HomeMy WebLinkAbout2018-03-13 Hearing Examiner Minutes •
CITY OF CALDWELL
CALDWELL HEARING EXAMINER MINUTES APPROVED
Community Room, Caldwell Police Department
110 South 5th Avenue, Caldwell, Idaho
Date J 7 l�/ / g
March 13, 2018, 7:00 P.M.
I. Call to Order—Hearing Examiner, Mr.Jerome Mapp, opened the meeting for the public hearing
at 7:10 p.m.
II. Review of Proceedings—Mr.Jerome Mapp outlined the procedures for the public hearing.
Members Present:Jarom Wagoner(Senior Planner/Development Team Leader); Lori Colligan
(Administrative Secretary)
Members Absent: Brian Billingsley (Planning Director), Robb MacDonald (City Engineer)
Old Business:
III. Mr. Mapp approved the Minutes of the January 9,January 17, and January 30, 2018 meetings as
previously signed by Hearing Examiner Mapp.
IV. New Business:
1. Case Number SUP-18-02:A request by Michael McCarthy for a special-use permit to
construct two new single-family dwellings within the C-C (City Center) zoning district. The
subject property is located at 123 Cleveland Boulevard (Parcel R0648000000) in Caldwell,
Idaho.
Testimony:
Jarom Wagoner, Senior Planner, 621 Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell, ID 83605, presented the staff
report and stated that the applicant is requesting special use permit approval to construct two
new single-family dwellings within the C-C (City Center) zone.There are currently a tri-plex and
single-family structure on the subject property. The applicant intends to demolish the existing
single-family structure, and construct two new smaller type single-family dwellings.
Mr. Michael McCarthy, 2401 N. 26th, Boise, Idaho stated that Jarom explained it well in the staff
report. He is requesting to add 2 single family homes.
Mr. Mapp asked if the triplex is staying.
Mr. McCarthy said yes.
Mr. Mapp asked Jarom about setbacks.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
March 13, 2018
Jarom said yes, there will be setbacks but City Center setbacks are less than regular. The
applicant is meeting the setbacks and density.
Mr. Mapp asked where would there be parking.
Mr. Wagoner replied that City Center allows parking parking on the street.
Mr. McCarthy stated that there would be parking on the street, parking on 2"d Ave and none on
Cleveland. There will be off street parking on the north side of property.
Mr. Mapp asked if the triplex would have off street parking.
Mr. McCarthy said yes.
Mr. Mapp asked if the two single family homes would have off street parking as well.
Mr. McCarthy said yes.
MR. MAPP CLOSED THE PUBLIC TESTIMONY.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for SUP-18-02 (Special Use Permit):The Hearing Examiner
accepted the comprehensive plan analysis as listed in the staff report.
Findings of Fact for SUP-18-02(Special Use Permit):The Hearing Examiner accepted the general
facts as outlined in the staff report, public testimony, and the evidence list.
Conclusions of Law for SUP-18-02 (Special Use Permit):The Hearing Examiner accepted the
Conclusions of Law as outlined in the staff report.
ORDER OF DECISION FOR SUP-18-02:The Hearing Examiner ORDERED that Case Number SUP-
18-02 (Special Use Permit)BE APPROVED with the following conditions: 8.2 through 8.7
2. Case Number SUP-18-03:A request by Eric and Dora Salinas for a special-use permit to
operate an Event Center and Night Club within the T-N (Traditional Neighborhood)
Zone. The subject properties are located at 424 E. Elgin (Parcels R0190200000 and
R0190000000) in Caldwell, Idaho.
