HomeMy WebLinkAbout2021-02-23 Hearing Examiner Minutes Regular Caldwell Hearing Examiner Min tes
Tuesday,February 23,2021, 7:00 p. .
Community Room, Caldwell Police Depart
110 South 5th Avenue,Caldwell,Idaho
Call to Order- Hearing Examiner, Mr. Bruce Eggleston opened the meeting for the public
hearing at 7:01 p.m.
II. Review of Proceedings-Mr. Bruce Eggleston outlined the procedures for the public
hearing.
Members Present: Robb MacDonald (City Engineer); Debbie Root(Senior Planner); Bruce
Eggleston (Hearing Examiner); Katie Phillips (Associate Planner); Lori Colligan
(Administrative Assistant)
Members Absent:
HI. Consent Calendar:
1) Old Business:
1. Case Number CMP-20-04/ZON-20-05/SUB-20P-05: A request by Heartland
Townhomes Property Management LLC and Trilogy Development, Inc.,for
comprehensive plan map amendments, rezones and approval of a preliminary plat for
AeroSky Park Subdivision,a proposed commercial/industrial development of parcel
R35305, 35.4 acres, located on the southeast corner of Hwy 20/26 and Aviation Road,
Caldwell, Idaho.The City of Caldwell 2040 Comprehensive Plan designates the property
as"Commercial and Services." A map amendment is proposed to allow for industrial
zoning. The 35.4 acre subject property is currently zoned'C-4' (Interchange/Freeway
Commercial) and the applicant is proposing 12.6 acres of"C-3" (Service Commercial)
and 24.82 acres of"M1" (Light Industrial)zoned property.The proposed plat contains 6
commercial lots and 14 industrial lots. The subject property is located in the APO-1
Land Use Limitation Zone.
Testimony:
Ms. Debbie Root,Senior Planner, 621 Cleveland Blvd.,Caldwell, ID stated the applicant is
requesting commercial/industrial development on a parcel R35305, 35.44 acres, located on
the southeast corner of Hwy 20/26 and Aviation Road,Caldwell, Idaho. The 35.44 acre
subject property is currently zoned C-4 (interchange/freeway commercial) and is located in
the APO-1 Land Use Limitation Zone in the Industrial Airport Overlay zone. The applicant is
requesting a comp plan amendment to designate 24.82 acres from"commercial and service"
to"manufacturing and production."A rezone of 12.16 acres from C-4 to C-3 and a rezone of
24.82 acres from C-4 to M-1. This is consistent in this area. This property lies within the
APO zone and
1
Hearing Examiner Minutes 02/23/2021
cannot develop residentially. They have had a number of conversations with the applicant,
street sections identified on the preliminary map do not meet the requirements of the
Engineering Department.There have also had conversations regarding the access,the City
would like to have the right in/right out access at the 1/4 mile.The preliminary plat has not
been updated to reflect the Engineering comments,with that said; changing the width of the
roads is going to change the dimensions of the lots. It is not accurately reflecting what will
be on the ground at the time of development.
Mr. Eggleston asked Ms. Root and Mr. MacDonald about the issue of the west entrance.
Mr. MacDonald,City Engineer, 621 Cleveland Blvd.,Caldwell,ID stated it has taken ITD a
while to decide what they were going to allow. Their approval has changed a little;there is
an approved right in/right out at the 1/8 mile and not an approved access at the 1/4 mile.
The City would prefer to see the right in/right out at the 1/4 mile. Staff is willing to work
with the applicant over the next couple of weeks and work with ITD to get an approval.
Mr. Eggleston asked about the cul-de-sac and connecting it to the eastern boundary.
Mr. MacDonald stated they reviewed that when this application first came in,they have not
placed any requirements that this development has to connect to HWY 20/26.
Mr. Eggleston asked about the A Drain,does that present an issue as far as the roadways are
concerned.
Mr. MacDonald stated the A Drain was an existing ditch and has since been tiled.The A
Drain is a city facility,owned and operated by the City of Caldwell. It is not a conflict with
any of the City's standards.
