HomeMy WebLinkAbout2021-03-15 City Council Minutes lit
�LDwEa
CITY COUNCIL WORKSHOP
AGENDA
Monday,March 15,2021
6:00 PM
DISCUSSION ITEMS:
Finance Department
Budget Discussion regarding Employee Wages/Benefits and City Projects
Planning&Zoning Department
Multiple ordinance amendments to the Planning&Zoning Ordinance and an emergency ordinance for clarification
of City Center and Central Business District boundaries and regulations
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING
AGENDA
Monday,March 15,2021
7:00 PM
INVOCATION OFFERED BY PASTOR DAVE McGARRAH OF DEER FLAT FREE METHODIST CHURCH.
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG.
ROLL CALL.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST DECLARATION.
SPECIAL PRESENTATIONS.
a. Advocates Against Family Violence (Kim Deugan)
b. Caldwell Housing Authority(Mike Dittenber)
AUDIENCE PARTICIPATION.
CONSENT CALENDAR: [ALL CONSENT CALENDAR ITEMS ARE ACTION ITEMS]
I1) Approve acceptance of the minutes of the Regularly Scheduled City Council meeting held on March 1, 2021;
the minutes for the City of Caldwell Hearing Examiner meeting held on January 26,2021;the Caldwell Traffic
Commission meeting held on March 3,2021;and the Caldwell Youth Master Plan Committee meeting held on
October 22,2020;
2) Approve the Order of Decision for Case No.ANN20-000010/SUB20-000013 (Langley Hall Subdivision);
3) Approve the Order of Decision for Case No. SUB-20P-10(10th Avenue Heights Subdivision);
4) Approve request from Advocates Against Family Violence to waive the rental fee in the amount of$100.00 for use
of the Caldwell Train Depot Plaza to conduct a community-wide candlelight vigil ceremony for National Crime
Victims Rights Week on April 24,2021;
5) Approve the appointment of John Ottenhoff to the Pathways& Bike Committee with a term to expire December 31,
2021;
6) Approve Resolution declaring items from the Caldwell Fire Department as surplus for disposition to public auction;
7) Approve Resolution declaring items from Treasure Valley Community College Caldwell Campus as surplus for
disposition to scrap;
8) Approve Resolution declaring items from the Caldwell Police Department as surplus for disposition to the Valley
County Sheriff's Office;
9) Approve Resolution authorizing the execution of an Agreement with Crane Alarm Service for fire alarm and security
monitoring for City-owned buildings;
10)Approve the amendment to Resolution No. 50-21(A) updating the designated records custodian for the Caldwell
Industrial Airport;
11)Approve Resolution authorizing the execution of the Display Agreement with Homeland Fireworks, Inc. for the July
4,2021 event at Brother's Park;
12)Approve Resolution authorizing the execution and payment of the Annual Maintenance Agreement with ISR
Millennium Software in the amount of$3,599.71;
13)Approve Resolution authorizing the purchase of a forklift from Idaho State Surplus in the amount of$29,000.00 for
use by the Caldwell Fire Department;
14)Approve Resolution authorizing the purchase of a 3M Opticom System from Advanced Traffic Products in the
amount of$60,190.00 for use by the Caldwell Fire Department;
15)Approve Resolution authorizing the construction of a drafting pit at CFD Station No. 3 by Beniton Construction in
the amount of$126,692.50 for use by Caldwell Fire Department;
16)Approve Resolution authorizing the purchase of a 2019 Ford EcoSport in the amount of$16,500.00 for use the
Caldwell Police Department;
17)Approve Resolution authorizing the purchase of a High Intensity Actuated Crosswalk(HAWK)system from Altitude
Signal,LLC in the amount of$14,660.00 for use by the Street Department;
r
Page 1 of 2
18)Approve Resolution authorizing the purchase of two traffic control cabinets and one replacement cabinet from
Econolite Group, Inc. in the amount of$90,150.00 for use by the Street Department;
19)Approve Resolution authorizing the reimbursement in the amount of$30,000 to New Beginnings Housing LLC for
the eligible construction of right-of-way improvements for Hope Plaza II at Elgin Street and 14th Avenue;
20)Approve Resolution accepting the ranking of contractors for the Pool and Pool House Construction Project and
authorize the Engineering Department to proceed with negotiations with the Number#1 ranked firm—Core;
21)Approve Resolution authorizing the purchase of a Groundsmaster 3300 4WD Mower from Turf Equipment &
Irrigation Inc.in the amount of$26,933.51 for use by the Parks Department;
22)Approve Resolution authorizing the purchase of a Walker T-27HP Kohler EFI Mower from Smith's Lawnmower
Sales and Service in the amount of$13,809.00 for use by the Parks Department;
23)Approve Resolution authorizing the acceptance of the Proposal for Design of Sewer Truck Line — Hwy. 20-26
Project from Bowen,Collins&Associates in the amount of$63,710.00;
24)Approve Resolution accepting the Warranty Deed from Vallivue School District #139 for a portion of frontage
property for future right-of-way improvements along Smeed Parkway;
25)Approve request from Heap Herders to waive the Memorial Park rental fee in the amount of$125.00 and the Special
Event Permit fee in the amount of$75.00 for the Spring Bling Car Show,a community-wide event for the purpose of
raising funds for the cure of Muscular Dystrophy;
26)Approve Resolution declaring items from the Wastewater Treatment Plant as surplus for disposition as scrap, public
auction and donation to a non-profit organization.
OLD BUSINESS:
1) ACTION ITEM: Continued from March 1,2021: Public Hearing(Quasi-Judicial): TE-20-07: A request by J&
J Property Development, LLC for a 24 month Time Extension of a Preliminary Plat for CIRRUS POINTE
Subdivision. The original development consists of 373 residential lots in an R-1 (Low Density Residential) zone on
162.48 acres. Phases 1-5 containing 160 residential lots have been developed. The applicant is requesting to
complete the 213 residential lot development of Cirrus Pointe. The 2040 Comprehensive Plan designation is Low
Density Residential. The development is located at the southeast corner of Montana Avenue and Orchard Street in
Caldwell,ID.
NEW BUSINESS:
1) ACTION ITEM: Public Hearing: Concerning Bill No 10,Ordinance No. 3330,an emergency ordinance enacted
by the Caldwell City Council amending Chapter 10, Article 3, Section 10-03-11 of the Caldwell City Code,
amending certain definitions applicable to zoning within the City of Caldwell; amending Chapter 10, Article 12,
Section 10-12-02 modifying the applicability of the City Center District zoning regulations to align with the new
definitions in 10-03-11.
2) ACTION ITEM: Consider Bill No. 10, Ordinance 3330, an emergency ordinance enacted by the Caldwell City
Council amending Chapter 10,Article 3, Section 10-03-11 of the Caldwell City Code;amending certain definitions
applicable to zoning within the City of Caldwell,amending Chapter 10,Article 12,Section 10-12-02 modifying the
applicability of the City Center District zoning regulations to align with the new definitions in 10-03-11 with a
request to waive the rules and pass on the first reading.
3) ACTION ITEM: Public Hearing (Quasi-Judicial): SUB20-000012 and DAA-20-01: A request by Pine Street
LLC, to modify the Selah Estates Development Agreement recorded as inst. #2008023676. Also requesting
approval of a Preliminary Plat for Selah Estates Subdivision, a single-family residential development in an R-1
(Low Density Residential) zone on parcel R25052012 containing 18.76 acres. The proposed subdivision consists
of 52 single-family lots and 9 common lots. The 2040 Comprehensive Plan designates this property as Low
Density Residential. The subject property is located on the northwest corner of Homedale Road and 10th Avenue.