Testimony:
Jarom Wagoner, Senior Planner, 621 Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell, ID 83605, presented the staff
report and stated that the applicant is requesting special use permit approval to operate an
event center and nightclub within the T-N (Traditional Neighborhood) zone. The applicant
proposes to hold weddings, quinceaneras, dinner shows, and concerts along with charity and
holiday events. Some background on the property. Mr. Mapp has seen this property before for
a very similar request—nightclub/event center.That was prior to it being zoned T-N (Traditional
Neighborhood). That request was approved with conditions of approval; landscaping, paving,
parking, and there was a time allotted for these conditions. The conditions were never met and
Hearing Examiner Minutes
March 13, 2018
•
the business was closed down. Twelve months have passed so a new Special Use Permit is
required. If this request is approved, there are several conditions that are listed. Staff's initial
thoughts were to require some improvements up front. However, after meeting with the
applicant they have decided to allow the applicant time to make these improvements. They
have done this type of business before and another significant factor is they have purchased the
property and are vested in the property. The previous tenants rented the property. We would
suggest giving them 5 months to get paving and landscaping done.
Mr. Mapp said if he does approve this request the applicant needs to submit a professional site
plan showing landscaping, paving, parking, etc. Would the recommendation be to allow them 5
months to complete improvements?
Mr. Wagoner said that is correct.
Eric Salinas, applicant, 424 E. Elgin, Caldwell, Idaho testified that they have recently purchased
the building and he has a high respect in the community for the entertainment business and also
on a personal level as well.They currently have a restaurant and bar and would like to add the
event center to hold concerts, weddings, community events, holiday bazaars, dinner shows and
receptions. He hopes to build up this area of Caldwell. Part of the parking area does needs
landscaping. They have invested most of their money into the business. They are doing very
well with the restaurant. He respects the 5-month time request but would hope for 6 months;
they need a little bit of time to hold events to fund the improvements. They have the
background and ability within their family to get the job done.They just need a little time to
have events and raise funds. They will do basic landscaping within the first 3 months; painting,
remove a tree, fencing, clean up, fixing broken windows, signage and repairing damage from the
previous owners.
Mr. Mapp congratulated Mr. Salinas on the purchase of the building and asked if the restaurant
was currently open?
Mr. Salinas replied yes.
Mr. Mapp explained that this is the third or fourth time this request has come before him and so
he really needs to see some progress within the first 5 months and then see where we are after
that.
Mr. Salinas said that he understands the site plan is not up to scale.They have done quite a bit
of remodeling inside for the restaurant.They have passed all code/inspections. They have also
met with neighbors in order to develop relationships.
Mr. Wagoner said he would request leniency with Mr. Mapp's discretion. In reviewing the site,
upgrades to parking lot are especially needed. The Elgin side frontage is isolated. Maybe
separate that from other requested improvements. The back part is going to be need
improvements that are more professional.
Mr. Mapp said the paving would need to be done immediately. Within 5 months they should
have the right-of-way along Denver and 5`h Street completed. Elgin will need a little more time.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
March 13, 2018
Mr. Salinas said that Denver needs more time. Between 5th Street and Elgin they are 90%done,
the rest could be completed within a month.
Mr. Mapp asked if the parking lot could be done in phases.
Mr. Salinas said yes. He said they plan to add power for outdoor lighting for outdoor events.
Mr. Mapp asked if there would be issues with outdoor events.
Mr. Wagoner said they could make that part of the Special Use Permit. He said the parking lot
the needs the most improvements, he said they might need until the middle of November to
complete that. Starting on the frontage on Elgin Street would be the main focus for the first 5
months.
Mr. Mapp confirmed the timeline of 8 months (until November) for the parking lot. Landscaping
would be 6 months (September).
Mr. Salinas said that would work.
Mr. Wagoner recommended that if this request is approved Mr. Salinas should meet with him
on site in the next couple of weeks to go over the timeline of improvements so he has a clear
understanding of what needs to be done.
Ana Salinas, 424 E. Elgin, Caldwell, Idaho, signed in favor but chose not to speak.
Dora Salinas, 523 15th Ave. N., Nampa, Idaho, signed in favor and testified that she is co-owner
with her son. She believes he has said everything she wanted to say.
Monica Salinas, 523 15th Ave., N., Nampa, Idaho, signed neutral but chose not to speak.
Manuel Olvera, 2108 Polk Street, Caldwell, Idaho testified in opposition but was not present to
speak.
MR. MAPP CLOSED THE PUBLIC TESTIMONY.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for SUP-18-03 (Special Use Permit):The Hearing Examiner
accepted the comprehensive plan analysis as listed in the staff report.
