HomeMy WebLinkAbout1980/07/17 P&Z MINUTES ZONING COp�2;lISSI
ON y[INUTES
PLANi�ING MID 17 , 19�C
July •Council Chambers
City Hall Bob
30 p .m ' • n the Starr Farish ,
opened at •T : were Boyd henry +
was Present and ?lel Lewis .
The meeting John Pilote . Jim Oates
by Chairman Free , Don ToileY , to dis-
enter , Bill by Starr Farish as
Carp and seconded rove them
Bob Carpenter minutes and BPP
It was moved by of the June 19
pe with the reading
nously •
Motion carried unanl' Flood
written . hearing on a proposed
agenda was a public resented a
for Caldwell • Mr . Lewis T' it states
First item on the Ordinance Entails . Basically ,
,e Prevention ordinance estab-
brief summary of what, the and other terms used ,
defines floodinE sets forth the need for
enabling legislation , tible to flooding , limi-
terlishes the area susceP an . inclines a liability
compliance and grearestrictions a stud of the U . S .
The area was determined by Y
tation clause . River adjacent to Caldwell , Indian.
Geological Survey of the Boise
Creek and its tributaries , and the Dixie Drain . The survey estab-
lished the 100-year flood area ( storm that occurs on a statistical
basis once in 100 years or 1°� of the t� fu;urelaPtivitiesc� istthees
spspecific requirements to be applied to
flood plain , for instance future structures such as mobile homes
must be anchored, construction methods an materials and :__lig .
must recognize the flood hazard . Elevaticns have been establishedust the river and Indian Creek above which floor levels mist be
located . The floodway has been established and there can be ::o
encroachment upon that floodway . The Cite is now uer the e�ergeriCy
program which was instituted some years a,_o . It is a reauirement that
financing of any federal grant or fi;: nc i r of any t,:pe of b • _ _ding
by a federally insured institution with i' ::•rally i.r. tired fur, or
direct grants will not be allowed in flog : Dain, without the
acquisition of flood insurance . This instra- ce can only
if the city enters into this program and aitpts the ne . ssaraCCn1r-R
nances . Essentially , all over the U . S . bu__ding has cone o y ordi-
flood plain and unusual floods occur causi `errific 'ama n •in The
government is instituting a program whereb' a.ny building fines
•plain should meet elevation reouirten s ar.? _imitations the flood
fully will prevent the damages that haves that hope_
oc- ,bred in
Following this explanation John. Pi,, the past .
tee ower. the puolic hearing to
take testimony from the audience . T:,�r
80-7-1 closed the ' e''- no comments and Pilote
public hearing . Starr Far_sh mov and Bo
the motion to recommend •
adoption of ths ordin yd Henry seconde
Motion carried unanimously , a` `e to the
City COUnci
The next public hearing was on chaff es
make it comply with the 1;; the
explained that "lood IIazal,; '°-.
the zoning ordinancEr,-(31,2:,Prev.'7ti0 Ing ON ,
which was 0r n�_r
rovi ;
without benefit de f for onies fG_ dinarv , •
1 he emer�eref • a ,, to
areas the study which its ba' flood Lewis
have changed as comJlet a, a was Alam ove
Part . Changes are beia result of tl stud,, e`i subse• desi€'nated rlaY
the U , S . G . � posed firth , finer quentl
the text , map for the flood p1 •• e tonin easing, for Y . The
The City Attorne • nc the
has recommended file 1 , y has re�r��'11 riy an obr1 na e t most
addi „ion o f a s r tha
further t`�e d ng into adopt
check on the compatibilit o' ab�1it Pro�'osed or mfor
co
Y efi Y clause d.inance mance
nitions 1e a well as and
_ _ -1- to oPened
Dick Winner was
on what year ' s data
from the audience .
testimony me first was that occurre�
the hearing to take uestions • of a flood
and asked two _ on the basis the poise
River .
recognized lain established + rutted on
flood P peak was cons ? poise
further
was the or since Lucky the area increased • 'Ir . Lewis
100 ,years ago or data was was closed•
on what basis ublic hearing ht the
Secondly , and the P He said heart=
was offered reuestions . istical
testimony to address the q
was called uponstorm that produces the 100-Ye ^ established ,
the dams . The storm along
study established the where it would go
average and was not related to
flow and tYien the flow spread oat to
then the area is the result of the area that
the Boise River . the increase
Agency determines
rogram . Then
storm . The Federal Flood Insurance
accommodated the whathe area was in the emergency p
without any study what , r a ; _ ° or three year pe ram . t0
a considerable study mi made o', a he
determine the boundari Don Tolley indicateu
more accurately information ased when the zoning
was under the impression that tn�
ordinance was approved, which included the floo- plain overlay , would
meet any obligations the City might have an; he questioned the need
to amend the ordinance . He further in cuirec. where the figures came
from at that time . Mr . Lewis said they were the result of Judgments
made then and came from the Federal : food Inru ante Agency . dllote
then indicated he would like to try t-, clarif - the situation S he
understands it . The program initiate.. origin:._yy because the federal
government found itself in a position eontic;;albe having deClar!