4) ACTION ITEM: Public Hearing (Quasi-Judicial): ANN-20-07/SUB-20P-14: Craig Kulchak is requesting to
annex three (3) acres with a zone designation of R2 (Medium Density Residential) consistent with the
Comprehensive Plan designation. Also requested is approval of a Preliminary Plat for Lake Park Subdivision
consisting of 11 single-family residential lots with an average lot size of 6128 sq. ft. and three (3) common lots.
The subject property is located 780 south of the intersection of Lake Ave. and Homedale Road on the west side of
Lake Ave. [11-3N-3W-NE] in Caldwell,Idaho.
5) ACTION ITEM: •Consider Bill No. 68 (Ordinance No. 3316)for Case No. ANN-20-07 (Lake Park Annexation)
with a request to waive the rules,pass on the first reading,and approve the summary for publication.
6) ACTION ITEM: Public Hearing: CASE NO TE-20-10: A request for a time extension of a Preliminary Plat for
Canyon Crossing Subdivision, a residential development in an R-2 (Medium Density Residential) zone containing
31 residential lots and 5 common lots on 8.5 acres+/-, on parcel R02666101, and (Phase I) Lots 1-13 of BLK 1
Canyon Crossing Phase I containing 11 multi-family residential lots recorded on March 18,2020. Phase I units are
currently under construction. The development is located on the southwest corner of Syringa Lane and Florida
Avenue. The development is subject to Canyon Crossing Development Agreement, Instrument number 2016-
049500. **APPLICANT HAS REQUESTED THAT THIS ITEM BE CONTINUED TO THE MAY 3, 2021
CITY COUNCIL MEETING**
7) ACTION ITEM: Financial Report acceptance.
8) Council Reports.
9) Mayor's Comments.
10)Adjournment.
Next Regular City Council Meeting is on Monday.April S. 2021 at 7:00 p.m. in the Community Room at the Caldwell
Police Station at 110 South Fifth. Any person needing special accommodations to participate in the meeting should contact
the City Clerk at 411 Blaine Street or call #455-4656 prior to the meeting. The entire agenda packet and minutes can be
viewed on the City of Caldwell's website: www.citvofcaldwell.com. Cualquier persona que necesita arreglos especiales
para participar en la reunion debe comunicarse con el Secretario de la Ciudad en 411 Blaine Street o flame al#455 a 4656
antes de la reunion.
Page 2 of 2
BOOK 62 PAGE 42
WORKSHOP
CALDWELL CITY COUNCIL
March 15,2021
6:00 P.M.
MINUTES
WORKSHOP WAS HELD FOR THE PURPOSE OF DISCUSSION REGARDING:
1) FINANCE DEPARTMENT: BUDGET DISCUSSION REGARDING EMPLOYEE
WAGES/BENEFITS AND CITY PROJECTS
2) PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT: MULTIPLE ORDINANCE AMENDMENTS
TO THE PLANNING & ZONING ORDINANCE AND AN EMERGENCY ORDINANCE
FOR'CLARIFICATION OF CITY CENTER AND CENTRAL BUSINESS DISTRICT
BOUNDARIES AND REGULATIONS
The Roll of the City Council was called by the City Clerk with the following members present: Allgood,
Hopper(via Zoom),Callsen, Pollard(via Zoom),and McGee(via Zoom). Councilman Wagoner entered at
6:05 p.m.
The Mayor opened the workshop at 6:00 p.m.
The Mayor reported that Councilman Allgood had previously requested a workshop to discuss employee
wages/benefits. The Finance Director would provide information regarding City projects.
Carol Mitchell, City Finance Director at 411 Blaine Street, provided an overview of current projects four
projects to include the Caldwell Memorial Park Swimming Pool Project, the Weymouth Parking Lot
Project (to accommodate downtown parking needs), BMX Park Upgrades Project, and Golf Course
Equipment Project. The completion of such projects would total $2 million out of the $3.7 million
appropriation. The remaining balance would be allocated for improvements to the pool and recreation
building. She noted that tonight's review of these specific projects was a recap from previous discussions
held during the 2020 budget session. The pool contractor has been selected and will be approved tonight
by City Council. It is estimated that the new pool would be operational in May 2022. She asked if
Council has other priorities beyond the proposed projects.
Councilman Callsen indicated that he concurred with the projects as presented.
Councilman Wagoner asked if the parking along the railroad on Main Street is being utilized near the new
theater.
Mayor Nancolas reported that that due to the COVID-19 crisis, currently there is available parking along
the tracks from Kimball to 12th. When the temporary closure of the theaters has lifted and events
associated with Indian Creek Plaza return this summer, the railroad parking will be well utilized once
again.
Mr.Orton reported that the new parking area would allow an additional 160 spaces.
Councilman Allgood recommended that improvements at the dog park be addressed.
Ms. Mitchell reported that funding has been allocated for improvements at the dog park during this current
budget year.
Councilman Wagoner asked the new parking area includes frontage and railroad crossing infrastructure
improvements.
Mr. Orton reported that any improvements associated with the UPRR crossing would be delayed at this
time.
In response to questions from Councilman Wagoner, Ms. Mitchell reported that the Pickle Ball Club is
working with Denise Milburn, Recreation Coordinator, regarding potential improvements at existing
locations managed by the Parks&Recreation Department.
Ms. Mitchell provided a summary of the needed equipment needs for the Golf Department to include the
purchase of 20 golf carts at $2,500 each. Councilman Hopper recommended the golf equipment be
purchased by means of a loan with the Golf Department paying back the expense to the General Fund.
Councilman Allgood asked for tonight's workshop to discuss wages and benefits for the purpose of
retaining Police Department personnel.
Alyssa Battaglia, Human Resource Director, provided an overview comparison of wages and benefits for
Caldwell Police Department officers versus similar positions within the cities of Nampa, Pocatello,
Moscow and Twin Falls. She noted that thirteen (13)officers have left Caldwell Police Department since
January 2020.
BOOK 62 PAGE 43
Councilman Allgood reported on how the City of Nampa provides incentives to their officers that remain
with their wages. He expressed his concern regarding the overload of new employees within the police
force and the need to retain officers.
The Mayor requested a special workshop be held for the purpose of only discussing the wage/benefit issue.
Jerome Mapp, Planning&Zoning Director at 621 Cleveland Boulevard,reported on the proposed changes
to the Zoning Ordinance including multi-family housing feasibilities, zoning classifications, land-use
defmitions, and institutional zones/hospital zones. Mr. Mapp noted the inability to execute multi-family
units within the institution and hospital overlay zones under the current ordinance.
Councilman Hopper reported on the intensions of Council when the institutional and hospital zones were
initiated. He recommended that the purpose of these zones be well explained within the Planning &
Zoning Ordinance,rather than changing the designations every few years.
Councilman Wagoner inquired about the downtown map provided as an discussion exhibit. He noted that
there are currently two local historic districts are the Steunenberg Historic Residential District and the
North Caldwell Historic District. Discussion followed concerning the variance between a nationally
recognized historic site versus a local historic district.
Mr. Mapp outlined the contents of the proposed emergency ordinance, which would be effective for 180
days.
The workshop adjourned at 6:59 p.m.
REGULARLY SCHEDULED MEETING
CALDWELL CITY COUNCIL
March 15,2021
7:00 P.M.
MINUTES
Mayor Nancolas opened the meeting at 7:00 p.m.at the Caldwell Police Department Community Room.
He reported there was a City Council Workshop with discussion about Employee Wages and Benefits,City
Projects,Multiple ordinances and City Center District Boundaries and Regulations.