Findings of Fact for SUP-18-03 (Special Use Permit):The Hearing Examiner accepted the general
facts as outlined in the staff report, public testimony, and the evidence list.
Conclusions of Law for SUP-18-03 (Special Use Permit):The Hearing Examiner accepted the
Conclusions of Law as outlined in the staff report.
ORDER OF DECISION FOR SUP-18-03:The Hearing Examiner ORDERED that Case Number SUP-
18-03 BE APPROVED with the following conditions: 8.2 through 8.12 with the addition of 8.13
and 8.14.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
March 13, 2018
8.13:The applicant shall provide a detailed site plan of the property in question. Site plan shall
be to scale and identify the location of parking, landscaping, curb cuts and other necessary items
to depict what the applicant proposes to do on site.
8.14:The Hearing Examiner will give the applicant 6 months to complete the landscaping and 8
months to complete the paving of the parking lot.
3. Case Number SUB-18P-01/ZON-18-01: A request by Trilogy Development and Kristi
Watkins to rezone 18.12 acres, more or less, from R-1 (Low Density Residential)to R-2
(Medium Density Residential), a Comprehensive Plan Map Change from Low Density
Residential to Medium Density Residential with a development agreement, and for
Preliminary Plat approval of Dover Place Subdivision consisting of 18.2 acres, more or less,
to be subdivided into 67 residential lots and 10 common lots. The subject property is
located at the northwest corner of Ward Road and Skyway Street in Caldwell, Idaho.
Testimony:
Jarom Wagoner, Senior Planner, 621 Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell, ID 83605, presented the staff
report and stated that the applicant is requesting to rezone 18.12 acres, more or less from R-1
(Low Density Residential)to R-2 (Medium Density Residential) and approval of a Preliminary Plat
for Dover Place Subdivision consisting of 67 residential lots. Also being requested is a
Comprehensive Plan Map change from Low Density to Medium Density Residential.
Kristi Watkins,JUB Engineers, 250 S. Beechwood, Boise, Idaho testified that on behalf of Trilogy
Development she is requesting a rezone and preliminary plat approval for Dover Place
Subdivision. They are proposing a preliminary plat to divide the 18.12 property into 77 lots.
Comprised of 67 single-family lots, 6 common lots, and 4 shared driveways. The open space
would include common areas, landscape buffers, pathways, and playground. They know traffic
is a concern and within the next few weeks they will be proposing another development further
down the way which will open up Skyway clear out to Middleton Road at some point in the
future which we are hoping will alleviate a lot of the traffic on Ward and KCID. Sewer water and
pressurized irrigation will all be provided by the City and all the proposed roadways will be
dedicated to the City. We are in agreement with all conditions in the staff report.
Mr. Mapp asked about the flag lots and asked if the verified they are still buildable lots.
Ms. Watkins said yes.
Carlos Larios, 19618 Portsmouth Way, Caldwell, Idaho signed up in opposition of the case. He
stated is he in opposition and thinks there will be too many people in that subdivision and traffic
will be a problem. He thinks the houses are too small and prefers they build houses the same
size. He thinks no one cares about what is going on and he cares where he lives and he wants to
speak his mind.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
March 13, 2018
Mr. Mapp said he understands traffic is a concern but he cannot dictate what size houses go in.
Under state code,you can put a manufactured home on any lot. He does understand his
concerns and what they have done does comply with city code. The City Engineering
department deals with traffic concerns. His concerns are noted.
Mr.Wagoner replied that if this is approved this will continue all improvements along that road.
That will help with traffic in the area.
Ms. Watkins rebuttal—the size of homes was a concern at the neighborhood meeting as well.
This is the same developer as all the homes in the surrounding area. They are putting another
development in down the road that will open up Skyway, which will help alleviate traffic.
MR. MAPP CLOSED THE PUBLIC TESTIMONY.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for ZON-18-01 (Rezone):The Hearing Examiner accepted the
comprehensive plan analysis as listed in the staff report.