Mr. Eggleston asked if they considered the application complete enough to make a decision.
Mr. MacDonald stated there are some incomplete items on the plat; the access,one road
section that may need to be adjusted. He thinks conceptually it will not change much, it may
be a situation that can be worked out before it goes to City Council.
Ms. Root stated she agreed with Mr. MacDonald. She would like the plat to be complete as it
goes to City Council.
Ms.Jane Suggs,9839 Cable Car Street, Boise, Idaho (applicant) stated she is here
representing AeroSky Park. This product has already been annexed,they are requesting a
rezone. The zoning is similar to the surrounding properties. Economic Development paid
$150,000 to tile the A Drain. She is not against further discussions with City staff. They do
agree with most of the conditions in the staff report. They need to add an Idaho Power
easement as well. Condition 20.1 states the applicant shall modify the preliminary plat to
reflect the City of Caldwell road standards for the public industrial roads within the
2
Hearing Examiner Minutes 02/23/2021
development and in accordance to PA-5 or as amended and this needs to be done prior to
going to City Council. They don't agree with that.
Mr. Eggleston asked if she had an updated letter that supersedes the previous letter.
Ms.Suggs stated she did not,she has an email.
Mr. Eggleston asked what the timing would be on these conditions.
Ms.Suggs said by the end of the week. The issue she has is the Engineering condition asking
them to put all the information from ITD on their plat. She would rather it just say she will
comply with whatever ITD requires.
Mr. Eggleston asked Mr. MacDonald about the discussion of the ingress/egress-the prelim
plat in hand reflects that? Are we all on the same page on that?
Mr. MacDonald stated yes,he thinks they are all on the same page. He understands the
applicant's hesitation regarding ITD. He thinks this is something they can work through; he
is comfortable revising that requirement.
Mr. Eggleston asked about adding a condition about no residential uses allowed,should we
add that or is it contained elsewhere.
Rebuttal:
Ms.Suggs stated she thinks it sounds like we are in agreement. She will make a
commitment to have a revised preliminary plat to staff next week.
Mr. Eggleston closed the public testimony.
Comprehensive Plan Map Amendment:
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for CMP-20-04 (Comprehensive Plan Amendment) The
Hearing Examiner accepted the comprehensive plan analysis as listed in the staff report.
Findings of Fact for CMP-20-04(Comprehensive Plan Amendment)The Hearing
Examiner accepted the general facts as outlined in the staff report,public testimony, and the
evidence list.
Conclusions of Law for CMP-20-04(Comprehensive Plan Amendment): The Hearing
Examiner accepted the Conclusions of Law as outlined in the staff report.
ORDER FOR CMP-20-04:The Hearing Examiner RECOMMENDED that Case Number CMP-
20-04(Comprehensive Plan Amendment) is approved with the conditions listed as 8.2
and 8.3 of the staff report.
Rezone:
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for ZON-20-05 (Rezone)The Hearing Examiner accepted the
comprehensive plan analysis as listed in the staff report.
3
Hearing Examiner Minutes 02/23/2021
Findings of Fact for ZON-20-05 (Rezone) The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts
as outlined in the staff report, public testimony, and the evidence list.
The rezone proposal is more compatible with the surrounding land uses and provides more
industrial capacity to support the airport enterprise.
Conclusions of Law for ZON-20-05 (Rezone): The Hearing Examiner accepted the
Conclusions of Law as outlined in the staff report.
ORDER FOR ZON-20-05:The Hearing Examiner RECOMMENDED that Case Number ZON-
20-05 (Rezone) is approved.
Preliminary Plat:
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for SUB-20P-10 (Preliminary Plat)The Hearing Examiner
accepted the comprehensive plan analysis as listed in the staff report.
Findings of Fact for SUB-20P-10 (Preliminary Plat)The Hearing Examiner accepted the
general facts as outlined in the staff report,public testimony,and the evidence list.
There are outstanding issues of detail having to do with the points discussed and they will be
amended to the preliminary plat application before it goes to City Council.