Reverend Martin Flaherty of Deer Flat Free Methodist Church provided the invocation. Mayor Nancolas
led the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag.
The Roll of the City Council was called by the City Clerk with the following members present: Allgood,
Wagoner,Hopper(via Zoom),Callsen,Pollard(via Zoom),and McGee(via Zoom).
CONFLICT OF INTEREST DECLARATION
None.
SPECIAL PRESENTATIONS
a. Advocates Against Family Violence(Kim Deugan)
The Mayor introduced Kim Deugan of Advocates Against Family Violence. She reported that
in 2020,AAFV provided 32,997 advocacy, support,emergency shelter,housing,education,and
awareness services. Hope Plaza Phase 1 provides 48 housing units, Phase 2 provides 30
housing units and 14 community units for transitional and permanent housing. There are plans
to break ground in 2021 for Phase 3 with an additional 30 housing units. She reported on the
poor condition of the Hope's Door Shelter. She expressed appreciation to the City of Caldwell
for their continued support over the years.
The Mayor thanked Ms.Deugan for the many community services offered through AAFV.
Councilman Wagoner expressed appreciation of the presentation and the sharing of Jane's story
in the handout exhibit. .
b. Celdwell Housing Authority(Mike Dittenber)
Mike Dittenber of the Caldwell Housing Authority read a letter into the record by the Board
President,Arnoldo Hernandez:
I apologize for not personally attending tonight's meeting. I am currently out of town on
business, but I would like to take a few minutes to tell you (via this letter) about the Caldwell
Housing Authority happenings in 2020 and what is being planned for 2021.
On December 19, 2019, the housing authority made its final loan payment to the federal
government, severing a seventy-nine(79)year partnership with federal oversight. Not only did
the final loan payment end oversight of the housing authority, but it also ended monthly rent
subsidies provided to the tenants of Farmway Village. 2020 was a year that would test the
post-subsidized management and finances of the housing authority. Not long after the year
BOOK 62 PAGE 44
w
started, we were hit with a pandemic, which caused additional challenges for the housing
authority.
As 2020 came to an end, we looked back and found our organization rose to the occasion and
met every challenge. We were able to keep rents at Farmway less than 65
% of the market. We were able to reorganize existing staff automate and outsource much of
our administrative operations;and in the end realized a 42%net gain in year-end deposits.
Pandemic protocols and a changed work environment gave us the opportunity to think about the
availability of affordable housing in our community. We look forward to 2021 and beyond
We are proud to announce we are entering our 3'd consecutive year with the same rent
structure, while rents in Canyon County continue to increase during the housing shortage. We
are also proud to offer workforce housing in addition to agriculture worker housing—creating
the reliable workforce that Caldwell business owners need.
Staff of the housing authority are working diligently to set the foundation for the next eighty(80)
years of service to our community. We are looking for opportunities to expand into the
downtown arena and we recently received approval from the county to develop RV parking and
related amenities at Farmway Village.
e
In parting, we have an active(and engaged)Board of Directors and a reliable and experienced
staff of personnel to lead the housing authority into the future.
Sincerely,Arnoldo Hernandez
Mayor Nancolas thanked Mr.Dittenber for providing the report.
AUDIENCE PARTICIPATION
None.
CONSENT CALENDAR: [All Consent Calendar items are considered action items]
1) Approve acceptance of the minutes of the Regularly Scheduled City Council meeting held on
March 1,2021;the minutes for the City of Caldwell Hearing Examiner meeting held on January
26, 2021; the Caldwell Traffic Commission meeting held on March 3, 2021; and the Caldwell
Youth Master Plan Committee meeting held on October 22,2020;
2) Approve the Order of Decision for Case No. ANN20-000010 / SUB20-000013 (Langley Hall
Subdivision);
3) Approve the Order of Decision for Case No. SUB-20P-10(10t Avenue Heights Subdivision);
4) Approve request from Advocates Against Family Violence to waive the rental fee in the amount of
$100.00 for use of the Caldwell Train Depot Plaza to conduct a community-wide candlelight vigil
ceremony for National Crime Victims Rights Week on April 24,2021;
5) Approve the appointment of John Ottenhoff to the Pathways& Bike Committee with a term to expire
December 31,2021;
6) Approve Resolution No. 85-21 declaring items from the Caldwell Fire Department as surplus for
disposition to public auction;
7) Approve Resolution No. 86-21 declaring items from Treasure Valley Community College Caldwell
Campus as surplus for disposition to scrap;
8) Approve Resolution No. 87-21 declaring items from the Caldwell Police Department as surplus for
disposition to the Valley County Sheriff's Office;
9) Approve Resolution No. 88-21 authorizing the execution of an Agreement with Crane Alarm Service
for fire alarm and security monitoring for City-owned buildings;
10)Approve the amendment to Resolution No. 50-21(A)updating the designated records custodian for the
Caldwell Industrial Airport;
11)Approve Resolution No. 89-21 authorizing the execution of the Display Agreement with Homeland
Fireworks,Inc.for the July 4,2021 event at Brother's Park;
12)Approve Resolution No. 90-21 authorizing the execution and payment of the Annual Maintenance
Agreement with ISR Millennium Software in the amount of$3,599.71;
13)Approve Resolution No. 91-21 authorizing the purchase of a forklift from Idaho State Surplus in the
amount of$29,000.00 for use by the Caldwell Fire Department;
14)Approve Resolution No. 92-21 authorizing the purchase of a 3M Opticom System from Advanced
Traffic Products in the amount of$60,190.00 for use by the Caldwell Fire Department;
15)Approve Resolution No. 93-21 authorizing the construction of a drafting pit at CFD Station No. 3 by
Beniton Construction in the amount of$126,692.50 for use by Caldwell Fire Department;
16)Approve Resolution No. 94-21 authorizing the purchase of a 2019 Ford EcoSport in the amount of
$16,500.00 for use the Caldwell Police Department;
17)Approve Resolution No. 95-21 authorizing the purchase of a High Intensity Actuated Crosswalk
(HAWK) system from Altitude Signal, LLC in the amount of $14,660.00 for use by the Street
Department;
18)Approve Resolution No. 96-21 authorizing the purchase of two traffic control cabinets and one
replacement cabinet from Econolite Group, Inc. in the amount of$90,150.00 for use by the Street
Department;
BOOK 62 PAGE 45
19)Approve Resolution No. 97-21 authorizing the reimbursement in the amount of $30,000 to New
Beginnings Housing LLC for the eligible construction of right-of-way improvements for Hope Plaza II
at Elgin Street and 14th Avenue;
20)Approve Resolution No. 98-21 accepting the ranking of contractors for the Pool and Pool House
Construction Project and authorize the Engineering Department to proceed with negotiations with the
Number#1 ranked firm—Core;
21)Approve Resolution No. 99-21 authorizing the purchase of a Groundsmaster 3300 4WD Mower from
Turf Equipment&Irrigation Inc. in the amount of$26,933.51 for use by the Parks Department;
22)Approve Resolution No. 100-21 authorizing the purchase of a Walker T-27HP Kohler EFI Mower
from Smith's Lawnmower Sales and Service in the amount of $13,809.00 for use by the Parks
Department;
23)Approve Resolution No. 101-21 authorizing the acceptance of the Proposal for Design of Sewer Truck
Line—Hwy.20-26 Project from Bowen,Collins&Associates in the amount of$63,710.00;
24)Approve Resolution No. 102-21 accepting the Warranty Deed from Vallivue School District#139 for a
portion of frontage property for future right-of-way improvements along Smeed Parkway;
25)Approve request from Heap Herders to waive the Memorial Park rental fee in the amount of$125.00
and the Special Event Permit fee in the amount of $75.00 for the Spring Bling Car Show, a
community-wide event for the purpose of raising funds for the cure of Muscular Dystrophy;
26)Approve Resolution No. 103-21 declaring items from the Wastewater Treatment Plant as surplus for
disposition as scrap,public auction and donation to a non-profit organization.
