HomeMy WebLinkAbout2018-08-22 CHPC MinutesP-CIL D
CALDWELL HISTORIC PRESERVATION COM ISSION MIN
Meeting of August 22, 2018 @ 6:3 t 01
Caldwell Public Library — Idaho Room
1010 Dearborn, Caldwell, Idaho
Call to order. Chairperson King called the meeting to order at approximately 6:31
p.m.
II. Roll Call
Members Present. Jacob King, Don Burwell, Steve Maughan, Megan Dixon, Randy
Lyons and Nicole Bradshaw.
Members Absent. None.
Others Present. April Cabello, Planning Technician.
Others Absent. Rob Hopper, City Council Liaison and Brian Billingsley, Planning,
Zoning Director
III. Approval of Minutes.
MOTION TO APPROVE THE MINUTES OF JUNE 27, 2018.
MOTION: Commissioner Bradshaw SECOND: Commissioner Dixon, MOTION
PASSED.
MOTION TO APPROVE THE MINUTES OF JULY 11, 2018.
MOTION: Commissioner Bradshaw SECOND: Commissioner Dixon, MOTION
PASSED.
IV. Certificate of Appropriateness Interviews.
Action Item: CA -18-15. Applicant: Bryan Fine, 601 S 131h Ave. Request for approval
to remove 9 windows and 1 door, replace 21 windows, patch and fill-in window and
door areas, repair stucco and add a 6' fence along street side and backyard.
Bryan Fine, Applicant, 601 S 13'h Ave., gave testimony explaining that originally they
planned on a minor renovation and determined that it would be an extensive
remodel mainly because the electrical was a 70amp service and could not run a
microwave and a toaster at the same time. Mr. Fine stated that he spoke with Brett
Clark and Kris in the building department and they made the process sound easy.
Mr. Fine further stated that he had asked for direction on how this process should
work and submitted the building permit application. The building permit was
approved in two days even with the floor plan showing the windows and the infill of
the windows but he did state that in the description of work. The description of work
was just, insulation, and interior framing; he did not realize it was supposed to be a
lengthy and in-depth description. There was some miscommunication but all the
change was on the plans. He received a call from the Building Department that the
windows were missed in the review as it was not in the description of work. Mr. Fine
further stated that originally, he had not planned to replace any windows but his boss
CHPC Meeting, August 22, 2018
Page 1
i
came in and offered to buy the windows for him; Mr. Fine ordered the next day not
realizing that he needed a building permit. Mr. Fine took delivery of the windows the
day the call came in from the Building Department. On July 26th the Building
Department called to ask if he was replacing windows; he said yes and that he had a
permit to close them in and it was stated so on the plans but he was unaware he
needed a permit to change out windows. The Building Department stated that the
inspectors had missed the windows during the plan review and not only would a
permit be required to change out windows, but also the change needed a Certificate
of Appropriateness. Mr. Fine stated that within a half hour he was at the P & Z office
getting help for the application process for the Certificate of Appropriateness. Mr.
Fine stopped work, as he did not want to cause any damage with the city and has
been waiting and sitting in limbo waiting for this meeting. Mr. Fine further explained
that it was a tragic miscommunication. As a builder, he should have known, and he
has lived in this community for 30 years, 10 years before the Historic District, and
has seen many changes. Mr. Fine shared that they are just barely in the district by
100ft. Mr. Fine further stated that he has seen 3 houses completely torn out, 100ft
elms torn out, parking lots go in and endless changes but has never seen a posting
like the one in his front yard stating that there are meetings being held and it just got
over -looked. An honest mistake by the City and himself. Mr. Fine explained that the
new floor plan depends on the closing of nine windows and one door. If the windows
are not closed in, instead of having a mirror over the vanity they would have a
window and the walk in closet would have five windows.
Chairman King stated that he would like to be clear on what the commission will be
looking at and the commission will review anything seen from the right-of-way. The
property is on a corner so that doubles the right-of-way and the commission takes
into consideration views from an arm's length and or from the street.
Chairman King asked Mr. Fine if he was aware of the standards that the commission
is held to, The Standards for Historic Preservation that were established by the
National Park Service.
Mr. Fine responded yes.
Chairman King referred to the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation,
and that the items being proposed, such as filling in windows, are not
generally recommended. The commission will ask questions to help the applicant
move forward.
Commissioner Dixon tried to explain in a different way, explaining that the
commission is mindful of situations like this, but as a commission they must think
about the precedent that they are setting.
Mr. Fine acknowledged the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation
and stated that as a family, they are committed to this project. They have lived in this
neighborhood for 30 years and does not plan to leave, they are not investors, but are
homeowners.
Chairman King explained to the applicant that the commission would have a
discussion and in no way is this the decision; this is just a discussion to help the
commission come to a decision.
Chairman King discussed the infill of windows from the Everett side, expressing
concern about it becoming one big stucco wall and the home having the look of a
commercial building.
CHPC Meeting, August 22, 2018
Page 2
A
Commissioner Maughan shared that the commission's prime directive is from the
curbside and that the commission has to ask themselves does the house retain its
original profile in terms of the windows, eaves, doors and the original look of the
building. The paint, the inside and the backyard the commission does not regulate.
This home has a particular look with the way the windows were set up and what the
Builder's intention was of how the home was to look from the street.
