HomeMy WebLinkAbout1980/10/16 P & Z MInutes PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION MINUTES
October 16 , 1930
Inc meeting was called to order at 7 : 30 p .m. In the Council Chamber
s
by Chairman John P I iOLe . Present were Don To i los , Ralph Nyblad , J Lm
Oates , Tom Ensley , Bob Carpenter , Bill Free , Bud Grant and Mel Lewis .
Ralph Nyblad moved and Jim Oates seconded the motion to dispense with
the reading of the September 13 minutes and approve them as written .
Motion carried unanimously .
The first three items on the agenda were public hearings . John Pilate
opened the hearing scheduled for consideration of an ordinance amend-
ing the present regulations on fences , walls , hedges , etc . , in the
City of Caldwell . No one from the audience testified and the public
0-10-1 hearing was closed . It was moved by Tom Ensley and seconded by Bill
Free to recommend to the City Council the adoption of the proposed
ordinance . Motion carried unanimously .
Opened next was a public hearing on a request by Ray Kuntz for a
variance to remodel his residence at 1204 Teton Avenue and extend
the addition 10 feet into the 20-foot required rear setback. Mr .
Kuntz indicated that at the last meeting he submitted a petition
signed by several neighboring property owners stating they did not
object to the project . Floyd Vance , 1222 Teton , was recognized and
said he had no objections to the addition . Since there was no further
,0-10-2 testimony , the public hearing was closed . Don Tolley and Ralph Nyblad
paN moved and seconded to grant the variance as requested . Motion carried
unanimously .
The last public hearing was for a special use permit to use part of
the building on the southeasterly 100 feet of Lot 6 , Block 2 of In-
dustrial Site No . 3 in the 3600 block of Arthur Street for Treasure
Valley Gymnastics Academy . This location is in an M-1 Light Indus-
trial Zone . At a previous meeting the Commission determined this
could be a special use subject to hearing. Dick Winder introduced
himself as representing the owner of the property and also introduced
the head of the gymnastics school . He said they would answer any
questions regarding the request . The only comments were offered
by Ray Kuntz , who said his daughter was involved in the gymnastics
program and he felt it was a good project . The public hearing was
30-10-3 then closed . Bob Carpenter moved the special use permit be granted
as requested subject to meeting the life-safety codes and to connect-
ing to the sewer. Tom Ensley seconded the motion . Motion carried
unanI.mously .
The preliminary plat of Ustick Industrial Park was presented by Mr .
Lewis . His report is as follows : This is an industrial subdivision
subject to the provisions of an agreement for layout and development
approved by the City Council . Three variances are being considered .
One is for a double-fronted lot (Lot 2 , Block 2) , one for the length
of the culdesac , and one for a T-shaped rather than circular culdesac .
00.11 It was his recommendation that these variances be accepted . There is
also a question on the angle at which Arthur meets Ustick Road . The
ordinance specifies the minimum should be 70° . Proposed is 60° 141_ �
is the same angle as the corridor developed b JUB Engineers to the
-1-
-2-
southeast
2-southeast through the county and into Nampa. it was the Engineer ' s
recommendation that this part be accepted too . The Southeast Inter-
egN ceptor project will extend the sewer to serve this subdivision . The
property would be responsible for its lateral system off of that
interceptor and a general lateral system plan has been submitted and
approved . The property will also be responsible for all future con-
nection fees to the interceptor . Water will be extended by an agree-
ment with the City along Ustick from Cleveland and this will be subject
to the 'water main extension policy as will the distribution system
within the subdivision . A general drainage plan has been submitted .
Until adequate drainage is provided to the northwest or from Cleve-
land Boulevard , Lot 9 of Block 1 is to be dedicated for a receiving
and settling basin to accept the drainage . Arthur Street is to be-
come part of the transportation corridor and 60 feet is provided .
All streets are to be developed with concrete curb and gutter and
acceptable valley sections . Width will be 50 feet gutterline to
gutterline . The half street policy would apply to Ustick . It was
requested that there be no access where the corridor and the railroad
come in to provide a means for overpass or grade separation across
the railroad in the future . It is the owner ' s intention to sell
off Block 3 which contains one lot but wants to do it subject to
approval of the plan. The City would require as part of the building
permit a deed for Arthur Street from Blacker ' s and from the developer
and also a deed for the north half of Ustick adjacent to the property
60-10-4 being developed . Moved by Carpenter, seconded by Free to accept the
Engineer ' s report as the findings of the Commission . Motion carried
80-10-5 unanimously . Bill Free then moved to recommend the preliminary plat
to the City Council subject to the Engineer ' s report and to allow
the developer to sell off Lot 1 , Block 3 subject to dedication of
the right of way for Ustick and Arthur. The motion was seconded by
}Bob Carpenter and carried unanimously .
