HomeMy WebLinkAbout2019-03-27 CHPC Minutes CALDWELL HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MINUTES
/� �fAPPROVED
Meeting of March 27, 2019 @ 6:30 P.M. r�r "1 �6u I
Caldwell Public Library — Idaho Room Date k( g/
1010 Dearborn, Caldwell, Idaho
I. Call to order. Chairperson King called the meeting to order at approximately 6:32 p.m.
II. Roll Call
Members Present. Jacob King, Steve Maughan and Nicole Bradshaw.
Members Absent. Randy Lyons and Megan Dixon.
Others Present. April Cabello, Planning Technician; Rob Hopper, City Council Liaison.
Others Absent. Jerome Mapp, Interim Planning & Zoning Director; Jarom Wagoner,
Senior Planner
III. Approval of Minutes.
MOTION TO APPROVE THE MINUTES OF FEBRUARY 13, 2019 and FEBRUARY 27,
2019.
MOTION: Commissioner Maughan SECOND: Commissioner Bradshaw, MOTION
PASSED.
IV. Certificate of Appropriateness Interviews.
Action Item: CA-19-02 Applicant: Bryan Fine, 601 S 13th, Caldwell, ID 83605. Request
for approval to replace existing sliding wood garage door with an insulated Thermcore
Steel garage door.
Bryan Fine, Applicant, 1224 Everett Street gave testimony explaining that he would like
approval to replace the homemade 72 year garage door that slides sideways since it is
rotted due to weathering. He stated that he has expensive tools in the garage and
needs to insulate and secure the garage.
Chairman King acknowledged the weather damage done to the garage but wondered if
the garage doors are on a slide system.
Commissioner Maughan stated that the rail system is probably original, but wondered if
the wood doors are original.
Mr. Fine responded that he does not know if the wood doors are original and shared
that he did look for similar doors and what he submitted is the closest he could find to
the original doors.
Commissioner Bradshaw asked if it was originally built as a garage.
Mr. Fine responded that the previous owner always used it as a garage.
Commissioner Maughan and Chairman King stated that it was originally a garage.
CHPC Meeting, March 27, 2019
Page 1
The commissioners discussed garage door guidelines.
Chairman King stated the garage door is a notable feature of the entire site, the front door
and the detached garage is on 13th and that is why he called this case to the commission.
Even though it is a secondary building, the features are notable.
Commissioner Bradshaw wondered if the garage door would stay on the sliding system.
Mr. Fine responded no and said that he tried to find something with vertical slats to make
it look like a sliding door.
Commissioner Maughan stated that there is either a complete replacement or a custom
replacement but that is more expensive.
Chairman King shared his concern that the vertical slating of the V-5 and V-10 do fall in
line but would the horizontal seams of the door call attention away from the vertical
slating.
Chairman King stated that from a historical preservation standpoint, it would be preferable
to keep the sliding wood aspect.
Commissioner Maughan stated that garage doors with windows are not what the
commission wants.
Councilman Hopper shared that this is a unique situation as most garages in the district
are loaded from the alley. In this situation the homeowner does not have much choice of
garage doors beyond picking garage doors that is close to the original appearance,which
looks like the model the applicant has chosen.
Commissioner Maughan shared that he did find a website, Heritage Hill Web and the
advice is if possible to rehang, motorize and create the sliding return but otherwise
replicate as much as possible the profile as seen from the street.
Councilman Hopper noted the proposed picture has the appearance of middle handles
and wondered if the applicant was planning on that.
Mr. Fine responded that it would be an aftermarket use.
Commissioner Maughan stated that if they make a motion it would clearly need to state
to approve a solid garage door with vertical elements as a prominent set of the panels
with no windows. Preferably, model 192 V10 model listed by the applicant.
Mr. Fine responded that is going up in price and hoped to go with the V5 model.
Commissioner Bradshaw suggested making a recommendation to add handles so it
looks like a slide door to match the period style.
Chairman King acknowledged the applicant's effort on the entire site.
Chairman King stated that he is okay with model V5 circled on the application.
