HomeMy WebLinkAbout2021-05-26 CHPC Minutes CALDWELL HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MINUTES
Meeting of May 26,2021 @ 6:30 P.M.
Caldwell Police Department—Community Room
110 S 56 Avenue, Caldwell, Idaho
I. Call to order. Vice-Chairperson Lyons called the meeting to order at approAimately 6A
Q,s•F[OVED
II. Roll Call
Members Present. Randy Lyons, Megan Dixon, Tim King, and Sue Schap*Date 91-7 (Z t
Members Absent.Jacob King, Steve Maughan, and Nicole Bradshaw.
Others Present.Jerome Mapp, Planning&Zoning Director; and April Cabello, Planning Technician.
Others Absent. Rob Hopper, City Council Liaison.
III. Approval of Minutes. Action Item.
MOTION TO APPROVE THE MINUTES OF JANUARY 27, 2021.
MOTION Commissioner Dixon SECOND: Commissioner T. King, MOTION PASSED.
IV. Certificate of Appropriateness Interviews. None.
V. OLD BUSINESS: None.
VI. NEW BUSINESS: Discussion Items.
Historic Preservation updates.
Jerome Mapp, Planning and Zoning Director shared that there were a couple of things he
wanted to bring to the commission's attention. He had provided a sheet on the
Commission's duties, which he had given to all our boards and commissions. The purpose
of that was for the commission's application and to let the commission know that the
commission can set the agenda. The commission may conduct surveys, e.g. to restore and
preserve historic properties; and shared that the commission has a list of various duties.
Attending meetings and reviewing applications is good,but stated that it is not the only
thing that the commission can do. As your staff, we just want to make sure that the
commission understood that.
Mr. Mapp further stated that we could talk about in our future meetings about what kind of
projects we want to consider. In addition, he had finished the budget for FY 22. If the
commission had some type of project that it wanted to bring forward, we could do this for
next year. We could research to see how much the cost would be; we might go to City
Council to ask for some funding.
Mr. Mapp shared a flyer about the Idaho Odd Fellow Historical Society open house and
rededication of the building on July 31, and shared that he had visited the Canyon County
Historical Society museum.
Page 1 of 7 Caldwell Historic Preservation Minutes May 26, 2021
Commissioner Schaper asked what are the best resources to learn about the history of
Caldwell,where is our community history? We had a centennial. Is there a Centennial
book? Are there resources that she should be looking at to get up to speed?
Mr. Mapp stated the Comprehensive Plan is a good place to start and informed the
commission that he is working on updating the Comprehensive Plan and will have more
information regarding the historic history and information.
Commissioner Dixon shared that Jan Bowles, the former Archivist of the College of
Idaho, digitized for her at least four brochures from the first two decades of the 20th
century and made them into PDFs to share with students. They are useful information
about the very beginning of Caldwell. She thinks they all date from the era just before and
just after irrigation was introduced by the Boise Project and found this background
helpful. She also shared that Commissioner Maughan has often mentioned the book Big
Trouble about the history of Caldwell, the history of the murder of Governor Steunenberg.
She will figure out a way to share the files since they should be in the City's records.
Mr. Mapp suggested having these items as links on the Historic Preservation web page.
Commissioner Schaper shared that she would like information on when Caldwell was
founded and the deep history of Caldwell because then the commission can do all kinds of
things. The commission can add more walking tours, alert people to histories of different
communities who have been here,but may have not been acknowledged because maybe
the homes they lived in were not the elaborate,beautiful ones that we all like to admire.
She shared that she walks around and all she sees is a surface.
Commissioner Dixon stated that it reminds her of a project the commission had been
discussing before the pandemic,which is to get a history major,perhaps at the College of
Idaho,to record interviews with our local historian Chuck Randolph. He is basically one
of those living repositories of so much information. That might be something that that the
commission could look at, again, for this fall. The commission also talked about having
the new US historian supervise the student, maybe do an independent study, one of those
things that that could give the students some experience and also benefit the historic
knowledge of the city.
Commissioner Dixon asked what areas of Caldwell have been surveyed and where are
more areas that are historic because it seems like there will be development pressure
coming.
Mr. Mapp asked what the commission would like to accomplish in 2022.
