HomeMy WebLinkAbout2017-10-03 DESIGN REVIEW COMMISSION CITY OF CALDWELL
DESIGN REVIEW COMMISSION MINUTES
Community Room,Caldwell Police Department APPROVED
110 South St°'Avenue, Caldwell, Idaho
October 3,2017, 12 OOPM [D2ate—I"711/(,
Due to a recording malfunction;there is no digital recording of this meeting.
L Call to Order—Brian Billingsley called the meeting to order at approximately 12:00 p.m.
Members Present:
Staff: Brian Billingsley(Planning Director),Jarom Wagoner(Senior Planner/Development Team
Leader),April Cabello (Planning Technician)
Commission Members:Tressa Dodge, Rick Hall,Tyler Morgan,
Other: Keri Sigman (Economic Development& Destination Caldwell)
Members Absent: Lori Colligan (Administrative Secretary), Cheyne Weston (Design Review
Commissioner)
IL Review and Approval of the Agenda and any Amendments
III, Old Business
A. Approve Minutes for August 22, 2017 Meeting with corrections.
MOTION made by Commissioner Dodge to approve the minutes,
SECOND by Commissioner Morgan.Approved unanimously roll call vote.
IV. New Business
A. Case Number DR-17-05:A request by Bob Jenkins for design review approval for the
property located at 212 S. Kimball Avenue in Caldwell, Idaho.
Jarorn Wagoner, Senior Planner, 621 Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell, ID 83605, presented the staff
report and stated that the applicant is requesting design review approval for exterior facade
changes to the building located at 212 S. Kimball Avenue (The McLeod Building).
Mr. Wagoner shared that The McLeod Building is also known as the Lavering Building was
constructed in 1907 and is located within the Downtown Caldwell Historic District. The
building's exterior was covered with metal siding in the 1960's and that was recently
removed exposing the original brick.
Bob Jenkins, applicant; 915 Main Street, Caldwell, Idaho 83505 thanked the committee for
having standards and keeping to it. Mr.Jenkins informed the commission that they are
focusing on the ground floor and have already removed the tin from the building, replaced
_._.__ age 1
windows and painted trim work. Mr.Jenkins further testified that Horsewoods is in suite
212; suite 210 will be an expansion for Horsewoods, and the corner suite will be Flying M
Coffee Shop. Mr.Jenkins stated that he wants to expose and paint the building;they
exposed all the above windows and will put in additional glass. Mr.Jenkins stated that they
will not paint the brick unless the brick was already painted. They want to install two
windowed garage door systems on the plaza side and the Horsewood,side to bring the look
from outside in. They are working on a retractable awning and restoring the glass arch over
the garage door system;this would be called Industrial Chic and compared the look to 10
Barrel in Boise.
Commissioner Dodge asked if the stools would be permanent.
Mr.Jenkins responded they would be removable.
Commission Morgan asked staff about code requirements for the awnings.
Brian Billingsley, Planning Director responded that the awnings would be required to be 14
feet above the sidewalk and 4 feet out.
MOTION TO CLOSE TESTIMONY:Commissioner Morgan. SECOND:Commissioner Dodge.
Passed: Unanimous vote.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis:
The Caldwell Planning and Zoning Commission accepts the Comprehensive Plan components as
listed below in 5.1 and 5.2
Enter into MOTION:Commissioner Dodge SECOND:Commissioner Morgan. Passed: Unanimous
vote.
Findings of Fact:
Enter into MOTION: Commissioner Dodge SECOND:Commissioner Morgan. Passed: Unanimous
vote.
Conclusions of Law: MOTION: Commissioner Dodge SECOND: Commissioner Morgan Passed:
Unanimous vote.
ORDER OF DECISION FOR DR-17-05 (Design Review)MOTION:Commissioner Dodge that Case
Number DR-17-05 be approved with the following conditions: SECOND:Commissioner Morgan.
APPROVED by unanimous vote.
• Required to install a minimum of seven (7) pedestrian amenities as required by Caldwell
City Code 10-02-05(8).
• All colors must be substantially similar to those allowed by the Plaza Faced Design
Handbook.
Page 2
B. Case Number DR-17-06:A request by Lynn Myers and Quantum Lenders Trust for design
review approval for the property located at 708 Main Street in Caldwell, Idaho.
Jarom Wagoner, Senior Planner, 621 Cleveland Blvd.,Caldwell, ID 83605, presented the staff
report and stated that the applicant is requesting design review approval for exterior fagade
changes to the building located at 708 Main Street(The Steunenberg Block Building).
Mr. Wagoner shared that The Steunenberg Block Building was constructed in 1906 and is
listed on the National Register of Historical Buildings.The buildings desing is reflective of the
Richardsonian Romanesque Revival-style of architecture.
JoAnn Lowe,applicant representative;419 Larkspur Court, Caldwell, ID 83605 stated that
she would have the applicant, Lynn Myers via phone to present his case.
