Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2020-11-11 CHPC Minutes CALDWELL HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MINUTES Meeting of November 11,2020 @ 6:30 P.M. Caldwell Police Department—Community Room 110 S 5'h Avenue,Caldwell,Idaho I. Call to order. Chairperson King called the meeting to order at approximately 6:35 p.m. II. Roll Call APPROVED Members Present.Jacob King,Megan Dixon,Randy Lyons. Date 2- _ Members Absent.Nicole Bradshaw and Steve Maughan. Others Present.Jerome Mapp,Planning&Zoning Director; Rob Hopper, City Council Liaison, and April Cabello,Planning Technician. Others Absent. None. III. Approval of Minutes. MOTION TO APPROVE THE MINUTES OF AUGUST 26,2020. MOTION Commissioner Dixon SECOND: Commissioner Lyons,MOTION PASSED. IV. Certificate of Appropriateness Interviews. Action Item: CA-20-12 Applicant: Chad Kmiecik, 1312 Blaine Street,Caldwell,ID.A request for a Certificate of Appropriates to build an approximately 529 square foot detached garage. The site is located at 1312 Blaine Street, Caldwell, ID within the Steunenberg Residential Historic District. April Cabello,Planning Technician, 621 Cleveland Blvd.,Caldwell,ID presented the staff report. Ms.Cabello shared with the commission that the applicant desires to receive a Certificate of Appropriateness from the Historic Preservation Commission to build a 529 square foot detached garage. Ms.Cabello gave background on the application and shared the reason this application is before the commission is because per the Decision Matrix adopted by resolution states construction or installation of garages or accessory structures for a contributing property is commission level approval.The subject property 1312 Blaine Street is located in the R-1 Zone and exists in the Steunenberg Residential Historic District.The subject property had the National Register Recommendation Survey in 1999.The 1999 survey documented the subject property with an estimated construction date of 1920;the style was Arts&Crafts Bungalow and listed as contributing in a potential district.The 1999 survey noted to be in good condition with aluminum siding,wood windows with aluminum storms and an asphalt shingle roof.The comments made on the survey stated that it was altered but retains historic integrity;brackets and windows display characteristics of historic period.The applicant is seeking approval to build a detached garage at the rear of the property not visible from the street.The existing home is 2,033 square feet and is 23 feet in height;the proposed detached rear garage will be 529 square feet and be 23 feet in height. The subject property currently has a home and a shed and no demolition will be required or requested for any structure.The applicant will be required by city code to pave the parking area and meet all setback and building requirements. Page 1 of 6 Chad Kmiecik,Applicant, 1312 Blaine Street,Caldwell ID gave supporting testimony stating he would like to build a detached garage in the back of the property with alley access and noted the change in the plan reducing the height. Chairman King asked about the siding width. Mr.Kmiecik responded that he did not know the current width and referred the commission to the pictures of the shed and stated the siding will be the same as on the shed. The siding looks very similar to the siding on the house. Commissioner Dixon thanked the applicant for the narrative,photos and the plans. Mr.Kmiecik stated for the record,the materials are hardiplank cement lap siding,architectural asphalt roofmg shingles,vinyl single hung windows to look similar to the old style vertical up and down,and a steel garage door.The color will match the house. Chairman King stated for the record one of his biggest goals is the relationship between the applicant and the commission.It is not just that the commission wants the district to look a certain way;they want the applicant to be happy with their house as well. Mr.Kmiecik stated that they are excited because they have done a lot of work on the house to make it look nice and they want to help improve the area and bring it back to its former glory. Chairman King stated the commission appreciates their effort. Ruth Kmiecik, 1312 Blaine Street,Caldwell,ID signed in favor of the application but did not wish to speak. Mark Subia,2315 Parker Avenue,Caldwell,ID signed in favor of the application and shared that he has built two detached garages on the North End of Boise,both of which had bonus rooms above them and the City of Boise welcomed them and did require the structure matched the house. He also helped build a Queen Anne and it had a bonus room.He also built a detached garage on College Avenue that had a bonus room above it in the College District that matched the existing house.He is building a house on 1216 Parker that will have a detached garage that will match the existing house.The commission should welcome anyone trying to make an improvement to improve the Historic District. Jerome Mapp,Planning Director, 621 Cleveland Blvd.,Caldwell,ID stated for the record and brought to the attention of the commission that an Accessory Dwelling Unit is not before the commission this evening;they are looking at a request for a garage. Mr.Mapp submitted exhibit A,the definition of a shed because a question came up if the applicant could have a garage and a shed,and they can. Chairman King closed