HomeMy WebLinkAbout2020-07-08 CHPC Minutes APPROVED
Q11_
CALDWELL HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMOSION MINUTES
Meeting of July 8,2020 @ 6:30 P.M.
Caldwell Police Department—Community Room
110 S 5th Avenue,Caldwell,Idaho
I. Call to order. Chairperson King called the meeting to order at approximately 6:35 p.m.
II. Roll Call
Members Present.Jacob King,Randy Lyons,Megan Dixon,Nicole Bradshaw and Steve Maughan.
Members Absent.None.
Others Present.Jerome Mapp, Planning&Zoning Director; and April Cabello, Planning Technician.
Others Absent. Rob Hopper,City Council Liaison.
HI. Approval of Minutes.
MOTION TO APPROVE THE MINUTES OF February 12,2020 and February 26,2020.
MOTION Commissioner Dixon SECOND: Commissioner Bradshaw,MOTION PASSED.
IV. Certificate of Appropriateness Interviews.
Action Item: CA-20-05 Applicant: William and Madeline Buckendorf, 1805 Everett Street,
Caldwell, ID.Public Hearing,Commission Level approval-approving the change to the land use
category of the existing Home Office/Study attached to the existing garage to an Accessory
Dwelling Unit,and recommending the Approval for a Special Use Permit.
Jerome Mapp,Planning&Zoning Director, 621 Cleveland Blvd.,Caldwell,ID presented the staff
report.Mr.Mapp shared with the commission that there are two parts to this application and the
first motion would be for the approval or denial of the Accessory Dwelling unit and issuance of
the Certificate of Appropriateness and the second motion would be for the recommendation of
approval for the special use.
Mr.Mapp gave background on the application.The home was built in 1931 and consisted of a
dwelling and a detached garage. In 1982 the property owner received a building permit to add a
336 square foot study area to the existing garage,and the current setback of the garage is 4 feet
from the alley way and 3 feet from the property line.The study was added to the garage with the
same setback and under planning rules as long,they kept the same setback there is no issue with
the side yard setback so the use is conforming to the code.The study included a roughed-in
plumbing for a restroom. In February 2020 the current property owner submitted a building permit
to complete the bathroom and the previous Planning and Zoning Director approved in 2019
approved the bathroom based upon the 1982 addition was plumbed. The Planning&Zoning staff
informed the current owner that study would not be used as a living space as an accessory
dwelling unit in the R-1 zone would require a special use permit.The current property owner
Pagel of 10
contacted Planning&Zoning in May 2020 to inquire about the process to apply for a special use
permit and was informed that a Certificate of Appropriates would need to be obtained before
submitting for a special use permit to allow the accessory dwelling unit to be utilized legally.
Mr.Mapp shared that the property is surrounded by R-1 Low Density Residential land use and that
a single-family dwelling unit requires 2 parking spaces off street and the accessory dwelling unit
requires 1 parking space.The setbacks have been met and as far as this process,the code reads that
any change in use with in the historic district shall first require approval and issuance of a
Certificate of Appropriateness before the applicant can apply for or obtain any other permit or
license that may be required.
Commissioner Maughan asked if there were any staff recommendations.
Commissioner Dixon stated that normally the reports include staff recommendations and
application of the principles to the case and the commission is wondering where those are
contained in the staff report.
Mr.Mapp responded that the commission needs to ask from the applicant is how this use is going
to transpire.If they plan on moving in someone full time that could be an issue or if a family
member was visiting town and were to use the space for a temporary purpose that is a different
scenario.The commission needs to determine how the use will be used and what impact it will
have.
Commissioner Dixon asked to clarify about the use,because presumably if a person in their own
home invited a relative to stay for a period of time,no special use permit is required for that and
wondered if this special use permit is required at a further stage for the installation of the oven and
the sink.
Commissioner Maughan stated that to his understanding all the construction is complete.
Mr.Mapp responded that everything is done.
Commissioner Dixon confirmed that installation of an appliance does not come before the
commission.
Mr.Mapp stated that the applicant will explain next but,he will bring out some thoughts. The unit
as far as he knows does not have a kitchen, in his years of planning that was the key issue but
things have changed and now all you have to have is a microwave or a nutra-wave oven,or ninja
cooker and it serves the same purpose.
Mr.Mapp shared that this use has been there since 1982 and has not affected the neighborhood at
this time. Questions to ask are if it is a full time residence,what impact will it have? If it is an
accessory use for family, members in short periods of time,what kind of impact will that have.
