HomeMy WebLinkAbout2018-12-11 P&Z Commission MinutesCITY OF CALDWELL APPROVED
CALDWELL PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSIONMINUTES._._ _ C' VVj)g IL
Community Room, Caldwell Police Department `3
110 South 51h Avenue, Caldwell, Idaho
December 11, 2018,7:00 P.M.
Call to Order -Chairperson Doty-Pomoransky called the meeting to order at 7:00 p.m.
Review of Proceedings -
Roll Call -
Members Present: Ed Doty-Pomoransky, Betsy Hunsicker, James Nelson, Roger Page, Dana
Vance
Members Absent:
Staff Present: Jarom Wagoner (Senior Planner/Development Team Leader), Lori Colligan
(Administrative Secretary)
Staff Absent: Brian Billingsley (Planning & Zoning Director), Robb MacDonald (City
Engineer)
Old Business: Approve minutes of October 9, 2018 regular meeting.
MOTION: Commissioner Nelson. SECOND: Commissioner Page. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
New Business:
1. Case Number SUP -18-17: A request by Bail Hotline Bail Bonds for a special -use
permit to operate a Bail Bonds Use within the C -C (City Center) Zoning District. The subject property is
located at 316 S. 10`h Avenue in Caldwell, Idaho.
Testimony:
Jarom Wagoner, 621 Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell, ID 83605, Senior Planner, presented the staff report.
Mr. Wagoner stated the applicant is requesting a special use permit to operate a bail bonds facility
within the C -C (City Center) Zoning District. Accessibility is an issue as far as parking and access
because of the location.
Commissioner Hunsicker asked if this use was allowed in other zones or does every zone require a
special use permit.
Mr. Wagoner replied that there are zones where it is not allowed (residential zones), zones where it
is outright allowed and zones that would require a special use permit.
Commissioner Page asked how is this request consistent with the comprehensive plan and why do
we have a comprehensive plan if we're just going the extreme opposite direction of what we have
planned.
" V v
Mr.. Wagoner replied. that th.e:compr6hens ve .plan is a guiding document. This area -is city center
:and. that s.why this request is a speeial.use permit and not outright allo.wed.like it would be in
'some ofthe 'other commercial zones.: There are :different retail. desires in the downtown, The core
,of city center- has a .m"uch different feel,and look than the;outskirts of city center.
Commissioner Hunsicker asked if this. was a special use because it is an office or because it is a bail
bonds use.
Mr. Wagoner replied that is it not because it is an office use. There is a business district in the
-downtown area from 5th to 10th and from the Boulevard to the railroad tracks.
Commissioner Vance asked about 5.2 and the request being inconsistent with the comprehensive -
plan. -It is talking about accessibility and.frontage. How many"businesses are located in this
building?
Mr. Wagoner replied hebelieves:itcan. house up to four separate businesses:
Commissioner Vance asked'if there are any parking, requirements and will they be able to meet
them?
Mr. Wagoner stated there.are parking requirements. City center allows for on street parking within
800 feet -of the site to be allowed toward that -total and that definitely meets the requirement for
city code. There is not parking on loth Avenue but there are a couple on Cleveland Blvd.ard some
limited on-site parking.
Commissioner Vance stated she remembered bail bonds company being there for -some -time.
Mr. Wagoner stated there was one there but their special use was revoked. They did- not -comply
with the conditions.
Me. Jason Raymond, 316 S. loth, Caldwell, Idaho (applicant) stated they area California owned
company looking to expand to other states. They have been operating in Ada County for a year.
They chose this location because there. was a bail -bonds office there before. They want to comply
and -fulfill-the, of the City. - They.have no problemswith..the.conditions and.can getstaraed.on
that immediately: He knows parking is a concern; most of their business is done digitally. They
very seldom have office visits. They will probably have only one employee there during the day and
maybe one -other throughout the day. They rented out multiple:suites and one will remain vacant
so they will have that space for parking as well.
Commissioner Hunsicker asked about the future use for the other suite.
Mr. Raymond stated the landlord did not separate the units so they had no other choice and at this
time they have no desired use for it.
Commissioner Hunsicker stated that typically you see bail bond shops close to the courthouse, did
they look at other locations and what was the decision to go to this location.
.Mr. Raymond said they did look at several -locations. One location was next to the Aladdin' Bail Bond
office, however, they had con tract`with'the.ir landlord that they would not;allow any other bail bond
companies to move in close to th6ft They looked in other areas and they niade.the decision
because ofthe signage usage on 10th and because it would be easier to expose: their comp2ny's
name`to the: area.
MOTION TO CLOSE PUBLIC TESTIMONY: Commissioner Page. SECOND: CommissiorierNelson.
.Passed: Unanimous voice vote.
Commissioner Nelson said there is a,reason for the comprehensive plan. So :as wemoveforward if
we tweak a little here and little there it doesn't change what, we're looking for -in. the City Center.. He
does appreciate the property rights of the individuals that own the property. But we do have
comprehensive plan for a reason. We have codes for a reason. We have zones for a reason" and he
wants the city to follow its plan and he doesn't feel comfortable with trying to change that plan.