Lynn Myers, applicant,9460 W. Peoria Avenue#B, Peoria, AZ 85345 via phone testified that
the hardware on the plaza side of the building,front repair work for reinstallation and then
focus on the back of the building and the functionality.Mr. Myers would like to install a
panoramic door on the east plaza side for dining and suggests using the back area for entry,
food service,and large crowds.The east side would open up onto the plaza with retractable
awnings and the balcony area to give a greater vista dining area. Mr. Myers stated they
need to work out the sprinklers and fire exit and will use colors from the design handbook
for the awnings and accent colors.
Commissioner Morgan asked the location of the staircase.
Mr. Wagoner stated that all interior remodeling is not on the commission's agenda.
Commissioner Morgan asked about outdoor seating and planters.
Mr. Myers responded that they would install benches under the awning area, might install
planters and that the intent is to add to the overall effect.
Commissioner Dodge asked about the retractable awnings being festive.
Mr. Myers responded that the awning would be a solid color and will be installed by a
commercial awning company to ensure it is functionality strong and that the color and
materials to be addressed later.
Commissioner Dodge asked staff about the colors.
Mr. Wagoner explained to the commission that they can place conditions on the order of
decision to read;compliant with colors in the design guidelines.
Page 3
MOTION TO CLOSE TESTIMONY:Commissioner Morgan.SECOND:Commissioner Dodge.
Passed: Unanimous vote.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis:
The Caldwell Planning and Zoning Commission accepts the Comprehensive Plan components as
listed below in 5.1 and 5.2
Enter into MOTION:Commissioner Dodge SECOND:Commissioner Morgan. Passed: Unanimous
vote.
Findings of Fact:
Enter into MOTION:Commissioner Dodge SECOND:Commissioner Morgan. Passed: Unanimous
vote.
Conclusions of Law: MOTION:Commissioner Dodge SECOND:Commissioner Morgan Passed:
Unanimous vote.
ORDER OF DECISION FOR DR-17-06(Design Review)MOTION: Commissioner Dodge that Case
Number DR-17-06 be approved with the following conditions: SECOND:Chairperson Hall.
APPROVED by unanimous vote.
• Required to install a minimum of one(1) pedestrian amenity as required by Caldwell
City Code 10-02-05(8).
• All colors must be substantially similar to those allowed by the Plaza Faced Design
Handbook.
C. Case Number DR-17-07: A request by Bob Carpenter for design review approval for the
property located at 712 Main Street in Caldwell, Idaho.
larom Wagoner,Senior Planner,621 Cleveland Blvd.,Caldwell, ID 83605, presented the staff
report and stated that the applicant is requesting design review approval for exterior facade
changes to the building located at 712 Main Street(The Roberts Building).
Mr. Wagoner shared that The Roberts Building was constructed in 1894 and is listed on the
National Register of Historical Buildings.The building is a pressed-brick construction and is
an example of the early Romanesque style.
Bob Carpenter,applicant,Caldwell, ID 83605 stated that the entire back of the building is
coming off and will have re-purposed retractable windows,stucco and sandstone.
Commissioner Dodge asked about the colors.
Mr.Carpenter responded no colors at this time,only the design.
Commissioner Morgan wondered about the sandstone and stucco.
Page 4
Mr.Carpenter responded that the sandstone being used will be salvaged and re-purposed
from the building.
Chairman Hall asked what it will look like and wondered about windows.
Mr. Carpenter responded that it will be stucco over brick.
Commissioner Dodge questioned about the required outdoor amenities; pedestrian
amenities.
Mr. Carpenter responded that they are only working on the back of the building.
Commissioner Dodge stated that color is the only condition.
MOTION TO CLOSE TESTIMONY:Commissioner Dodge, SECOND: Commissioner Morgan.
Passed: Unanimous vote.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis:
The Caldwell Planning and Zoning Commission accepts the Comprehensive Plan components as
listed below in 5.1 and 5.2
Enter into MOTION: Commissioner Dodge SECOND:Commissioner Morgan. Passed: Unanimous
vote.
Findings of Fact:
Enter into MOTION:Commissioner Dodge SECOND:Commissioner Morgan. Passed: Unanimous
vote.
Conclusions of Law: MOTION: Commissioner Dodge SECOND:Commissioner Morgan Passed:
Unanimous vote.
ORDER OF DECISION FOR DR-17-07(Design Review)MOTION: Commissioner Dodge that Case
Number DR-17-07 be approved with the following condition: SECOND: Commissioner Morgan.
APPROVED by unanimous vote.
• All colors must be substantially similar to those allowed by the Plaza Faced Design
Handbook.
V. Next Design Review Commission Meeting: October 17,2017
VI. Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned at approximately 1:30 p.m.
Page 5
Respectfully submitted by April Cabello,
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BY THE CHAIR,ON THE DATE NOTED BELOW:
Commissioner Rick Hall,Chair Date
ATTEST:
Brian Billings ey, for
Due to a recording malfunction;there is no digital recording.
Page 6