Commissioner Dixon shared they will have discussion later and her sense of the application at this
point is that it is the use alone that comes before the commission because no visible changes will
occur to the building.
Page 2 of 10
Commissioner Maughan shared that the commission should consider if the use is compatible with
the historic uses in the neighborhood,will this change the neighborhood. Given that this use is
prevalent in the neighborhood,his first sense is it does not affect the neighborhood.
Mr.Mapp stated that the applicant needs to give their presentation,and the commission may add
conditions to the approval. The commission can approve,deny or approve with conditions.
Commissioner Dixon shared that the commission talks a lot about precedent,the one thing she
wondered about in terms of the character of the neighborhood and the kinds of actions that take
place in the buildings, is whether a Special Use Permit is a prerequisite to collecting rent from a
separate space.
Mr. Mapp responded no,we have no control one way or the other.
April Cabello,Planning Technician, 621 Cleveland Blvd. shared that for accessory dwelling units
to be part of a property, it is required that the property owner has to live in the main house or the
accessory dwelling unit.
Mr.Mapp shared that this is the question to ask the applicant: will they allow someone to live in
the accessory dwelling unit on a permanent basis or part time.
Commissioner Maughan shared that anyone can buy a house in the district and turn the home into
an Air-BNB or a rental,people can rent out rooms in their house and we have no say over that.
The commission should approve or not approve the special use,and speculation about what people
will do in the future is beside the point.The commission needs to decide if this is a compatible use
with in the Steunenberg Residential Historic District.
Ms.Cabello shared that the decision would be for the Certificate of Appropriateness for the
accessory dwelling unit and then the recommendation would be special use.
Commissioner Lyons stated to clarify,to be approved with conditions,those conditions go on
forward regardless of the ownership of the house.
Discussion was held between the commission and staff regarding the issuing of a separate address
for an accessory dwelling unit. Staff reported that there are regulations from the fire department
that bear on this issue.
Madeline Buckendorf,applicant, 1805 Everett Street gave supporting testimony stating she had a
point of order that was submitted to staff on Tuesday after receiving the staff report adding some
additional facts that she felt was important.
The Commission acknowledged receiving those additional comments from the applicant.
Ms. Buckendorf shared that the building in question includes the one car garage built in 1931 and
the addition constructed in 1982.The addition received a building permit from the City of
Caldwell for the 1982 addition;at that time it had a kitchen area with cupboards,counters, sink
and electric outlets for a stove and a refrigerator. The previous owner had a stove and refrigerator,
the unit had a wall separating the kitchen from the bathroom area with existing roughed-in
plumbing for a toilet and sink already hooked up to the sewer and water.The only change since
made to the addition was replacement of composition shingles with architectural style shingles
Page 3 of 10
approved by the Commission around 2014;no other changes have been made. There are no plans
to alter it in the future.The previous owner used the office as a study,and the applicant and current
owner,Madeline Buckendorf obtained a Home Occupation Permit to use the space as a home
office.
Ms. Buckendorf shared that it is their opinion that changing the use of the 1982 addition from a
study/home office to an accessory dwelling unit will not adversely affect the Steunenberg
Residential Historic District.There will be no change the original setting or footprint of the
addition.Only one or maybe two people could temporarily stay in the addition at a time.
Ms. Buckendorf shared that the additions west elevation is located on S 18t Street directly across
from rental home and Air BNB home. The east elevation faces the backyard;the addition is
attached to the garage,which faces north into the alleyway. The Buckendorf's own one car,which
they keep in the garage. Only one street parking space would be used on part-time basis. Foot
traffic would not be increased and the addition does not have a separate address and the property
owners live on the same property.
Ms. Buckendorf stated that even though the setbacks may not be in the purview of the Caldwell
Historic Preservation Commission,the setbacks for the garage were established back in 1931 and
we do not know what they were.The addition has had the same setbacks on its elevation facing
south 18th. The original setbacks on the existing building should be considered as part of the
historic character of the Steunenberg Historic District. She does not know how to answer the
question about a separate address.
Ms. Cabello responded to the question about the address,for a home office stating that a home
office would not have a separate address;the only time a separate address is issued is when the
accessory dwelling unit is rented. When someone other than the homeowner is living in the
accessory dwelling unit, it is required for emergency services to have a separate address.