Commissioner T. King, shared that he had done research on the North Caldwell Historic
District, it is actually under the State Historic District jurisdiction and not the City of
Caldwell,but he would like to see the commission try to acquire that under the City of
Caldwell's jurisdiction and also the downtown historic area. There is a lot of development
going on in the downtown, and he would like to see the commission have a voice.
Commissioner T. King addressed one of the questions about finding information on
Caldwell. When he was researching the North Caldwell Historic District,he ran into a
database and he believed it was at the University of Idaho that has a lot of information on
history and specifically the North Caldwell Historic District,which has a rich history, and
Page 2 of 7 Caldwell Historic Preservation Minutes May 26, 2021
many connections with the college. William Boone the first preacher at the Presbyterian
Church had a house and it is still there. Commissioner T. King shared that he had done a
streetscape work plan labeled N. Caldwell Historic District Streetscape Improvement Plan
and he thought maybe the commission could present it to City Council to see if the
commission could get funding for the project. He felt the streetscape would add to the
district. The church is still in good shape. The Presbyterian Parsonage House is still in
good shape,the two houses on the corner are nice. The William Isaacs House is a nice
house;unfortunately,the Blatchley House and the Boone House have been converted into
apartments. All these houses were built in the 1890s.The homes were actually a part of
the original town site. He stated that he would like to do a little bit more research on what
actually took place there. It is important that the commission try to keep the houses that
are still in fairly good shape.
Commissioner Dixon shared that the Isaacs house was restored when Chuck Randolph
was still on the commission. The commission had a fair amount of discussion about that.
Chuck Randolph knows this neighborhood so that is a great reason to try to catch him.
Commissioner Dixon's recollection is that the college has some things in the archives that
would describe some of these things. She remembered seeing something about the
Caldwells. It would be good to gather these things together and at least make a
bibliography, if not collect a digitized version.
April Cabello, Planning Technician, stated for the record that she believed that the
commission was asked by the owners of the Isaacs House to hear the case even though it
was not required,because it is not a local district. They wished to have the Commission's
blessing on what they were doing.
Mr. Mapp shared that he talked to the City of Boise's Historic Preservation Planner and he
volunteered to come out and speak to our commission when we want him to come. The
commission should make a list of what they want to do for the next 20 years. The
commission needs a direction and together, we can make a difference in the community
with Historic Preservation.
Commissioner Schaper said one reason why she brought up a deeper understanding of the
history of Caldwell is that if this body wants to include more neighborhoods as historic
neighborhoods, she suspects neighborhood approval is often an issue. If the seed has
already been sown of making people aware of what they have,whether it is the history of
their place, or understanding architectural styles, and nifty things, they already start to
develop a sense of awareness and pride. When she is walking her dogs, she thinks there is
actually a lot of cool mid-century modern stuff in Caldwell. There must be names for
these features. What are ways to communicate that to the public before a neighborhood
might be absorbed. She receives Caldwell Perspectives and they have articles now and
then on architectural styles, it is a good way to start getting people saying,that is my
house or that is my neighborhood. So that if the commission does start to incorporate more
neighborhoods,people might be more invested if they have already started to value it
rather than persuading people to value it when the looming threat of absorption in historic
neighborhoods seems to be on the horizon.
Vice-Chair Lyons thanked Mr. Mapp, Commissioner T. King for all the information, and
the commission's comments. It helps the commission to refocus after this period of the
COVID, the commission has not had an opportunity to take action, go out and be
Page 3 of 7 Caldwell Historic Preservation Minutes May 26, 2021
productive,or proactive. As Mr. Mapp asked the commission what accomplishments they
wanted for 2022, April Cabello has also asked the commission what is our focus for this
year. What is our objective,how can we make this commission better? So many
wonderful parts of Caldwell are being rediscovered. To have an intern or a student in the
College of Idaho take that project on, would be such a productive product that we could
integrate into our commission into what our objectives are.
Mr. Mapp thanked Vice-Chair Lyons and the commission and stated that he sees good
things coming.
Mr. Mapp shared that May is Historic Preservation month and that is something the
commission can plan for next year. Depending on what the commission choose to do.
They can start small,but it could grow every year.
Caldwell Perspective.
