HomeMy WebLinkAbout2016-05-10 H.E. Minutes ' CALDWELL HEARING EXAMINER MINUTES
May 10, 2016
I. Call to Order—Hearing Examiner, Mr.Jerome Mapp, opened the meeting for the public hearing
at 7:02 p.m.
II. Review of Proceedings—Mr.Jerome Mapp outlined the procedures for the public hearing.
Members Present:Jarom Wagoner(Senior Planner/Development Team Leader); Robb MacDonald (City
Engineer); and April Cabello (Planning Technician).
Members Absent: Brian Billingsley(Planning Director).
III. Old Business:
A. Mr. Mapp approved the Minutes of the March 8, 2016 and March 15, 2016 meetings as
previously signed by Hearing Examiner Mapp.
IV. New Business:
A. Case Number SUP-16-03:A request by P16 Preschool for a special-use permit to operate a
preschool within the R-1(Low Density Residential) Zoning District. The subject property is
located at 1710 N. Illinois Avenue in Caldwell, Idaho.
Testimony:
Jarom Wagoner,Senior Planner/Development Team Leader, 621 Cleveland Blvd.,Caldwell,
ID 83605, presented the staff report and stated that the applicant is requesting special use
permit approval to operate a preschool within the R-1 (Low Density Residential) zone.
Mr.Wagoner reported that the subject property is the site of Sacajawea Elementary
School. The preschool has been operating for a few years without the understanding of a
need for a special-use permit approval, as it is a separate function of the school.
Mr.Wagoner explained that the applicant is looking to get funding and needs to show that
they are an allowed use where they are located.Therefore the City was contacted by the
applicant and was informed that they need to obtain a special use permit due to the fact
that the preschool is not part of the school and is open to the public and so therefore the
City did not see this as an ancillary use to the school.
Mr.Wagoner further stated that staff finds this application to be in compliance with the
comprehensive plan and recommends approval.
Hearing Examiner Minutes Page 1
Hearing on May 10,2016
Mr. Mapp confirmed with staff that there have been no issues over the period of time this
facility has been open.
Mr.Wagoner confirmed.
Maria Quitugua, applicant representative, P16 Preschool, 1710 N Illinois Avenue, Caldwell,
ID signed in favor of the application and stated that she is the Program Coordinator for the
Preschools located at Sacajawea and Wilson Elementary .They service 20 preschool
students at Sacajawea and have found more opportunity for services but to obtain funding
they are required to apply for a state license which means they need to have a Special Use
Permit from the City of Caldwell.
Mr. Mapp wondered about the operating hours and who sponsors this program.
Ms. Quitugua responded that the hours of operation are from 9am to 3pm and that the
program is run by the YMCA but it is funded through United Way.
MR. MAPP CLOSED THE PUBLIC TESTIMONY.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for SUP-16-03 (P16 Preschool Sacajawea Special Use):The Hearing
Examiner accepted the comprehensive plan analysis as listed in the staff report.
Findings of Fact for SUP-16-03 (P16 Preschool Sacajawea Special Use):The Hearing Examiner accepted
the general facts as outlined in the staff report, public testimony, and the evidence list.
Conclusions of Law for SUP-16-03 (P16 Preschool Sacajawea Special Use):The Hearing Examiner
accepted the Conclusions of Law as outlined in the staff report.
ORDER OF DECISION FOR SUP-16-03 (P16 PRESCHOOL SACAJAWEA SPECIAL USE):The Hearing
Examiner ORDERED that Case Number SUP-16-03 IS APPROVED with conditions:
8.2 -8.4 as written
B. Case Number SUP-16-04:A request by P16 Preschool for a special-use permit to operate a
preschool within the R-1 (Low Density Residential) Zoning District. The subject property is
located at 400 E. Linden Street in Caldwell, Idaho.
Testimony:
Jarom Wagoner, Senior Planner/Development Team Leader, 621 Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell,
ID 83605, presented the staff report and stated that the applicant is requesting special use
permit approval to operate a preschool within the R-1 (Low Density Residential) zone.
Mr.Wagoner reported that the subject property is the site of Wilson Elementary School.
The preschool has been operating for a few years without the understanding of a need for
a special-use permit approval, as it is a separate function of the school.
Mr.Wagoner explained that the applicant is looking to get funding and needs to show that
they are an allowed use where they are located.Therefore the City was contacted by the
Hearing Examiner Minutes Page 2
Hearing on May 10, 2016
applicant and was informed that they need to obtain a special use permit due to the fact
that the preschool is not part of the school and is open to the public and so therefore the
City did not see this as an ancillary use to the school.
Mr.Wagoner further stated that staff finds this application to be in compliance with the
comprehensive plan and recommends approval.