Ms. Buckendorf further expressed that she did not know why this structure was not grandfathered
in at the time of the historic district.
Commissioner Bradshaw confirmed that the garage/home office does not have access off le
Avenue.
Ms. Buckendorf responded that there is a sidewalk that goes from the house backdoor to the home
office front door.
Commissioner Maughan stated that it is in the backyard and is not visible from the right-of-way.
Ms. Buckendorf shared that the only wall in the interior is the wall between the bathroom and
kitchen area,the rest of the area is open.
Commissioner Dixon asked for clarification that currently there is no oven, sink or refrigerator but
previously there had been.
Ms.Buckendorf responded that there is a refrigerator and oven now that they started to do the
bathroom.The previous owner had a refrigerator and stove in the unit but took them with him
when he sold the property. The unit was wired for a refrigerator and stove,originally.
Page 4 of 10
Commissioner Maughan stated that issue before the commission is whether this is a compatible
use in the neighborhood and they cannot control what is inside.The applicants use seems to him in
keeping with the neighborhood and does not change the appearance. It is a straightforward
approval from their perspective as a Historic Preservation Commission and that is his opinion but
the commission can talk a lot more about it but if the commission feels that way then he would be
happy to move forward.
Chairman King confirmed the one car garage parking,and street parking.
Ms.Buckendorf responded yes,they have only one car and there is parking on Everett Street.
South 18th is a dangerous street to park on.
Commissioner Dixon shared as a resident of the district that adding one car from a person staying
temporarily or visiting would be minimal.
Commissioner Bradshaw wondered why this was coming before the commission is this was
already an approved use.
Commissioner Dixon stated it is formalizing this use.
Ms. Cabello stated when this was originally approved as a study it was not approved as a dwelling
unit and the applicant is coming into compliance so the use can be appropriate and be approved
through the proper special use process.
Chairman King closed the public hearing.
The commission discussed the reasons of why this would be appropriate.
Commissioner Maughan stated that he had stated his opinion in the previous section of the
meeting and would like it to be known that he would like to say it again but take it from the record.
Chairman King stated that structure has been used in this manner since 1982 and makes sense in
that end of the district is the college area and to have a study or secondary unit seems natural and
feels comfortable with the use.
Chairman Lyons stated that is an established dwelling and is not in conflict as it was established
prior to the district being established.There are no changes being done to the dwelling and agrees
with Chairman King.
Commissioner Dixon shared that the use of someone living in the structure does not change the
character of the district and does not think the concern for a parking space is material given
existing practices and would be minimal compared to other dwellings on Dearborn.The current
occupant's stated intention is to have close friends and family stay in the dwelling not persistently
but temporarily and seems well within their rights. Given the configuration of the house and the
accessory dwelling, it is unlikely to be established as a fully separate address or dwelling. If
someone in the future wanted to do that they would need to create,an entrance onto 18th and that
would come before the commission.
Commissioner Bradshaw stated that she understands the concern and the commission has to think
about what this could like for the district in the future.Could this be turned into a rental that does
Page 5of10
not fit with the what the Historic Commission and district is trying to do but agrees with
Commissioner Dixon that if this was a rental,there would need to be a front entrance off of 18th
and that would have to come before the commission.Commissioner Bradshaw further stated that
she did not feel it impacts the look of the district.
Commissioner Dixon would like to state on record that the applicant pointed out that the existing
footprints of the building are part of the historic character and would support that statement.
Chairman King asked the commission if there were any other conditions regarding the use beyond
as stated in the application for friends and family and extended stay.
Commissioner Dixon stated that no condition they could establish along those lines is in their
purview.If the applicants do not plan to change the structure then that is the extent of the
commission's responsibility.
Chairman King confirmed the conditions in the application as stated.
FINDINGS OF FACT
5.1 The Historic Preservation Commission accepts the staff report and the evidence list(consisting
of the written and verbal staff report,public testimony,the case file,and the sign-up sheets)and
facts brought forward during public testimony.
The Historic Preservation Commission further finds the following:
02-17-11-03: CHANGE IN ZONING CLASSIFICATION OR CHANGE IN USE;
FINDINGS:
(1) The commission's decision in regard to certificates of appropriateness for a change in
zoning classification,change in use,home occupation permit, special use permit,and/or
temporary use permit shall be based on the following findings:
A. That the request supports the city of Caldwell's comprehensive plan goals,policies,and
recommendations contained within section 11, special sites/historic areas,of said plan is
True.