MOVED by Pollard,SECONDED by Allgood to approve the Consent Calendar as printed.
Roll call vote: Those voting yes: Pollard, McGee, Allgood, Wagoner, Hopper, and Callsen. Those
voting no:none. Absent and/or not voting:none.
MOTION CARRIED
OLD BUSINESS
(ACTION ITEM: CONTINUED FROM MARCH 1, 2021: PUBLIC HEARING [QUASI-
JUDICIAL]: TE-20-07: A REQUEST BY J & J PROPERTY DEVELOPMENT, LLC FOR A 24
MONTH TIME EXTENSION OF A PRELIMINARY PLAT FOR CIRRUS POINTE
SUBDIVISION. THE ORIGINAL DEVELOPMENT CONSISTS OF 373 RESIDENTIAL LOTS IN
AN R-1 (LOW DENSITY RESIDENTIAL)ZONE ON 162.48 ACRES. PHASES 1-5 CONTAINING
160 RESIDENTIAL LOTS HAVE BEEN DEVELOPED. THE APPLICANT IS REQUESTING TO
COMPLETE THE 213 RESIDENTIAL LOT DEVELOPMENT OF CIRRUS POINTE. THE 2040
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN DESIGNATION IS LOW DENSITY RESIDENTIAL. THE
DEVELOPMENT IS LOCATED AT THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF MONTANA AVENUE
AND ORCHARD STREET IN CALDWELL,ID)
Debbie Root, Senior Planner at 621 Cleveland Boulevard,was sworn in by the City Clerk and provided
an update report concerning the requested survey by the developer as requested by City Council at the
previous meeting held on March 1,2021. She noted that she was not present at the public hearing on
March 1, 2021 but listened to the entire testimony on record and spoke with Jerome Mapp, which
represented the Planning&Zoning Department at the hearing.
Ms.Root indicated that Mr.Butler did provide somewhat of a survey,which was made available to the
Council Members within the agenda packet. The diagram is unclear inasmuch has it does not show a
preliminary plat but does outline the existing driveway. Staff viewed aerial photos of the site from
1985 to present as well as researched Canyon County records to see when the homes were constructed.
It appears that two were built in 1957; one was built in 1959, and an additional one in 2002. Such
research indicates that the homes and driveway access was in existence when the original development
began. Since Idaho was a non-record state, the easement documents could possibly have been
undocumented. She emphasized that the prescriptive easement issue is a legal matter between the
developer and the residents.
Ms. Root continued by reporting that staff has discussed with the developer the need to provide an
easement,rather than require the property owners to purchase additional property. Mr.Butler reported
to staff today that he spoke with each of the property owners and they have come to a verbal
agreement.
Staff recommends that only the time extension for Phase VI be approved at this time. There is a fmal
plat pending for Phase VI and the developer has submitted construction drawings. They would be
required to come back with an additional time extension for the remaining phases after a new
preliminary plat has been submitted with all of the mandated changes. Such changes would include
the required easement and road alignment. Montana Avenue will not be realigned to the east at an
angle as originally planned.
Elwin-Butler of Matrix Engineers and representative for J & J Properties, 3122 Suntree Street,
acknowledged being sworn in and spoke in favor of the request. He reported that the access point
issue has been verbally resolved with the current residents,noting that the subject access easement was
used for many years by the homeowners.He outlined the results of the survey explaining that the width
of the easement was widened around 2012 to allow for emergency vehicles. The developer will
provide a twenty-foot(20-ft.) wide access easement for the homeowners. There is one portion of the
BOOK 62 PAGE 46
existing easement that is wider and therefore the developer will honor its current boundaries. The
residents requested that the lane be kept private; therefore, paving will be completed to the end of the
lane with a locked fence put in place for the purpose of emergency access.
In response to questions from Councilman Wagoner, Mr. Butler clarified that each residents already
has a five-foot easement;therefore, the total lane width would be twenty-five feet. A perimeter fence
will be constructed.
Councilman Allgood emphasized that the application for Phases VII & VIII should include actual
landmarks and provisions.
William Felts, 14220 Orchard Avenue, acknowledged being sworn in. Mr. Felts concurred with the
plan proposed by Mr.Butler.
Robin Hadeler, 14218 Orchard Avenue,acknowledged being sworn in and agreed with the twenty foot
easement proposal. He thanked Mr. Butler for meeting with the residents and questioned if all the lots
along the roadway would be a minimum of 10,000 square feet. He noted that the gate will deter the
lane being used by the public.
Liz Schandorff, 14214 Orchard Avenue, acknowledged being sworn in and agreed with the twenty-
foot easement proposal,which would be adequate for emergency vehicles. She asked if she would be
required to remove existing trees and landscaping currently located within the five-foot easement
portion on her property.
Mr. Orton and Mayor reported that the trees and landscaping would be eligible to remain under the
grandfp ther clause at this time.
The Mayor reported that the completion of additional phases within the development would trigger the
need for a public hearing.
In rebuttal, Mr. Butler clarified that in order to provide the easement, the square footage of the
referenced lots are approximately 8,000 sq.ft. in size,which still exceeds the minimum requirement.
Ms. Root reminded Mr. Butler that the development agreement requires the density to remain below
2.5 units per acre, which does not meet the 8,000 sq. ft. proposal. She noted that staff recommended
within the conditions of approval that the lots would remain at 10,000 sq. ft. or greater. However, in
this case where the developer has made allowance to keep the easements intact,the subject lots may be
re-evaluated to make sure that they are in compliance with the development agreement.
MOVED by Callsen,SECONDED by Wagoner to close the public testimony portion of the hearing.
MOTION CARRIED
EVIDENCE LIST FOR CASE NO.TE-20-07:
The Mayor presented the Evidence List: staff report,sign-up sheets,preliminary plat,and aerial map of
Cirrus Point.
MOVED by Callsen,SECONDED by Allgood to accept the Evidence List as presented.
MOTION CARRIED
FINDINGS OF FACT ON CASE NO.TE-20-07:
MOVED by Allgood, SECONDED by Callsen to accept the general facts as outlined in the staff
report,the public testimony that was given in this matter,the evidence list that was presented.
MOTION CARRIED
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW ON CASE NO.TE-20-07:
MOVED by Callsen, SECONDED by Allgood that the Caldwell City Council has the authority to hear
this case and to make the decision to approve or deny; and the public hearing was noticed and heard
within the guidelines of applicable state codes and local ordinances.
MOTION CARRIED
ORDER OF DECISION ON CASE NO.TE-20-07
MOVED by Callsen, SECONDED by Allgood based on the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of
Law,the Caldwell City Council hereby orders that Case No. Case No. TE 20 07, a request for a
24 month time extension of the preliminary plat approval of Cirrus Pointe Subdivision is
approved with the conditions as outlined within the staff report along with an additional
requirement that signed easement agreements between the residents and the developer must be
provided before applications for Phases VII&VIII are submitted.
Mr. Wagoner asked if the signed easement could be misconstrued for the homeowners to request
additional footage beyond the agreed upon twenty foot provision? He asked for an amendment to the
motion for clarification.
