Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1979-10-18 P & Z MINUTES PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION MINUTES October 18 , 1979 The meeting was called to order at 7 : 30 p.m. in the Council Chambers by Chairman John Pilote . Present were Starr Farish, Bud Grant , Al McCluskey , Bob Carpenter, Betty Ann Lodge , Pete Olesen, John Hull, Boyd Henry , Tom Ensley and Mel Lewis . Also attending were Mayor Pasley , Councilwomen Bauman and Williams , and Councilman Hopper. It was moved and seconded by Starr Farish and John Hull to dispense with the reading of the September 20 minutes and approve them as written. Bob Carpenter asked that the minutes be amended to show that he was present. The motion was amended and , after a vote , carried. First item on the agenda was a public hearing to consider zoning for proposed areas being considered for annexation. The Chairman explained that the Engineer would review each area and that testimony would be taken on each area separately. Mr. Lewis described Area A as being generally located northeast of Farmway Road and Logan Street (known as Blocks 1 and 2 of Hill View Place) and including a tract in the northeast corner of Lot 16 of Mitchell ' s Acreage . Proposed zoning is R-1 single family residential. No testimony was offered on the proposed zoning for this area. Moved by John Hull, seconded by Bud Grant to recommend an R-1 residential zoning to the City Council for Area A if it is annexed. Motion carried. Area B is located generally north of Logan and extending approximately 140 feet on each side of the centerline of Marshall Avenue extended and also includes an area north of Logan and adjacent to the east of the above-described areas . Proposed zoning is R-1 single family residential . No testimony was offered on the proposed zoning for this area. Moved by Starr Farish, seconded by John Hull to recommend to the City Council an R-1 residential zoning for Area B if it is annexed. Motion carried. Area C is generally situated west of Marshall Avenue between West Ash and West Elm extended . Proposed zoning is R-1 single family residential . The City Engineer stated that a petition had been received from resi- dents in this area, but the petition was concerning annexation and not zoning. He further stated that petitions on annexation will be forwarder to the City Council for consideration at their public hearing. Dorothy Ring was recognized and inquired about the designation for animals in the H-i zone . Mr. Lewis read the Code which stated that one animal per acre is permitted and this can be exceeded by special permit . As there was no testimony regarding the proposed zoning, Boyd Henry and Bud Grant moved and seconded that in the event Area C is annexed, the recommendation from the Planning and Zoning Commission would be for R-1 single family residential zoning. At this time Bill Keys inquired if the R-1 zone was limited to single family residences or are duplexes allowed . He was informed that du- plexes are allowed by special permit and must be spaced 75 feet between building sites . Location of Area D is generally west of S . Kimball Avenue, north of West Beech, east of the extension of the Hoshaw Drain and south of the present City limits . Proposed zoning is R-1 single family residen- -1- -2- tial . No testimony was offered on the proposed zoning for this area. Moved by Tom Ensley , seconded by Bud Grant to recommend to the City Council a zoning of R-1 in the event it is annexed . Motion carried. emN Area E is generally located west of S. Kimball including Hill Drop Subdivision, an area to the north and an area between Hill Drop Subdivision and S . Kimball Avenue . Proposed zoning is R-1 single family residential. Hearing no testimony , Bud Grant and Starr Farish moved and seconded to zone Area E R-1 single family residen- tial if it is annexed. Motion carried . Area F includes land between S. Kimball and S. Tenth Avenues . Higer Subdivision, Hendrickson Subdivision and Hendrickson Sub- division No. 2 are being considered along with a few other tracts for an R-1 zoning. No testimony was offered on the proposed zoning for this area. Moved by John Hull, seconded by Bud Grant to recom- mend this area to be annexed as R-1 single family residential if it is annexed. Motion carried. Area G is generally located west of S . 