Vice-Chair Lyons stated that he talked with Chantelle of the Caldwell Perspective about
possibly contributing articles to their paper. He explained to Chantelle that it is the
commission's plan to provide a story every month about a historical site in in a district,
have a picture of a home with permission of the homeowners,with a historical note or
story of who lived there. Information on the original occupants or maybe the lineage of
people who have gone through the homes,because there are homes, in our district,that
one famous person after another has lived there, and integrated themselves into our
community. Chantelle of the Caldwell Perspective was very excited and there is no cost
for the stories. Chantelle asked the commission to stay away from the Steunenberg
assassination, as it will be a story given by someone else and asked how soon the story
could be submitted. Vice-Chair Lyon stated it would be fall, or maybe this summer if we
have the help from the intern from the College of Idaho. Vice-Chair Lyon asked for
someone to spearhead this project.
Commissioner Dixon shared that the College of Idaho archivist retired and has not been
replaced. The archival material is in boxes in the library basement. It would be slightly
challenging,but they did tell us that they marked all the boxes. Perhaps something for a
student or an interested community member who has time? She felt that would be of
mutual benefit to the city and the college.
Commissioner Dixon suggested that at the next meeting, the commission start making a
list. She felt the idea of interns this fall would be a great step.
Review Fencing Ordinance.
April Cabello shared with the commission that the reason why fencing is on the agenda
was she had a few questions on the fencing ordinance regarding staff level review. The
way the ordinance currently reads is that wrought iron or picket fence does not require a
Certificate of Appropriateness. It is staff's understanding that a six-food,wood wing
fence, as long as it was behind or flush with the front side of the home to the back of the
home, did not require a certificate of appropriateness. Staff wanted to confirm with the
commission that was the commission's understanding.
Page 4 of 7 Caldwell Historic Preservation Minutes May 26, 2021
Commissioner Dixon shared a historical commentary, and maybe a reason why this is a
good thing to bring up. We might not finish it tonight and it seems like it would be better
if the all commissioners could be present. One of the reasons she thought about this and
brought it up sometimes over the past few years is that in the community, a fair amount of
confusion exists as to what is appropriate, even according to city code. The commission
has had cases, multiple times,where they have had to go to residents and point out to them
that their fences do not conform, not even to historic preservation district requirements,
but simply the city code. That often has to do with a setback, sometimes has to do with
wanting a six-foot fence to face the street. Sometimes what people do rather than look at
code is drive around the neighborhood and see fences that were grandfathered in,because
they were built in a certain way before the code was established. People look at it and
think they can do the same thing. Most homeowners have been quite cooperative,but it is
important to continue thinking about how the public gets the information,particularly in
this district about what is appropriate for fencing,because wooden fences will tend to
decay at some point,people want to replace them, and so forth. A minor or a subcategory
is houses that had a chain link around them when the district was created. If anyone goes
to replace chain link, according to code it may not be replaced with a chain link fence.
April Cabello responded, if it is just a repair. Depending on the level of repair. If the
homeowner is actually removing it, then no, they cannot replace it.
Commissioner Dixon stated it is a persisting concern, which she thinks is worth the full
commission discussing and the director weighing in, and perhaps Councilman Hopper.
However, some homeowners have put in fences, and then come to the commission after
the fact. The question is how hard the commission Should push back. In what situation
does the commission care enough? Commissioner Dixon thought the commission has had
recourse to the city's legal staff, and that sometimes has not been fully effective, or it has
created some contention. It is worth looking through the fencing ordinance. What does the
commission think is in the best interest of the district?
April Cabello shared that the Steunenberg Historic District Fencing Code has been
changed,that the finished side of the fence(happy side)to be facing out was added to the
code. The current fencing code reads, corner homes in the district can have a six-foot
fence,but it has to be set back five feet from the existing sidewalk and has to be out of that
40-foot vision triangle. With new commission members, it would be good to have a
discussion on fencing and at what point, it needs to come to the commission for a
certificate of appropriateness. What level should it be appropriate for staff level approval?
It would be a good discussion item on a future agenda, or we could put it as an action
item, if the commissioners wanted to discuss and vote. That way,the commission has the
option to review the fencing code and make changes. It is not something that has to be
done right away. It could be in a month or two and give the commission a chance to
review the current fencing code.