BOOK 62 PAGE 47
It was agreed by the motion maker and the second to amend the motion to read:
MOVED by Callsen, SECONDED by Allgood based on the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of
Law,the Caldwell City Council hereby orders that Case No. Case No. TE 20 07, a request for a
24 month time extension of the preliminary plat approval of Cirrus Pointe Subdivision is
approved with the conditions as outlined within the staff report along with an additional
requirement that signed easement agreements between the residents and the developer, per details
provided within tonight's public testimony,must be provided before applications for Phases VII &
VIII are submitted.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Callsen, Pollard, McGee, Allgood, Wagoner, and Hopper. Those
voting no:none. Absent and/or not voting:none.
MOTION CARRIED
MOVED by Callsen,SECONDED by Allgood to close the public hearing.
MOTION CARRIED
NEW BUSINESS
(ACTION ITEM: PUBLIC HEARING: CONCERNING BILL NO 10, ORDINANCE NO.
3330, AN EMERGENCY ORDINANCE ENACTED BY THE CALDWELL CITY COUNCIL
AMENDING CHAPTER 10, ARTICLE 3, SECTION 10-03-11 OF THE CALDWELL CITY
CODE, AMENDING CERTAIN DEFINITIONS APPLICABLE TO ZONING WITHIN THE
CITY OF CALDWELL; AMENDING CHAPTER 10, ARTICLE 12, SECTION 10-12-02
MODIFYING THE APPLICABILITY OF THE CITY CENTER DISTRICT ZONING
REGULATIONS TO ALIGN WITH THE NEW DEFINITIONS IN 10-03-11)
The Mayor declared the public hearing open.
Jerome.Mapp, Planning&Zoning Director at 621 Cleveland Boulevard,provided the staff report. He
outlined the contents of the proposed ordinance noting areas of concern by Planning & Zoning staff
with the current ordinance.
Councilman Hopper commented that the City Center Zoning designation was purposeful and the
boundaries had been established for a purpose.
Discussion followed.
In response to questions by Council Members, Mr. Waterman clarified that this is an emergency
ordinance under the requirements of the Idaho State Code. It is effective for only 182 days and cannot
be continued for an additional period. He noted that this is not an interim ordinance, which is also
outlined within the Idaho State Code.
In response to questions from Councilman Hopper, Mr. Wagoner noted that a local historic district is
regulated by the local Historic Preservation Commission and buildings or sites on the National Historic
Register are regulated by the State Historic Preservation Office(SHPO).
The Mayor noted that no persons signed in to provide public testimony.
MOVED by Allgood,SECONDED by Callsen to close the public hearing.
MOTION CARRIED
(ACTYON ITEM: CONSIDER BILL NO. 10, [ORDINANCE 3330], AN EMERGENCY
ORDINANCE ENACTED BY THE CALDWELL CITY COUNCIL AMENDING CHAPTER
10, ARTICLE 3, SECTION 10-03-11 OF THE CALDWELL CITY CODE; AMENDING
CERTAIN DEFINITIONS APPLICABLE TO ZONING WITHIN THE CITY OF
CALDWELL, AMENDING CHAPTER 10, ARTICLE 12, SECTION 10-12-02 MODIFYING
THE APPLICABILITY OF THE CITY CENTER DISTRICT ZONING REGULATIONS TO
ALIGN WITH THE NEW DEFINITIONS IN 10-03-11 WITH A REQUEST TO WAIVE THE
RULES AND PASS ON THE FIRST READING)
The Mayor read the ordinance by title only:
AN EMERGENCY ORDINANCE ENACTED BY THE CALDWELL CITY COUNCIL
AMENDING CHAPTER 10,ARTICLE 3, SECTION 10-03-11,OF THE CALDWELL CITY CODE,
AMENDING CERTAIN DEFINITIONS APPLICABLE TO ZONING WITHIN THE CITY OF
CALDWELL; AMENDING CHAPTER 10, ARTICLE 12, SECTION 10-12-02, MODIFYING THE
APPLICABILITY OF THE CITY CENTER DISTRICT ZONING REGULATIONS TO ALIGN
WITH THE NEW DEFINITIONS IN 10-03-11; PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE;
PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; AND REPEALING ALL ORDINANCES, RESOLUTIONS,
ORDERS AND PARTS THEREOF,IN CONFLICT HEREWITH.
MOVED by Allgood, SECONDED by Callsen to waive the three reading process and consider Bill
No. 10(Ordinance No.3030)on its first reading by title only.
e
BOOK 62 PAGE 48
Roll call vote: Those voting yes: Allgood, Wagoner, Hopper, Callsen, Pollard, and McGee. Those
voting no:none. Absent and/or not voting:none.
MOTION CARRIED
MOVED by Allgood, SECONDED by Callsen to sponsor Bill No. 10(Ordinance No. 3030)and move
for its passage on its first reading by title only.
Roll call vote: Those voting yes: Allgood, Wagoner, Callsen, Pollard, and McGee. Those voting no:
Hopper. Absent and/or not voting:none.
MOTION CARRIED
(ACT/ONITEM: PUBLIC HEARING [QUASI-JUDICIAL]: SUB20-000012 AND DAA-20-01:
A REQUEST BY PINE STREET LLC, TO MODIFY THE SELAH ESTATES
DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT RECORDED AS INST.#2008023676. ALSO REQUESTING
APPROVAL OF A PRELIMINARY PLAT FOR SELAH ESTATES SUBDIVISION, A
SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT IN AN R-1 [LOW DENSITY
RESIDENTIAL] ZONE ON PARCEL R25052012 CONTAINING 18.76 ACRES. THE
PROPOSED SUBDIVISION CONSISTS OF 52 SINGLE-FAMILY LOTS AND 9 COMMON
LOTS. THE 2040 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN DESIGNATES THIS PROPERTY AS LOW
DENSITY RESIDENTIAL. THE SUBJECT PROPERTY IS LOCATED ON THE
NORTHWEST CORNER OF HOMEDALE ROAD AND 10TH AVENUE)
The Mayor outlined the quasi-judicial public hearing process and asked the City Clerk to swear in
those who would be providing public testimony. He declared the public hearing open.
Debbie Root, Senior Planner at 621 Cleveland Boulevard, acknowledged being sworn in and outlined
the contents of the staff report. She noted that the developer has effectively worked out details with
City staff. Staff had addressed with the developer the need for larger lots and open space along the
property line,which would be appropriate and consistent with the previously submitted plat.
A detailed list of proposed amendments to the development agreement was provided to staff by Mr.
Schultz. The Engineering Department requested all items within the development agreement match
requirements within the current City Code. If Council approves the request, a newly revised
development agreement would be drafted and provided to Council for their consideration.
The developer has met the access requirements to Pat Lane. The lots are varied in size and there is plenty
of open space including park amenities. All of the requirements have been met for landscaping within
the R-1 zoning designation. Staff is recommending approval of the amended development agreement as
proposed by both Mr. Schultz and the Engineering Department. The preliminary plat is compliant with
the Caldwell City Code.
In response to questions from Councilman Wagoner regarding the subdivision's access issues, Ms. Root
reported that the developer has worked with Engineering Department regarding the restricted 10th
Avenue access.
Matt Schultz, 8421 South Ten Mile, Meridian, acknowledged being sworn in and spoke in favor of the
request. He noted that Dr. Black has owned the property since 2008 when the original plat was drafted.
The access along 10t Avenue was recommended by the Canyon County Highway District. Access
along Homedale Road is not allowed. Updates have been made to the plat to meet the current
requirements within the City Code. The average lot size is over 9,000 sq.ft. The residences on the west
boundary line will be single-story structures and fencing will be provided. The homes are approximately
1,800 sq. ft. for single-story residences and 2,200 sq. ft. for double-story residences. The provisions
within the development agreement have been reviewed and agreed upon by the neighbors. The
developer concurs with the staff report.