The vacation of a part of the south end of N. Indiana Avenue has
been requested by the Highway Department as a consideration in the
interstate highway system through Caldwell . The Department is
dealing; with Mr. Morgan and will construct another cul-de-sac , chanty,
the drainage and put the drainage on the end of Indiana into the
state 's storm sewer. They are asking the City to vacate Dart of
the existing cul-de-sac and the title would revert to Mr. Morgan ' s
lot . Access would then be provided to the property, curb and
guter
removed and fence installed . Mr. Lewis indicated the City has
the Highway Department to put the entrance as far to the side as
possible such that a guard rail can be installed
The dead end will be marked by the Highway ° Protect traffic ,
parent . Subject to rebuilding of y Department to :carie it ap-
draina ,e and the culdesac , taking care of the
f protecting traffic around the culdesac, the vacation
could be recommended to the City Council . Th., �nc-ineer al
lated that the City receive the deed for the tract �o stipu-
structing the new portion of street and right Oactinvo1ed in con-
0-10-6 and seconded by Don Tolley and Ralph 1, blad to recommend was moved
of a part; of the south endof' p , y nd the vacation
noted above . Motion c<tr'r'j ' L Indiana subject to the stipulations
001 ana,limously
Mr. Lewis stated that at this time the City would like
with adding certain properties to the AP to proceed
protects the airport and rises around the airport Cverla
perties are Cit y Zone which
City-owned and were recently annexedaa1Ost of the prop_
1 vi: tit z.n-
dustrial . The Braun-HIarris property would also be included in the
overlay . Other properties under consideration are those for which
avigation easements have been obtained . Among these would be the
subdivisions Caldwell Interstate No . 1 and proposed Industrial Site
No . 5, and the Mountain Bell property . Don Tolley inquired about
semi-spot zoning properties rather than defining a corridor to take
in all overlay territory at one time . Lewis explained that only
those properties that have made a commitment were being considered
and also that much of the land northeasterly of the freeway is still
in the county . It was pointed out by Pilote that although the concern
at present is for those properties over which the City has some juris-
diction , the county perhaps should be consulted about the use of that
area. This subject could be considered in the future . After further
j0-10-7 discussion , Tom Ensley and Bud Grant moved and seconded to establish
the next meeting date as a public hearing to hear testimony on the
proposed additions to the Airport Overlay Zone . Motion carried with
one opposing vote .
Charles Callsen has rcyucsLed a variance from the subdivision ordi-
nance to build two residences in less than a year on property too
small to plat on E. Syringa Lane . Mr. Lewis explained that the
proposal is to divide their land which is 177 ft . by 300 ft . into
two building sites . The property is deeded in two pieces , one 147
feet and another 30 feet for a possible right of way which was being
considered in the past but never dedicated . Mr . Lewis indicated he
would have no objections to the division of the property if they
would preserve 28 feet on the east - not necessarily deed it now
but just not use it because there is a chance a right of way will he
needed some day especially for development of the south part of the
property . Sewer is not available but any recommendation for a vari-
ance should include at least an investigation of the property ' s
eventual participation in providing itself with a sewer . This has
been done recently by covenants approved by the owner and by the City
in which the property is covenanted itself . Water could be extended
to serve the two building sites . The actual property division would
be 74 .6 , 74 . 6 and 28 feet . Mrs . Callsen was asked if she would be
willing to preserve 28 feet for a possible right of way and to enter
into covenants guaranteeing participation in providing sewer to the
80-10-8 property and she responded affirmatively . After a discussion , Don
Tolley moved to recommend to the City Council the granting of the
variance to issue two building permits subject to right of way and
covenant conditions . The motion was seconded by Ralph Nyblad . Motion
carried unanimously .
No one was present to discuss a special use permit to install Etas
pumps at R and B Market .
At this time John Pilote asked Bob Carpenter to chair the meeting
during the discussion on the Dixie Slough Townhomes project . Mr .
Lewis reported that the proposed development could be considered
as a planned unit development with the requirement of at least 2
acres minimum being waived or that the developer could separate
some of the units thereby making them duplexes which would be al-
lowed in an R-1 zone with a special permit if the separation of
75 feet per building site policy were waived . The property con-
tains 1 1/2 acres . Nine units are anticipated which will fall
within the density limitation of 4-6 dwelling units per acre in
the single family residential zone . It is the intention to separate
•
-4-
ownerships under the townhouse concept so a special use permit is
e-Nrequired . Sewer is available along the Dixie Drain and the Engineer
recommended that the units he charged under the multiple unit rate .
Water is available in Ray Avenue . The water main extension policy
would apply and all units must be separately metered . The planned
unit development would require platting to identify properties as
they are to be sold under separate ownership . A variance for zero
lot lines is included in the special use permit . There is 130 foot
wide right-of-way for the Dixie Drain behind the units but as proposed
the 20-foot rear setback will be encroached upon so a variance is beinr
requested for this . The street is now improved with concrete curb
and gutter and pavement . Sidewalk is required and the prints indicate
this is planned to be included . Documents will be required for main-
tenance of all common ground , private driveways , sewers or other
common interests in the maintenance of the buildings themselves .
