HomeMy WebLinkAbout2021-07-27 Design Review Minutes CITY OF CALDWELL
DESIGN REIVEW COMMISSION M . Q
Community Room,Caldwell Police D;,artment iPPROVED
__
110 South 5th Avenue,Caldwell,I . • , r..
July 27,2021 12:00PM Date v_12
CALL TO ORDER— Commissioner Dodge called the meeting to order at approximately 12:00 p.m.
Commission Present: Tressa Dodge,Tyler Morgan, and Nicole Dovel-Moore
Commissioners Absent:Alexandria Vogt
Staff Members Present: Jerome Mapp, Planning Director; April Cabello, Planning Technician
Staff Members Absent: none
I. CONSENT CALENDAR: [All consent Calendar items are considered action items]
1. Approve Minutes from the February 23, 2021 meeting.
MOTION made by Commissioner Dovel-Moore to approve the minutes.
SECOND by Commissioner Morgan Passed: unanimous voice vote.
II. OLD BUSINESS:None.
III. NEW BUSINESS
ACTION ITEM: PUBLIC HEARIN
Case Number DR21-000003: A request by Jennifer Mohr for Design Review approval for the
Roberts Building located at 712 Main Street, Caldwell. The development is located in the
Caldwell City Center(C-C) District.The applicant is proposing to renovate the Main Street
and Indian Creek Plaza facades and remodel the second floor apartment. In addition,the
applicant proposes to add two-second floor apartments with lofts in the unfinished shell space
within a partially raised roof.
Jerome Mapp, Planning Director,621 Cleveland Boulevard stated that the applicant will need
more than five minutes to make their presentation.We will put that on the record.This is the
request by Cole Architects Jennifer Mohr to remodel/repurpose the existing structure at 712
1of7IPage
Main both facades on Main Street and Indian Creek Plaza. The current structure is vacant,it
has one apartment on the second floor and it is surrounded by Indian Creek Plaza on the
south and Main Street to the north. It is within the City Center zoning district. I am going to
let the architect go into details about the structure. However,the things we will be looking at is
regarding building height,materials, colors,wall openings and projecting elements.The
applicant is providing two amenities which currently exists,bicycle rack and benches. There's
no surface parking required for this development within the city code 10-12-04(16A) states
that residential mixed uses and uses located in the properties listed on the National Register of
Historic Places are exempt from parking requirements. There is no signage being proposed
this time. Mr. Mapp shared Engineering's comments stating the applicant is to contact the
City Engineering Department to pay water and sewer connection fees for additional
residential units. The fee shall be paid prior to the issuance of a certificate of occupancy of
completion. Staffs key design features of this application is that they are bringing residential
into the city core with the redesign of the second level,and adding two additional residential
units. My understanding is that at least one of the units will have visual access to Indian Creek.
The design features, as mentioned,comply with the Indian Creek Plaza and the City Center
guidelines.
Commissioner Morgan confirmed with staff that there is no variances being requested.
Mr. Mapp responded no variances being requested.
Commissioner Dovel-Moore asked staff with this building being in the historic district,does
this need to go before Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission.
Mr. Mapp responded that our historic preservation commission only reviews projects within
the Steunenberg Residential Historic District. This case is for the Design Review Commission
to review.
Ian Hoffman, Coal Architects, 720,West Ada Street, Boise, Idaho, 8370 applicant
representative and stated that they are excited about this project;we think that it is going to be
a great amenity to the City of Caldwell. This project falls underneath both the Main Street as
well as the Indian Creek Plaza area.Therefore,we have two design guides that we are working
with. There are minor improvements that we are proposing, such as the bike racks,but other
than that, everything else will maintain the same.We are not doing any work on the exterior
of the building. We are sandwiched between two adjacent buildings;we have a zero lot line.
For the proposal to the roof,we're looking at increasing the height loft on the Indian Creek
Plaza side and create a roof deck for one of the and mechanical screening.What this does is it
looks at a very holistic approach;both of those raised portions are set back from the street.