Commissioner Dixon stated for the record her recollection, as part of the commission is
that we had asked a homeowner to lower the height of the fence, according to the
guidelines. Her understanding is the homeowner has not yet lowered the fence,but did not
know whether that mattered, in that particular case. Does the commission really need that
to change? It would be worth discussing, when staff should get to say, okay, you could do
it that way and when should the commission discuss it. Would that affect the guidelines?
Would it affect the ordinance,but what is the line that the commission wants to hold?Just
Page 5 of 7 Caldwell Historic Preservation Minutes May 26, 2021
•
for the sake of conversation, her impulse would be clear sight line down axis streets (that
is,Dearborn, Everett, Fillmore).That would be her vote if she still had one. She looked
through the fencing code before coming this evening and tried to picture what do each of
these mean and what have we sometimes seen in requests for new fences or changes. She
guesses the one thing that certainly sticks out is that many people are kind of pushing for
more privacy in their yards, which often is going to mean requests for six feet fencing.
Where do you allow the six-foot fence, where do you hold the line on it not being six feet,
if it is a new fence?
Mr. Mapp suggested putting information on the Historic Preservation website, and at least
guide applicants. Either some language or some type of direction.
April Cabello stated that the way the code is right now,if it is a corner lot, and the request
is for a six-foot fencing that is not wrought iron, it would come before the commission for
review. The questions that have come up is on the wing fence on the interior lot line.
Maybe the commission could come to an agreement again on at what point is that staff
level approval. The way code reads now,the six foot fence,the commission would not
have a say on that what they do have a say is on the"solid"six foot fence. The
commission would have a say on the style or material of that fence. Per current code,the
setback is five feet on a corner lot from the sidewalk.
April Cabello shared that a while ago the commission decided the fencing code was
getting too confusing with the normal city fencing codes being different from the
Steunenberg Residential fencing code. The commission decided to mirror the city fencing
code on a corner lot. A corner lot has an option to do a four-foot fence outside of the
vision triangle or a three-foot fence and it can go up to the sidewalk. Alternatively,they
can do a six-foot fence but have to be five feet in off the sidewalk and out of the 40ft
vision triangle.
Commissioner Dixon confirmed it is more the material and the style of the fencing that the
commission would review.
April Cabello further shared that vinyl and chain link fencing is not allowed in the
Steunenberg District. If the applicant wants to do fencing other than wrought iron,they
have to come to the commission. Wood has been approved, and per code wrought iron and
picket fencing is approved.
Commissioner Dixon stated that as with many things,making sure as part of the work of
the commission that we clarify exactly whether the presented design is intended to be
executed or as a sample has proved to be useful. To clarify, make sure that they are not
just showing us a nice picture,but that it is exactly what is planned, which helps to
alleviate misunderstandings later.
April Cabello stated that when the commission votes on a fencing case the commission
may put condition with their approval. The commission can specify exactly what is
approved. It is best that the commission states when they are approving the case, the exact
type of fence, exact type of design and exact type of material. That way, it is in the
minutes, it is in the in the record. It will also be placed on the certificate of
appropriateness.
Page 6 of 7 Caldwell Historic Preservation Minutes May 26, 2021
April Cabello stated that she would add the topic of fencing a future agenda for more
discussion.
Review Gutter requirements.
April Cabello shared that in the Historic Preservation code, it does not discuss gutters.
With the bad weather and windstorms this year, we are getting many homeowners that are
asking about gutters. Not having gutters is a hazard for the house and the weather can
damage. Is staff level approval okay for gutters. Homeowners should not have to wait for
a month or two before being heard by the commission for something as simple as gutters.
Staff would update the decision matrix.
April Cabello stated that she would make sure to add fencing, gutters, and the decision
matrix to one of the future Historic Preservation agendas.
Commission & Staff Reports. None.
VII. Meeting adjourned at approximately 7:45 p.m.
Respectfully submitted by April Cabello,
MINUTES APP'OVED AND SIGNED BELOW BY CHAIRMAN KING ON THE DATE NOTED BELOW.
/.1 . _A l t'11/21
Vice-Chaim i s i Date
,/
//����..�� #1 //--2-1
ATTEST. erome Mapp, Pla .ng Dir:'tor Date
For detailed minutes, please request a copy of the digital recording.
Page 7 of 7 Caldwell Historic Preservation Minutes May 26, 2021