disaster areas and continually pumping -oney i �o areas to he'
who had been wiped out by floods . The -onlept c= caged to o � p peopl
vi.ding insurance to these people so tha. tie o-.:n age were s, fof pro-
were in fact pa, it;; the insurance nremiz . ( ° ,,. feting
T Y ::71 it cr,ae su
ase the
government initiated the emergency pro(;r -- ^n a cursory n
tion . They now are going into :- .ase 2 alte111:1,7100paoceyrsoith:r ethe a-
ack anstud
in detail and redefining the boundaries . Wadying
development
asking us to do , ock anent ; S
Y �• according to i :lo control
development in those areas by controllin; ;taurther
is built by making it meet tertian criteri? lit and hew it
will continue to provide insurance . 3oe Henryact basis they
were not passed by the City , then 7u, :_clp :Bot ifthisliving or have businesses in the fo 'insurance and was in_`ormed they wountilbe. ,cllo�entl,
that financing through any federal o_ get f d`'ederall getnted out
could not be obtained without flood i s ��.3^J,'r a
a deadline to meet the requirements c , urane ed f;encies
P 1 ,m .t'--
could
r . Was under
formed the Commission that the City At he r°
ordinance under the Planning* Act prove ~ Lewis n_
ne) ad ise�
of the City which involves "esro. 'option of the
Zonin Public hearin-s j than ?olive
g Commission and the City Cou^ e powers
line . }Much discussion1 be Oce ,he the ^� -�•"71 n
d
not had e ensued . F,�., - �iW
30-7 nOugh
time to the -linar �er -o ,i SePte 7b .
decision on it . look at
nance the Tolley moved dinar^e t� ;le
nted til., , deader
to Count til-they want with ityl^ with r.c recommer,+3thE ^omn,`_ o an ltlte1liThad30 _ n y said forn i went
T 3 IIe r he vo i .; the motion C=ed fc- anti ' � 'St;ordinance be forty ;Wove that the pr lacyofthem do 7 `'1'dl-
for adoptio -edto the econ -S*
pc Ad cI
in favor n the motion City ^ounc: y tan es • ern
of the was se - vZth In the
voted in ° i°n and h cOfle b
favor t- fee Starr ; ZOniz,g
Don eco
O f ,a mot . OT
volley asked to to voted it oleos 'rlshmendatiOn
ing the motion , lave his vote a4 the tie . i?'e Three
eco�ie 1.c �' Th Cts ' voted
1n the kion earri�a1rman
____- ,utP, 1J °Ppos-
White-Riedel and
uest from salon to
on a req ling
hearing a hair sty
a public t to allow 05 S • Kimball •
office
next was use permi at 13 one
Opened for a specialoffice building is only
Company there there were
their professional stated that Bethought If
locate in 11418 S , Kimball , occupied . he lot
Fullbright � that is 12 cars in t
John at present Sua11 10 to
s
in the building are a and their customer
20 spaces and there with 3 or operators office spaces ,
about opened there other two available Originally
a beauty shop in to street •
irking out on the requirements
and then businesses located ace req
felt there might be some p' $eauty
office builling floor floor space •
he based on feet
the parking was 350 square
space for every space._
for each chair .
which are l P sp opera-
s
would be
aces plus 1 . 5
shop requirements arespaces and
of White-Riedel indica�,ed that the o
Larry Wickham He thought there were around 2 > p
opening with 3 chair: • acent church for six
s had been made with the ad,j was adequate .
said arrangement It was his opinion that parking employee spaces . d t'-',it the special use permit
After a discussion , Bob Carpenter move3
80-7-4sail he wo,�1 ', second the motion but wanted
be granted . Don Tolley :Tall a letter
to amend it and include that What hite-Rre eiedelfhas theuseof the six
from the church stating irking lot . Carpenter inquired if
parking spaces in the church P � s ion as the ch':rer1 vali-
this would mean that the permit is good g
dates that parking , but if the church revokes that agreement then
the beauty parlor would in effect be out of business . The indica-
tion was that it would or else they would be required to come up
with six more spaces , according to the Chairman . Carpenter then
stated he could not accept the amendment recause he did not feell
at this point the parking should be a concern , so the motion died.