In response to questions from Councilman Wagoner, Mr. Schultz confirmed that they would prefer to
keep the access along 10th Avenue—not along Homedale Road.
Brent Orton, Public Works Director at 621 Cleveland Boulevard,clarified that a letter was received from
Canyon Highway District stating that they would not support an access along Homedale Road.
Mr. Schultz clarified that requirements for a full access along 10`x'Avenue have been met.
The Mayor read into the record a letter from Betty Hunsicker in favor of the request and labeled it as CC-
1000.
Dear Sirs:
Unfortunately, I am not able to attend the city council meeting in person because my daughter was
invited to play violin at the Caldwell school board meeting tonight. Please accept this written testimony.
I am supportive of the Selah estates proposal. This comes after many emails and discussions with the
developer, me letting go of the 20 undeveloped acres in front of my house, and their wiliness to make
some concession.
BOOK 62 PAGE 49
The proposal has been described as a "semi-custom" development, similar to Cumberland Estates or
Sienna Hills with multiple homebuilders (at least three [3] likely more than that per emails with Mr.
Schultz). Obviously, this is an important point to create an attractive and desirable neighborhood along
the gateway into Caldwell.
I don't know how best to ensure that this is indeed how this property is developed, and would defer to
your expertise on this matter. One possible consideration would be that any material change in property
ownership(say a new builder or owner buying 50%or more of the property) would require re-approval
on the development agreement/plat/etc.
While I believe that the current owner has every intention of developing the property as proposed, we
(the neighbors and the community) deserve the opportunity to, if ownership changes hands now or in the
future, ensure that the spirit of the development remains consistent with what is being approved today.
Thank you for your consideration. Betsy Hunsicker
The Mayor and the City Attorney clarified that the amended development agreement, if approved,
would remain with the property and thus any new owner/developer would be obligated to fulfill the
requirements within the same document.
Mr.Orton concurred that the 10t Avenue access is a full access.
In rebuttal, Matt Schultz expressed appreciation to the Hunsicker family for their involvement and
concern with the development plan. Mr. Schultz reported that Ms. Hunsicker had asked for a
guarantee that there would only be one owner who would comply with the conditions outlined within
the development agreement. Although there cannot be such a guarantee,the development agreement
is fairly robust and will produce the controls as expressed by the neighbors. This will be a high-quality
development. The development agreement will remain with the land until any future conditions are
approved.
Councilman Hopper expressed concern with the road grade along 10`" Avenue. Are there any
reservations by staff due to the road grade associated with the designated access point?
Mr. Orton responded that the most significant concern would be with site distance and acceleration.
The standards would be met per the guidance documents from the Association of Highway and
Transportation.
MOVED by Allgood, SECONDED by Wagoner to close the public testimony portion of the hearing.
r
MOTION CARRIED
EVIDENCE LIST FOR DAA-20-01 AND SUB20-000012:
The Mayor presented the Evidence List: staff report, sign-up sheets, preliminary plat, the amended
development agreement,aerial of SUB-20-000012 and CC-1000(letter by Betsy Hunsicker).
MOVED by Callsen,SECONDED by McGee to accept the Evidence List as presented.
MOTION CARRIED
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ANALYSIS FOR CASE NO.DAA-20-01:
MOVED by Callsen, SECONDED by Allgood to accept the Comprehensive Plan Analysis as
presented in the staff report under roman number V.
MOTION CARRIED
FINDINGS OF FACT ON CASE NO.DAA-20-01:
MOVED by Allgood, SECONDED by Callsen to accept the general facts as outlined in the staff
report,the public testimony that was given in this matter,and the evidence list that was presented.
MOTION CARRIED
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW ON CASE NO.DAA-20-01:
MOVED by Callsen, SECONDED by Allgood that the Caldwell City Council has the authority to hear
this case and to make the decision to approve or deny; and the public hearing was noticed and heard
within the guidelines of applicable state codes and local ordinances.
MOTION CARRIED
ORDER OF DECISION ON CASE NO.DAA-20-01:
MOVED by Allgood, SECONDED by Hopper based on the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law,
the Caldwell City Council hereby orders that Development Agreement#2008023676 modifications be
approved with the conditions as listed in Section IX of the staff report.
BOOK 62 PAGE 50
10
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Allgood, Wagoner, Hopper, Callsen, Pollard, and McGee. Those
voting no:none. Absent and/or not voting:none.
MOTION CARRIED
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ANALYSIS FOR CASE NO. SUB20-000012:
MOVED by Callsen, SECONDED by Hopper to accept the Comprehensive Plan Analysis as presented
in the staff report under roman number X.
FINDINGS OF FACT ON CASE NO. SUB20-000012: MOTION CARRIED
MOVED by Callsen, SECONDED by Allgood to accept the general facts as outlined in the staff
report,the public testimony that was given in this matter,and the evidence list that was presented.
MOTION CARRIED
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW ON CASE NO. SUB20-000012:
MOVED by Allgood, SECONDED by Callsen that the Caldwell City Council has the authority to hear
this case and to make the decision to approve or deny; and the public hearing was noticed and heard
within the guidelines of applicable state codes and local ordinances.
MOTION CARRIED
ORDL'k OF DECISION ON CASE NO. SUB20-000012:
MOVED by Callsen, SECONDED by Allgood based on the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law,
the Caldwell City Council hereby orders that hereby order that Case Number SUB20-000012, a
request for Preliminary Plat for Selah Estates Subdivision, a single-family residential development in
an R-1 (Low Density Residential)zone on parcel R25052012 containing 18.74 acres be approved with
conditions listed in Section IX&XIV to be enumerated in a Development Agreement.
Councilman Wagoner expressed his disapproval of the determination by Canyon County Highway
District concerning the 10th Avenue access rather than along Homedale Road.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Callsen, Pollard, McGee, Allgood, Wagoner, and Hopper. Those
voting no:none. Absent and/or not voting:none.
MOTION CARRIED
MOVED by Allgood, SECONDED by Wagoner to close the public hearing.
MOTION CARRIED
(ACTION ITEM: PUBLIC HEARING [QUASI-JUDICIAL]: ANN-20-07/SUB-20P-14: CRAIG
KULCHAK IS REQUESTING TO ANNEX THREE(3)ACRES WITH A ZONE DESIGNATION
OF R2 (MEDIUM DENSITY RESIDENTIAL) CONSISTENT WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE
PLAN DESIGNATION. ALSO REQUESTED IS APPROVAL OF A PRELIMINARY PLAT
FOR LAKE PARK SUBDIVISION CONSISTING OF 11 SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL
LOTS-WITH AN AVERAGE LOT SIZE OF 6128 SQ. FT. AND THREE (3) COMMON LOTS.
THE SUBJECT PROPERTY IS LOCATED 780 SOUTH OF THE INTERSECTION OF LAKE
AVE. AND HOMEDALE ROAD ON THE WEST SIDE OF LAKE AVE. [11-3N-3W-NE] IN
CALDWELL,IDAHO)
The Mayor declared the public hearing open and noted testimony would be applicable to both items. He
explained that the annexation request would be addressed first. If the annexation were approved,Council
would then consider the preliminary plat request. If the annexation were denied, the request for the
preliminary plat would not move forward.
Debbie Root, Senior Planner at 21 Cleveland Boulevard, acknowledged being sworn in and outlined the
contents of the staff report. She noted that concern had been expressed by the neighbors about the
density of the proposed subdivision. Neighbors had requested that the parcel remain in Canyon County
and/or that the density be reduced from eleven(11)to eight(8)units. The developer submitted a revised
plan today providing an additional landscape buffer adjacent to one of the neighbors at the north
boundary.