the public testimony. V FINDINGS OF FACT 5.1 The Historic Preservation Commission accepts the staff report and the evidence list(consisting of the written and verbal staff report,public testimony,the case file,and the sign-up sheets) and facts brought forward during public testimony. The Historic Preservation Commission further finds the following: Page 2 of 6 02-17-11: FINDINGS FOR GRANTING A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS: (1) The commission shall review application(s)with the findings outlined below as pertaining to the request for a certificate of appropriateness.The commission may attach conditions of approval to the application to ensure compliance with the findings.Modifications to the application may be submitted and will be considered at a staff level. In reviewing the modification,planning staff will utilize the original findings under which the application was reviewed to ensure the project still complies with the requirements for a certificate of appropriateness. (Ord.3126, 1-16-2018) (2) The commission shall find that the design of the project is consistent with the following plans and guidelines that apply to the property: A. U.S. Secretary of the Interior's standards for rehabilitation and guidelines for rehabilitating historic buildings. B. Chapter 10 of this Code,as amended and adopted by City Council. C. Steunenberg Residential Historic District design guidelines,as amended and adopted (copies available in the Caldwell Planning and Zoning Department). D. City of Caldwell Comprehensive Plan,as amended and adopted by City Council.(Ord. 2905,9-4-2012) 02-17-11-04: NEW CONSTRUCTION;FINDINGS: (1) The following objectives and fmdings, shall be considered where applicable to the proposal: A. Minimizes Traffic Impact:That the site design minimizes impact of traffic on adjacent streets and that the pedestrian and bicyclist have been provided for by requiring sidewalks, landscaping,and safe parking lot design as appropriate.Commission finds this to be true. B. Landscaping: That the proposed landscaping enhances the historic district and neighborhood with attributes that include,but are not limited to,protection of desirable existing trees,provision of street trees,and adequate screening methods where needed to buffer adjacent uses and unsightly areas or features. Considerations relative to this subsection(1)B: 1.The location,height and materials of walls,fences,hedges,and screening plantings to ensure harmony with adjacent developments; 2.The planting of street trees and the unnecessary destruction of existing trees and landscape features; 3.The provision of plantings or other screening methods reasonably required to conceal outdoor storage areas,trash receptacles, exposed machinery installation,utility buildings and installations and similar accessory areas or other unsightly developments. Chairman King stated that this does not pertain to this case. C. On Site Grading And Drainage:That on site grading and drainage have been designed so as to minimize off site impact and provide for erosion control as required by the city of Caldwell. Chairman King stated that this does not pertain to this case. D. Review Of Building Mass:That the mass of the building shall be reviewed for its relationship to other buildings within the local historic district.The commission finds this to be true. E. Proportion Of Building Facades: The height to width relationship shall be compatible and consistent with the predominant architectural character of the local historic district.The commission finds this to be true. Page 3 of 6 • • F. Shadow Relief/Design Interest:The exterior of the building shall provide shadow relief and design interest compatible with the architectural character of the local historic district. The commission fords this to be true. G. Appropriateness Of Materials: The appropriateness of materials shall be reviewed as they relate to building mass, shadow relief,and compatibility with other buildings within the local historic district.The commission finds this to be true. H. Consistency Of Design:The commission shall find that the design of the project is consistent with the plans and guidelines listed in section 02-17-11 of this article. (Ord. 2905,9-4-2012).The commission finds this to be true. VI CONCLUSIONS OF LAW 6.1 The Historic Preservation Commission has the authority to hear this case and order that it be approved or denied.The public notice requirements were met and the hearing was conducted within the guidelines of applicable Idaho Code and City ordinances. VII ORDER OF DECISION 7.1 Based on the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law,the Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission hereby orders that Case Number CA-20-12,a request by Chad Kmiecik for a Certificate of Appropriateness to build a detached garage located at 1312 Blaine Street is APPROVED. MOTION: Commissioner Dixon SECOND: Commissioner Lyons PASSED: unanimous voice vote V. Audience Participation. None. VI. Actions Since Last Meeting. • Discussion Item: Chairman King reviewed case number CA-20-09 Applicant: Oscar Correa, 1615 Fillmore Street,Caldwell,ID.Commission Level approval to remove and close up 2 small side windows and 1 large side window on the front sunroom. • Discussion Item: Chairman King reviewed case number CA-20-10 Applicant: Brian Clendenon, 1620 Dearborn Street,Caldwell,ID. Staff Level