HomeMy WebLinkAbout2021-07-29 P&Z Commission Minutes APPROVED
CITY OF CALDWELL
CALDWELL PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION i' u • - ": 9 ..t
Community Room,Caldwell Police Department Date 1.l.) 1
110 South 5th Avenue,Caldwell,Idaho -----
July 29,2021,Special Meeting 7:00 P.M.
Special Meeting—7:00 p.m.
Call to Order—Commissioner Betsy Hunsicker called the meeting to order at 7:10 p.m.
Roll Call—
Members Present: Betsy Hunsicker, Shawn Hannan,Brett Slaughter
Members Absent: Jim Nelson,Alex Zamora
Staff Present: Jerome Mapp,Planning Director; Kate Phillips,Associate Planner; Lori Colligan,
Associate Planner; Cindy Brogdon,Administrative Assistant
Staff Absent: Robb MacDonald,City Engineer; Debbie Root, Senior Planner
Others Present:
Review of Proceedings-
CONSENT CALENDAR:
1) Approve minutes of the June 8, 2021 Regular meeting.
MOTION: Commissioner Harman. SECOND: Commissioner Slaughter Passed:Unanimous roll call vote
2) Approve minutes of the June 29, 2021 Special meeting.
MOTION: Commissioner Harman. SECOND: Commissioner Slaughter Passed:Unanimous roll call vote
Old Business:N/A
New Business:
1) Case Number OA-21-08:A request by the Planning and Zoning Department to amend Chapter 10,
Article 12,City Center Zoning District,of the Caldwell City Code and with a new designation of
Central Business District.
Testimony:
Jerome Mapp,Director of P&Z,621 Cleveland Blvd.,Caldwell,ID laid out the changes to
Chapter 10,Article 12.He stated that with the rapid growth in the city,it was found that the
ordinances currently do not meet the needs for this growth. He is proposing for this ordinance to
clarify with better understanding the conflicts in the land use schedule, setback requirements,
parking requirements,and other items.Within the Central Business District,you have the City
Page I 1
Planning and Zoning Minutes
Center District,Historic City Center District and the Indian Creek Corridor District.This ordinance
creates boundaries for the four different districts.
He stated that in March an emergency ordinance was approved by the City Council.He stated that
P&Z held a Workshop/Open House on July 8, 2021 for these ordinance changes.Then tonight
they are being presented to the P&Z Commission in a public hearing.With the P&Z
Commission's recommendation to approve tonight, it will be taken to the City Council on August
16,2021 for them to act upon and extend the ordinance for the Central Business District. City
Center currently defined in the code is only talking about a small piece of this area. Within this
ordinance draft,anything underlined is new language,and anything crossed out is set to be
removed. He described how the Caldwell Train Depot will be used for the Caldwell Transit
Transfer Station for use in the year 2050.
Commisioner Hunsicker asked if that terminology is specific to rail or light rail.
Mr.Mapp responded that it is transfer to the site via vehicle or bus.
Commissioner Hunsicker stated that she would not like to see a transit center in the downtown area.
Mr.Mapp responded that the transit station is being planned for 2050.Thirty years out and many
things will change in that time.This is a plan for future growth.There will also be sites at the
College of Idaho and at Cleveland Blvd./Ustick area. Parking garages may need to be built in the
downtown area to accommodate this transfer station.This Transfer Station will help promote the
Central business District,the Downtown just as Destination Caldwell does currently.There will be
changes in the Land Use schedule for the Central Business District and the City Center District.
Commissioner Hunsicker asked if an item on the land use schedule is struck out does that mean that
it is not allowed.
Mr.Mapp responded in that zone it will not be allowed.
Commissioner Hunsicker asked why aren't daycare centers allowed outright in these districts.
Mr.Mapp responded that daycare centers are allowed by Special Use Permit anywhere within the
city,not just these districts.
Commissioner Hunsicker asked why then is a family daycare permitted.
Kate Phillips,Associate Planner 621 Cleveland Blvd.,Caldwell, ID responded that it has to do with
the number of children allowed at one time.