Conclusions of Law for SUB-20P-10 (Preliminary Plat): The Hearing Examiner accepted
the Conclusions of Law as outlined in the staff report.
ORDER FOR SUB-20P-05: The Hearing Examiner RECOMMENDED that Case Number SUB-
20P-05 (Preliminary Plat) be approved with conditions as listed in 20.1 through 20.16,
with a change to condition 20.12 regarding traffic mitigation (WORDING TO COME FROM
CITY ENGINEER) and the addition of condition 20.16 stating no residential uses will be
allowed in the commercial areas to maintain compatibility with the APO Overlay zone.
2) Case Number: Case Number ANN-20-09/PUD-20-04: A request by Riley Planning
Services on behalf of Tanner Leighton,Triple Dot Development, for annexation of 20.35
acres with a designation of R-1 (Low Density Residential) and Planned Unit
Development(PUD)with a Preliminary Plat for El Monterey Subdivision with 118
residential units,consisting of ten (10) Multi-family lots [72 Units], 19 Townhomes, 27
single-family residential lots and eight(8) common lots. The 2040 Comprehensive Plan
designates this property as Low Density Residential. The proposed density for the
development as a PUD is 5.8 units per acre. The subject properties are located at 2921
Marble Front Road in Caldwell, Idaho, parcel numbers R35117 and R35117010. The
subject property is contiguous to Van Buren Elementary School and is located
southwest of Mosaics Charter School.
Testimony:
Debbie Root,Senior Planner, 621 Cleveland Blvd.,Caldwell, ID 83605,stated the applicant is
requesting annexation of 20.35 acres with a designation of R-1 (low density residential) and
a Planned Unit Development(PUD)with a preliminary plat for El Monterrey Subdivision
4
Hearing Examiner Minutes 02/23/2021
with 118 residential units, consisting of ten (10) multi-family lots [76 units], 19 townhomes,
27 single family residential lots and eight(8) common lots. The 2040 Comprehensive Plan
designates this property as low density residential.The proposed density for the
development as a PUD is 5.99 units per acre. The subject properties are located at 2921
Marble Front Road in Caldwell, Idaho. The subject property is contiguous to Van Buren
Elementary School and is located southwest of Mosaics Charter School. It meets a growing
need in the community for housing. The development meets the required open space
requirements. They are providing pathway connections. Staff is supporting this
application,they did receive quite a few letters,they are part of the staff report. Concerns
about multi-family not fitting in this area. Those concerns are heard and the applicant has
placed single family next to the existing single family. There were concerns about traffic,
but there is much more development coming to this area. They applicant has completed a
traffic impact study.
Mr. Eggleston read a letter from the principal from Van Buren, it stated their excitement
about the project. (Exhibit 2.1).
Mr. Eggleston stated his primary job is to make sure this is in compliance with the PUD
ordinance. It must meet certain requirements. Ms. Root has listed those in the staff report.
Mr. Eggleston stated he is trying to solidify that this meets the PUD requirements and it
seems they do that. He appreciates the request for additional amenities.
Mr. Eggleston stated the staff reports talks about the common driveway standards for the
multi-family and he wants to verify that they have been met.
Mr. MacDonald stated the roadways that are private are consistent,as far as he can tell this
meets the criteria of private.The only issue is item A,it needs to be 26'wide.
Ms. Root stated to clarify the internal circulation within the multi-family,that roadway must
be 26'wide.The short common driveways that are not greater than 150' can be 24'wide.
Mr. Eggleston asked about a recent case dealing with access for multi-family,has the fire
department signed off on this?
Ms. Root stated yes.
Mr. Eggleston asked about school bus stops, have the locations been worked out?
Ms. Root stated it is required she is not sure if the locations have been figured out.
