HomeMy WebLinkAbout2021-06-08 Planning & Zoning Commission Minutes CITY OF CALDWELL
CALDWELL PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION MINUTES
Community Room, Caldwell Police Department
110 South 5th Avenue,Caldwell,Idaho
June 8,2021,Regular Meeting 7:00 P.M.
APPROVED 1
Regular Meeting—7:00 p.m. Cj
Call to Order—Betsy Hunsicker called the meeting to order at 7:03 p.m Date 9(712_1
Roll Call—
Members Present: Betsy Hunsicker,Shawn Harman,Brett Slaughter,Alex Zamora
Members Absent:Jim Nelson
Staff Present: Jerome Mapp,Director;Robb MacDonald,City Engineer;Kate Phillips,Associate
Planner;Lori Colligan,Associate Planner,Cindy Brogdon,Administrative Assistant
Staff Absent:Debbie Root, Senior Planner
Others Present:
Review of Proceedings-
CONSENT CALENDAR:
1. Approve minutes of the March 30,2021 regular meeting with amendment for minor spelling
correction on page 2.
MOTION: Commissioner Zamora.SECOND: Commissioner Harman.Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
2. Approve minutes of the rill 3,2021 regular meeting with amendment to correct title for Kate
Phillips to Associate Planner.
MOTION: Commissioner Zamora. SECOND: Commissioner Harman.Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Old Business: N/A
New Business:
1. Case Number OA-21-04:A request by the Planning and Zoning
Department adding a new Article 15 to Chapter 10, of the Caldwell City Code, regarding the
development of Multi-Family Housing,
Testimony:Betsy Hunsicker stated this case is being continued to a date to be determined.
MOTION: Commissioner Harman. SECOND: Commissioner Zamora.Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
2. Case Number OA-21-05:A request by the Planning and Zoning Department amending
Page I 1
Planning and Zoning Minutes
Chapter 12 Article 05-3M, of the Caldwell City Code,regarding Placement of Nonpermanent
Items in City Center Design Requirements with a new designation"Outdoor Seating".
Testimony:Betsy Hunsicker stated this case is being continued to a date to be determined.
MOTION: Commissioner Harman SECOND:Zamora.Passed:Unanimous roll call vote.
3. Case Number SUB21-000009: A request by Ted Burke on behalf of Hall
Investments, LP for a Preliminary Plat for Cloud Gate Industrial Park, consisting of 12
buildable lots and 1 common lot,with a private road in an"M-1"(Light Industrial)zone. The
subject property is located on East Chicago Street adjacent and east of 2419 E. Chicago Street,
Caldwell, Idaho.
Testimony:Betsy Hunsicker stated this case is being continued to 6/29/2021.
MOTION: Commissioner Harman SECOND: Zamora.Passed:Unanimous roll call vote.
4. Case Number OA-21-03: A request by Virjon Brahimllari for an amendment to the Zoning
Ordinance Chapter 10,Article 13, Section 3 regarding land use; to allow for Automotive Sales in the T-
N(Traditional Neighborhood).
Testimony:
Ms.Katie Phillips,Associate Planner,621 Cleveland Blvd.,Caldwell,Idaho stated the applicant owns
property addressed as 300 E. Frontage Road. Recently,the applicant was informed that the tenant
currently occupying the property and operating a daycare will not pursue renewing a lease.
The applicant reached out to the City regarding a new business venture for the site and inquired as to
whether he could operate a Used Automotive Sales lot on his property. Mr.Brahimllari indicated that he
has a background in auto mechanics and sales and would like to operate a used car business at his
property located in the T-N(Traditional Neighborhood)zone.
Automotive sales is not a permitted use in the T-N(Traditional Neighborhood)zone. As Mr.
Brahimllari pointed out to staff,there are other permitted uses in the T-N zone that create more impact to
the surrounding area Staff recognizes that this is the case,however,theusecurrently is not allowed and
staff is not in support of the request.
Jerome Mapp,Director of Planning&Zoning at 621 Cleveland Blvd,Caldwell,Idaho stated that if
allowed,then this type of usage would have to be allowed in all areas with Traditional Neighborhood
classification.The City did not want this type of use in the Traditional Neighborhood zoning
classification.Traditional Neighborhood also consists of the area around County Courthouse and County
offices.