Commissioner Bradshaw agrees that model V10 gives more of the seam in the middle
but because the seams on the original garage doors cannot be seen enough to know that
they are sliding doors she would be fine with the model V5 with handles.
CHPC Meeting, March 27, 2019
Page 2
• Commissioner Bradshaw made a motion to approve model #199 V5 garage door in white
with two handles in the middle that makes it look like a sliding door without windows.
Motion to Approve Case Number CA-19-02:
MOTION: Commissioner Bradshaw SECOND: Commissioner Maughan MOTION
PASSED WITH A UNANIMOUS VOTE.
V. Audience Participation. None.
VI. Actions Since Last Meeting.
• Discussion Item: CA-19-01. Commission Level C of A issued for CA-19-01 at
1823 Cleveland Blvd to John Hogg for the approval to replace windows facing
Cleveland Blvd. and 19th Ave. with one or two vertical double hung windows.
Based upon the structural issues, the Chairman is authorized to give approval
changing away from the double hung windows; the siding is to be replaced with
Truewood Cottage Lap Siding with a 5 1/2 or 6 inch lap; the front door is to be
replaced with a door that has 6 lights and 2 panels.
• Discussion Item: CA-19-03. Building Official Level C of A issued for CA-19-03
at 1214 Blaine Street to Judy Subia for approval to demolish this declared
unsafe structure and, due to its current structural condition, to order the
immediate demotion of the structure.
VII. Old Business.
• Action Item: CA-16-11. Applicant: 424 S 20th Avenue. April C. reported that
the applicant emailed stating they would be completing the fencing and come
into compliance with the Certificate of Appropriateness that was approved. P& Z
gave until June 1, 2019 for the applicant to comply.
• Action Item: Steunenberg Facebook page. April C. reported that Steve
Maughan, Jan Boles, and Rob Hopper are the FB administrators. Staff would
like the commission to handle maintaining and updating the FB page. Rob H.
shared that it would be nice to highlight some great things that are happening.
The commission would like to add links to the City website, Historic
Preservation, and Code Enforcement, as well as links to the Steunenberg
Residential Historic District code. Chairman King shared that he likes all the
ideas and wants to organize their time together as a commission to work on the
FB page and the News Letter. Commissioner Bradshaw suggested taking 10 to
15 minutes after each meeting to update the FB page.
• Action Item: News Letter. April C. reported that the commission may work on
the newsletter outside the CHPC meeting, but once the newsletter is ready for
final review it should be placed as an action item on the CHPC agenda.
Chairman King reviewed what needed to be updated and agreed to keep this as
an action item on all agendas.
• Action Item: 2019 Projects. Chairman King stated that the owner's mailing list
and newsletter would be the number one project and made a note to keep this
as an action item on all agendas.
VIII. New Business.
• Action Item: Commission attendance and quorum. April C. expressed her
concern for the commission and the attendance because of the CLG status and
C of A applications. The commission discussed the number of commissioners
CHPC Meeting, March 27, 2019
Page 3
• and possibly adding another member or an alternate member; and the
commission discussed how to recruit another member.
IX. Commission & Staff Reports.
Staff Report:
April C. reported that she had reached out to SHPO and Legal Counsel for training
sessions but needs dates and times that the commission chooses. The commission
would like the training on a regularly scheduled meeting date and time.
April C. suggested updating the Design Guidelines for the Historic District to add types
of allowed products.
Commission Report:
The commission held a discussion regarding the future building of homes on vacant
lots, land use, and design review.
Steve M. asked about the process to trim trees along Blaine and Cleveland since
homeowners are coming to him asking about flaggers. Rob H. responded that Blaine
and Cleveland are ITD territory and not the city's, and that the homeowner should
contact ITD.
X. Meeting adjourned at approximately 8:12 p.m.
Respectfully submitted by April Cabello,
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BELOW BY CHAIRPERSON KING ON THE DATE
NOTED BELOW.
airperson King Date
ATTEST: Jarom -
�qon Senior Planner Date
For detailed minutes, please request a copy of the digital recording.
CHPC Meeting, March 27, 2019
Page 4