Visibility from the street is very limited to that raise in height and it is also very limited as far
as the scope of the height,we only had to raise it about, 10 feet or so on the Indian Creek Plaza
2of7IPage
side. It is generally undetected on the Main street side.There will be a patio on the Indian
Creek Plaza side for one of the apartments. Our proposal is to maintain the historical integrity
of the Main Street side;we are proposing replacing those existing windows with matching new
energy efficient windows. Same with the door and the Juliet balcony being restored to its same
appearance. The only proposal that we are currently making is on the bottom tile band and we
were looking at proposing a change to wood,more historically appropriate dark panel
material on the base.The current entry to the residential unit is plywood,and a wooden door.
We are proposing putting infill storefront in that area. The material palette currently is the
existing brick,existing river rock on the Indian Creek Plaza side that we are anticipating trying
to paint in order to kind of match the rest of the palette of both the new proposed building as
well as the design guides for the Indian Creek Plaza.We are within those boundaries of trying
to maintain to that relevance for the Indian Creek Plaza side.There is existing stucco that we
are looking at trying to paint,but it is existing. From the Main Street side the tile,they are
looking at changing that to a dark,painted wood or metal material that matches a little bit
more of the historical quality. The door/entry up into the residential units, currently is
plywood, and we are proposing matching the historical significance of the upper area with the
lower area so that all ties together, as well as adding a covered overhang to that patio to
provide shelter for tenants walking in so they're not getting rained or snowed on. They intend
to surround the mechanical units and screen them from visibility so you cannot see that from
the street,which is because it's stepped back so far.We are proposing to increase the height 10
feet or so to help create an appropriate head height for the apartment, as well as stepping back
that facade so that you have the rooftop deck and that is also covered with a an overhang for
rain and snow and things like that.We want to match those kind of historic qualities.The
Indian Creek Plaza side,we are matching the more contemporary look that is already existing
and adding to that. From the Main Street side,we are proposing a covered overhang,with a
historical kind of matching.We are trying to maintain that historical integrity as much as
possible. On the Indian Creek Plaza side,pushing back that apartment building around 10 to
12 feet, adding a covered overhang trying to activate that that kind of courtyard area so there
is a lot of activity on the ground but also up in the apartments above.
Commissioner Morgan stated that it is pretty easy from a Design Review perspective to look at
all this and say,job well done but we're talking about residential now facing Indian Creek
Plaza. What does the city have as far as regulations or code when it comes to residential. I do
not know if the commission has talked about residential facing Indian Creek Plaza? I do not
want dirty laundry hanging over the metal rail.
Mr. Mapp responded that is a valid question and it is not discussed,that he could find in the
City Center code other than it does state live,work play.
Chairperson Dodge stated that at one point,it was passed to have retail and restaurants on the
bottom level. Anything above that can be different in terms of not retail and restaurants.
3of7 I Page
Office spaces okay on the second floor and ground level in that area to be retail and
restaurants.
Mr. Mapp responded that is correct. Per the ordinance, a special use permit is required to have
an office on the first floor.
Commissioner Morgan stated that he thinks it is a great.
Chairperson Dodge stated that there is an existing apartment above the bookstore.
Commissioner Dovel-Moore stated that there are apartments above extreme pizza with access
to the plaza. There are things in the window; it gives it some character.
Mr. Hoffman stated that this would be intended to be an area that residents can be out front if
they want to have plants or something like that,or some place to sit and or watch events and
concerts. It is something to keep in mind but we find that the benefits outweigh things like
hanging laundry.We are providing extra lighting on that back area that does comply with any
increased Plaza requirements. They are increasing the lighting with Gooseneck lighting. At
this time,we are not proposing any particular signage.The intent is to maintain that street
face as much as possible,and only enhance it.
Commissioner Dovel-Moore asked about the canopy on the front on the Main Street side and
will there be any lights mounted on the wall underneath that canopy.
Mr. Hoffman responded that they do anticipate having lighting for emergency egress.There
will be a light underneath the canopy so we do not have any night sky issues. It will not be
shining up into the open. It will be contained within the main entry area.
Commissioner Dovel-Moore asked about the material for the addition, on the Main Street
side to screen the HVAC units and on the Indian Creek Plaza side,it looks like. Is the material
black metal siding.
Mr. Hoffman the color will be a dark metal finish aligning with those kind of guidelines of the
Indian Creek Plaza side and then wrapped around, they want that to be a continuous holistic
look,we don't want it to be an ugly metal panel. The intent is to be an elevated kind of
contemporary look to the rest of the building.