Commissioner Hunsicker:What zones are automotive sales allowed?
Ms.Katie Phillips: Auto Sales are allowed in C-3 Service Commercial and M-1 Light Industrial zoning
classifications.
Virjon Brahimllori,(Applicant)at 11098 W.Abram Dr.Boise,ID 83714. Stated that this property is
next to the freeway.With current zoning,he would be allowed to have an auto shop with air compressors
and impact guns going all day long.He is not allowed to have autos sitting on a lot with 10-12 customers
coming by daily.The current daycare has about 60 daily drive-by. The dealership cars would be kept
clean and no auto shop with noise would be on site.These are not broken down cars but clean cars ready
for sale.In the summer we would like to hold barbeques and movies at the back of the building for the
Page I2
Planning and Zoning Minutes
. ' community.The site allows between 25-30 cars maximum.It is not a large dealership and would not
create traffic.
Commissioner Slaughter asked if there a fence between this property and the park.
Virjon Brahimllori stated that there currently is no fence that separates the property from the park.There
is an Auto Shop on the same frontage road at the corner.
Hugo Arriaga,(Opposition)at 316 E. Galveston St.Caldwell,Idaho stated that he disagrees with this
becoming a dealership for the following reasons:Number 1,the proximity of the dealership to the park.
Many children play daily in the park.The daycare does have a lot of traffic,but they are also families.
Customers to the dealership are strangers to the neighborhood and would be in close proximity to the
children at the park.Number two,is that this dealership would decrease the value of homes in the area.
Virjon Brahimllori stated that the daycare was eventually going to close.The dealership would bring in
less traffic,noise and customers than other businesses allowed in T-N zoning.There will be two parking
spots for customers.
MOTION TO CLOSE PUBLIC TESTIMONY: Commissioner Zamora SECOND: Commissioner
Harman Passed:Unanimous roll call vote.
Commissioner Zamora stated concerns of this specific action to change the entire ordinance.This will not
only affect this neighborhood, but it will have implications to other neighborhoods. I am not in favor of
amending that ordinance.
Commissioner Harman stated that he agrees.. If you do that, you can open yourself up to putting it
everywhere. -
Commissioner Slaughter stated when we drive-to Boise from here. You can see all the frontage roads.
There is a slew of businesses even dealerships.He wonders if this is pushing off the inevitable.The other
thing is that he does not.like picking and choosing which businesses can operate. When you have
automotive shop repair shop versus a dealership.
Commissioner Hi nsicker stated that this feels like a very one off action.Maybe there is an opportunity in
the-future-to look-at the alloweduses-andevaluate;if-it-make sense-to-have-anauto-shop-inthe-traditional--
neighborhood zone.
Commissioner Hunsicker stated that she is not sure this is the time to address this based on kind of a one
off need. She does not think that one person's request on one lot is the right place. She feels like the land
use needs some cleanup.
Commissioner Slaughter questioned why a variance was not requested.
Commissioner Hunsicker stated that a variance could not be requested,as it is not an allowed land use.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis: The Caldwell Planning and Zoning Commission accepts the
Comprehensive Plan components as listed in 5.1 and 5.2.MOTION:Commissioner Nelson.SECOND:
Commissioner Zamora.Passed: Unanimous voice vote.
Findings of Fact: The Caldwell Planning and Zoning Commission accepts the Findings of Facts
components as listed and the evidence list. MOTION: Commissioner Nelson SECOND:Commissioner
Zamora. Passed:Unanimous voice vote.
Page I 3
Planning and Zoning Minutes
Conclusions of Law: The Caldwell Planning and Zoning Commission accepts the Conclusions of Law
components as listed. MOTION: Commissioner Nelson. SECOND: Commissioner Zamora. Passed:
Unanimous voice vote.
RECOMMENDATION FOR OA-21-03(Ordinance Amendment)MOTION:Commissioner Zamora
that Case OA-21-03 be denied. SECOND: Commissioner Slaughter.Passed:Unanimous roll call vote.