10th Avenue and contains Forest Green Park Subdivision and a 160 by 160 foot tract bounded by Spruce Street , Forest Green Park and S. 10th Avenue . Proposed zoning is R-1 single family residential . Buntley Wilcox, owner of the above tract, requested that his property be zoned R-3 if annexed because he operates a saw, chain saw, lawn mower, etc . , sharpening business there . Dr. Hobert Ring of 406 E. Spruce indicated he supported R-1 Residential for Forest Green Park Subdivision and would also support Buntley ' s request for R-3 for 3200 S. 10th Avenue . Paul Mann of 407 Spruce Street also said he was in favor of R-1 zoning for Forest Green Park. It was pointed out during discussion that Mr. Wilcox ' s request called for a "spot" zone of his property and this would not be in accordance with the Comprehensive Plan. His business could continue with grandfather rights as a non-conforming use . Hearing no further testimony, Pilote closed the public hearing. Moved by Bud Grant , seconded by John Hull to recommend to the City Council that , if annexed, Area G be zoned R-1 single family residential. Motion carried. Area H is an enclave located on the west side of S . 10th Avenue near Chaparro Estates . Proposed zoning is R-1 single family resi- dential. Eileen Bartlett Hill , whose mother Mrs . Allen lives within the area proposed for annexation, inquired if R-1 was the most restric- tive zone available and , if so , did not protest the zoning. Moved by Bud Grant , seconded by Betty Ann Lodge , to recommend R-1 single family residential zoning for Area H if it is annexed . Motion carried . Area I is another enclave located generally on the east side of S . 10th Avenue adjacent to and south of the Junior High School property . Proposed zoning is R-i single family residential . No testimony was offered regarding zoning for this property. Moved by Starr Farish, seconded by John Hull that in the event Area I is annexed, a recommen- dation of R-1 single family residential be forwarded to the City Coun- cil . Motion carried. 1 Included in Area J are McCarthy and Rosewood Subdivisions and the property bounded by Brian Avenue , Lucky Way, S. 10th and Ustick. The former are being proposed for R-1 zoning and the latter property -3- for R-3 multi- family high density re:-;tiential. zoning. This area is designated as high density and professional offices on the Plan and is zoned R-1 in the County . The County Plan shows an undefined red or commercial area at the corner of the intersection. Two petitions have been filed by property owners in Rosewood and McCarthy Subdi- visions objecting to the proposed R-3 zoning of the property owned by Schuyler Enochs . The veterinary clinic is a non-conforming use in the County zoning but could exist in its present state under grandfather rights . Responding to the call for testimony were the following: Gwyneth Lavoy who lives in Rosewood Subdivision did oppose the R-3 zoning if high density residential units were planned . Schuyler Enochs informed the Commission he had moved out with his business because he didn't want to be in town and there were no houses around him at that time. He would like to have his property zoned commercial. Mike Ayers of 4007 Brian spoke in opposition to the R-3 zoning. Others objecting to the R-3 zoning were Ron and Sonia Huyck, 3810 Brian; Richard Miller, 616 Ross Lane ; and Dorothy Ring, 406 E. Spruce. After a discussion, it was moved and seconded by Betty Ann Lodge and Tom Ensley to recommend Area J less Mr. Enochs ' property to the City Council for an R-1 single family residential zoning if it is annexed and to table action on Enochs ' property for further study. Motion carried. Area K is generally located on S . 10th Avenue and south of Rudolph Manor Subdivision, and is approximately 240 feet by 160 feet. Pro- posed zoning is R-1 single family residential. There was no testimony on this proposed zoning. Moved by Tom Ensley , seconded by Boyd Henry to forward a recommendation for R-1 zoning for Area K if it is annexed . Motion carried. General location of Area I'4 is adjacent and west of Montana Avenue 660 feet and north of Big Sky Estates 212 feet . Proposed zoning is R-1 single family residential . Pat Rarick of 3104 S . Montana asked if his shop and house he is renting would be protected by grandfather rights . He was informed they would . Since no further testimony was given, it was moved and seconded by Bud Grant and Boyd Henry to recommend R-1 zoning for Area M if it is annexed. Motion carried. Area N is also located generally west of S . Montana Avenue and is bounded by a line parallel to and approximately 330 feet south of Spruce on the north , a line parallel with and approximately 990 feet south of Spruce on the south and extends approximately 660 feet west of S . Montana Avenue on the west . Proposed zoning is H-1 single family residential . No testimony was offered on the proposed zoning . Starr Parish and Bud Grant moved and seconded to recommend to the City Council in the event this