HomeMy WebLinkAbout2021-01-27 CHPC Minutes CALDWELL HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MINUTES
Meeting of January 27,2021 @ 6:30 P.M.
Caldwell Police Department—Community Room APPROVED
110 S 5th Avenue, Caldwell,Idaho
I. Call to order. Chairperson King called the meeting to order at approximaJttg:35 p.m. (,121 I Z_�
II. Roll Call
Members Present. Jacob King, in person and via zoom Megan Dixon, Randy Lyons, Nicole Bradshaw,
Steve Maughan and Tim King.
Members Absent.None.
Others Present. Jerome Mapp, Planning & Zoning Director; and April Cabello, Planning Technician in
person and via zoom Rob Hopper, City Council Liaison.
Others Absent. None.
HI. Approval of Minutes.
MOTION TO APPROVE THE MINUTES OF NOVEMBER 11, 2020.
MOTION Commissioner Maughan SECOND: Commissioner Lyons,MOTION PASSED.
IV. Certificate of Appropriateness Interviews.
Action Item: Case Number CA-20-14 Applicant: Shawna Rust and Mike Mussell of Mussell
Construction, 1918 Blaine Street, Caldwell, ID.A request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to
build an addition to the rear of the existing house. The site is located at 1918 Blaine Street,
Caldwell, ID within the Steunenberg Residential Historic District.
April Cabello, Planning Technician, 621 Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell,ID presented the staff report.
Ms. Cabello shared with the commission that the applicant desires to receive a Certificate of
Appropriateness from the Historic Preservation Commission to build a 343 square foot addition to
the rear of the existing house. The addition will be a master bed and bath for the applicant's elderly
parents.
Ms. Cabello gave background on the application and shared that this application is before the
commission because the addition will be partially visible from Blaine Street. The subject property
was included in the National Register Recommendation Survey in 1999.The 1999 survey
documented the subject property with an estimated construction date of 1910; the style was
Vernacular/Arts&Crafts Brackets,the plan was Rectangular/Bungalow and the house was
listed as contributing in a potential district. The 1999 survey noted to be in fair condition with
asbestos siding,wood porch posts, wood brackets. The comments made on the survey stated that
the porch was enclosed; large windows in front; retains enough character-defining features for it to
contribute to a potential district.The applicant is seeking approval to build an addition to rear of
the home. The existing home is 1016 square feet and is 23 feet in height; the proposed addition
will be 343 square feet.The applicant will be required to meet all setback and building
requirements. Ms. Cabello further shared the surrounding homes are of various sizes.
Page 1 of 4
•
• Shawna Rust, 1918 Blaine Street,applicant, stated she purchased the home in the fall of last year
and her parents are living in an assisted living facility. She would like to have the opportunity to
bring her parents home with her and that is why they are doing the addition to the back of the
house.
Mike Mussell,PO Box 3304,Nampa, ID,Mussell Construction,applicant's representative
explained that this home is a craftsman style home and the hope is to go out the back side so they
do not interfere with the original design of the home. They will take the back bedroom and add a
little bit more space so there is a sitting room and a large master bath with accessibility for the
parents so they can access the tub and shower.By adding onto the back,they will keep with the
rectangular shape,meeting the setback requirements.They will match the exact siding,corbels and
white vinyl windows.It will be a good match to what was built back in 1910.Mr.Mussell shared
that they will build a wood ramp in the back and meet the current code and this will make it easier
for the parents to access the main level of the house.
Commissioner Dixon asked the applicant to verify the square feet of the addition.
Mr.Mussell confirmed the addition is 343 square feet.
Chairman King asked if the rafters would be exposed and have some of the wooden brackets
matching the existing home.
Mr.Mussell responded yes they would match the home almost identical.
Commissioner Dixon asked staff and the applicant's representative if the changes are visible from
Blaine.
Ms.Cabello responded yes.
Commissioner Dixon stated the visibility will be minimal and appreciated the application coming
before the commission. She further shared that if it were not visible,this would have been a staff
level approval.
Mr.Mussell responded that the addition would match; the addition will be difficult to see from the
street.
Commissioner Maughan thanked the applicant for the clarity,the architectural drawings and the
thoroughness of the application.
Chairman King closed the public testimony.
FINDINGS OF FACT
5.1 The Historic Preservation Commission accepts the staff report and the evidence list(consisting
of the written and verbal staff report,public testimony,the case file, and the sign-up sheets)
and facts brought forward during public testimony.