Commissioner Burwell stated that he thought he had read that the original building
did not have the same windows.
Mr. Fine responded that the house has four different style windows in the upstairs
and the original storm windows do not match and that the reveal is about 6'/2 inches,
the reveal on the screen windows is 4 inches, the grid patterns do not match up from
window to window. There have been recodifications over the years.
Commissioner Burwell explained his idea of style and architecture and that he is
hesitant to say that this is an architectural style and that the integrity of the home is
dependent upon keeping the windows exactly where they are now.
Commissioner Maughan shared that houses are of their age, that people produce
the styles of the age.
Commissioner Burwell wondered if filling in the windows would affect the integrity of
this house.
Commission Maughan responded that it impacts the original view of the house from
the curb, which is the commission's core standard and that the statement made by
Commissioner Dixon about precedent is important.
Commissioner Burwell and Commissioner Maughan continued an in-depth
conversation regarding integrity.
Sheri Fine, applicant, wondered if it matter whether you could not see the house from
the street because of the bushes. She explained that the bushes have been
removed, and they will put in new landscaping.
Chairman King stated that the original survey picture taken of the home is what the
commission is trying to use as the standard.
Discussion between the applicant and the commission was held regarding the district
and changes that have happened and why.
Commissioner Lyons expressed his concern of consistency and continuity.
Commissioner Bradshaw asked the applicant to explain the proposed changes listed
on the site plan.
Mr. Fine reviewed and explained the site plan changes and noted that there is an
alteration to the plan. That he was originally going to raise up the two bay windows
on the 13th side and the back of the south side, but he decided not to raise the seals
of the bay windows.
Discussion was held about the fencing location along 13th and between them and the
neighbor.
CHPC Meeting, August 22, 2018
Page 3
The commission discussed options instead of infilling the corner windows.
Chairman King closed the public testimony.
Motion to Approve Case Number CA -18-15 with the following conditions:
• Replacement windows as submitted without the bay windows along 13th
being raised.
MOTION: Chairman King SECOND: Commissioner Maughan MOTION PASSED
WITH A UNANIMOUS VOTE.
Stucco, new application with a Freestyle texture.
MOTION: Commissioner Bradshaw SECOND: Commissioner Dixon MOTION
PASSED with a 5 to 1 vote.
• Infill of windows with the distinction being the two corner windows on the
eastern side of Everett, listed as C & D on the application are retained; infill 1
door.
MOTION: Commissioner Maughan SECOND: Commissioner Bradshaw MOTION
PASSED with a 5 to 1 vote.
Fencing has been continued to a later date, applicant to submit a new
application when ready to proceed with fencing.
V. Audience Participation.
None.
VI. Actions Since Last Meeting.
April Cabello reviewed the Certificates of Appropriateness that were issued by staff:
CA -18-13. Applicant: 1214 Dearborn Street, Elizabeth Wakeman. Staff Level
C of A issued for window replacement on the rear sides and rear of the home.
CA -18-11. Applicant: 1621 Fillmore Street, John Roeder. Commission Level
C of A issued for removal of old deck and stairs, replace with new deck and
two sets of stairs with the following conditions: cedar shingles and siding,
posts to be wrapped and have decorative top and bottom, deck floor and
steps to be trex or like material, wood risers, skirt will be duplicated to keep
same look, if porch roof is to be replaced the applicant must submit a new C
of A application Chairman approval.
VII. Old Business.
Action Item: Continued discussion: notifying New Owners in the
District. April C. reported to the commission that she emailed the
commission the newsletter that Brian B. has said not to reinvent, but it had a
section that talked about an old walk the commission had and needed
something else to fill that area of the newsletter. April C. stated that no
commission member responded and that a mailing will be done once the
CHPC Meeting, August 22, 2018
Page 4
commission submits a replacement article. April C. also asked the
commission to email her addresses that are for sale and that she would add
them to the mailing list.
Commissioner Bradshaw suggested filling the mailer with information about
the Facebook page.
Commissioner Dixon suggested having detailed City Code along with the
Steunenberg Historic District Code.
Commissioner Maughan suggested adding a link on the City Web Page to
the Steunenberg Historic District Commission Facebook page.
Commissioner Bradshaw offered to manage the Facebook page.
April C. reminded the commission to email the list of addresses listed for sale.
The commission discussed adding little stories about people in the district to
the Facebook page and the newsletter.
Action Item: Update CA -16-11. Applicant: 424 S 20t' Avenue, Fencing.
Continued item.
VIII. New Business.
None.
IX. Commission & Staff Reports.
Staff Report:
April C. reported that a fencing letter was mailed to the owner of 1220 Everett
for fencing that was being installed.
Commission Report:
The commission discussed the possibility that the College of Idaho students
would transcribe the recording of the May 10, 2018, walk around the district.
The commission discussed doing a visual map of grandfathered no longer
allowed fences.
The commission discussed holding a special meeting to review the CLG
process.
X. Meeting adjourned at approximately 8:41 p.m.
Respectfully submitted by April Cabello,
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BELOW BY CHAIRPERSON KING ON THE DATE
NOTED BELOW.
Z -r3-11
Chairperson King Date
- --'�_,��,�
ATTEST: Brian Billingsley, P&Z Director Date
For detailed minutes, please request a copy of the digital recording.
CHPC Meeting, August 22, 2018
Page 5