Findings of Fact for ZON-18-01 (Rezone):The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as
outlined in the staff report, public testimony, and the evidence list.
Conclusions of Law for ZON-18-01 (Rezone):The Hearing Examiner accepted the Conclusions of
Law as outlined in the staff report.
ORDER OF DECISION FOR ZON-18-01:The Hearing Examiner RECOMMENDED that Case Number
ZON-18-01 (Rezone) BE APPROVED with the following conditions: 8.2—8.3
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for SUB-18P-01 (Preliminary Plat):The Hearing Examiner accepted
the comprehensive plan analysis as listed in the staff report.
Findings of Fact for SUB-18P-01 (Preliminary Plat):The Hearing Examiner accepted the general
facts as outlined in the staff report, public testimony, and the evidence list.
Conclusions of Law for SUB-18P-01 (Preliminary Plat):The Hearing Examiner accepted the
Conclusions of Law as outlined in the staff report.
ORDER OF DECISION FOR SUB-18P-01/ZON-18-01:The Hearing Examiner RECOMMENDED that
Case Number SUB-18P-01/ZON-18-01 (Preliminary Plat and Rezone) BE APPROVED with the
following conditions: 12.2—12.10
4. Case Number ZON-18-02:A request by Leroy Gillatt& Christian Faith Center to rezone 5
acres, more or less, from R-1 (Low Density Residential) to a C-2 (Community Commercial)
zoning designation on 0.75 acres, more or less; and R-3 (High Density Residential) zoning
designation on 4.25 acres, more or less, with a Development Agreement. The subject
property is located at 5106 S. 10th Avenue (Parcel R2503000000) in Caldwell, Idaho.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
March 13, 2018
Testimony:
Jarom Wagoner, Senior Planner, 621 Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell, ID 83605, presented the staff
report and stated that the applicant is requesting to rezone approximately 5 acres from R-1
(Low Density Residential)to C-2 (Community Commercial) on 0.75 acres, more or less and R-3
(High Density Residential) on 4.25 acres, more or less with a Development Agreement.
Jim Thorpe, 23498 Boise River Road, Caldwell, Idaho, applicant,testified that he represents the
buyer. The purchase and sale agreement was entered into between himself and Christian Faith
Center under the condition that they are able to acquire an acceptable rezone of the property to
suit the desired use of the buyer. He submitted a document showing elevations of the
proposed building as well as proposed playground equipment(PZ-1001). There are changes
from the last time they presented this case; they have added a 6 ft fence around the entire
perimeter of the property and have called that out on a 2 ft berm. Additionally,they have trees
placed along that perimeter. They have also removed one of the 4-plexes and made it into a
playground/common area. They feel the commercial use is appropriate to the area with 10th
Avenue being a major artery roadway.
Mr. Mapp asked the applicant why they are asking for R-3 and C-2.
Mr. Thorpe said they would have more to offer the community with a commercial area up front.
Mr. Mapp asked why don't they have a mix of duplexes and 4-plexes.
Mr. Thorpe said that could be accomplished, he is open to feedback and willing to make
adjustments to satisfy the desires.
Mr. Mapp said it is not his job to design; his job is to make sure the request meets code. He
needs to decide if this rezone will impact the neighbors, traffic patterns, and if it's functional. It
may not have been explained well at the last meeting.This is a sensitive site. His expectation is
more than just basic information. He asked Mr. Thorpe if he has reviewed the staff report.
Mr. Thorpe said yes, he has.
Mr. Mapp asked if he agreed with the conditions in the staff report.
Mr. Thorpe said yes.
Mr. Mapp asked if the 4-plexes are what they want to build.
Mr. Thorpe said yes.
Mr. Mapp asked if they thought one playground would be adequate.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
March 13, 2018
• Mr.Thorpe said yes. However, if the City deems that another playground is necessarythey have
the different corners between the 4-plexes that they could add additional play areas.
Mr. Mapp said he would like to see everything thought out rather than being an afterthought.
Mr.Thorpe said they have responded to all of the comments and this plan is the beginning of a
conversation. They put forth what they would like to do and then would like to receive
feedback and then make adjustments.
