance access point as vehicles from those units would be backing into the access into the development. Mr. Eggleston agreed that is an issue. He asked the City Engineer how close is that ingress/egress to the outer edge of the proposed roundabout. Robb McDonald (City Engineer) 621 Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell, ID 83605 stated that the access point itself is at a sufficient distance from the roundabout.The concern is that if you have someone backing out of that unit,there could be cars coming around the corner. That is the real concern. Mr. Eggleston asked what the approximate distance from the ingress/egress to the outer edge of the roundabout. 9 Hearing Examiner Minutes 08/24/2021 Mr. McDonald stated that it is close to 286 feet. Mr. Eggleston asked Mr. McDonald if there are any more concerns about the street layout or the fire turnaround on this property for the proposed plan. Mr. McDonald stated that he has no other concerns. Mr. Eggleston asked how long the hammer-head was for turning around. Mr. McDonald stated that it is about 40 feet. Mr. Eggleston asked about the 3 parking stalls at the entry of the development for visitors. He believes that they would have the same safety issue with backing out into the entryway. Mr. McDonald responded that those parking stalls on a public road are not allowed. 90 degree parking off of a public road is not permitted unless it is for a driveway for a building or a facility. He wants to take a closer look at that to determine if it is acceptable. Mr. Eggleston stated that it is not an ideal location being just a few feet away from ingress/egress and it would be difficult to see anyone making a right turn into there as your backing out. Mr. McDonald stated that he would like to look that over again. He didn't know that it would constitute holding up a recommended approval on that alone. He believes that he could work with the developer to find a location that is more appropriate. Mr. Eggleston stated that he would like to go over the Comprehensive Plan designation. There is a viable development for medium density residential. He asked what are staff's thoughts about business/commercial land use designation and Comprehensive Plan and would that provide a more suitable use for this corner. Ms. Root stated that the question of suitability is whether anyone can make it work for that proposed use.The access constraints,The ROW dedication for the roundabout,and the canal. It is a tricky piece of property regardless of commercial or residential. Residential right on that roundabout is not ideal.With that,the City Council is growing concerned about losing commercial frontage and properties. Mr. Eggleston stated that the applicant is not seeking a zone change. Some of the specifics on the staff report based on the review of the applicants plat the PUD deviates from the requirements. These deviations seem on the extreme edge of exceptions to the dimensional standards of the zoning code. He asked if these deviations make this project less viable with the wide swing in deviation. Ms. Root stated that staff feels that their density is a little high for the configuration shape and the Planned Unit Development.With the amenities that they have proposed,they could have asked for relief from the required amenities.Typically what we are seeing in PUD's for townhomes is 3300 square feet. It appears to be extreme. Mr. Eggleston stated that it is unclear what those amenities are. 10 Hearing Examiner Minutes 08/24/2021 Ms. Root stated that the applicant has indicated on their plat a sport court. I am unable to tell if that is a basketball court or a pickle ball court.The applicant has stated that they have a sport court and gazebo. However,they are in a small limited space. She stated that her opinion is that the City Council is not going to view this application favorably.This parcel is constrained,and the applicant could ask for relief from the amenities. The applicant has also identified a small dog park. Mr. Eggleston asked if the bridge across the canal was installed, could it be considered an amenity. Ms. Root stated that if the bridge were installed and that property became available for the use and enjoyment of the residents within this development. If the dog park was over there or if it was just a small open space that in its condition it would have to be landscaped and maintained. If the bridge were installed it would provide access. It could be part of the pathway. Mr. Eggleston asked if the bridge was a condition for approval.There may be a question if the canal supports the idea of a bridge. Ms. Root responded that the canal company told her that the applicant would have to comply with the Bureau of Reclamation requirements for application.Typically,the Bureau of Reclamation and Pioneer Irrigation have not precluded the construction of bridges on those facilities.They would have to go through a