HomeMy WebLinkAbout2017-04-26 CHPC Minutes •
CALDWELL HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MINUTES
APP- •V. D
Meeting of April 26, 2017 @ 6:30 P.M. cc
Caldwell Public Library — Idaho Room
1010 Dearborn, Caldwell, Idaho
I. Call to order. Chairperson Maughan called the meeting to order at approximately
6:32 p.m.
II. Roll Call
Members Present. Steve Maughan, Randy Lyons, Jacob King, Nicole Bradshaw.
Megan Dixon, and Don Burwell
Members Absent. None.
Others Present. Brian Billingsley, Planning & Zoning Director
Others Absent. April Cabello, Planning Technician and Rob Hopper, City Council
Liaison.
III. Approval of Minutes. Continued to next meeting.
IV. Certificate of Appropriateness Interviews.
Continued from April 12, 2017: Case No. CA-17-01. Applicant: Jack Verdine.
Represented by: ABC Seamless/Steve Burak. A request to alter the siding by
replacing the beat-up, broken siding with Seamless T3 to make it look as originally
constructed, but not altering the rafts, soffit, fascia, or window trims. Subject property
is located at 1201 Cleveland Blvd.
Chairman Maughan re-opened the hearing and asked Mr. Billingsley to provide an
update to the Commission on the items that staff has collected.
Mr. Billingsley submitted the following exhibits: HP-1000 (Letter from City of Boise),
HP-1001 (Copies of Building Permits), HP-1002 (Email from Sarah Schafer of the
City of Boise on building permits), HP-1003 (Email from Sarah Schafer of the City of
Boise on City Council meeting minutes), HP-1004 (Email from Matt Halitsky of
SHPO), HP-1005 (Email from Chris Bryant from Caldwell Building Department, and
HP-1006 (Information on Asbestos Siding).
Commissioner King asked Mr. Burak if he attended any Historic Preservation
Commission meetings after the City of Boise code changed to prohibit steel siding.
Mr. Burak replied that he did not attend any of the meetings other than the City
Council appeal meeting and possibly one other city council meeting.
Commissioner Dixon stated that according to the information supplied by the City of
Boise changed their historic district boundaries and codes in 2001 and 2004 to
prohibit steel siding in their historic districts. The Commission discussed this aspect
and agreed that the work completed by Mr. Burak in the 1990's is grandfathered.
Chairman Maughan mentioned that the State Historic Preservation Commission is
recommending that the applicant use a replacement of materials with wood or a non
CHPC Meeting, April 26, 2017 Page 1
textured lap siding to match the original siding. He also reminded the Commission
that decisions like this are precedent setting.
Commissioner King asked Mr. Burak a question about the existing siding materials
on the house. He also made a statement that this house is the first house on
Cleveland Blvd. that is in the historic district and is concerned about placing steel
siding on the first house in the district.
Mr. Burak asked questions to the Commission. He asked voting members to identify
themselves. He asked how many members actually reside in the historical district.
All but one member reside in the district. He asked if anyone on the Commission
travelled to Boise to view the houses that he sided with steel siding. Nobody
acknowledged viewing his homes, but Chairman Maughan stated that virtually
everyone knows what steel siding looks like on a historical house. Mr. Burak stated
that he drive through the district and found numerous homes with stucco, vinyl and
aluminum siding. Chairman Maughan also acknowledged that several homes were
re-sided with non-compliant materials before the Caldwell's historic district was
created.
Mr. Burak asked what kind of material the Commission is going to approve. Mr.
Billingsley replied that the Commission can approve the request for steel siding and
place conditions on the approval if necessary or deny the request and place on the
record the reasons for its denial and notify the applicant is writing as to what actions
can be taken to obtain a certificate of appropriateness.
Chairman Maughan listed the various possibilities before the Commission. He said
the Commission can: 1) approve the request. 2) deny with a recommendation of an
alternative covering such as milled wood or hardy board. 3) deny with a
recommendation of removing the insulating board to seal the existing asbestos
siding as much as possible and remediate the various holes and entries that the
application of the insulating board has created and ask that the house be returned to
its previous state as much as possible. 4) deny with a recommendation to remove
the asbestos siding and replace with an appropriate siding.
A discussion ensued between Commissioners on the various options. The
Commission discussed the pro's and con's of approving the application. They also
talked about recommending a code amendment to prohibit non-compliant materials
in the historic district.
Commissioner Bradshaw asked what the cost difference is between steel and wood
siding. Mr. Burak stated he is giving his client a great deal and the cost difference
between wood and steel is great.
More discussion ensued between Commissioners on what they can do to help Mr.
Verdine and codifying their desire to not allow non-compliant materials in the district.
Chairman Maughan closed the public testimony and asked the Commission to make
a decision.
Motion was made by Commissioner Dixon to deny said request because it does not
meet the Commission's guidelines. Recommended actions by the Commission to
obtain a certificate of appropriateness:
1. Replace with compatible milled wood or cement board siding over existing
boarding with flat profile with a standard reveal.
CHPC Meeting, April 26, 2017 Page 2
2. Remove the insulating board, repair any damage to existing asbestos
siding, seal and paint.
3. Remove asbestos siding and replace with compatible siding material.
Motion seconded by Commissioner Burwell.
Motion approved unanimously.
Mr. Billingsley advised the applicant of his right to appeal this decision to the City
Council and provided the proper paperwork.
V. Audience Participation. None.
VI. Actions Since Last Meeting. None.
VII. Old Business. None.
VIII. New Business. None.
IX. Commission & Staff Reports.
Staff Report:
• Mr. Billingsley invited members of the Commission to apply for a seat on the
soon-to-be implemented Downtown Design Review Commission.
• Mr. Billingsley encouraged the Commission to look at the building at Kimball
and Arthur. The owner is in the process of removing tin siding from the brick
building that is on the National Register of Historical Places.
• Mr. Billingsley informed the Commission that the request to amend the
Historical Society's agreement with Canyon County to replace the canopy in
VanSlyke Museum has been approved.
X. Meeting adjourned at approximately 8:00 p.m.
Respectfully submitted by Brian Billingsley,
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BELOW BY CHAIRPERSON RANDY MAUGHAN
ON THE NOTED BELOW.
( /07 lo
Chairperson Maughan Date
•
ATTEST: Brian Billingsley, P&Z Director Date
For detailed minutes, please request a copy of the digital recording.
CHPC Meeting, April 26, 2017 Page 3