Ms. Penelope Constantikes, PO Box 405 Boise, Idaho (applicant) stated she agrees with
conditions in the staff report. Density is 5.99. There are a variety of housing types in this
area, and 2 schools located nearby. The project vision was to create a development that was
concept sensitive. It was carefully laid out to blend in with the area. Pathway connections
to Lincoln and Van Buren are approximately placed,providing Van Buren agrees. This is a
unique and innovated amenity package. They have a roundabout, amphitheater,
community building, and pathway connections.They will work closely with the schools on
the bus stop connections. They would be happy to work with staff on additional
5
Hearing Examiner Minutes 02/23/2021
recommended amenities. They are aware the drive aisle needs to be increased to 26'.
These will be aesthetically pleasing. They are happy to incorporate all conditions of
approval.The applicant agrees to a pathway connection to the park. They respectfully
request approval.
Mr. Eggleston asked about the estimation of ownership?
Ms.Constantikes stated 100%.
Mr.Eggleston asked what is the range of the cost of the townhouses.
Ms.Constantikes stated between$200,000 and$400,000.
Mr. Eggleston stated some of the letters talk about the availability of parking in the multi-
family area?
Ms.Constantikes stated they have a lot of parking and it meets the standards of the City.
They are happy to add more if needed.
Mr. Eggleston asked if the applicant intends to develop this?
Ms.Constantikes stated they are planning on doing all the building.
Mr. Eggleston is looking for the design guidelines they are working with.
Ms.Constantikes stated each unit has a porch unit,front door and back yard. They will be
incorporating stone accents,there will be balconies. The color palate has been selected to
be pleasing. They have done everything they can to make it attractive.
Ms.Constantikes gave photo samples that Mr. Eggleston entered as an exhibit(PZ-1000).
Mr. Robb MacDonald wanted to clarify that the mitigation for the development would be
going to Middleton and Linden.
Mr.Tanner Leighton,811 E McKinley, Boise, Idaho stated he would just like to reiterate that
he would like to work with the City.
Ms.Kelsey Leighton, 811 E McKinley St, Boise, Idaho signed in favor but chose not to speak.
Mr. Keith Bowen, 3916 W.Cassia St., Boise, Idaho signed in favor but chose not to speak.
Mr. Brian Alan, 211 S Alaska,Caldwell, Idaho (opposition) stated he does not want this
development to happen right now,he thinks it's too soon. He thinks there is too much
development going on right now. Lastly,he doesn't think Van Buren is going to be able to
take the load. Van Buren is pretty well full now.
Ms. Pratt, 2803 Makrana Street,Caldwell, Idaho (opposition) stated she is new to the area.
She has been in the Marble Heights subdivision for about 4 months now. She never thought
the empty lot would be empty forever. Coming from California,she knows what housing
and multi-family can bring to a community. She would love to see the multi-family piece
really be evaluated.
6
Hearing Examiner Minutes 02/23/2021
• Ms.Jenny Campus, 292 Bianca Street, Caldwell, Idaho stated her biggest concern is narrow
* streets with a busy school and the two developments closest to the development is small.
To add this number of new residents could present safety hazards. The school is already
strained,this will add more population to the school system. The other issue is that all the
surrounding developments are single family and we are short on single family houses,there
is an element being added that doesn't fit currently.
Ms.Andrea Espe, 612 Dandy Ave., Caldwell stated his house abuts right up to this
agriculture land. The roundabout will come into her side yard. She knew this would be
developed eventually.They are not against development,but against the multi-family
development. It's not cohesive with what is there. All of those residents are going to go out
Marble Front and through their subdivision. She questions the 12-unit row townhouses;
how will they keep any standards for the rest of the residents. How do they keep a standard
of low crime,single family,community minded things.
Mr. Kai Hyland, 513 Darby Ave, Caldwell, Idaho signed in opposition but chose not to speak.
Ms. Nicole Hyland, 513 Darby Ave,Caldwell, Idaho signed in opposition but chose not to
speak.
Ms.Sharon Lamb, 2815 Makrana St.,Caldwell, Idaho signed in opposition but chose not to
speak.
Mr.Steven Waster, 519 Darby Ave.,Caldwell, Idaho signed in opposition but chose not to
speak.
Mr. Edward Jordan,608 Danby Ave., Caldwell, Idaho signed in opposition but chose not to
speak.