Commissioner Hunsicker asked why aren't bars are allowed in these districts.
Mr.Mapp responded that existing bars may remain,but no new ones will be allowed.
Commissioner Hunsicker asked if there are going to be bars in the community, it makes sense that
they would be in the business district.
Mr.Mapp responded that bars are being replaced with drinking establishment with food.
Commissioner Hunsicker asked where in Caldwell are bars allowed.
Page 12
Planning and Zoning Minutes
Mr.Mapp responded that there are zoning areas in the City that allow bars,just not in the city
center.
Commissioner Hunsicker asked why beer tasting has been struck from the land use table.
Mr.Mapp responded that they would be allowed,but would have to serve food.He also stated that
the elected city officials do not want to see bars increase in the city center.
Commissioner Hunsicker stated that the Central Business District is a large area and partially
residential. She asked if the vision was for all of this residential to eventually become business.
Mr.Mapp stated that his conversation with the City Council is that they would like to see this area
grow over the years.The idea is that as the City Center tries to expand,it will grow into zone 1,
then zone 2,then zone 3 and finally zone 4.The idea is for this district to grow slowly over the
years.The new setbacks tables are aligned to the zones within the Central Business District.
Commissioner Hunsicker asked if 45' building height is about three stories. She asked if three
stories was the tallest building height allowed.
Mr.Mapp responded that is correct for the Central Business District.
Commissioner Hunsicker asked if the building heights does not allow for five story buildings.
Mr.Mapp responded that for now that is correct. But that could change going forward as things
change in this District.Parking requirements in the Central Business District are minimal. We are
consolidating all land use to one location within the ordinance.Definitions for land use have been
added."Only in the C-C"language has been removed.Parking standards have been clarified.
Parking for the City Center Zone has been added. Added Medallion signs for buildings.
Commissioner Hunsicker noted that she has seen a sign on a business that is not for that business.
Mr.Mapp responded that it might be grandfathered in.There are now sign sizes in the ordinance.
There has been landscape code included within the Central Business District ordinance so it is
easier to find tree selection guidelines. City Center District Design Requirements have been
included. A Design Guideline booklet has been presented to the City Council.The outdoor seating
ordinance has been added to the ordinance.
Commissioner Hunsicker expressed concern for the drinking establishments in the downtown area.
She asked if there is a way to specify a drinking establishment that does not serve hard liquor.
Mr.Mapp responded that the distinction is hard alcohol.
Commissioner Hunsicker responded that it is hard liquor with no food.
Commissioner Slaughter suggested that a brew establishment should be approved.
Mr.Mapp stated that they would have to serve food on site to establish the food requirement. No
food trucks.
Commissioner Hunsicker stated that she would like to see micro brews who only serve brews in the
downtown area. She stated that putting in a kitchen is hard to do. She thinks the ordinance needs
more work.
Page 13
Planning and Zoning Minutes
Sabrina Minshall, (Neutral) 106 S.Kimball,Caldwell,ID stated that she has concerns for any
motion that has not been reviewed adequately i.e.: definitions-drinking establishment.Another
concern is businesses wanting to come to Caldwell,but may back out due to the food rule. She
does not think this ordinance is creative enough. She wants to know how to activate a move from
zone 1 to zone 2 or 3. She has concerns with the parking regulations and setbacks. She feels that it
is not progressive enough. She believes that the parking requirements are inhibitive to new
development. She would like to see zero line setbacks in the future vision. Over all a need to
design code to a future vision of downtown.The city could be turning away businesses. She does
not feel that the ordinance is ready to go to the City Council.
Commissioner Hunsicker asked what the urgency is. She asked when the current code expires.
Mr.Mapp responded that the current code expires in August.He feels that this ordinance is required
to clear up land use issues.The current code cannot be extended.The City Council's direction
regarding alcohol with food has been on the radar for 2 years.
Commissioner Hunsicker asked if the ordinance is not approved today,what would happen.
Mr.Mapp responded that the City Council would have to approve it ultimately.
Commissioner Hunsicker asked if they could approve with recommendation to have more business
involvement.