-7-5 Tolley moved to grant the special use permit with proof from White-
Riedel that the church agrees to let them .se their parking Tot
for at least six parking spaces and that agreement is to be on file
in the Engineer ' s office . If at anytime td.e church reneges on this ,
White-Riedel will have to prove they have six more off-street hark-
ing spaces or the special use permit will be null and void . :' e
motion was seconded by Starr Farish and carried with one opposing
vote .
A public hearing was then held on a variance requested by Mark
Woodhall to create two substandard lots on the corner of 5th an
Harrison 60 by 75 feet each . Mr . Woodhall �s aware that the sewer
line to the existing house would have to he moved in order to con-
struct a dwelling unit on the other Uuildinr site . The staff reported
that parking to meet code requirements can he provided for both resi-
dences . It was also pointed out that this reouest is in character
with the neighborhood as there are several similar property divisions
in the vicinity . The zoning is R-2 medium density residential . Sine
there was no testimony from the audience , it was assumed that no one
would be adversely affected if the variance were granted . A motion
80-7-6 was made by Don Tolley to grant the variance subject to providing the
necessary off-street parking and to moving? the sewerline . The notion
was seconded by Bob Carpenter and carried unanimously .
/14 The following public hearing was for a variance requested by Stan Smit
for 55 feet of frontage on the building •site adjacento
It was explained that a setback problem would bo
create1 a ;ainsttlthe
existing residence at 2302 College if the property were divided with a
60-foot frontage on the new building site . One of thr requirements
of dividing this property would be to close the
Butter which is vacated Poplar Street an ..ection of curb and
to workout the drainage
-4-
problem with the City . The owner of the other half of vacated
Poplar is also to agree to close his 25 feet of curb and gutter .
John Pilote opened the public hearing on this request to take testi-
mony from the audience . Mark Roberts , 2724 College , commented that
he had no objection to paying for his 25 feet of curb and gutter but
did want to be assured that the water problem will be solved . Stan
Smith informed the Commission that correcting that problem will
require removal of an additional 65 feet of curb in front of the
existing house . He has agreed to work with the City and replace the
whole 102 feet . He also remarked that when the street was vacated ,
one of the conditions was to tile a drain ditch . An easement was
never granted to property owners on Colorado to get their irrigation
water across the rear of the property . lie will be granting this
easement to give the neighboring residents access to their irriga-
tion . As there was no further testimony , the public hearing was
80-7-7 closed . After a discussion , it was moved and seconded to grant
the variance for 55 feet of frontage because that would be a better
solution than to create a setback problem for the existing residence .
Making the motion were Jim Oates and Bob Carpenter . Granting of the
variance is subject to closing the curb and gutter at vacated Poplar ,
solving the drainage problem and giving an easement . The motion
carried with one opposing vote .
No one was present to discuss a special use permit for a sign on
property at Chicago , Linden and the interstate .
Pat Tegge appeared before the Commission to request a variance to
construct a 4-car garage which would extend into the side setback
at 3rd and Everett to the property line . His property is 100 feet
by 120 feet and there is an existiry house on the interior 50 feet
which Mr . Tegge indicated may be removed in the future . He wants
to use the rear part of the corner area for his structure which
will house 4 automobiles and provide for storage . He would like to
preserve the front for a building site in case he decides to se-
parate ownerships . The zoning is R-3 Residential and Mr . Tegge
pointed out that directly across the alley is a C-3 zone ( Elsie
Steele ' s property ) . He said he wants to build the garage along
the property line on the alley and along the side property line
to take up all the space he can to keep away from any strips where
80-7-8 weeds can grow . It was moved and seconded by Starr Farish and
Don Tolley to schedule a public hearing in August for consideration
of the variance . :Motion carried unanimously .
An application has been filed by the State of Idaho Department of
Transportation for the vacation of part of the alley in Block 56
of Boone ' s Addition (on 10th between Galveston and Freeport and
behind the Pizza IIut ) . The Highway Department is acquiring right-
of-way for the interstate down to Freeport Street and is also ac-
quiring some right-of-way to widen 10th Avenue . To do that , parking
will be eliminated along the 10th Avenue side of the Pizza Hut park-
ing lot . The State is going to cut off access to the alley and
since several utilities are located in the alley , obviously it cannot
be isolated . We have asked the Highway Department to negotiate a way
out so we can get in there from Freeport and 11th . We also must get
back an easement for the utilities and are asking for an adequate
-5-
easement off of the corner for a turnaround where trucks could get
in there since the Pizza Hut will have access only from Freeport .