Parking has been adequately shown. Fifteen spaces are required and
00-10-9 30 have been provided . After a discussion , Don Tolley moved to set
a public hearing for a special use permit on November 20 and to
waive the requirement of 2 acres for a planned unit development .
The variance to extend the units into the rear setback is included .
The motion was seconded by Ralph Nyblad and , after a vote , carried
unanimously .
John Pilote resumed the chair for discussion of a variance requested
by Glenn Schmidt to construct a 20 by 36 foot garage in the rear set-
back 3 feet from the side property line at 2116 Colorado . There is
an existing garage that will be removed and replaced by a larger
eigN structure which is unable to meet the 4-foot setback to the lot line .
Mr. Schmidt 's reasons for wanting to construct a new garage were
i0-10-10 listed in a narrative read by Mr . Lewis . Jim Oates and Ralph Nyblad
moved and seconded to establish the next regularly scheduled meeting
for a public hearing on the variance . Motion carried unanimously .
Gerry Weeks appeared before the Commission seeking a recommendation
to the Council to allow construction of a 6-foot high fence out on
the right of way to enclose the rear yard at 424 Cottonwood Street .
Tenth Avenue , which also borders the corner lot , has been improved
with curb , gutter and sidewalk and the owners ' desire is to go out
to the sidewalk with the fence . At the present time a 3-foot solid
or 4-foot vision fence is permitted on the right of way but the Weeks
are interested in a fence for privacy . Mr. Lewis explained that the
real problem arises when widening of a street occurs (10th is desig-
nated as an arterial with an 80 foot right of way ) or the installation
of utilities becomes necessary . Once the fence is in , it is very
difficult to get the owner to remove the fence from the right of way
at his expense and the city gets stuck buying fence removal . It was
suggested that perhaps some kind of wording could be incorporated in-
to the granting of the variance to protect the city . Mr . Lewis ack-
nowledged that it could be done but considerable work would be involved
in preparing the documents which would covenant the land forever on
the titles or until the fence complied with the code . After considerabl
30-10-11 discussion , Bob Carpenter moved to recommend to the City Council they
grant permission for the fence on the right-of-way with the stipula-
tion that the owners provide covenants guaranteeing they will be
responsible for providing access to that right of way when requested
by an authorized party . The motion was seconded by Don Tolley and
carried unanimously .
4
-5-
Renewal of a special use permit for McGarvin Construction to con-
struct l0-plexes on N. Indiana on part of Lot 10 and Lots 11 and
12 of Torrens and Tucker Addition was considered next . The permit
was granted 10-19-79 . No changes are being requested in the original
1-10-12 permit . Torn Ensley and Jinn Oates moved and seconded to grant a one-
year extension to the permit . Motion carried unanimously .
An application for a special use permit has been filed by Guy Loftis
of Treasure Valley Pipe Supply , Lith and Albany , to allow the use of
his property for the expansion of United Metal and Scrap Company .
He indicated he intended to perpetuate the sale of pipe so the use
would be a mixture . The yard will be fenced by a solid fence not
L-10-13 less than 8 feet in height . Bob Carpenter and Ralph Nyblad moved
and seconded to set a public hearing for the next meeting on the
special use permit subject to enclosure with an 8-foot fence
of the scrap metal yard . Motion carried unanimously .
A request for a 7-foot encroachment into the rear setback to remodel
the residence at 2208 Ellis Avenue was submitted by Bill Ballantyne .
He is proposing to put an 8 ft . by 20 ft . extension onto the rear
of his house . Work has been started as no plot plan is required
by the Building Office for remodeling and there was a misunderstand-
ing as to the rear setback requirement . Mr. Ballantyne has only a
21 foot rear yard and would be unable to build without using a por-
tion of the rear setback area . The Commission determined that a
public hearing could he held on November 6 at the earliest to be
able to meet the code requirements for advertising and notification
emIN so the work could be completed while the weather was still good .
)-1,14 It was moved and seconded by Don Tolley and Jim Oates that inasmuch
as the City issued the building permit and work was begun , Mr.
Ballantyne should be extended the courtesy of a special meetIng on
November 6 for a variance . The hearing will be held at 12 : 00 Thurs-
day , Nov. 6, in the Council Chambers . Motion carried unanimously .
Mr . Lewis informed the Commission that one other item had come to
his attention . The special use permit to construct 3 duplexes in
Spring Meadow subdivision expired and a request will be submitted
by the developer to renew that permit at the next meeting .
Meeting adjourned at 9 : 20 p .m.
Respectfully submitted ,
Sylvia Robison
Secretary pro tem