Mr.Mapp responded that changes identified could continue to be made.
Commissioner Harmon stated that he has seen where we could be driving business away due to
additional regulation.
Mr.Mapp responded that the land uses are compatible with each land use zone.
Commissioner Hunsicker asked if all retail is allowed. She asked if vaping specifically is allowed.
Mr.Mapp responded that no vaping would be allowed due to direction from the City Council.
Commissioner Hunsicker stated that there is a missing process for how to change the zoning
districts going forward.
Mr.Mapp responded that currently we are focusing on a small area.When that begins to grow,then
it would be expanded out to zone 2.
Commissioner Hunsicker asked if there are different setbacks for the major streets.
Mr.Mapp responded that if a parcel is residential,then it would follow the residential setbacks. If
it is commercial,then they follow the commercial setbacks.
Commissioner Hunsicker stated that there needs to be a definition change to the wine,beer or cider
establishment. Those establishments should not be required to have food.The change should be for
beer,wine and cider establishments to be permitted.If the beer,wine and cider establishments
would be required to prepare food on site,it would inhibit business growth to the City Center. She
agrees that drinking establishments serving just hard liquor should not be allowed.
Page I 4
Planning and Zoning Minutes
If the City Council insists on food being served,then it should not have to be prepared on site. It
should be recommended with those changes and with the intention to re-evaluate the zones and
setbacks in those areas making sure that there is a plan for the future.
Mr.Mapp asked for clarification that the commission would like staff to review the possibilities for
future expansion.
Commissioner Hunsicker responded that she would like to see that review being done with the
City's Economic Developer,Destination Caldwell, or the Chamber of Commerce.
Mr.Mapp stated that he would take the Commission's suggestions to the City Council.If they
choose to add them into the document,then at that time he would make the changes.
Commissioner Slaughter agreed with the recommendations.
Commissioner Hunsicker stated that their recommendation is to recommend this ordinance to the
City Council with the changes suggested. For beer,wine and cider establishments to be allowed
without having to be required to serve food.
Mr.Mapp recommended that the Commission might want to consider actually stating that they
would like to see food trucks.
Commissioner Hunsicker stated that alternative food services such as food trucks or catered food
from local businesses to be allowed. She stated that the definition of"Live Entertainment"should
be revised to 2 nights per week given the current availability of live entertainment. She also
recommends that there is further discussion on the ordinance to refine the boundaries and setbacks
to fulfill the vision of this area.
Mr.Mapp stated that he would re-evaluate the expansion of the Central Business District
boundaries.
MOTION TO CLOSE PUBLIC TESTIMONY: Commissioner Harmon SECOND:
Commissioner Slaughter.Passed:Unanimous voice vote.
RECOMMENDATION FOR OA-21-08 (Central Business District).MOTION: Commissioner
Harman that Case OA-21-08 be approved with the following conditions: beer,wine and cider
establishments be permitted in the Central Business District without being required to serve food
from within the establishment.That alternative food services such as food trucks or catered food
from local businesses be allowed instead.That the definition of"Live Entertainment"be revised to
2 nights per week.That staff reevaluates the expansion of the Central Business District's
boundaries.That reevaluation to be done with the City's Economic Developer,Destination
Caldwell,or the Chamber of Commerce.
SECOND: Commissioner Slaughter. Passed:Unanimous roll call vote.
Planning and Zoning comments/concerns:
Next Planning and Zoning Commission Scheduled Public Meeting Date: August 10, 2021.
Adjournment MOTION: Commissioner Hunsicker SECOND: Commissioner Harman.
The meeting was adjourned at approximately 9:10 p.m.
Page 15
Planning and Zoning Minutes
Respectfully submitted by Cindy Brogdon
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BY COMMISSIONER HUNSICKER ON THE DATE NOTED
BELOW:
?f)14/t------ q M. zi1
Betsy Hunsicker,Chair Date
ATTEST: / r
Jerome M. p, h it• or of Planning and Zoning
FOR DETAILED MINUTES,PLEASE REQUEST A COPY OF THE RECORDING.
Page 16
Planning and Zoning Minutes