Ms. Root noted that the connection request to Lake Avenue was not approved by the City Engineer.
The land-use request is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan even though there have been concerns
expressed by the public regarding compatibility issues with the surrounding area. The Engineering
Department is in favor of the development as planned,noting that the preliminary plat is consistent with
the Subdivision Ordinance.
Counoilman Wagoner expressed concern with the roadway being located to the south within the
preliminary plat design. He recommended it be relocated to the northern portion of the plat, which
would allow more compatibility with the surrounding parcels. He outlined potential difficulties in the
traffic patterns with the roadway's current placement.
In response to questions from Councilman Allgood, Ms. Root reported that the turnaround indicated on
the plat meets the requirements from the Caldwell Fire Department.
BOOK 62 PAGE 51
Discussion followed between Councilman Wagoner and Public Works Director, Brent Orton, regarding
the poftntial relocation of the roadway.
Craig Kulchak, Developer at 4839 Mountain View Drive, Boise, acknowledged being sworn in and
spoke in favor of the request. He outlined the amenities within the current preliminary plat and reported
that extensive research had been conducted concerning the placement of the roadway to the south of the
development.
Nick LcCross, of BA Engineer at 5505 W. Franklin Road, Boise, acknowledged being sworn in and
spoke in favor of the request as presented.
Cynthia Smith, 16871 Lake Avenue, acknowledged being sworn in and spoke in opposition to the
request. Ms. Smith stated that the development does not fit with the demographics of the surrounding
area. She expressed concern regarding density of the development, fencing issues, single level
residences versus double level,landscaping berms for additional privacy,light pollution and maintenance
of the irrigation ditch. She requested that the new residence not have access to the existing lane used by
the homeowners.
In response to questions from Councilman Allgood, Ms. Smith expressed her concern with the proposed
two-story homes within the development, which would create less privacy for the existing homes. She
also noted that the current fence along the boundary is an electric wire fence due to livestock.
Bob Smith, 16871 Lake Avenue, acknowledged being sworn in and spoke in opposition to the request.
Mr. Smith expressed concern about weed control at the site, loss of property value due to the housing
development,maintenance of the irrigation ditch,use of his private lane by the developer or his staff,and
no follow-up by the developer since the neighborhood meeting. He noted that he owns horses and spoke
to the potential damage will could occur with the placement of a fence along the property border. He
referenced the need for a buffer between the properties; noting a landscaping berm would assist with
irrigation issues since he uses flood irrigation. Livestock issues would remain a concern whether the
roadway is placed to the south or north portion of the property.
In rebuttal, Mr. Kulchak reported that communication has taken place consistently via email with Mr.
Smith. Mr Kulchak had also provided his own contact information to Mr. Smith for easy access
regarding property issues. There is one access point, which is located on the southeast corner of the
parcel. He was not aware of anyone using the lane to Mr. Smith's residence. Contact has been made
with Pioneer Irrigation about the irrigation line to the east of the site. This information was
communicated with the Engineering Department for purpose of upgrades being made to the pumping
station. The station's use will be augmented to allow for pressurized irrigation at the site. There will be
no flood irrigation within the new development.
Mr. Kulchak explained they are currently working on three other projects in Boise valley. One of the
homes recently sold for $900,000. He will work with the neighbors about fencing related to livestock
issues. In addition to the planned fencing within the development, a rod iron or PVC fence could be
placed on the west end of the property along the ditch.
Mr. Kulchak noted that he had spoken with Mr. Smith via email about reimbursing him for the
inconvenience of taking care of the ditch prior to his current ownership. There are now plans to tile the
ditch due to safety concerns. The amount of lots have been reduced from 14 to 11 and single layer
residences as well as two-story homes are allowed in accordance with the comprehensive plan.
Discussion followed as initiated by Councilman Wagoner regarding the potential relocation of the
roadway from the south end of the property to the north boundary. Councilman Wagoner inquired if the
sewer line could be moved to the north boundary.
Mr. Orton reported that there could be potential problems with the relocation of the sewer line from the
south boundary to the northern portion due to the need for depth.
MOVED by Allgood,SECONDED by Hopper to close the public testimony portion of the hearing.
MOTION CARRIED
EVIDENCE LIST FOR ANN-20-07&SUB-20P-14:
The Mayor presented the Evidence List: staff report, sign-up sheets, aerial map of ANN-20-07, the
preliminary plat,and the updated landscape plan.
MOVED by Callsen,SECONDED by Wagoner to accept the Evidence List as presented.
MOTION CARRIED
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ANALYSIS FOR CASE NO.ANN-20-07:
MOVED by Callsen, SECONDED by Wagoner to accept the Comprehensive Plan Analysis as
presented in the staff report under roman number V.
MOTION CARRIED
BOOK 62 PAGE 52
FINDINGS OF FACT ON CASE NO. ANN-20-07:
MOVED by Allgood, SECONDED by Wagoner to accept the general facts as outlined in the staff
report,the public testimony that was given in this matter,and the evidence list that was presented.
MOTION CARRIED
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW ON CASE NO.ANN-20-07:
MOVED by Callsen, SECONDED by Allgood that the Caldwell City Council has the authority to hear
this case and to make the decision to approve or deny; and the public hearing was noticed and heard
within the guidelines of applicable state codes and local ordinances.
MOTION CARRIED
ORDER OF DECISION ON CASE NO.ANN-20-07:
Councilman Wagoner addressed comments made within public testimony regarding compatibility of
the new development with existing residences. He explained that change will continue to come to the
area and the R-2 zoning classification is appropriate for the site.
MOVED by Wagoner, SECONDED by Hopper based on the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of
Law, the Caldwell City Council hereby Case Number ANN-20-07, a request to annex parcel
R3272601000, 2.90 acres, with a zone designation of R-2 (Medium Density Residential) consistent
with the 2040 Comprehensive Plan designation of Medium Density Residential be approved with
conditions of approval listed in Section 10 pf the staff report.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Wagoner, Hopper,Callsen, McGee, and Allgood. Those voting no:
Pollard. Absent and/or not voting:none.
MOTION CARRIED
COMPrREHENSIVE PLAN ANALYSIS FOR CASE NO. SUB-20P-14:
MOVED by Callsen, SECONDED by Hopper to accept the Comprehensive Plan Analysis as presented
in the staff report under roman number XI.
MOTION CARRIED
FINDINGS OF FACT ON CASE NO. SUB-20P-14:
MOVED by Allgood, SECONDED by Hopper to accept the general facts as outlined in the staff
report,the public testimony that was given in this matter,and the evidence list that was presented.
MOTION CARRIED
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW ON CASE NO. SUB-20P-14:
MOVED by Callsen, SECONDED by Hopper that the Caldwell City Council has the authority to hear
this case and to make the decision to approve or deny; and the public hearing was noticed and heard
within the guidelines of applicable state codes and local ordinances.
MOTION CARRIED
ORDER OF DECISION ON CASE NO. SUB-20P-14:
MOVED by Wagoner, SECONDED by Hopper based on the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of
Law, the Caldwell City Council hereby orders that Case No. SUB20P-14 a request for a preliminary
plat, Lake Park Subdivision, containing 2.90 acres with 11 residential lots and 2 common lots on R-2
(Medium Density Residential)zoned property,be approved with the conditions of approval in Section
17 to bre enumerated in a development agreement and additional conditions be included as follows: 1)
The roadway would be located to the north of the subject property for the purpose of removal of the
stub street currently shown at the Chestnut Subdivision,thus allowing traffic to access Lake Avenue as
well as assist with the elimination of livestock concerns, and 2) The number of residential lots be
reduced from eleven to ten.