process to do that and go through the work and application to do that. Mr. Eggleston again asked if the bridge was a condition for approval. Ms. Root stated that it should be a condition of approval as they are proposing that as a future bridge. Mr. Eggleston asked if the open space was integrated into the design or is it more of an afterthought. Ms. Root stated that her belief is that it is just what was left over. However,with the constraints of the property,add to that the challenge to provide integrated open space,the requirements of a public road versus a private road there have been additional challenges. Mr. Eggleston asked if the applicant has achieved the open space requirements. Ms. Root responded that it is unclear based on the information provided. Mr. Eggleston asked if the property across the canal is considered part of their open space. Ms. Root responded that currently it is non-qualifying open space. Mr. Eggleston asked if they provided a bridge,would it then be classified as open space. Ms. Root responded that under condition 10.9 the bridge has to be installed prior to the issuance of certificate of occupancy. Mr. Eggleston stated that one of the solutions to unit 1 ingress/egress issue is to eliminate that unit. It does not appear that there is room to move anything. He asked what staff would recommend to rectify this issue at the entry point. 11 Hearing Examiner Minutes 08/24/2021 Ms. Root stated that staff has asked the applicant to remove unit 1. Mr. Eggleston asked again about the three visitor parking stalls at the entryway into the development and what is the density index for visitor parking. Ms. Root stated that the additional visitor parking is a requirement to be a PUD. For lots less than 45 feet in width for every fourth unit there is one additional parking space. Mr. Eggleston asked if this was the minimum standard. Ms. Root responded yes. Amy Johnson (Applicant) at 24 E. Main St.,American Fork, Utah 84003 stated that they had originally looked at this property for a commercial location. However,the ingress/egress was a problem for our business constituents on making the property profitable.That was the reason for looking towards townhomes. There is another property in this area with townhomes,so they thought it would be a good fit.As far as the amenities,she is open to crossing the canal.They have been working with the canal company for a bridge permit. They would be open to adding that ground to their open space. They are open to moving the dog park across the canal.This is an infill PUD,so it is a little different. She stated that they are amenable to making those recommended changes to present to the City Council.As for Unit 1,they did not feel that it was an issue. She says that they could move the three parking stalls to the back of the development. If they were required to remove unit 1,they would like to install raised garden beds as well as a community garden. If that would be an applicable amenity,then they would like to do that. Mr. Eggleston stated that the elevations drawings are different. Ms.Johnson responded that they are different fixtures,but similar floor plans as far as size. Mr. Eggleston stated that you have to walk up into the unit,so the main floor is in the proposal,not the photograph. He asked if the proposal is going to be the same where your main floor is elevated from the ground floor by four steps.You are currently showing that they are going to be slab on grade. He asked which of the two is the proposal. Ms.Johnson responded that it would be the slab on grade for this development. Mr. Eggleston clarified that these townhomes would be two-story with similar modulation of the frontage. Ms.Johnson responded that yes it is the two story with the bedrooms on top. Mr. Eggleston asked if either of the designs were ones that she has used in other projects. He asked if the city would be guaranteed of this look, or is this just typical. He asked if this a generic look. Ms.Johnson responded that they are still open on that. They will follow the design standards as far as construction drawings are required for the City of Caldwell. This plan has been built in other cities. 12 Hearing Examiner Minutes 08/24/2021 Mr. Eggleston asked how close they would hew to the drawings presented. With PUD's it would be expected to have a high level of expectations for design, open space and amenities, thereby allowing the higher density. He feels that this development should be extremely nice and what he is seeing is generic. Ms.Johnson asked for clarification if the house plans or the site plan is generic. Mr. Eggleston responded that both are generic. He explained that the PUD ordinance is basically a trade,where density is traded for a higher quality development. He is not seeing integrated open space and amenities into the development. Ms.Johnson responded that they were placed in the middle of the development as the