HomeMy WebLinkAbout2021-03-23 Hearing Examiner Minutes APPROVED
Regular Caldwell Hearing Examiner Minutes �y �,
Tuesday,March 23,2021, 7:00 p.m. Cy `- AJL-rl,
Community Room, Caldwell Police Department Date ( 1 ( a
110 South 5th Avenue,Caldwell,Idaho
Call to Order- Hearing Examiner, Mr. Bruce Eggleston opened the meeting for the public
hearing at 7:00 p.m.
II. Review of Proceedings- Mr. Bruce Eggleston outlined the procedures for the public
hearing.
Members Present: Robb MacDonald (City Engineer); Debbie Root(Senior Planner); Katie
Phillips (Associate Planner); Lori Colligan (Administrative Assistant)
Members Absent:
III. Consent Calendar:
1) Old Business:
1. Case Number PUD-21P-01: A request by Gary McAllister,on behalf of C.L.J
Holdings,for a Planned Unit Development(Infill) and a preliminary plat for Oregon
Commons,a single-family residential development in an R-1 (Low Density Residential)
zone on parcel's R35423000, R35404000 and R35401000 containing 1.86 acres. The
proposed subdivision consists of 9 single-family lots.The 2040 Comprehensive Plan
designates this property as Low Density Residential. The subject property is located
480 feet north of the intersection of Ash Street and Oregon Avenue, Caldwell,ID.
Testimony:
Ms. Debbie Root,Senior Planner, 621 Cleveland Blvd.,Caldwell, ID stated the applicant is
requesting a Planned Unit Development(Infill) and a preliminary plat for Oregon Commons,
a single-family residential development in an R-1 (Low Density Residential) zone on parcels
R35423 (0.84 ac), R35404 (0.66 ac), and R35401(0.35 ac)totaling 1.86 acres. The proposed
subdivision consists of nine (9) single-family lots and one (1) common lot. The 2040
Comprehensive Plan designates this property as Low Density Residential. This
development is under the density allowed. The subject property is located 480 feet north of
the intersection of Ash Street and Oregon Avenue,Caldwell, ID. Staff recommends approval
of this project.
Mr. Eggleston asked about the side yard setbacks,did the applicant asked for a possible 0
setback for detached units.
Ms. Root stated that was correct.
Mr. Eggleston asked what the building requirements are for this setback?
1
Hearing Examiner Minutes 03/23/2021
Ms. Root stated during the building permit process it will be determined if they will need a
fire barrier or sprinkled units.
Mr. Eggleston asked if the fire marshal has made any specific recommendation for fire
separation.
Ms. Root stated he stands with current code and will look at fire hydrant placement.
Mr. Eggleston asked what minimum separation is between units that are not 0 setback.
Ms. Root stated the building official requires structures to be 10 ft from the property line or
have firewall construction. Construction must meet code based upon fire separation
distance.
Mr.Gary McAllister, (applicant) 2115 E Bowstring St., Meridian, Idaho stated Deb did a good
job on the presentation. This is a good infill project. He thinks there are a lot of people that
would like to sell their house and stay in Idaho.The HOA will take care of the frontage of the
units.
Mr. Eggleston asked if there will be fencing around the project.
Mr. McAllister stated they haven't narrowed that down yet.
Ms.Carolyn Rees, (Neutral) 25525 Ustick Road, Caldwell, Idaho, owner of 1924 Oregon
Avenue. She stated this is a one-block street with a small house and not much frontage. She
would hope sidewalks would not be put in as it would take away from the lot. It's hard to
tell what this will look like from the drawing. Will the entire street be full of other people's
cars?What will they do with the RV's? She's not sure how they will determine who the
buyers are. It seems congested.
Mr.Trenidy Eccles, (Neutral) 1924 Oregon St., Caldwell, ID stated he is not opposed to new
development. Adding sidewalks would reflect poorly to the houses already there. They
should be reimbursement for taking the frontage of those properties if they do that. If the 3
ft.setback is passed,can he also have that same right? He had a petition written up and the
original agreement was for 4 houses not 9 and he isn't sure if he has seen that. He is not
opposed to a few houses and upgrading the houses that are there. If this approved does he
have the same rights,what requirements will they be held to?