Commissioner Dovel-Moore shared that she loves that look and that modern style is in the
handbook. She shared that there will be a lot of heat radiating off the building and a wood
might absorb the heat a little bit better.
4of7IPage
Commissioner Dovel-Moore asked about the existing bike racks and benches and wondered if
they are adding more elsewhere along the street?
Mr. Hoffman responded the existing bike racks and benches are to remain,they are counting
those amenities towards this projects requirement.
Commissioner Dovel-Moore stated out in front of the building,there is two benches and one
bike rack existing,so if that can count,they meet the requirement.
Chairperson Dodge stated that the metal trim is considered building ornamentation for
pedestrian.
Jennifer Mohr,Cole Architects, 1008 W. Main Street, Boise,ID signed in favor of the
application but did not wish to speak.
Geovanni Florenca, Cole Architects, 1008 W. Main Street,Boise, ID signed in favor of the
application but did not wish to speak.
Lee Gentice, Pontifex Capital, 1109 W. Main Street Ste 350, Boise, ID signed in favor of the
application but did not wish to speak.
MOTION to close the public testimony made by Commissioner Morgan SECOND made by
Commissioner Dovel-Moore Passed: unanimous voice vote.
The commission discussed the color palette and the color trend in the plaza and had further
questions.
MOTION to reopen public testimony made by Commissioner Morgan SECOND made by
Commissioner Dovel-Moore Passes: unanimous voice vote.Testimony is approved to be
reopened.
Ian Hoffman, Cole Architects, 720,West Ada Street, Boise,Idaho. In regards to the material
palette,I completely agree that we want to make sure that that is a timeless quality. Our intent
is to look at the guidelines that laid out in the Indian Creek Plaza and overall master plan.
They have a set palette of colors that we were able that we have to respond to,but also to look
at existing context and buildings left and buildings literally,the building to the left of ours is
brick with black steel. Currently,the building to the right is a gray brick. To answer question
for adjacencies, and looking at the on trend,we definitely do not want to just be on trend we
want to be timeless quality is something that we do take seriously and that we want to adhere
5of7IPage
•
to. We feel like we are meeting that requirement by following the palette,not blending too
much with the buildings in immediate adjacencies.
Commissioner Morgan stated that for this project,he thinks they are spot on;it is more of a
general discussion of the whole health of the city and what makes it difficult is, unless you
want to pay a lot of money,things like the lighter bronze storefront becomes very expensive.
If you throw dark bronze in with a super light,stucco now you are messing with this weird,
combo. There is not a whole lot of different storefront colors out there other than dark bronze
and clear anodized. I think you are doing all the right things.
Mr. Hoffman stated that they would be considering this for later discussion,maybe some
public art or a mural of some sort and trying to add some kind of more vibrancy to that area as
well. So that's something that we always consider has not been decided upon yet and we would
come back for approval on that.
MOTION to close the public testimony made by Commissioner Morgan SECOND made by
Commissioner Dovel-Moore Passed: unanimous voice vote.
FINDING OF FACT:
The Design Review Commission accepts the general facts as outlined in the staff report,public
testimony, and the evidence list. MOTION: Commissioner Morgan SECOND: Commissioner
Dovel-Moore. Passed: unanimous voice vote.
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW:
The Design Review Commission accepts the Conclusions of Law as outlined in the staff
report. MOTION: Commissioner Morgan SECOND: Commissioner Dovel-Moore. Passed:
unanimous voice vote.
ORDER OF DECISION FOR DR21-000003 (Roberts Building Design Review) MOTION:
Commissioner Morgan that Case Number DR21-000003 be approved with the following
conditions: 8.2 through 8.6 and additional conditions:
8.7 The Design Review Commission would like to add that the City of Caldwell Planning and
Zoning continue to look at the overall color palette and health of the of the color palette in the
downtown City area.
IV. Adjournment
MOTION TO ADJOURN: Commissioner Dovel-Moore
SECOND made by Commissioner Morgan
Passed: Unanimous voice vote.
6of7IPage
The meeting was adjourned at approximately 1:15 p.m.
Respectfully submitted by April Cabello,
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BY THE CHAIR, ON THE DATE NOTED BELOW:
Co missioner ressa Dodge, hair ate
ATTEST: ---
/ A
Jer,me Mapp, anning Director
7of7IPage