Mr. Mapp said there is a Development Agreement that is part of this application. That will
define items or conditions that need to be met. When he approves a case there is not much
negotiation that goes on after that.
Mr.Thorpe presented what he believed could be approved based on previous conversations.
Mr. Mapp said they haven't responded why the zone can't be R-2.
Mr.Thorpe said it involves the return on the investment, the amount of revenue that can be
generated, and the construction costs.
Mr. Mapp asked Mr. Wagoner asked how many units would be allowed if this was zoned R-2.
Mr. Wagoner answered that within the R-2 zone typically the maximum is 10 dwelling units per
acre. They would not include the entire parcel as a portion is designated for Commercial. The
remaining is approximately 4.25 acres that would allow for 42 units total with an R-2 as a mixed
use development.
Mr. Mapp told Mr.Thorpe the other issue is that the surrounding areas are zoned R-1.
Mr. Thorpe said if the City's rule is that you cannot go from R-1 to R-3 then that's what we'll
have to follow. If that is what you will approve then I would like to hear any objections now so
we don't have to keep going through this process. If your ruling is that you will accept R-2 and
C-1 then I will change this drawing to represent that and bring it back to the next meeting for
your approval.
Larry Gillatt, 2212 Windance Ct., Nampa, Idaho, Idaho signed in favor but chose not to speak.
Ron Ames, 5104 S. 10th Street, Caldwell, Idaho stated that the piece of property we're discussing
is located in an area designated by the Comprehensive Plan as an R-1 area. He'd also like to
point out that spot zoning in Idaho is illegal. C-2 in front also goes against the Comprehensive
Plan. The change in use will alter the essential character of the neighborhood. The change in
use would negatively affect property owners and poses a threat. The change in use is not
desired by neighbors. Apartments have a negative value on existing homes. Also, 10th Avenue is
a high traffic area. Allowing a project that adds traffic is not a wise move. He would ask that this
project be denied.This project should be single-family homes as in the surrounding areas. In
Hearing Examiner Minutes
March 13, 2018
closing, he has a letter from Dixie Parker who lives at 5301 S. 10th Avenue. She was not able to
attend this meeting. (Exhibit PZ 1002)
Gary Eskew, 5315 S. 10th Avenue, Caldwell, Idaho said he has lived here for 30 years. A lot of
problem here it is that it is a busy road. Typically, there are 2 to 3 cars off the road every winter.
Adding 120 parking spots and children going to school and have to walk across 10th Avenue is
dangerous.There is no plan for a waste pond for water runoff. He can see no reason to choke
the whole system down by placing a commercial property in the only entrance. He strongly
opposes this request he believes it is dangerous. His concern is his property value and the
safety of the neighborhood.
Eric Eskew, 323 Sunridge Drive, Caldwell, Idaho. His problem with request is the traffic. His
parents live where Pat Lane dead ends.They already have trouble getting out of driveway let
alone with the addition of 4-plexes. Going from R1 to R3 and adding commercial is destroying
the whole community. There are plenty of other areas to build this. Everything from 10th
Avenue to Farmway is zoned R1. At the neighborhood meeting,they said maybe a doctor's
office or a pizza hut. It does not seem right for the area.
William Adams, 522 S. 10th Avenue, Caldwell, Idaho said he lives south of this area. He was at
the last meeting and at that time there was no plan of development for the place. There are
accidents there all the time. It's a struggle to pull out of his driveway.This would double the
numbers at a minimum without divider lanes or turn lanes. There is a potential for 16 different
property owners for each duplex. He doesn't feel this will benefit the neighborhood. At the last
meeting Mr. Mapp suggested we all get together and meet. He was not approached once.
Development is going to happen but not 4-plex.
Jeff Hunsicker, 216 E Pat Lane, Caldwell, Idaho stated he was under the impression his wife
submitted a letter to be read.
Mr. Mapp replied that he has it and he has read it.