MOTION: Commissioner Maughan SECOND: Commissioner Bradshaw. Passed: Unanimous
voice vote.
B. That the request will be congruous with the historical,architectural,archeological,
educational,or cultural significance of the local district is True.
MOTION: Commissioner Maughan SECOND: Commissioner Dixon. Passed: Unanimous voice
vote.
C. There will be no significant effect on the exterior of the site is True.
MOTION: Commissioner Maughan SECOND: Commissioner Dixon. Passed: Unanimous voice
vote.
Page 6 of 10
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
The Historic Preservation Commission has the authority to hear this case and order that it be
approved.
ORDER OF DECISION
Based on the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law,the Caldwell Historic Preservation
Commission hereby orders that Case No.CA-20-05,a request by William and Madeline
Buckendorf to receive a Certificate of Appropriateness from the Historic Preservation Commission
for an accessory dwelling unit,is APPROVED and recommends APPROVAL of the Special Use
Request with the following conditions:
ORDER FOR CA-20-05(Certificate of Appropriateness)MOTION: Commissioner Maughan
that Case Number CA-20-05 be approved SECOND: Commissioner Lyons. Passed: Unanimous
roll call vote.
ORDER FOR CA-20-05(Recommendation for Special Use)MOTION: Commissioner
Bradshaw that Case Number CA-20-05 Recommendation for Special Use be approved with the
following condition SECOND: Commissioner Maughan. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
• Setbacks—as is,the current footprint of the structure is part of the historic character and trying
to shoehorn old historic properties into new plat standards is inappropriate.
Action Item: CA-20-07 Applicant: Stephen Marshall, 1824 Fillmore Street,Caldwell, ID.
Public Meeting, Commission Level approval—approving a re-roof to replace 3%asbestos Slate
Tile roofing material with like artificial slate tile roofing material named DaVinci Bellaforte Slate.
Jerome Mapp,Planning&Zoning Director,621 Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell, ID presented the staff
report.
Mr.Mapp shared with the commission that the request is to replace a storm damaged slate roof
with a new product,artificial slate tile called DaVinci Bellaforte in the Steunenberg Historic
District.
Stephen Marshall,applicant, 1824 Fillmore Street gave supporting testimony and presented a
PowerPoint presentation.
Mr.Marshall shared with the commission that the slate roof was the 81-year-old original roof and
shared pictures of the roofing surrounding the chimney taken by the State Farm adjuster,which
showed the boards that would carry true slate. Slate was shown on the house blueprints but was
crossed through and tile was written in. Mr.Marshall stated that he contacted Quality Tile roofing
in Boise to see if they could save the slate tile roof.
The commission shared with Mr.Marshall that they had read the submitted application and seen
all the pictures.
Page 7of10
Commissioner Maughan stated that he felt the commission had a clear idea of what is being
proposed and that the minimum requirement would be architectural style roofing but what is being
proposed is something substantially better and that he is supportive of the proposal.
Mr.Marshal continued to explain the proposed roofing material.
Commissioner Dixon stated that this is a material that has not come before the commission.
Commissioner Dixon asked Mr. Marshall if the material is a more expensive version of something
to use because the engineered material is resilient and to resemble slate material.
Mr.Marshall stated it is more expensive because it is the only artificial slate with a 50-year full
warranty.
Commissioner Dixon stated that there seemed to be a concern with the Boise Historic Preservation
Commission.This material was approved for 1127 Warm Springs Blvd.by the Boise Historic
Preservation Commission but that commission has since denied this material due to it being a
synthetic material and not a common roof type in our region.
Commissioner Dixon stated that technically according to the Department of the Interior,
commissions are not to accept artificial materials when natural ones are available. However,under
the current circumstances clearly there is no like to replace the like with,of the immediate
predecessor because it was 3%asbestos,which is illegal and no longer used.The homeowner is
trying to find a visually appropriate material that would be used on the roof and there is no exact
replacement for the prior roof.
Commissioner Dixon stated that there was a slate appearance to the previous roof so in our case
contrary to the final message from Boise,there is a historic precedent for using slate and it is not a
different replacing.
Commissioner Maughan acknowledged and agreed with Commissioner Dixon stating that the
roofing material is a superior product with a 50-year warranty that looks like slate and placed on a
low pitch roof,which can barely be seen from the frontage. Given those things he is in favor.