Mr. Mapp confirmed with staff that there have been no issues over the period of time this
facility has been open.
Mr.Wagoner confirmed.
Maria Quitugua, applicant representative, P16 Preschool, 1710 N Illinois Avenue, Caldwell,
ID signed in favor of the application and stated that she is the Program Coordinator for the
Preschools located at Sacajawea and Wilson Elementary.They service 40 preschool
students at Wilson and have found more opportunity for services but to obtain funding
they are required to apply for a state license which means they need to have a Special Use
Permit from the City of Caldwell.
Mr. Mapp wondered about the operating hours and who sponsors this program.
Ms.Quitugua responded the hours of operation are from 9am to 12pm and 12:30pm to
3pm and that it is ran by the YMCA but is funded through United Way.
MR. MAPP CLOSED THE PUBLIC TESTIMONY.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for SUP-16-04(P16 Preschool Wilson Special Use):The Hearing Examiner
accepted the comprehensive plan analysis as listed in the staff report.
Findings of Fact for SUP-16-04(P16 Preschool Wilson Special Use):The Hearing Examiner accepted the
general facts as outlined in the staff report, public testimony,and the evidence list.
Conclusions of Law for SUP-16-04 (P16 Preschool Wilson Special Use):The Hearing Examiner accepted
the Conclusions of Law as outlined in the staff report.
ORDER OF DECISION FOR SUP-16-04(P16 PRESCHOOL WILSON SPECIAL USE):The Hearing Examiner
ORDERED that Case Number SUP-16-04 IS APPROVED with conditions:
8.2 -8.4 as written
C. Case Number SUP-16-02:A request by KTSY Radio/Blue Mesh for a special-use permit to
construct a Wireless Communications Facility within the H-C (Highway Corridor)Zone. The
subject property is located at 14702 Karcher Road in Caldwell, Idaho.
Testimony:
Jarom Wagoner,Senior Planner/Development Team Leader, 621 Cleveland Blvd.,Caldwell,
ID 83605, presented the staff report and stated that the applicant is requesting special use
Hearing Examiner Minutes Page 3
Hearing on May 10, 2016
permit approval to construct a 65-foot tall radio cell tower in the center location of the site
which is zoned H-C(highway corridor) and if it was to fall, it would only fall on its self.
Mr.Wagoner shared that the property was recently annexed into the City because they
required City Services.
Mr.Wagoner further stated that staff recommends approval.
Mr. Mapp wondered if there was an existing tower on this site.
Kelly Hogan, applicant representative KTSY Radio-Blue Mesh, 943 W. Overland Rd,
Meridian, Idaho,83642,signed in favor of the application and stated that the purpose of
this application is to expand the communications capability of the Radio Station KTSY and
add a communications facility for wireless broadband services into this area.The proposal
is to install a 65'tower because currently there is no tower for the radio station,what they
have is a pole that is mounted on the building.This facility will help augment that capacity
to move more data and better services.The structure is a self standing 65'tower,so there
are no guide wires or any kind of support structures. It is very ballasted and heavy inside
the ground and will hold its self up. There will be some communications radios at the top
primarily for broadband communications into the south west Caldwell valley area.
Mr. Hogan also stated that the licenses for the radio transmitters have been approved by
the FCC and in addition they did file an ASR and has also been approved for this process.
Mr. Hogan asked that this request be approved.
Mr. Mapp asked if the FCC documents were available to review.
Mr. Hogan will supply the documents to staff if Mr.Wagoner requires them.
Mr. Mapp wondered how deep the footings will be.
Mr. Hogan responded about 5 'A feet deep and a portion of the tower will be stuck in the
ground and a structure will be built around it that is filled with concrete and rebar.
MR. MAPP CLOSED THE PUBLIC TESTIMONY.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for SUP-16-02 (KTSY Radio/Blue Mesh Cell Tower Special Use):The Hearing
Examiner accepted the comprehensive plan analysis as listed in the staff report.
Findings of Fact for SUP-16-02 (KTSY Radio/Blue Mesh Cell Tower Special Use):The Hearing Examiner
accepted the general facts as outlined in the staff report, public testimony, and the evidence list.
Conclusions of Law for SUP-16-02 (KTSY Radio/Blue Mesh Cell Tower Special Use):The Hearing Examiner
accepted the Conclusions of Law as outlined in the staff report.
