HomeMy WebLinkAbout1980/03/20 P&Z MINUTES PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION MINUTES
March 20 , 1980
00-111 The meeting was called to order at 7 : 30 p .m. in the Council Chambers .
Present were Bud Grant , Jim Oates , John Hull , Bob Carpenter , Starr
Farish , Boyd Henry , Al McCluskey , Ken Hopper , Ralph Nyblad and Mel
Lewis . Also attending was Councilwoman Alta Williams .
Starr Farish moved to dispense with the reading of the February 21
minutes and approve them as written . The motion was seconded by
Jim Oates . Motion passed .
The first item on the agenda was a public hearing for a request to
rezone a part of Tract U of Mountain View Subdivision from R-2 to
R-3 and also consideration of a special use permit for a mobile
home park subject to the zoning being changed . The property in
question is between Cleveland Boulevard, S . Florida Avenue , Cherry
Street and Locust Street . Part of the tract is zoned C-3 Commer-
cial to a line which is 300 feet from and parallel with the center-
line of Cleveland Boulevard . The City Engineer read a report of
the site inspection made by the Engineering Department . The report
is as follows : Present use of the property is pasture with one
residence located on it . Surrounding Tract U is Edmark ' s auto body
shop, Honda sales , two vacant lots , one of which will used for a
retirement center , a mobile home sales company, a mobile home park
to the west , and 5 residences diagonally across on Cherry Street .
Locust Street has curb , gutter and paving and Cherry and Florida
are gravel . The staff would recommend Cherry and Florida be curbed ,
/'IN guttered and paved as a condition of whatever is going to be developed
on Tract U . Sewer is available at the pump station owned privately
and Mr . Lasher would have to be contacted and agree to its use . Water
is available . Since irrigation water is available at Cherry , any
development would have to be approved by Pioneer Irrigation District .
A waste ditch parallel to Locust and one along Florida must be pre-
served or shown to be unnecessary . Legal requirements of advertising
and notification have been met .
John Pilote then opened the public hearing to take testimony from
the audience . Recognized by the Chair was Mr . Lyman Belknap who
stated he was representing Green Acres Properties and would be glad
to answer any questions . Gary Lasher , who owns property adjacent
to the tract , testified that he has mixed emotions about a mobile
home park on that site . He said that when the mobile home park on
Tracts S and T to the west was being considered , the neighbors at
that time objected and as a result the owners were required to leave
a vacant area about 200 feet by 100 feet on Cherry. He did think
it would be a good place for multi-family residences , but did not
know if he would or would not oppose a mobile home park if and when
it comes up for consideration . As there was no further testimony ,
the public hearing was closed . The Commission then discussed the
rezoning to R-3 of the above property and found that : 1 . Utilities
are available with some restrictions or stipulations ; 2 . R-3 uses
would be in harmony with the general nature of the surroundings ;
3 . R-3 uses might provide a transition zone between commercial uses
1 along Cleveland and the medium density character of the area to the
south ; !a . There would be no apparent damage or loss to anyone because
of the rezoning . Bob Carpenter then moved that a recommendation to
-1-
-2-
80-3-1 the City Council to rezone that part of Tract U that is presently
R-2 to R-3 Residential be made . The motion was seconded by Boyd
emN Henry and , after a vote , carried .
Jesse Knight ' s request for a special use permit to have a mobile
home park on his property near the Boise River on Plymouth Avenue
was scheduled for a public hearing at this meeting . Mr . Knight
wants to have 4 mobile homes and has submitted a general site plan .
The zone is R-3T which would accommodate a mobile home park with a
special use permit . To the south along Boise Avenue are 10 resi-
dences and a mobile home . Easterly is the slope up to Canyon Hill
and to the north is the river bridge on old Highway 30 , with the
Boise River along the west side of the property . On the site at
this time is a mobile home that is occupied and one that is vacant .
There is a private well and a private disposal system for the exist-
ing mobile home . The nearest waterline is 2 or 3 blocksaway at
1st and Plymouth and the nearest sewer is about 2 blocks away . As
has been discussed previously , the sewer would not extend to this
property by gravity but would require a pump station . Consideration
for use of this site as a mobile home park involves the requirements
of the mobile home park ordinance , one of which is mandatory connec-
tion to a public sewer system. Other general requirements are ade-
quate water supply, underground utilities , paved roadways , laundry
facilities and fencing or screening of some sort . Mr . Knight is
appealing to put the mobile homes on septic tanks and has had con-
tact with the Southwest Health District , who regulates private
^ disposal systems in the City .