Mr. Eggleston stated as far as his property he has to follow the code for him.This project
will meet the requirements for this project.
Ms.Audra Eccles, (Neutral) 1924 Oregon St.,Caldwell, ID stated she strongly disagrees with
9 buildings going up. It wouldn't look comfortable with the rest of the neighborhood. To
stack 9 homes doesn't seem appealing.Traffic is a concern to her. She isn't sure about the
yards.
2
Hearing Examiner Minutes 03/23/2021
Mr. David Routt, (opposed) 1824 Idaho Ave.,Caldwell, ID stated he wanted to confirm he
had received the petition.
Mr. Eggleston stated yes, it is part of the record.
Mr. Routt stated he had planned for this area to be open pasture land for the community.
He doesn't want them to destroy the peaceful community. In addition to these concerns
there has been little communication with the neighbors. In the preliminary meeting,they
were told there would be 8 houses and a common lot. The people of this community are
disgusted about building a modern neighborhood. They ask that only 3 houses be built.
They ask it be kept in harmony with the buildings around it.
Mr. Eggleston asked staff about the neighborhood meeting. The record shows the process
itself was properly followed and noticed.
Ms. Root stated that was correct,sometimes the design changes.The discrepancy between 8
and 9 lots is not out of alignment. In addition,the developer could have gone through the
simple lot split process and put in 8 houses without any kind notification. Staff felt going
through the planned unit development procedure was appropriate.
Rebuttal:
Mr. Eggleston stated there was an opportunity for a lot split to do 8 houses and had he
considered that?
Mr. McAllister stated the plan didn't function very well.
Ms. Root stated the 8 units would have been available without platting and no oversight
over the development.
Mr.Eggleston closed the public hearing.
The PUD allows for affordable housing, improving the standards, housing design and things
of this nature. Meeting the qualifications of a PUD or a standard subdivision or a simple lot
split process there is essentially give and take. The PUD allows for a better quality. That is
the tradeoff for this type of development vs just with lot splits.The Cpmprehensive flan
looks at this type of development as infill as a better quality.
The surrounding neighborhood is also single-family houses. There is a landscape buffer
around the cul-de-sac.This project meets or exceeds the requirements of the fire
department. He would like to add that we are facing a situation that affordable housing is at
a crucial shortage.This appears to be a more affordable type of housing. That is done here
in a manner that can be integrated into the neighborhood successfully.
PUD and Preliminary Plat:
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for PUD-21P-01 (Preliminary Plat) The Hearing Examiner
accepted the comprehensive plan analysis as listed in the staff report.
3
Hearing Examiner Minutes 03/23/2021
Findings of Fact for PUD-21P-01 (Preliminary Plat) The Hearing Examiner accepted the
general facts as outlined in the staff report, public testimony, and the evidence list.
Conclusions of Law for SUB-20P-10 (Preliminary Plat): The Hearing Examiner accepted
the Conclusions of Law as outlined in the staff report.
RECOMMENATION FOR PUD-21P-01: The Hearing Examiner RECOMMENDED that Case
Number PUD-21P-01 be approved with the following conditions: 10.1 through 10.11
Planning Issues- None
The next regularly scheduled Hearing Examiner meeting is scheduled for April 27, 2021.
The Hearing Examiner adjourned the meeting at approximately 8:0 p.m.
Respectfully submitted by Lori Colligan,
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BY THE HEARING EXAMINER, BRUCE EGGLESTON, ON THE
DATE NOTED BELOW:
ref / G 2D
r. Bruce Egglesto• Date
ATTEST:
r
C.J2(04--.4- 74 `1/1,1.--ttAi ) 2_021
(Debb ,Senior Pla er Date
For detailed Minutes,please request a copy of the digital recording.
4
Hearing Examiner Minutes 03/23/2021