HomeMy WebLinkAbout1979-08-16 P & Z MINUTES PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION MINUTES
August 16, 1979
04)
The meeting was called to order at 7 : 30 p .m. in the Council Chambers
by Vice-Chairman Bob Carpenter. Present were Don Tolley , Starr Far-
ish, John Hull, Betty Ann Lodge, Tom Ensley , Bob Nicholes , Ralph
Nyblad, Mel Lewis , and. Al McCluskey .
Starr Farish and John Hull moved and seconded to dispense with the
reading of the July 19 minutes and approve them as written. Motion
passed.
The public hearings were delayed until enough members were present
to form a quorum.
First item to be considered was a request by Everett Purcell of
T and T Construction Company to obtain two building permits in
less than a year on property too small to plat at Parker and West
Oak. Mel Lewis explained the property development with respect
to adjoining properties and indicated the deeding of a cul-de-
sac , a 28-foot half right-of-way for future West Oak extending to
the west and 28-foots/ right-of-way along the south side to the east
79-8-1 would be required. After a discussion, John Hull made a motion to
recommend to the City Council the granting of a variance for two
building permits on the above property. The motion was seconded by
Betty Ann Lodge and carried with one opposing vote .
eiN A special use permit is being sought by the developers of Spring
Meadow to construct duplexes on Lot 1, Block 3 , Lot 6 , Block 3 and
Lot 5 , Block 2 of Spring Meadow. As planned, the lots conform with
the policy of spacing duplexes no closer than 75 feet from building
(9-8-2 site to building site in the R-1 zone . Don Tolley and Tom Ensley
moved and seconded to set a public hearing for September 20 . Motion
carried.
Bob Carpenter then opened the public hearing portion of the meeting.
First on the agenda was a request for a variance to divide Lots
11-15, Block 76 of Mountain View Subdivision No . 2 into two pro-
perties for separate ownerships with the corner lot having less
square footage than required by ordinance . The properties in
question are located on Walnut near its intersection with Iowa.
Dimensions of the corner lot will be 52 . 14 feet by 140 feet . There
is an existing residence on each lot and no further building will
(9-8-3 be done . It was moved and seconded by Bob Nicholes and Starr
Farish to grant the variance to Jim Schelhorn to create a substan-
dard corner lot . Motion carried.
Opened next was the public hearing for a variance to construct a
residence that will extend 10 feet into the rear setback area on
Lots 23 and 24 , Block 117 of Strahorn Addition at 5th and Everett .
The application was filed by Caldwell Realty and Developers , Inc .
Starr Farish reported he had received a phone call from Mr. Kimble
who lives at 505 Everett , Lots 21 and 22 . Mr. Kimble said that
regardless of whether the residence fronts on 5th or Everett , since
it would be a variation only into the rear setback and he lives
adjacent to that property, he has no objection to it . Hearing no
further testimony , Carpenter closed the public hearing. A motion was
-2-
79-8-4 made and seconded by John Hull and Starr Farish to grant the variance
for the rear setback. Motion carried.
41
The public hearing was then opened for consideration of a variance
requested by the Senior Citizen' s Center organization to expand the
existing building 13. 8 feet to the alley line in the rear. The ex-
pansion is for storage. It was noted that the Employment Office
building adjacent to the center is constructed to the alley line.
79-8-5 Since no objections were voiced from the audience , Betty Ann Lodge
and Tom Ensley moved and seconded to grant the variance . Motion passed .
A public hearing was held for consideration of a special use permit
for a planned unit development on South Montana south of the High
School tennis courts. The project will consist of 49 units on a
tract that is 5 acres less the site that will be used to construct
a seminary school building. The density in an R-1 zone is 4-6
dwelling units per acre and the proposed development will have 10+
units per acre . Mel Lewis said he had some recommendations but would
wait to make them except for defining a planned unit development .
A P .U.D. is normally platted to sell out units or divide ownerships .
This project is intended to remain under one ownership and no units
will be sold, therefore platting is not required . The special use
permit issued will govern what is done by the conditions that are
placed upon it . James Gipson provided a detailed description of
the project with respect to sewer, landscaping, irrigation, improve-
ments and maintenance . Bob Carpenter then called for testimony from
the audience. Mike Gable was recognized and indicated that , although
he was not opposed to this type of project , he would like to see some
access through this area to connect 10th Avenue and Montana Avenue .