Commissioner Dixon stated for the record 1824 Fillmore is a shallow pitched roof, it is less visible
than the home at 1127 Warm Springs Blvd.As a commission,they are talking about the precedent
and the default is to seek a"natural"material,but under these circumstances,the commission is
establishing for future discussions and the record that synthetic DaVinci Bellaforte Slate Tile
seems to be a very appropriate choice in the case of this house, 1824 Fillmore,and in light of the
long-term quality of the material.
Commissioner Lyons asked the applicant for the color of the proposed slate tile.
Mr.Marshall responded it would be the lightest color they have,Castle Gray.
Commissioner Bradshaw shared that the Steunenberg Historic District Guidelines does not
indicate that artificial materials are not appropriate, it talks about that the commission is to select
replacement-roofing materials to retain the historic character of the property using materials
similar in texture,finish and color to the origina,l and that the use of composition shingles is
encouraged.
Page 8 of 10
•
Commissioner Dixon stated that she wanted it clear for the discussion and the record that the
synthetic material was grounds for denial in Boise but that the commission is expressing they are
NOT concerned with the adjective `synthetic material' and the commission is very pleased with
the quality of the proposed tile.
Commissioner Maughan stated that this is a straightforward approval.
Chairman King agreed and stated that he was very impressed with the applicant's approach and
thoroughness to put the slate roofing back even if it is a slightly different material.
Commissioner Maughan made the motion to move to approve the application CA-20-07.
Motion to Approve Case Number CA-20-07
MOTION: Commissioner Maughan SECOND: Commissioner Bradshaw. Passed: Unanimous
voice vote.
V. Audience Participation.None.
VI. Actions Since Last Meeting.
Discussion Item: Chairman King reviewed case number CA-20-01 Applicant: Russell McElveny,
1201 Blaine Street,Caldwell,ID. Staff Level approval to re-roof,removing shingles and replacing
with architectural style shingles.
Discussion Item: Chairman King reviewed case number CA-20-03 Applicant: Hogg Family Trust,
1918 Cleveland Blvd.,Caldwell,ID. Staff Level approval to replace the front egress window to
the basement.
Discussion Item: Chairman King reviewed case number CA-20-04 Applicant: Dan Walters, 1807
Fillmore,Caldwell,ID. Staff Level approval for Fire Damage Repair: like for like as per the
application to a portion of the roofing, siding and one window. Any changes to the submitted
application should be submitted to the Planning&Zoning Department for Re-Review.
Discussion Item: Chairman King reviewed case number CA-20-06 Applicant: John&Anna
Westing, 1824 Everett Street,Caldwell,ID. Staff Level approval for Repair/replace poolroom
roof: like for like as per the narrative,replacing roof windows visible from the street.Any changes
to the submitted application should be submitted to the Planning&Zoning Department for Re-
Review.
VII. Old Business.
• Action Item: Steunenberg Facebook page and C of I Student Internship: Commissioner Maughan
and Commissioner Dixon shared when the new US Historian arrives at The College of Idaho they
will have a full conversation with them and build a collaboration. The Facebook Page,the
commission had discussed having a College Internship and will talk with the College of Idaho
staff,but at the current moment as it is unclear what will be recommended for person-to-person
contact or occupying the same spaces,we should be patient.The normal approach to this kind of
task will have to be different for the near future.
Page 9 of 10
• Action Item:Newsletter and C of I student internship: Chairman King stated that the C of I
Internship had been covered in the previous discussion and asked staff if they were still waiting
something from the commission. April Cabello responded that the newsletter had been sent out
and would like in the future to have a C of I student internship handle that task.
• Action Item: Adding a new commission member: Commissioner Maughan stated that he had
considered inviting the three potential members who are interested,but due to the current
circumstances,he did not feel it was appropriate.Commissioner Maughan stated that he hopes
after the crest of the first wave of the virus and better understanding of what is and is not safe,then
we can invite them to a meeting.
VIII. New Business.None.
IX. Commission& Staff Reports.
• April Cabello shared that the July 22,2020 meeting is canceled but the commission will meet
August 12,2020 or August 26,2020.
X. Meeting adjourned at approximately 8:19 p.m.
Respectfully submitted by April Cabello,
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BELOW BY CHAIRPERSON KING ON THE DATE NOTED BELOW.
Chairperson King Date
ATTEST: Jerome Mapp,Planning Director Date
For detailed minutes, please request a copy of the digital recording.
Page 10 of 10