Mr. Eggleston stated he understands everyone's concerns.What we are trying to achieve is
the best possible outcome for growth that is needed in the area.
Rebuttal:
Ms. Constantikes stated she thinks that road improvement occurs with development. The
multi-family will generate approximately 18 vehicle trips. She lives in a townhouse and she
is not a criminal and she thinks it's unfair to believe that people who chose to live in a town
home are criminals. The developers are the owners,they plan to do background checks for
the residents. They have received different information in regards to the capacity at the
school,she heard it was under capacity. The charter school is under a lottery system.
Mr. Eggleston closed the public testimony.
Mr. Eggleston stated housing prices are currently through the roof. It seems like the intent
of the applicant is for home ownership. The other issue is the landscape plan shows a single
family lot pattern that exceeds the lot sizes to the west and south. He has seen hundreds of
PUD's that were not as forthright that were not trying to integrate themselves. This is a
very conscientious effort to buffer the uses. Quite frankly,it's commendable. He has been a
professional planner for over 30 years and this is one of the better designs. It does have
7
Hearing Examiner Minutes 02/23/2021
nice amenities and a significant amount of open space. He is quite impressed with the
design,the roundabout,the connectivity. Our Planned Unit Development code is sparse, it
has not kept up with the current housing trends. He wants to make it very clear to the
people interested in this and the City Council that this does indeed meet the criteria for a
planned unit development. Penelope stated they could increase parking in the multi-family
area. He will incorporate that into the conditions. Also,both staff and applicant talked
about additional amenities,he is all for that. It does raise the bar and it will provide an
example for future developments.
Annexation:
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for ANN-20-09: (Annexation) The Hearing Examiner
accepted the comprehensive plan analysis as listed in the staff report.
Findings of Fact for ANN-20-09: (Annexation):The Hearing Examiner accepted the general
facts as outlined in the staff report,public testimony, and the evidence list.
Conclusions of Law for ANN-20-09: (Annexation): The Hearing Examiner accepted the
Conclusions of Law as outlined in the staff report.
ORDER FOR ANN-20-09: The Hearing Examiner RECOMMENDED that Case Number ANN-
20-09: (Annexation) BE APPROVED with the following conditions: 10.1 through 10.3
Planned Unit Development:
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for PUD-20-04: (Preliminary Plat-PUD) The Hearing
Examiner accepted the comprehensive plan analysis as listed in the staff report.
Findings of Fact for PUD-20-04: (Preliminary Plat-PUD):
The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as outlined in the staff report, public
testimony,and the evidence list.
The proposed PUD and preliminary plat provides a good example of multiple use residential
development,it provides all the amenities and facilities as described in the PUD ordinance.
Conclusions of Law for PUD-20-04: (Preliminary Plat-PUD): The Hearing Examiner
accepted the Conclusions of Law as outlined in the staff report.
ORDER FOR PUD-20-04:The Hearing Examiner RECOMMENDED that Case Number PUD-
20-04: (Preliminary Plat-PUD) BE APPROVED with the following conditions: 14.1
through 16.18 with the addition of 16.19 the proposal shall include additional/optional
amenities with the potential for a tot lot or volley ball court or other amenity that can be
worked out in conjunction with the staff to further enhance the amenities in this
development. The addition of condition 16.20 recommends an increase in parking for the
multi-family development to accommodate visitors and make parking on the street
unnecessary and less attractive.The number of additional parking will be worked out with
the applicant and staff.
8
Hearing Examiner Minutes 02/23/2021
Planning Issues-None
The next regularly scheduled Hearing Examiner meeting is scheduled for March 23, 2021.
The Hearing Examiner adjourned the meeting at approximately 10:00 p.m.
Respectfully submitted by Lori Colligan,
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BY THE HEARING EXAMINER, BRUCE EGGLESTON,ON THE
DATE NOTED BELOW:
4)0,42 ?dzt
Mr. Bruce Eggleston Date
i- ie Root,Senior Plan r Date
For detailed Minutes,please request a copy of the digital recording.
9
Hearing Examiner Minutes 02/23/2021