best design.With a 54-foot road that was their only option. She also felt that it would be a better location that could be fenced in and children would be safer. Mr. Eggleston asked about fencing. Would it be along the property lines or around individual units or both. Ms.Johnson responded that they could have fencing on the back of the private backyards. She was planning on fencing the amenities. Mr. Eggleston responded that fencing is not shown. The amenities themselves seem rather vague. He specified some shortcomings on the site plan and provided the applicant with some alternatives. He can approve as is, deny or continue to another hearing where there can be more clarity on the site plan. Ms.Johnson asked if one of the choices could be approval with conditions. Mr. Eggleston responded that is a choice, but it could take another hearing to again review the final product is before it goes to the City Council. He stated that there needs to be 100% clarity on the site plan before it goes to the City Council. He stated that he could condition this plan,but it does not provide the ability to review it before the Council Hearing. He stated that his preference would be to have a continuation while the applicant updates the site plan. He stated that the safety issues are paramount of the things to be updated on the site plan. He also listed the dog park and when the bridge will be built. He stated that if this is sent onward to the City Council for them to examine these issues, it is not likely that they would approve it. He does not believe that the plan is up to the standards that the City would like to see from the standpoint of completeness,clarity, and design. Scott Argyle (Applicant's Engineer) at24 E Main St.,American Fork,UT 80003 stated that as has been mentioned previously,this property is a difficult piece of property with the shape, easement with the canal,road ROW dedication, landscape buffers,and access restrictions. The open space was calculated in CAD and they feel that they meet the ordinance even without the ground across the canal. He feels that unit 1 is in compliance with the ordinance. It may not be the most desirable,but it does comply with the ordinance. Amanda Award (In Favor) at 20090Batt Corner Road,Wilder, ID 83676 has chosen not to speak. Mr. Eggleston asked the City Engineer about the proximity of unit 1 to the ingress/egress and what resolution would be appropriate for the backing out into the street issue. 13 Hearing Examiner Minutes 08/24/2021 Mr. McDonald stated that it might be in compliance with the ordinance. However from a safety standpoint it makes him uncomfortable.That is the concern that he has. Mr. Eggleston stated that it is difficult to gauge the distance from the corner of the driveway to the street edge. Mr. McDonald stated that he believes it is 32 feet. Mr. Eggleston stated that the standard is 24 feet for residential. However, it does look short. Especially when people are coming off Florida. Mr. McDonald stated that the speed limit on Florida is 30-35 north of Ustick Rd. Mr. Eggleston asked if the roundabout would change that. Mr. McDonald stated that going into the roundabout would slow traffic down.Traffic would be accelerating out of the roundabout. Another problem with this driveway location is that while a vehicle is backing out,it could block traffic onto Florida while this happens. He feels it is just too close for comfort. He felt that his department could take a closer look at it again. Mr. Eggleston stated that taking a closer look at the location would argue for a continuation. He stated that his preference on unit 1 is to move the whole stack. He is not sure if that is possible. He believes that there should be more space at this location especially if there will be landscaping there. He is concerned with the line of site maybe further obscured.With fencing it is not going to get any better. Safety is a concern there.The same for the three parking stalls across the way. He does not believe that it is ready to go to the City Council for review. He does not like the idea of sending something like this without a final design that can be evaluated on its merits. He asked the City Engineer if it needs a little more time. Mr. McDonald stated that it is something that his department needs to look more into whether it is continued or it goes to the City Council. Before it should be sent to the City Council it would be best to make sure staff is comfortable with it. Mr. Eggleston stated that he would be comfortable with Staff's judgement. However he stated that he does not feel that the application is complete,and it is not something that he would recommend approval to the City Council. He asked if staff would like to approach another hearing or if it was sufficient for staff to review and then schedule to the City Council when the conditions have been met. Ms. Root stated that staff could make the