P-7-9 After a discussion , it was moved and seconded by Jim Oates and Boyd.
Henry to reommend vacating part of the alley in Block 56 of Boone ' s
Addition subject to an easement for an adequate turnaround , access
to street right-of-way from isolated remaining section of alley,
and easement for utilities . Motion carried unanimously .
In further action , the Planning and Zoning Commission upon a recom-
mendation from the City Engineer voted to recommend approval of the
final plat of Starlight Park , Unit 3 , subject to all of the stipula-
30-7-10 tions of the preliminary plat . The motion recommending acceptance
of the plat was made and seconded by Don Tolley and Starr Parish .
Motion carried unanimously .
Presented next was the final plat of Industrial Site No . 5 . Added
to the final plat was a T-shaped turn area to replace the former
cul-de-sac . This was to facilitate larger trucks turning around .
George Gillespie , Route 3 , Caldwell , was in the audience and inquired
about the effect the plat would have on the access to irrigation
headgates which serve properties across the interstate and which
are located about in the middle of the roadway along the north end
of the plat . Ron Blakiey of Blakley Engineers said an easement was
provided along Commercial Way between Industrial Way and the freeway
( 5-foot utility ) and a 25-foot permanent easement along the freeway
between the fence and the line shown along the plat . Inside of that
is a 20-foot easement for the irrigation line and power line for the
1 full length of the subdivision . He further stated that the check
boxes will have to be placed in the easement during construction
because there is no way the irrigation can be disturbed . It has to
be continued and is planned to be continued . Regarding parking on
the cul-de-sac , Blakley said it would be the City ' s prerogative to
restrict it . Tolley noted that one lot is quite deep and inquired
if there were fire lanes going through the large-sized industrial
lots and if the Fire Department had approved the plat . Lewis indi-
cated they had received a copy with the cul-de-sac before the T-sec-
tion was added . A copy with the revised part will be furnished to
the Fire Department before the final plat goes to Council . Lewis
reviewed the stipulations required for the preliminary and said he
would recommend the Commission approve the plat with all of the
conditions tied to the preliminary which include the avigation ease-
ment , improvements , drainage and moving of the irrigation to the
30-7-11 satisfaction of Canyon Hill Irrigation District . Starr Parish moved
to recommend approval of the final plat of Industrial Site No . 5 to
the City Council with the stipulations stated by the City Engineer
and with the approval of the Fire Department . The motion was seconded
by Boyd Henry and carried unanimously .
Dick Winder appeared before the Commission to request a recommendation
to the County to allow his mother-in--law to live in a mobile home on
his property at 2306 E . Ustick Road . These are granted in the
County ona temporary basis to a member of the immediate family ,
N7-12 according to policy . Don Tolley and Jim Oates moved and seconded
T to recommend to the County Planning and Zoning Commission the is-
suance of a permit with the understanding that it is for a member
of the immediate family and will be renewed on a yearly basis .
Motion
carried unanimously .
-6-
The Commission then reviewed expansion plans for the 7th Day Adven-
tist Church at Indiana and Linden . Mr . Art King said the church
1 was proposing to build a community service building on the northeast
corner of the property which contains 625 lineal feet on Linden and
is 300 feet deep . Function of the building is to collect and dis-
burse goods and clothing to persons in need or experiencing some
disaster such as fire . Some referrals from the Health and Welfare
would be served as well as needy members from the church . Mel
Lewis pointed out that a basic problem with the building is that
there needs to be a sewer investigation . There is sewer all around
the area and although this is in the middle and an extensive exten-
sion would have to be made , Mr . Lewis said he did not feel he could
authorize issuance of abuildingpermit if the structure were not on
sewer . He emphasized that at least an investigation should be made
to determine if it could be hooked into the city line . After lis-
tening to Mr . King ' s description of the facility , the Commission
ruled that since this was an entirely new building it couldn ' t be
construed as an expansion of the existing church . They , therefore ,
scheduled a public hearing for a special use permit to construct
a community service building adjacent to the church property . Mr .
King will get together with the Engineering Department and fill out
the proper forms and discuss further the sewer situation since it
had been the intent of the builder to put the new building on septic
tank .
Final item on the agenda was a report from the fence committee .
Pilote digtributed copies of a proposed draft for the members to
eitt look ata7( prepare comments on for the next meeting . He did mention
that electric fences and barbed wire fences are not addressed in
the present ordinance . Fences required for sight obstruction were
also not specifically covered .
Meeting adjourned at 10 : 00 p .m.
Respectfully submitted ,
Sylvia Robison
Secretary pro tem