Mr. Hunsicker is not opposed to development in Caldwell or on this property. It is his opinion to
rezone this parcel from R1 to R3 would be a big mistake. He feels like it would be done solely for
the benefit of one owner and to the detriment of every other property around it. In his opinion
what is proposed in this area is not even in the ballpark of what any of this is developed as, it is
so different from everything else. It is going to be a detriment to every single one of these
properties solely to increase the value of this property so that the person who bought it can get
rid of it.
Tim Rosandick, 315 E Pat Lane, Caldwell, Idaho stated he wants to make three points. 1) he
would like to submit to staff a quit claim deed that has a building restriction clause. (PZ 1002) 2)
A lot is going on and he is confused on what exactly is being proposed and what is going to be
built. The more questions you asked the applicant the more changes were being made on the
spot. That sounds like a half-baked plan and he doesn't want to be the victim of a half-baked
plan. 3) Mr. Mapp used the term a "sensitive property" and it is sensitive for everyone that lives
Hearing Examiner Minutes
March 13, 2018
• around there and has invested in their property. He cares about what happens and what the
impact is on his standard of living and his well-being and his personal safety. Clearly that many
bodies behind his fence in high density, a high profit development, is going to have a negative
impact on his economics and his neighbors as well. He remembers very well at the last meeting
that Mr. Mapp encouraged very strongly that the owner and developer work closely with the
neighbors and work it out. Mr. Mapp told property owners to engage in the conversations. No
one got the neighbors together for a substantive neighborhood meeting. You don't meet in the
dark of night, on a cold, muddy piece of property and call it a neighborhood meeting.
Karie Adams, 5222 S. 10th Ave., Caldwell, Idaho signed in opposition but chose not to speak.
Melanie Combs, 209 Pat Lane, Caldwell, Idaho signed in opposition but chose not to speak.
Mary Nelson, 219 E. Pat Lane, Caldwell, Idaho signed in opposition but chose not to speak.
Donna Syme, 219 E. Pat Lane, Caldwell, Idaho signed in opposition but chose not to speak.
Mr.Thorpe—In hearing the concerns we are able to address the concerns and make
adjustments, that is what he's been trying to do through this process. Regarding the two stories
looking over the fence,two story homes are allowed in current R1 zoning. Property value can
actually be raised by commercial zoning. As each property along 10th Avenue is developed that
road will be improved. We thought 6pm for a meeting at that location would be good, it kept
them from driving downtown and kept neighbors in their own community. Regarding the other
comment—it may be one owner or it may be several investors. He has a question for staff
regarding the quitclaim document, does that have any bearing on whether they can build or
not?
Mr. Mapp indicated that is a civil issue, not a city issue. We're dealing with the land use issue
according to the city's land use.That document cannot be settled with this body.
MR. MAPP CLOSED THE PUBLIC TESTIMONY.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for ZON-18-02 (Rezone):The Hearing Examiner accepted the
comprehensive plan analysis as listed in the staff report.
Findings of Fact for ZON-18-02 (Rezone):The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as
outlined in the staff report, public testimony, and the evidence list.
Conclusions of Law for ZON-18-02 (Rezone):The Hearing Examiner accepted the Conclusions of
Law as outlined in the staff report.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
March 13, 2018
ORDER OF DECISION FOR ZON-18-02:The Hearing Examiner RECOMMENDED that Case Number
ZON-18-02 (Rezone) BE DENIED. If City Council does choose to approve this request he would
add that the number of units be reduced and low density traffic commercial use be allowed.
V. Planning Issues—None
a. The next regularly scheduled Hearing Examiner meeting is scheduled for May 8, 2018
VI. Adjournment
The Hearing Examiner adjourned the meeting at approximately 9:57 p.m.
Respectfully submitted by Lori Colligan,
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BY THE HEARING EXAMINER, M.JEROME MAPP, ON THE DATE
NOTED BELOW:
/ !W7°I)'
ATTEST:
Fn
Mr.•eroe Mapp / D to
'Ak\
Jarom Wagoner, Senior Planner/ De ent Team Leader Date
For detailed Minutes, please request a copy of the digital recording.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
March 13, 2018