ORDER OF DECISION FOR SUP-16-02(KTSY Radio/Blue Mesh Radio Cell Tower Special Use):The
Hearing Examiner ORDERED that Case Number SUP-16-02 IS APPROVED with conditions:
8.2 -8.3 as written
Hearing Examiner Minutes Page 4
Hearing on May 10, 2016
•
D. Case Number ANN-16-04:A request by ElJay Waite and Andrea Jenkins to annex 1.02 acres,
more or less,with an R-1 (Low Density Residential) zoning designation for the property located
approximately 150 feet south of the intersection of Homedale Road and Indiana Avenue in
Caldwell, Idaho and to annex 0.94 acres, more or less,with a C-1 (Neighborhood Commercial)
zoning designation for the property located at the southwest intersection of Homedale Road
and Indiana Avenue in Caldwell, Idaho.
Testimony:
Jarom Wagoner,Senior Planner/Development Team Leader, 621 Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell,
ID 83605, presented the staff report and stated that the applicant is requesting to annex
approximately 1.96 acres into the City of Caldwell. Approximately 1.02 acres is requested
to be designated as R-1 (Low Density Residential) zoning and approximately 0.94 acres is
requested to be designated as C-1 (Neighborhood Commercial).
Mr.Wagoner stated that the applicant wishes to annex into the City to construct a
residential home on the property and to connect to city services.
Mr.Wagoner explained that the subject property if annexed into the city it will help to
provide areas for right of way acquisition.
Mr.Wagoner also stated that rather than having the applicant improve the site with curb,
gutter and sidewalk as there is none in the immediate area and in lieu of asking for a
deferral agreement so when the City feels its is appropriate then they will ask the
applicant to provide those improvements as listed in condition 8.5.
ElJay Waite, applicant, 1910 E. Homedale Road, Caldwell, ID, 83607,signed in favor of the
application and stated that the purpose of this application is because it is time to downsize
and he is about to retire and travel. Mr.Waite expressed that he didn't want his home left
without someone there. His daughter plans on building a house on the property and will
possibly have some commercial opportunity eventually, a small business that is family
relegated but there is nothing planned at this time.
Mr.Waite further shared that it was his understanding that there is a round about being
designed for the corner of Indiana and Homedale which will be welcomed by his family and
looking forward to having his family close by building a home on the residential piece.
Mr. Mapp asked if they had held a neighborhood meeting.
Mr.Waite responded that they first had gone to the county to do a rezone and had a
neighborhood meeting and had three individuals attend. Once they decided to annex to
the city, the same neighbors were contacted and informed it would be an annexation and
not a county rezone.
MR. MAPP CLOSED THE PUBLIC TESTIMONY.
Hearing Examiner Minutes Page 5
Hearing on May 10,2016
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for ANN-16-04 (Waite Annexation):The Hearing Examiner accepted the
comprehensive plan analysis as listed in the staff report.
Findings of Fact for ANN-16-04 (Waite Annexation):The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as
outlined in the staff report, public testimony, and the evidence list.
Conclusions of Law for ANN-16-04 (Waite Annexation):The Hearing Examiner accepted the Conclusions
of Law as outlined in the staff report.
RECOMMENDATION FOR ANN-16-04(WAITE ANNEXATION):The Hearing Examiner RECOMMENDED
that Case Number ANN-16-04 BE APPROVED with conditions:
8.2 -8.9 as written
E. Case Number ZON-16-01:A request by Steiner Development, LLC to rezone 2 parcels totaling
12.61 acres, more or less,from R-1 (Low Density Residential)to R-3 (High Density Residential)
with a development agreement; and a Comprehensive Plan Map Change from Low Density
Residential to High Density Residential. The subject properties are located at 5115 5. Florida
Avenue and 0 S. Florida Avenue (Parcel R3252400000) in Caldwell, Idaho.
Testimony:
Jarom Wagoner,Senior Planner/Development Team Leader,621 Cleveland Blvd.,Caldwell,
ID 83605, presented the staff report and stated that the applicant is seeking approval to
rezone approximately 12.61 acres from R-1 (Low Density Residential)to R-3 (High Density
Residential)with a development agreement and a Comprehensive Map Change from Low
Density Residential to High Density Residential. The applicant intends to construct a
multifamily complex with up to 156 residential units,a clubhouse, swimming pool,
landscaped open space, and an 8-foot wide meandering pathway throughout the
development.
Mr.Wagoner gave some background on the subject property explaining that in May of
2011,the City Council approved a request on the subject property for an assisted living
facility and a.PUD to allow for 15 8-plex buildings on the site for a total of 120 residential
units. That approval has since expired.
Mr.Wagoner further explained that this request is for the front parcels and no assisted
living,just a straight rezone to allow for the use being proposed. Staff finds that this
request does comply with the area and would be a good fit for some development of this
type.