5. Case Number SUP21-000004 (Continued from Hearing Examiner meeting 5/25/2021):
A request by Madeline Gregg on behalf of Thomas Development for a special use permit for
Norfolk Apartments, an 86 unit,multi-family housing development consisting of 5.8 acres on
parcel R35373013 zoned C-3 (Service Commercial). The parcel is located approximately 750'
southeast of the intersection of 21'Avenue and Chicago Street.
Testimony:
Ms.Katie Phillips,Associate Planner,621 Cleveland Blvd.,Caldwell,Idaho stated The applicant is
requesting special use permit approval for Norfolk Apartments, consisting of 86 residential housing units
on 5.8 acres located approximately 750'southeast of the intersection of Chicago Street and 21st Avenue.
The subject property is zoned C-3(Service Commercial).
Jerome Mapp,Director Planning&Zoning, 621 Cleveland Blvd.,Caldwell,Idaho stated this particular
project is near a number of services.We recommend approval of this project because it is adjacent to
existing services.
Andy Erstad,Applicant 310 N. 5th St.Boise, ID stated we are in agreement with the staffs findings of fact,
conditions of approval or recommended conditions of approval. With one exception,and that is,as we
read the report,it reads as though this is a subdivision or a project development that will go through
subdivision.Which delays the submittal of building permits.
Tom Mannschreck,Developer,420 W.Main Boise,Idaho stated that the timeframe for applying for
building permits would hinder their ability to remain affordable housing due to the escalating lumber
prices.Requested simultaneous submission of building permits.
•
Rabb McDonald,city_of fild3ellEugineer at 621 Cleveland Blvd„Caldwgll,_Idaho stated .t_thertere_.._.
real concerns with not following the current process.
After much discussion between staff,the applicant and Planning and Zoning Commission members,Mr.
Mapp suggested the Commission could approve the request with the condition that the applicant will
work with staff regarding the sequence of submitting for building permits and meeting all necessary
deadlines. The Planning and Zoning Commission was in approval of that recommendation.
MOTION TO CLOSE PUBLIC TESTIMONY: Commissioner Zamora SECOND: Slaughter.Passed:
Unanimous voice vote.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis: The Caldwell Planning and Zoning Commission accepts the
Comprehensive Plan components as listed in 5.1 and 5.2. MOTION: Commissioner Zamora. SECOND:
Commissioner Slaughter.Passed: Unanimous voice vote.
Findings of Fact:The Caldwell Planning and Zoning Commission accepts the Findings of Facts
components as listed and the evidence list. MOTION: Commissioner Zamora SECOND:Commissioner
Slaughter. Passed: Unanimous voice vote.
Page 14
Planning and Zoning Minutes
• Conclusions of Law: The Caldwell Planning and Zoning Commission accepts the Conclusions of Law
components as listed. MOTION: Commissioner Zamora. SECOND: Commissioner Slaughter. Passed:
Unanimous voice vote.
RECOMMENDATION FOR SUP21-000004 (Special Use Permit).MOTION: Commissioner
Zamora that Case SUP21-000004 be approved with the following conditions: 8.2 through 8.8 with the
following modification to exhibit PA-1: Building permit section will strike item number one and replace
it with"the applicant will work in good faith with staff to determine sequence of all plans necessary to
meet necessary deadlines"SECOND: Commissioner Slaughter.Passed:Unanimous roll call vote.
Planning and Zoning comments/concerns:
Next Planning and Zoning Commission Scheduled Public Meeting Date:June 29,2021.
Adjournment MOTION: Commissioner Harman. SECOND:Commissioner Zamora.
The meeting was adjourned at approximately 8:46 p.m.
Respectfully submitted by Cindy Brogdon
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BY COMMISSIONER NELSON ON THE DATE NOTED
BELOW:
(1-11/ 1/11 AC1 [74
Betsy Hunsicker,Chair Date
ATTEST: /v
Jerome Mapp, Dt ector • Planning and Zoning
FOR DETAILED MINUTES,PLEASE REQUEST A COPY OF THE RECORDING.
Page 15
Planning and Zoning Minutes