recommendations of what the changes should be and what staff would like to see modified and potentially take this forward to the Council. It will be hard pressed to pass muster with the Council no matter no matter how many changes are made at this level, due to the nature of the PUD. With that said,the constraints of the property provide the applicant opportunity to request relief from some of the amenities and some of the design requirements. It being an infill property it will be the applicant's job to sell it to Council and to this Hearing body. She stated that if the Hearing Examiner wants to continue this development and would like to see those changes,then staff is amiable to that as well. She isn't sure that with changes it will affect how the Hearing Examiner feels about it. 14 Hearing Examiner Minutes 08/24/2021 Ms.Johnson stated that she is more than happy to quickly supply and make the adjustments to be satisfactory for the staff review. She would prefer for a staff review after site changes and then to go directly to the City Council. Mr. Eggleston stated that he would like to address the closeness of the driveway to the intersection. He asked if it was possible to move the whole block a few feet to the southeast, to shuffle the whole side of the street. Mr.Argyle responded that it would be difficult unless they could reduce the setbacks between units. Ms.Johnson stated that another thing that they could do is to switch the floor plans to a bit narrower floorplan.Change from 2-car garage to 1-car garage floor plans. It is not what she wanted to do with this development.Alternatively,upon your recommendation,to remove a unit. However, if staff felt that the unit needed to be removed,then they would adjust to that. Mr. Eggleston stated that the applicant at some point would have to look at the City Council possibly denying this project.The overall design concept is good. He feels that the execution is needs some work and clarity. Mr. Eggleston closed the public testimony Comprehensive Plan Analysis for PUD21-000002 (Planned Unit Development):The Hearing Examiner accepted the comprehensive plan analysis as listed in the staff report. Findings of Fact for PUD21-000002 (Planned Unit Development): The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as outlined in the staff report, public testimony,and the evidence list. Conclusions of Law for PUD21-000002 (Planned Unit Development):The Hearing Examiner accepted the Conclusions of Law as outlined in the staff report. ORDER FOR PUD21-000002:The Hearing Examiner RECOMMENDED that Case Number PUD21-000002 (Planned Unit Development): BE APPROVED with the following conditions: 10.1-10.17 with the following amendments: 10.18-The plan of record in this application be redrawn to clearly show the amenities,the open spaces,the proposed bridge and the fence and landscaping treatments. Design change improvements to be reviewed by city staff and meet their expectations prior to being scheduled at City Council. 10.19-The driveway for unit 1 be moved 10' further from the intersection or the unit removed completely,whichever solution is the most viable.This is due to the safety hazard when backing out of unit 1 driveway to passengers and pedestrians,also due to the proximity to the intersection in the right of way line at the entry point of the subdivision. 10.20-The three visitor parking stalls at the entry way should be moved to another part of the project. They also present a safety hazard to ingress/egress into the development. 10.21-All conditions of approval will be reviewed and approved by City Engineering and City Planning Staff to their satisfaction in accordance with discussions had at this hearing before it is scheduled hearing at the City Council. Mr. Eggleston concluded the public hearing. IV New Business: 15 Hearing Examiner Minutes 08/24/2021 1) Case Number SUP21-000011: A request by Rage Development to locate a T-Mobile telecommunications tower on the Vallivue High School property located at 1407 Homedale Road, Caldwell, ID. The proposed tower will replace one existing 80'tall sports field light pole with a 100'tall co-location tower that will support both the sports field lighting and the cellular antennas. Support structures will also be located at the base of the tower in an enclosed 30'x 30' compound. Testimony: Mr.Eggleston has continued this case to the September 14,2021 Hearing Examiner meeting. Planning Issues-None The next regularly scheduled Hearing Examiner meeting is scheduled for September 14, 2021. The Hearing Examiner adjourned the meeting at approximately 9:31 p.m. Respectfully submitted by Cynthia Brogdon, MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BY THE HEARING EXAMINER, BRUCE EGGLESTON, ON THE DATE NOTED BELOW: Mr. Bruce Eggleston Da Debbie 'r. , Senior ' a ner Date For detailed Minutes,please request a copy of the digital recording. 16 Hearing Examiner Minutes 08/24/2021