HomeMy WebLinkAbout2019-01-24 Audit Committee Minutes Annual Audit Committee Meeting ° APPROVED
MINUTES
CITY OF CALDWELL
January 24,2019 ,1//Lf 1(gd 19
12:00 p.m. Date
•
(ROLL CALL)
The annual audit committee meeting convened at 12:00 p.m. in the City Hall conference room.
Those present included; Deputy Treasurer Carol Mitchell, Staff Accountant Rachelle Castleberry, Commissioner
Callsen, Eide Bailly Auditors Morgan Browning and Jodi Daugherty, retired Finance Director ElJay Waite, and
Washington Trust representative Eric Randall.
(TOPICS DISCUSSED)
Review of current position in the audit process:
• A quality review is in progress by Jodi and another audit partner.
• GASB 75 was implemented this year.This required an adjustment to net position and additional notes.
This is currently under review by the auditor's national assurance and they will provide feedback.
• Possible changes may occur in light of the reviews.
• A single audit was performed this year. A reminder of deadlines was given for filing with the
clearinghouse within the next 30 days as well as the filing of the bond covenants by March.
• Approximate completion of the financial statements is estimated to be within the next two weeks and
presentation to council is planned for February 19,2019.
Highlights of substantial changes for FY2018 audit:
• The City of Caldwell was able to prepare and provide the financial statements to the auditors this year.
• The City of Caldwell acquired an actuarial estimate for the preparation of the OPEB liability resulting
in no findings.This lead to the City of Caldwell receiving an unmodified opinion.
• The City of Caldwell began using the Springbrook accounting software to create funds and record the
adjusting entries for the financials.
Future Goals&Improvements:
• The City of Caldwell finance department plans on making processes more efficient while working
toward having a draft financial document ready at the beginning of the audit rather than a few weeks
into it.
• Auditor Morgan mentioned that the city is already preparing the URA and Health Trust audits within
this time frame.
Auditor Review of FY2018 Audit:
• Auditor Morgan mentioned that the primary audit opinion is only on the financial statements and notes
and not on the required supplemental information.He also mentioned that they did not find any issues
this year on internal controls.
• The auditors recommended that the Finance Director,Carol Mitchell,push down some of the day-to-
day work so she could focus more on review processes.
• There was also nothing to comment on in regards to compliance with state agreements or contracts.
• The auditors reported that the City did have federal expenditures of over 750,000 and therefore was
required to have a single audit.This year the single audit will be issued as a separate report.
• The auditors tested the control and compliance with the audit program and felt that the city had a good
handle on tracking federal expenditures. The audit program reviewed was the FAA grant funding.
Review was completed in collaboration with Toby Epler with JUB who handles almost exclusively
the procurement and compliance on this program.The auditors recommended that both contractor and
city have oversight of the grant. Recommendations were discussed such as holding monthly or
quarterly meeting to identify milestones and dates. The national assurance review will likely expect
some involvement from the City.
• Due to the new procurement policy implementation effective 10.1.18 there may be more depth on
future single audits to ensure compliance with the new policy.
Highlights of Financial Statements:
• The Fund level statements focus on the"Major Funds"identified by GASB,which may change from
year to year. This year these funds included the General Fund, Street Fund,and Other. This year the
Total fund balance was—27 million for all government funds,this amount includes—20.8 million in
the general fund of which—1.3 million is unassigned.
• ElJay commented that this amount seems accurate as with council's discussion on what the intensions
of future projects are.
• Cash Flow statements included a negative cash flow for Golf in the amount of(189,000).The auditors
recommend that this should be a positive cash flow. Discussion followed about the implementation
of restricted golf passes this upcoming year,which will help with cash flow in FY19.It was also noted
that the FY18 buyout of the previous golf professional and the purchase of new carts were occurrences
that used up cash flow in FY18;these occurrences are unlikely for FY19.
• NEW GASB 75 was implemented this year to record the OPEB liability.This required disclosures of
factors that go into the evaluation such as discount rate and salaries. Gallagher uses actuarial factors
to come up with an estimate using senses data.The liability was stated at 561,000 at year-end.Note
9, page 59, ensured that the data the actuary used was consistent with reports from the city. An
actuarial estimate is only required every other year.
• The 2006b GO bond was paid off in FY18.
Financial Review&Comments:
• The new City procurement policy was approved by council in October 2018,legal is looking to modify
it a bit to ensure all city policies are included.
• The City took over operations and management of PS golf course a full year earlier than expected in
FY18,the City is hoping that with the new golf board and new policy's it will bring positive changes
for FY19.
• The prior finance director,ElJay Waite,retired in FY18
• Discussion pursued regarding how the cemetery loan to golf would affect the cemetery fund. The
auditors feel that the cemetery fund is still healthy with cash flows to sustain the loan as well as
funding for any foreseeable capital needs for cemetery. Carol mentioned a 9%increase is play sales
in comparison to last year sales. Working on rate changes to also increase play this year. ElJay
mentioned that the new golf carts and development out there has created a lot of new interest in the
golf course.
• It is planned that ElJay and Eric will present to the board on February 19,2019 at 7pm.