1 John Pilote opened the public hearing and called for any response
from the audience concerning the request . The only comment was
from a lady who inquired if the property was just across the river
from Rio Vista Acres or south of the bridge , and she was informed
it was south of the bridge . Mr . Knight testified that he has a
98-foot well with ample water , no high water as test holes have
indicated , and the mobile homes would be 300 feet away from any
other homes . The public hearing was closed . There was considera-
ble discussion about what point of action the Commission should
take . If they were to grant the special use permit , it would be
subject to the mobile home ordinance requirements . In the event
he is unable to meet those requirements , it should be determined
what body has the authority , if any , to vary the requirements of
the ordinance . This will have to be investigated . The Commission
also discussed whether or not to permanently limit the park to 4
mobile homes . It was pointed out that the property is in the flood
plain and the homes will have to be elevated to meet flood insurance
program requirements and be anchored . After further deliberation ,
30-3-2 John Hull moved that the special use permit be granted for the mobile
home park subject to flood plain restrictions imposed on the land and
subject to meeting the mobile home park ordinance requirements . Bud
Grant seconded the motion . Motion carried . Another public hearing
will have to be held on the site plan and Mr . Knight will report back
on his ability or inability to meet the conditions as outlined .
The last public hearing held was for consideration of a Comprehensive
Plan change from medium density residential to frame and service com-
mercial for properties in Blocks 33 and 34 of Golden Gate Addition .
The legal requirements have been met for advertising a Plan change .
-3-
Mr . Lewis identified the area as generally between 1st and 3rd on
LTh Hannibal , a frontage road along the interstate . There is a house
on the south corner of Block 33 , with 40 feet of frontage that is
not included in the Plan amendment request , a residence on the part
of Block 33 owned by Jerry Sedlar , and one residence on the Spath
property in Block 34 . The rest of their land is vacant . On the
other side of the blocks and to the west are 3 residences facing
Ithaca across 1st Avenue . Directly behind on Blocks 33 and 34 are
residences on either corner and 7 mobile homes in between . The
Idaho Power substation is across Ithaca at 1st Avenue . Mr . Lewis
continued that eventually a storm sewer is planned on the alignment
of 2nd Avenue extended and rights-of-way for this will be required .
The 2nd Avenue sewer is there and an easement will be required for
it . Relaying of some sewerline is also anticipated . The City is
negotiating with the Highway Department to provide a storm sewer
outlet which is needed before this area can develop . The access
road will be improved with concrete curb and gutter and surfacing
and parking will be restricted . Water is available at 1st and
3rd Avenues and will involve construction of a main to serve these
properties . The water main extension policy will apply . The above
site inspection was made by the Engineering staff .
The public hearing was then opened by John Pilote . Speaking first
was Lonnie Spath, 2414 Washington , who indicated he has plans for
off-street parking when he moves Superior Welding Supply to that
site . Mable Jessen , who owns the residence at the corner of 3rd
and Hannibal , said she doesn ' t know if she is for or against the Plan
change but would like to know how this would affect her property
e4N taxes . G . W. Larsen , 217 Ithaca , testified he was neither for nor
against the proposal , but would like clarification as to what type
of businesses and structures were involved . Since there was no
further testimony , Pilote closed the public hearing . Mr . Spath
informed Mr . Larsen that a small park was planned for the corner at
1st and he was also anticipating a small convenience store as well
as Superior Welding . Mr . Sedlar intends to relocate his business ,
Underground Electric , on his property . Spath indicated to Mrs .
Jessen it was his opinion that her property taxes could go up but
the value of her property should also increase .
In subsequent discussion , Pilote asked the Commission to be looking
at a larger area along the interstate for possible future land use
i0-3-3 changes . It was then moved and seconded by Bob Carpenter and John
Hull to approve the land use change from medium density residential
to frame and service commercial for properties in Blocks 33 and 34
of Golden Gate Addition and to forward the recommendation to the
City Council at the appropriate time in August . The decision to
recommend a Comprehensive Plan change as requested was based on the
availability of utilities , the anticipated commercial uses which
will border the new freeway , and the availability of an improved
roadway which will have access to the interchange . Motion passed .
At this time the Chairman declared a brief recess .
Regarding Bob Hibbard ' s request for annexation of Mrs . Lawrence ' s
property on S . Kimball Avenue under an R-1 zone , Mr . Lewis recom-
mended delaying action until the City has straightened out its
80-3-4 annexation procedure . A motion was made and seconded by Starr
Farish and Bud Grant to table the request until the next regularly
-h-
scheduled meeting of the Planning and Zoning Commission . Motion
carried .
Next on the agenda was a review of the plans for expansion of the
Caldwell High School music room . Mr . Lewis explained that Commission
policy has been to review the expansion of a special use rather
than to require the public hearing procedure for approval . Roy
Payne was present to exhibit the proposed expansion . Mr . Payne said
the addition to the existing facility would provide 3000 square feet
for a band room and choir room. There would be minor remodeling
of the existing band room. It was determined from the plans that
no setbacks would be infringed upon or parking area reduced by the
addition . Location would be at the top of the bank that breaks off
to the new track facility and an asphalt walkway is shown as an
alternate in the bid for going to and coming from the field . An
old sewerline which would run under the building has been abandoned
and a new line tied into the 6" line from the vo-ag building . Ralph
30-3-5 Nyblad moved that the Caldwell High School be granted approval to
proceed with their expansion plans under the existing special use .