area is annexed it be zoned R-1 . Motion carried . Areas 0, P, Q, H and T, all located in the general vicinity of Montana Manor Subdivision, were considered together . Proposed zoning is R-1 single family residential . hearing no testimony on the proposed zoning , Bud Grant and Tom Ensley moved and seconded to 0.1 recommend an R-1 zoning for these areas to the City Council if they are annexed . Motion carried . Area U which is generally located on both sides of Cleveland Boule- vard and extending southeasterly from Ustick Road approximately 1100 -4- feet , has been proposed for C-3 service commercial zoning. Present County zoning for this area is C-3 . As no testimony was offered ''N regarding the proposed zoning, Bud Grant moved that if Area U is annexed it be designated C-3 Commercial . The motion was seconded by John Hull and, after a vote, carried. Area W is generally located along Cleveland Boulevard and north of Laster Lane and has the owner' s consent for annexation. Proposed zoning is as follows : A tract extending along and southwesterly of Cleveland Bou- levard beginning about 2900 feet from the intersection of Cleveland Boulevard and Ustick Road will be considered for C-3 service commercial zoning. M-1 light industrial zoning is being proposed for an area between the proposed transportation corridor and the railroad. The area between Cleveland and the proposed transportation cor- ridor to be located approximately 950 feet northeasterly of Cleveland is proposed for C-3 service commercial zoning. A tract located between the railroad and I-80N and east of Midway Road extended will be considered for M-1 light indus- trial zoning. There was no testimony regarding the proposed zoning. Moved by John Hull, seconded by Bud Grant to recommend the above zonings for Area W to the City Council. Motion carried. 79-10-1 A request will be sent to the City Council to hold a public hearing for consideration of the recommended zonings for the areas proposed for annexation. John Pilote then opened the public hearing for a special use permit to divide duplexes on Lots 1 and 40 , Block 3 of Starlight Park Unit 1 for sale to separate owners. Required to accomplish this conver- sion in addition to the special permit will be a variance for zero lot lines which go through the buildings and the filing of a plat and the necessary documents for protection of common interests . 79-10-2 Since no opposition was expressed from the audience , Starr Farish and Betty Ann Lodge moved and seconded to approve the special use permit with the stipulations stated above . Motion carried. The next public hearing was for a special use permit for a State licensed day care center at 820 S. 5th Avenue requested by Linda Woodhall . Approximately 25 children are anticipated. The granting of the special use permit would be subject to meeting specifications of the State , fire and building codes . No testimony was offered re- 79-10-3 garding the day care center. After a discussion, it was moved and se- conded by John Hull and Bud Grant to grant the permit with the pro- vision that all code requirements will be satisfied and that the operator will not exceed the 25-child maximum without again appearing pqN before the Commission. Motion carried. A public hearing was then held for a special use permit requested by i,IcGarvin Construction for separating ownerships in a 10-unit condo- minium to be constructed between N. Indiana and N. Michigan Avenues -5- south of Marble Front Road. Also requested was a variance for a 10- foot front setback from the cul-de-sac which would put the buildings on alignment with the existing residential setback along the street , according to Bob McGarvin. Hearing no testimony , Pilote closed the 79-10-4 public hearing. Starr Parish moved and Bud Grant seconded the motion to grant the special use permit and variance . Mr. Lewis stated that the motion should be amended to include the filing of a plat and the necessary documents covering common interests . The motion as amended carried . The next 3 public hearings concerned a part of Jack Stites ' property on east Chicago which Ed Smith and Steve Aldrich are interested in purchasing . They would like to operate a towing service and storage yard for wrecked automobiles on the easterly portion of the property and north of a metal shop building. This requires a special permit in the M-1 zone . Smith and Aldrich would also like to place a mo- bile home behind the mobile homes and residences on the portion of the property being retained by Stites and now occupied by the Stites family . For this purpose an expansion of the "T" Overly zone and a variance for a setback greater than the 55 foot