The Mayor consulted with the City Attorney concerning the motion, noting the conditions expressed
by Councilman Wagoner dramatically change the preliminary plat and thus could require a new
preliminary plat.
The City Attorney confirmed that the motion is viable.
Councilman Hopper recommended that the determination be continued until comments are received
from the Engineering Department and the developer regarding the proposed additional conditions of
approval.
The City Attorney reported that since the public testimony portion of the hearing was closed, the
motion should be voted upon. If the request is denied,the applicant could submit a new application.
The Mayor noted that any decision by City Council is subject to appeal. He expressed concern with
the proper procedure being followed concerning the outcome of the public hearing. The motion is
substantially different from the design of the presented preliminary plat. The motion does not allow
the public to comment on the recent proposal for the relocation of the roadway since it was not
BOOK 62 PAGE 53
advertised accordingly. He stated that the most transparent action would be to deny the application
and stating the appropriate reasoning. The applicant may then resubmit a new application or appeal the
action.
Councilman Callsen stated his opposition to the motion, noting that staff and engineers for the
developer have reviewed the application extensively and made appropriate recommendations.
Douglas Waterman reported that there is an appeal opportunity if the motion passed. He noted that it
was his opinion that the motion was not outside of the scope of what was appropriate.
c
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Wagoner. Those voting no: Hopper, Callsen, Pollard, McGee, and
Allgood. Absent and/or not voting:none.
MOTION FAILED
MOVED by Callsen, SECONDED by Wagoner based on the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of
Law, the Caldwell City Council hereby orders that Case No. SUB20P-14 a request for a preliminary
plat, Lake Park Subdivision, containing 2.90 acres with 11 residential lots and 2 common lots on R-2
(Medium Density Residential)zoned property,be approved with the conditions of approval in Section
17 to be enumerated in a development agreement.
Councilman Wagoner stated his support for the overall development and noted that it was his desire
that the request move forward. He encouraged other Council Members to support the current motion.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Callsen, Pollard, McGee, Allgood, Wagoner, and Hopper. Those
voting no:none. Absent and/or not voting:none.
MOTION CARRIED
MOVED by Allgood,SECONDED by Wagoner to close the public hearing.
MOTION CARRIED
(ACTION ITEM: CONSIDER BILL NO. 68 [ORDINANCE NO. 3316] FOR CASE NO. ANN-
20-074LAKE PARK ANNEXATION] WITH A REQUEST TO WAIVE THE RULES, PASS
ON THE FIRST READING,AND APPROVE THE SUMMARY FOR PUBLICATION)
The Mayor read the ordinance by title only:
AN ORDINANCE DETERMINING THAT CERTAIN LAND LAYS CONTIGUOUS TO THE CITY
LIMITS OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL, COUNTY OF CANYON, STATE OF IDAHO, AND
THAT SAID LANDS SHOULD BE ANNEXED TO THE CITY OF CALDWELL, IDAHO, AS
PART OF THE R-2 (MEDIUM DENSITY RESIDENTIAL) ZONE; DECLARING SAID LANDS
BY PROPER LEGAL DESCRIPTION AS DESCRIBED BELOW TO BE A PART OF THE CITY
OF CALDWELL, CANYON COUNTY, IDAHO; DIRECTING THE CITY ENGINEER AND
PLANNING AND ZONING DIRECTOR TO ADD SAID PROPERTY TO THE OFFICIAL MAPS
OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL, IDAHO; REPEALING ALL ORDINANCES, RESOLUTIONS,
ORDERS OR PARTS THEREOF IN CONFLICT HEREWITH;AND DIRECTING THE CLERK OF
THE CITY OF CALDWELL TO FILE A CERTIFIED COPY OF THE ORDINANCE AND MAP OF
THE AREA TO BE ANNEXED WITH CANYON COUNTY, STATE OF IDAHO AND THE
IDAHO STATE TAX COMMISSION,PURSUANT TO IDAHO CODE,SECTION 63-215.
MOVED by Callsen, SECONDED by Allgood to waive the three reading process and consider Bill
No.68(Ordinance No.3316)on its first reading by title only.
Roll call vote: Those voting yes: Callsen, Pollard, McGee, Allgood, Wagoner, and Hopper. Those
voting no:none. Absent and/or not voting:none.
MOTION CARRIED
MOVED by Callsen, SECONDED by Allgood to sponsor Bill No. 68(Ordinance No. 3316),move for
its passage by title only,and approve the summary for publication.
Roll call vote: Those voting yes: Callsen, Pollard, McGee, Allgood, Wagoner, and Hopper. Those
voting no:none. Absent and/or not voting:none.
MOTION CARRIED
(ACTION ITEM: PUBLIC HEARING: CASE NO TE-20-10: A REQUEST FOR A TIME
EXTENSION OF A PRELIMINARY PLAT FOR CANYON CROSSING SUBDIVISION, A
RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT IN AN R-2 [MEDIUM DENSITY RESIDENTIAL] ZONE
CONTAINING 31 RESIDENTIAL LOTS AND 5 COMMON LOTS ON 8.5 ACRES+/-, ON
PARCEL R02666101, AND (PHASE I) LOTS 1-13 OF BLK 1 CANYON CROSSING PHASE I
CONTAINING 11 MULTI-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL LOTS RECORDED ON MARCH 18,2020.
PHASE I UNITS ARE CURRENTLY UNDER CONSTRUCTION. THE DEVELOPMENT IS
LOCATED ON THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF SYRINGA LANE AND FLORIDA AVENUE.
THE DEVELOPMENT IS SUBJECT TO CANYON CROSSING DEVELOPMENT
AGREEMENT,INSTRUMENT NUMBER 2016-049500)
BOOK 62
PAGE 54
MOVED by Callsen, SECONDED by Pollard per request of the applicant to continue the hearing to
the Regularly Scheduled City Council meeting to be held on May 3,2021.
MOTION CARRIED
(FINANCE AND HUMAN RESOURCE REPORTS)
Councilman Pollard reported that the Finance Committee has reviewed current accounts payable in the
amount of$1,910,935.83 for the period ending March 10, 2021, a net payroll of$383,713.79 for the
pay period ending February 27,2021.
MOVED by Pollard, SECONDED by Allgood that accounts payable in the amount of$1,910,935.83
by check numbers 152152 through 152390 and payroll in the amount of$383,713.79 represented by
check,numbers 35773 through 35785 and direct deposits be accepted, payments approved and
vouchers filed in the office of the City Clerk.
(COUNCIL COMMENTS) MOTION CARRIED
None.
(MAYOR'S COMMENTS)
• The Mayor provided an update regarding current action by the Idaho legislators.
• He expressed appreciation for tonight's discussion at the City Council Workshop regarding
budgetary issues.
• He reported that he met the new Idaho Miss Amazing today. She requested the opportunity to
meet the other Council members as well.
• The AIC legislative update meeting is scheduled via Zoom on Friday.
(ADJOURNMENT)
MOVED by Allgood, SECONDED by Hopper to adjourn at 10:07 p.m.
MOTION CARRIED
APPROVED AS written THIS 5th DAY OF April ,2021.
•
May.1111
C o u•slpe on j, ir9, ,
� ifi
niI4 fiff•41 /-
4Jon
�
Councilperso Coy' ,Jr.r
Councilperson Counc' erson
ATTEST:
o` OF C
City Clerk - JtCi6600...)
���°�....,,�Ld •
G:°GORPO,?,,
• JAN d°• r _
15 E•
•
= 0L; • 0