He also expressed concern about the density and the traffic on Mon-
tana. Traffic on Montana was also the concern of Larry Grist , Pastor
of one of the churches in the vicinity. According to the City En-
gineer, one of the recommendations he would have is that the devel-
opers agree to improve Montana for one block on the west side along
with the seminary . He pointed out that it is planned for Chaparro
Street to eventually go all the way through from 10th on an align-
ment a half block south of the south boundary of the project . Don
Tolley questioned the increased density requested for the develop-
ment and, after a discussion , moved to not grant the special use
permit without further study on traffic and street conditions . The
motion died for lack of a second. John Hull then moved that the
special use permit be granted with the following provisions :
1. Their half of the street on Montana be improved.
2 . Landscaping be part of the plan.
3 . Fence around the entire project be required.
4 . Curb , gutter and sidewalk within the development be
provided.
5 . Sewer be brought in and approved by the City.
Starr Farish seconded the motion. Bob Carpenter then stated that
upon approval of the special use permit it becomes an accepted plan
emN unless an appeal is made to the City Council. The City Engineer
said he had some comments to the motion that the Commission might
want to consider. His recommendations were : 1) Sewer is to be
provided with easements and installation to meet the requirements
of the City. 2 ) For furnishing City water, an affidavit of non-
-3-
separation
3-separation of ownership must be recorded and a copy filed with the
City. 3) The west half of Montana Avenue bordering the project
olimN
as well as the church seminary school property must be improved
with curb , gutter and sidewalk. The border street policy will apply .
This means if they can' t fit the oil surfacing to the existing sur-
facing, it has to be rebuilt . 4 ) Some statement from Pioneer
Irrigation District ought to be enlisted indicating they approve
of the project irrigation plans . 5) I would make their letter of
July 16 which describes the landscaping, boundaries , sewer, etc . ,
a condition of the permit. 6 ) A survey of the land should be
required to identify where it is and a certified copy of that
79-8-6 survey be a condition of the permit . John Hull amended his motion
to include the Engineer' s stipulations and the amendment was seconded
by Starr Farish. Motion carried with one opposing vote .
Presented next for consideration by the Commission was the prelim-
inary and final plat combined for Logan-Washington Duet . The plat
was prepared for the dividing of the duplex on the corner of Logan
and Washington which is owned by Lorraine Johnson into two separate
units for sale. Mr. Lewis informed the Commission that all of the
requirements have been met and an agreement concerning the common
79-8-7 interests has been filed. Starr Farish and John ]dull moved and
seconded to recommend approval of the preliminary and final plats
of Logan-Washington Duet to the City Council . Motion carried.
Owen McLaughlin appeared before the Commission to request a variance
to divide the corner lot at 7th and Fillmore creating two small
building sites 62 x 100 and 58 x 100 feet . The property is located
9n8 in an R-2 zone. A motion was made and seconded by Don Tolley and
John Hull to set a hearing date of September 20 on the variance.
Motion carried.
Discussion was then held on whether or not a special use permit should
be required for Dr. Stritzke to locate a small animal clinic in a
C-2 Commercial zone on Elgin east of 10th Avenue . The existing
residence on Lots 5-8, Block 54 , Boone ' s Addition (100 x 120 ft . )
will be remodeled to provide facilities for surgery, limited kennels
and exercise lanes . The facilities will be entirely enclosed . Large
animals will be treated and vaccinated but will not be kept on the
premises . The zoning ordinance has no provision in the land use
table for a small animal clinic so an interpretation was requested
from the Commission. It was the decision of the Commission that if
the operation is kept within the boundaries as described by Dr.
Stritzke , the clinic could be considered a permitted use in a C-2
79-8-9 zone . A motion stating this decision was made and seconded by Tom
Ensley and Ralph Nyblad. Motion carried.
Ed Smith was present to discuss obtaining a variance for an additional
mobile home on a part of the Jack Stites ' property he is contemplating
buying on East Chicago. He and his partner intend to use an existing
shop building for automotive repair and auto body services . They
are also considering a tow service . There is a mobile home on
the property which faces on Chicago and they would like to put another
one on the back of the property and use Idaho Meat Packer ' s private
road for access . Chicago Street is zoned for mobile homes for 300
feet on each side of the centerline but the site proposed by Smith
would not be in this M-lel' zone. If they could locate it within the
_24_
011) 300 feet but more than 55 feet from the right-of-way of Chicago
Street, a variance would be required for a greater than the
79-8-10 maximum setback. After a discussion, Don Tolley moved that a
public hearing be set for consideration of a variance subject
to the location of the mobile home on the property . The motion
was seconded by Ralph Nyblad and, after a vote , carried .
Discussion on the County zoning ordinance was postponed until
the next meeting.
Meeting adjourned at 9 : 30 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Sylvia Robison
Secretary pro tem
3
emN