approval replacing wrought iron stair railing with wrought iron stair railing. • Discussion Item: Chairman King reviewed case number CA-20-13 Applicant:Nicole Bradshaw, 1916 Fillmore Street,Caldwell,ID. Staff Level approval re-roof,remove wood shake shingles and replace with architectural style shingles. VII. Old Business. • Action Item: Steunenberg Facebook page and C of I Student Internship: continued to a future meeting • Action Item:Newsletter and C of I student internship: The commission and staff discussed the value of the newsletter and how important it is to continue sending them to the residents in the district.It was suggested looking into having an article placed in the Caldwell Perspective. Page 4 of 6 • Action Item: Adding a new commission member: Commissioner Dixon shared that there are three potential candidates but with the craziness of this year and the COVID virus,it has not been pursued.It was suggested that the commission decide when they feel would be a good time to have the candidates come and meet the commission and see what the meetings are like. VIII. New Business.None. IX. Commission&Staff Reports. • Commissioner Dixon stated her appreciation for the write up in the staff report in section 2.5.Discussion followed among the commission,Mr.Mapp and Councilman Hopper. • Commissioner Dixon discussed a philosophical issue as a commission member she would like to consult with other bodies in the City about the framing of the concerns of the commission. It is time for a water-shed conversation as properties are changing hands and there is a lot of energy coming into the district and desire to make improvements. She does not want to see the commission fighting a wave of enthusiasm for making physical improvements to the dwellings.Example is Mr. Subia who testified tonight seemed as he came simply to say,if somebody wants to do something to improve their property,the commission should allow them to do it.There is a limit to that,given it is a Historic District but feels it needs some discussion. Councilman Hopper stated the commission knows a non-conforming structure when they see it and knows when it does not fit in with the neighborhood and the commission is a guide to determine if the structure will look okay and be harmonious.Commissioner Dixon stated that she felt more applications would be submitted with materials that are on the border, is the material historic or will the proposed material last longer.Councilman Hopper stated that things change and so do product, several years back the commission decided to allow vinyl windows because of the significate difference in cost.Councilman Hopper also shared the reason for having the commission is so that it really is the unity deciding how the district should grow and evolve and stay with the character. Commissioner Dixon suggested the commission have a conversation about how does the commission frame this and where does the commission think they might compromise in the future,the way the previous commission did with the vinyl windows. Councilman Hopper suggested working on the template for the hearing to make sure the commission is focusing on the appropriate things.Mr.Mapp asked the commission to point out things in the ordinance that do not fit or work for him to fix or clarify. Chairman King stated a gray area is the design or style. This district is full of working class people and it makes sense to make concessions in certain areas,the commission is guided by National level criteria, State and City Code,the commission's explanation is important but a lot of it has to do with the messaging of it.The commission needs to have more conversations within the community and say this is why the commission does what they do.The commission does not want not want to be the bureaucratic board of denial to this community for potential subjective reasons. Commissioner Dixon would like the commission to come together and talk about what they are seeing,what seems inbounds,look at streamlining the process and what really matters to the commission.Commissioner Dixon asked about the follow through on Certificate of Appropriateness and the compliance,what really matters. • April Cabello shared with the commission the meeting calendar for 2021 and explained that the primary regular meeting shall be held on the fourth Wednesday of the month unless there is not any certificate of appropriateness to review or other pertinent commission business to discuss.The supplemental regular meeting shall be held on the second Wednesday of the month if there are any certificates of appropriateness for consideration. • April Cabello shared with the commission the 2021 Annual Update Report Presentation to City Council schedule and the commission is scheduled to present on October 18,2021. Page 5 of 6 • April Cabello stated the November 25, 2020 has been canceled and the next meeting will be on December 9, 2020 to hear a Certificate of Appropriateness application. • Jerome Mapp informed the commission of a zoom Planning&Zoning training in January 2021. X. Meeting adjourned at approximately 8:00 p.m. Respectfully submitted by April Cabello, MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BELOW BY CHAIRMAN KING ON THE DATE NOTED BELOW. ^221 Chairma ng Date lop/ /--z --z/ ATTEST: Jerome Mapp,P1 'ng D ector Date For detailed minutes,please request a copy of the digital recording. Page 6 of 6