The motion was seconded by John Hull and carried.
An application has been filed by the Caldwell Bus Company requesting
a special use permit to construct a bus maintenance shop building
at the present site of the Bus Company, which is in an R-1 zone .
A maintenance or shop building itself would be considered a non-
conforming use in an R-1 zone . The owner is requesting that the
expansion be allowed as an ancillary use of the School District
since school buses are the predominant activity of the Bus Company.
Pat Kole , attorney for the Caldwell Bus Company , stated the building
is proposed to be constructed on a concrete slab that was in existence
prior to annexation of the property into the City. At present , buses
are being serviced on the slab . Kole pointed out that nowhere in the
code is reference made to where school buses can be placed . A school
or school use (public or semi-public ) is a permitted use in all zones
except industrial with a special use permit . It was his contention
that since 95% of the Bus Company ' s business is with the schools ,
it could be considered an ancillary use to the school and would be
permissible as a semi-public school use . He further informed the
Commission that he could find no case that has held there is any
distinction between a private bus company and school district itself
providing services . Relocation of the Bus Company to a commercial
or industrial zone where maintenance would be a permitted use would
involve expense to the owner and also to the School District , accord-
ing to Kole , as the present site is centrally situated with respect
to schools . In summary, Kole said on behalf of his client he feels
the City has the legal authority to grant a special use permit under
these circumstances . Mel Lewis then read 4 letters into the record .
One was from Darrel Deide , Superintendent of School District 132 ,
outlining some of the costs involved and inconvenience of relocating
the Bus Company and giving supporting data to the advantages of the
present site . The other 3 letters were from adjacent property
owners , Douglasses , Kingsliens and Wards , stating they had no ob-
jections to the proposed expansion . The letters are on file in
the City Engineer ' s office .
Some members of the Commission expressed concern over the legality
of the issue and Pilote indicated he would like to have the City
-5-
Attorney ' s opinion . Mr . Lewis said he didn 't feel uncomfortable
about the situation because there would be a hearing and an oppor-
tunity for the neighbors to come forth if they have any objections .
He also wanted to know if the Commission felt any other areas would
be impacted to which notices should be sent . As long as the expan-
sion is related to the school and not to private uses , it was Mr .
Lewis ' opinion it could be considered . Pilote stated he thought
the City Attorney should stipulate the Commission has the authority
to proceed with the request on the basis discussed . After a dis-
30-3-6 cussion , John Hull moved that this body approve going to public
hearing providing it is legal to permit construction of the building
on the slab , the legality of which is to be determined by the City
Attorney. The motion was seconded by Starr Farish . Motion carried .
James Gipson appeared before the Commission seeking a variance
from the off-street parking requirements for Caxton ' s on Main
between 3rd and 4th . A storage building is being constructed on
the property which will eliminate some of the parking . There are
45 employees , not all of whom drive . Based on the square footage
and the type of business , it was determined that 30-35 off-street
spaces would be the requirement . Caxton ' s can provide 25 , includ-
ing spaces being used in the 3rd Avenue right-of-way which is not
open . Customers generally use the on-street parking available .
It was Mr. Lewis ' opinion that a variance could be allowed subject
to Caxton ' s working out the use of the parking in 3rd, either by
lease , vacation of 3rd or some other arrangements . After a discus-
80-3-7 sion , it was moved and seconded by John Hull and Ralph Nyblad to
establish a hearing on the variance to reduce the parking require-
ments at Caxton ' s subject to the stipulation that they provide 14
spaces in that area now known as 3rd Avenue right-of-way . Motion
carried .
Chairman Pilote informed the Commission that , according to State law
and the municipal code , Planning and Zoning Commissions must adopt
rules of organization or by-laws . Since this has not yet been done ,
he has prepared a draft resolution for the members to review and
comment upon . This will be discussed at the next meeting .
Also distributed were copies of a proposed amendment to the subdi-
vision ordinance concerning industrial subdivisions . The amendment
was referred to the Commission by the City Council for public hearing
and recommendation and is the result of discussions with the Chamber
of Commerce Industrial Committee . The Chamber Committee feels the
subdivision ordinance platting requirements are too stringent as they
apply to industrial areas . Mr . Lewis indicated he was finding it
very difficult to require right-of-way for arterials in commercial
and industrial areas now. The proposed amendment will place with
the City Council the responsibility of determining what requirements
should apply to industrial development . Commission members were
asked to go over the proposed amendment for the next regular meeting .
Meeting adjourned at 10 : 00 p .m.
Respectfully submitted ,
Sylvia Robison
Secretary pro tem