Mr.Wagoner shared that there had been little response to this case and believes it is due
to the applicant showing exactly what the applicant is proposing and giving good details on
the amenities being provided. Mr.Wagoner also noted that a concerned resident across
the street from the proposed development was that the promises given of developers
years before stating that they would provide all the amenities but then only building half
the development and not providing any of the amenities and then walking away.
Hearing Examiner Minutes Page 6
Hearing on May 10,2016
Therefore there is a requirement that the applicant construct the club house prior to the
completion of 30%of the residential units therefore allowing the applicant to construct and
get the money flowing;allowing for the improvement be done before the completion of
the project.
Mr. Mapp wondered if there was a time in-between phases that the amenities have to
come in.
Mr.Wagoner responded that if condition 8.12 is applied they would have to provide and
have the amenities be constructed prior to 30%competition of the residential units.
Scott Stanfield, applicant representative, 826 3rd Street South, Nampa, Idaho, signed in
favor of the application and stated that the purpose of this application is to rezone from R-
1 to R-3 and this application does comply with the comprehensive plan. It provides a good
transition between the commercial and residential.The demand for multifamily has
increase and the desire to rent verses owning is greater; people don't want to maintain a
property they just want a place to call home and let someone else take care of it, allowing
families to go on vacation and spend their money elsewhere.
Mr. Mapp shared that the vacancy rate for apartments is like two percent.
Mr. Stanfield agreed and also stated that this project offers many amenities that are not
available in a single family residential project and feels this is a good product and meets the
needs that is out there and continues to grow. Also they have checked the FannyMae
reports and they are on the increase, not the peak for multifamily. •
Mr. Stanfield stated that the applicant has no problem with the conditions except for the
amenities condition 8.12. Mr.Stanfield said that 30%is a number that you have to analyze.
If they have to build the amenities at the 30%, that's not enough to support those
amenities and would prefer it to be 50%.
Mr. Mapp wondered if the applicant could work with 40%.
Mr. Stanfield responded that he would defer that question to Mr. Hinchey.
Mr. Map expressed his concern about why and when the amenities should be built.
Mr. Stanfield stated that they held a neighborhood meeting and only 4 people attended.
Mr. Mapp discussed with Mr.Stanfield the type of landscaping they planned to install, the
crime rate and the traffic increase.
Mr. Mapp commented that the applicant needs to find a better way to cross the street to
the public facility.
Mr. Mapp and Mr.Stanfield discussed the lower section of the project and suggested
possibly have some kind of an amenity even if it's a tot lot.
Hearing Examiner Minutes Page 7
Hearing on May 10,2016
John Hinchey,applicant, 341 Business Parkway,Atwater, CA signed in favor of the
application and addressed the amenities and stated that 40%would not be a problem.
Mr. Hinchey further explained they will have lighting and motion lighting throughout the
complex.
Mr. Mapp asked Mr. Hinchey if they agreed with the conditions outlined on the staff
report.
Mr. Hinchey responded yes they agree with all the conditions.
Jayme Hawthorne,2620 W. Stewart Ave, Boise, ID 83702 signed in favor of the application
but did not wish to speak.
William Mason, 826 3rd Street,South, Nampa, ID 83605 signed in neutral of the application
but did not wish to speak.
MR. MAPP CLOSED THE PUBLIC TESTIMONY.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for ZON-16-01 (The Village Rezone):The Hearing Examiner accepted the
comprehensive plan analysis as listed in the staff report.
Findings of Fact for ZON-16-01 (The Village Rezone):The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as
outlined in the staff report, public testimony, and the evidence list.
Conclusions of Law for ZON-16-01 (The Village Rezone):The Hearing Examiner accepted the Conclusions
of Law as outlined in the staff report.
RECOMMENDATION FOR ZON-16-01 (THE VILLAGE REZONE):The Hearing Examiner RECOMMENDED
that Case Number ZON-16-01 BE APPROVED with conditions:
8.2 -8.13 WITH CORRECTION TO 8.12
8.12 TO READ SAID AMENITIES SHALL BE COMPLETE PRIOR TO 40%COMPLETION OF THE
RESIDENTIAL UNITS.
V. Planning Issues—None
VI. Adjournment
The Hearing Examiner adjourned the meeting at approximately 8:15 p.m.
Hearing Examiner Minutes Page 8
Hearing on May 10, 2016
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BY THE HEARING EXAMINER, M.JEROME MAPP, ON THE DATE
NOTED BELOW:
-41/1yi` / c/�/// ' ATTEST:
M.Jerome Mapp i Date
Jarom Wagoner,Senior Planner/Development Team Leader Date
For detailed Minutes, please request a copy of the digital recording.
Hearing Examiner Minutes Page 9
Hearing on May 10, 2016