Commissioner Page stated this is at the core of our city right on a main street; 10th and Cleveland
Blvd. His concern is it being in the heart of our downtown. We're really focused on developing that
area and keeping with our comprehensive plan. He feels as though there might be a better. location.
Commissioner Vance said her thoughts specifically are that had it been the city's intent not to have
businesses of that nature, in the City Center it would not have been an option.for a special use..
Unless someone strongly objects, that's what the special use is about. Did any neighbor come out
and say they did.not want to see it here. Did any.other business object. We saw no one and so
basically we have a method by which you can add a certain type of business in this area, had the
City of Caldwell not intended them to be there, it wouldn't have"been an available option. If they
comply with the landscaping requirements and the signage -has to comply with planning and
zoning.
Commissioner Hunsicker stated that area is kind of the gateway. She has. concerns, it's across the
street from the library and to her it's not a business she feels is appropriate for the gateway into the
City. Especially given the other things right around there.
Commissioner Page stated that in addition to that regardless of who we have testifying or not
testifying -the Commission has a responsibility to the community to protect the environment, and
the City.Center that we want to have.
Commissioner.Doty asked if the Title Cash Company -had a special -use -permit: --....... --
Mr. Wagoner stated that is actually a non -conforming use. Payday loans are not allowed in the City
Center anymore.
Mr. Wagoner also confirmed the zones where this would be allowed; C-3 (community commercial)
and M-1 (light industrial).
MOTION TO RE -OPEN PUBLIC TESTIMONY: Commissioner Nelson. SECOND: Commissioner Page.
Passed: Unanimous voice vote.
Mr. Raymond stated he wanted to tell them a little bit about the company. He gets. the thoughts
about bail bonds. If you look at the company it is very reputable, they get involved in community.
They are constantly doing charity work; backpack giveaways throughout the counties. They are
constantly getting involved politically in. everything in California: The companyis always involved
with the community. Whate-Ver they need to do..is fine with them. They really just wan" t,an
operation where they can fulfilltlieir`duties. Boise is their hub office; this would be more of a
satellite place where they can have somebody who's licensed'w.hen we need.to go to the jail to post.
a bond orto visit:an inmate. It's not going to be our hub office like Ada county so theywould be
more than open to dumb it down to meet the needs of the Ci.ty".. This location is close;, they show'up
in suits .every day,theyare very professional. They deal with judges, they deal with attorneys, they
are`not your typ cal.company. They are very reputable. They have 37 offices throughout.California;
they are the largest Hispanic owned -bail bonds in the nation. There. is a lotto this company to offer
in every city tYiat'they are. in._ If you take the time to look them up they are not the stereotypical bail
bonds company; they are very professional in what they do.
Commissioner Doty asked if they found any other locations -that were permitted?
Mr. Raymond stated that he wasn't 100% involved in that process. He knows there were a few
other spots they weren't able to get into. He's not sure of the reasons why..
MOTION TO CLOSE PUBLIC TESTIMONY: Commissioner Page. SECOND:: Commissioner Nelson.
Passed: Unanimous voice vote.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis: The Caldwell Planning and Zoning Commission accepts the
Comprehensive Plan components as listed in 5.1 and 5.2. MOTION: Commissioner Page. SECOND:
Commissioner Vance. Passed: Unanimous voice vote
Findings of Fact: The Caldwell Planning and Zoning Commission accepts the Findings of Facts
components as listed. MOTION: Commissioner Vance. SECOND: Commissioner Page. Passed:
Uitanimous'voice vote.
Conclusions of -Law: The. Caldwell Planning and Zoning Commission accepts the- Conclusions of
Law components as listed. MOTION.: Commissioner Vance. SECOND: Commissioner Page. Passed:
Unanimous voice vote.
ORDER FOR SUP -18-12 (Special Use Permit) MOTION; Commis"sioner.Page that Case Number
SUP -18712b6 denied. SECOND: Commissioner :Nelson..The motion to Deny Approval passed,
with a majority voting in favor: Page, Nelson, Doty-Pomoransky, Hunsicker and one voting
opposed: Vance. Roll call vote
vo Planiling IssiTOS
Ai The: noxtregiilatlyscheduled Plahiiiiigand Zohilig:.Commission paring- $.c
,h i *scheduledfor-
February 12,291:0.
VII. Adjournment:MOTION: Commissioner Page 'SECOND: Hunsicker.
The rneetifig"W.—as adjourned atappt6ximately 7:45 p -.m.
M1,NUTESAPPROVED'AND SIGNED RYCHAIRPERSON ED'DOTY-POMORANSKY GN7HE.DATE
NOT D BELOW -
Doty -P mfiran'--'sky, Chair f Date
ATTEST:
Jarohi AI.CP, Sehior Plaiin0r
FOR DETAILED MINUTES, PLEASE REQUEST A COPY OF THE RECORDING.