maximum are necessary . No testimony was heard from the audience regarding granting the special use permit. In subsequent discussion , Betty Ann Lodge inquired as to whether or not the wrecked automobiles could be seen from the road 79-10-5 or if the yard would be screened or fenced. She then moved to table action on the permit until the property could be viewed. The motion was seconded by Starr Parish and carried. John Pilote then appointed a 3-person committee to look at the property and report back at the /'RN November meeting. Betty Ann Lodge will serve as chairman and will be joined by Bud Grant and Boyd Henry . John Hull and Bud Grant moved and seconded to also table action on the zone change and variance pending the committee ' s report . Motion carried . Next on the agenda was presentation of the preliminary and final of a plat of One Linden Plaza, a commercial subdivision located on the corner of Linden and Georgia in the C-1 area . The City Engineer' s report was as follows : Since the majority of the easements and all improvements have been provided for this area except a sewer and the remainder of a drain along Linden, I am recommending the preliminary and final of this plat be considered together. The south half of Linden is 25 feet and a 10-foot easement for utilities is al- ready dedicated. Easements have been otherwise provided for utilities that are not in the plat . Acceptance should be contingent upon: 1 . A sewer beim; provided to City stand- ards to serve all of the lots ; 2 . Application of the water main extension policy ; 3 . Provision of a pedestrian walkway along the street rights of way in connection with the parking lot adjacent ; 4 . Tiling of the remainder of the drain and irrigation line along Linden. 79-10-6 Moved by Tom Ensley, seconded by Bob Carpenter to recommend to the City Council the approval of the preliminary and final plat of One Linden Plaza subject to the Engineer ' s report . Motion carried. -6- A recommendation from the City P and Z Commission has been enlisted by the County regarding temporary placement of a mobile home on eRN property owned by Gary Vezzoso near the corner of Florida and Ustick . There is a house on the property and access to the mobile home will be by private lane . The mobile home will be occupied by Mr. Vezzoso ' s brother . Mr. Lewis explained that the County has a procedure whereby the issue a conditional use permit for a temporary use by a relative for 79-10-7 one year. After a discussion, Bob Carpenter moved to recommend to the County to issue a temporary permit for one year on the mobile home provided it satisfies County zoning, regulations . The motion was seconded by Starr Parish and , after a vote, carried. An application for a variance for a 5 ' by 8 ' illuminated sign to serve their new office building to be located at the intersection of Kimball and Paynter Avenues ( 1305 S . Kimball ) has been filed by White Riedel and Company . Two plans were reviewed showing proposed heights of 8 feet and 16 feet for the sign which will be constructed 79-10-8 of stucco and wood . Moved by Betty Ann Lodge , seconded by Tom Ensley to set a public hearing for November 15 for consideration of the variance . Motion carried. The County has asked for a zoning recommendation for a mobile home park proposed to be located on Midway Road near Owyhee Village mobile home subdivision. The layout plan of L u R Mobile Home Village was presented by the City Engineer with the following explanation. The zone change required would be from R-2 to R-2T. Sewer and water are not available at the present time so private wells and disposal sys- /"') tems will be used . The County has an ordinance stipulating sizes , recreation areas , etc . , for mobile home parks , so these requirements will have to be met . The park will remain under one ownership . After 79-10-9 a discussion, John Hull and Bud Grant moved and seconded to recommend to the County the zone chance be made to allow the mobile home park as requested subject to its meeting County zoning requirements and regulations of the Southwest Health District for private disposal systems . Motion carried . to High Density Resid. A Comprehensive Plan change from Medium Density Residential/and a rezoning from R-2 to 5-3 have been requested for that part of Tract U of Mountain View Subdivision which is not commercially zoned . The tract is bounded by Cleveland , Florida , Cherry and Locust . The owner desires the changes to accommodate a mobile home park . There was some discussion regarding any other Plan changes that could be con- sidered at the same time , however, no decisions were made . November 9-1u-10 15 was established as the