The Historic Preservation Commission further finds the following:
02-17-11: FINDINGS FOR GRANTING A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS:
(1) The commission shall review application(s)with the findings outlined below as pertaining to
the request for a certificate of appropriateness.The commission may attach conditions of
approval to the application to ensure compliance with the findings. Modifications to the
Page 2 of 4
•
• application may be submitted and will be considered at a staff level. In reviewing the
modification,planning staff will utilize the original findings under which the application was
reviewed to ensure the project still complies with the requirements for a certificate of
appropriateness. (Ord. 3126, 1-16-2018)
(2) The commission shall find that the design of the project is consistent with the following plans
and guidelines that apply to the property:
A. U.S. Secretary of the Interior's standards for rehabilitation and guidelines for rehabilitating
historic buildings.
B. Chapter 10 of this Code,as amended and adopted by City Council.
C. Steunenberg Residential Historic District design guidelines,as amended and adopted
(copies available in the Caldwell Planning and Zoning Department).
D. City of Caldwell Comprehensive Plan,as amended and adopted by City Council.(Ord.
2905,9-4-2012)
02-17-11-01:ALTERATIONS; FINDINGS:
(1) The commission's decision in regard to certificates of appropriateness for alterations shall be
based on the following findings as applicable to that property or request and as they relate to
historic preservation:
A.That the request is consistent with the Steunenberg Residential Historic District
design guidelines.The commission finds this to be true.
B.That the request is consistent with the Secretary of the Interior's standards for rehabilitation
and guidelines for rehabilitating historic buildings.The commission finds this to be true.
C.That the request supports the goals,policies,and recommendations of the City of Caldwell's
Comprehensive Plan and the plans referenced therein.The commission finds this to be true.
D.That based on the adopted design guidelines the request will not be incongruous with the
historical,architectural,archeological,educational,or cultural aspects of the local
district.The commission finds this to be true.
E.That the request complies with the dimensional standards and other applicable requirements
of chapter 10 of this code including,but not limited to, setbacks,height restrictions and
parking requirements,unless the commission finds that modifying those standards is
necessary to protect the overall characteristics of the local district and to comply with the
adopted design guidelines. (Ord.2905, 9-4-2012)The commission finds this to be true.
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
6.1 The Historic Preservation Commission has the authority to hear this case and order that it be
approved or denied.The public notice requirements were met and the hearing was conducted
within the guidelines of applicable Idaho Code and City ordinances.
ORDER OF DECISION
7.1 Based on the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law,the Caldwell Historic Preservation
Commission hereby orders that Case Number CA-20-14,a request by Shawna Rust and Mike
Mussell of Mussell Construction for a Certificate of Appropriateness to build a 343 square
foot addition to the rear of the home located at 1918 Blaine Street is APPROVED.
MOTION: Commissioner Dixon SECOND: Commissioner Bradshaw
PASSED:unanimous voice vote
V. OLD BUSINESS:None.
Page 3 of 4
VI. NEW BUSINESS: •
Action Item: Vote Chair and Vice-Chair for 2021.
Commissioner Maughan made the motion to appoint Jacob King as Chair.
MOTION: Commissioner Maughan SECOND: Commissioner Bradshaw
PASSED: unanimous voice vote
Commissioner Dixon made the motion to appoint Randy Lyons as Vice-Chair.
MOTION: Commissioner Dixon SECOND: Commissioner Maughan
PASSED: unanimous voice vote
Discussion Item: Commission& Staff Reports.
• Mr.Mapp introduced Tim King the newest member of the commission and shared that the
following commissioners had been re-appointed, Randy Lyons and Steve Maughan with a
term to expire December 31, 2023.
• Ms. Cabello shared that there will be no meeting on February 24, 2021.
VII. Meeting adjourned at approximately 7:30 p.m.
Respectfully submitted by April Cabello,
MINUTES APPROV D AND♦ SIGNED BELOW BY CHAIRMAN KING ON THE DATE NOTED BELOW.
,// j -Z6 262 /
Chairman - _ 51/ Date
A � 11�J • . C- Cc-t n 01 L, l 6
A ' : Jer. : ia'
"'�►� '' • g Director Date
For detailed minutes,please request a copy of the digital recording.
Page 4 of 4