public hearing date for consideration of a Plan change for part of Tract U of Mountain View Subdivision. Bob Carpenter assumed the Chair for the discussion on a rezoning requested by the owners of the property on which Custom Plastics is located near the intersection of Freeport and Eleventh. Rezoning is necessary to build another building adjacent to the existing one which is presently a non-conforming use in an R-2T zone . A C-3T commercial zoning is being sought for the entire tract of approximately 10-11 7 1/2 acres . Moved by Tom Ensley , seconded by John Hull to hold a public hearing on November 15 subject to the necessary information being brought in to the Engineering Department . Motion carried . Presented next was a preliminary of a plat of Happy Day Center -7- which is intended to provide for a commercial planned unit develop- merit in both the C-3 and M-1 zones in the City and County . The C-3 Commercial zone extends from Cleveland to the corridor and the M-1 Light Industrial zone from the corridor to the railroad. Right-of-way for the corridor is 80 feet as required and right-of-way for Cleveland should be the width required by the highway Department . Laster Lane should be a minimum of 60 feet . Easements will be required along all street right-of-way lines as stipulated by Idaho Power Com- pany . Water is to be from the City if an agreement can be worked out . If not , the developers will proceed with private wells . City sewer is desired if one can be provided in the southeast interceptor pro- ject the City is working on. Otherwise , private disposal systems will be installed in accordance with SWIID requirements . Plans for street improvements are to be approved by the City and by the High- way Department for Cleveland . The development will be in stages , beginning with the first 10 lots . Annexation has been requested 9-10-12 for the property . Moved by Bud Grant , seconded by Starr Farish to recommend approval of the preliminary plat of Happy Day Center to the City Council subject to the Engineer' s report . Motion carried. Ruth Johansen appeared before the Commission seeking a special use permit to operate a group day care center for 12 children in her home at 2905 S . Indiana Avenue . She has applied for a State license and the permit will be subject to meeting all requirements of zoning, 9-10-13 fire and safety , building code , and State regulations . It was moved and seconded by Starr Farish and Boyd Henry to set a public hearing for November 15 for the special use permit . Motion carried . The final topic on the agenda was a discussion on the right-of-way problem for the street approximately one block east of Georgia and south of Lincoln. Norman Rutzen and Scott Bistline were both present . The Planning Commission agreed several years ago that , due to the hardship on the rim side , a narrow right-of-way could be accepted in which a standard roadway could be built leaving little right-of- way behind the curb . The Planning Commission at that time also recommended a cul-de-sac . Most of the cul-de-sac would be dedicated from property owned by Mr . Rutzen ' s father-in-law, but part (25 feet ) would have to come from property owned by Wayne Schiess to the west . Rutzen reported he has been unsuccessful in his attempts to obtain the additional right-of-way for the cul-de-sac from Schiess and would like to have the City accent the cul-de-sac without the 25 feet until such time as Mr. Schiess decides to develop the back part of his property . Bistline stated he is opposing acceptance of a sub- standard street right-of-way on the part of the City and is challeng- ing interpretation of an old deed in which former owner Hire dedicated 15 feet generally located on the east side of Bistline ' s and Hick ' s land for public use . Rutzen ' s proposal was if that 15 foot piece of right-of-way could be used , he would see that the rest of the 40 feet was provided for the narrow right-of-way and would give 5-foot utility easements on that side . There are ;, building sites on the rim and Rutzen can either build one house a year or plat once the right-of-way is resolved . Action to be taken , according to Mr. Lewis , should be a recommendation to the City Council on what should be accepted for right- 10-14 of-way and how :it in to be given . After a lengthy discussion John Hull moved to recommend to the Council the acceptance of a 40-foot right-of-way and a substandard cul-de-sac for the present and to let the properties involved work out where the right-of-way is to be . The motion was seconded by Starr Farish and , after a vote , carried. Sylvia Robison, Secretary pro t Meeting adjourned at 11 : 00 p , m.