HomeMy WebLinkAbout1979-05-17 P & Z MINUTES PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION MINUTES
May 17 , 1979
The meeting was called to order at 7 : 30 p .m. in the Council Chambers
by Chairman John Pilote . Present were Bob Nicholes , Boyd Henry, Al
McCluskey, Pete Olesen, Starr Parish, Betty Ann Lodge, John Hull ,
Tom Ensley , Bob Carpenter and Mel Lewis .
Starr Parish moved to dispense with the reading of the April 19
minutes and approve tnem as written. The motion was seconded
by Betty Ann Lodge and passed.
John Pilote i r_lconed Boyd Henry to the Commission.
First on t<ne e'genua was a public hearing for consideration of Com-
prehensive i'1 :;: changes in O. T. Sanders Subdivision. Two applica-
tions have been submitted. Application "A" requests Lots 1-1 , Block
1 , and Lots 1-5, Block 2 be changed from Low Density Residential to
High Density Residential and Professional Offices , and Application
"B" is for Lots 5-10 , Block 1 and Lot 6 of Block 2 to be changed
from Low Density Residential to Medium Density Residential . Mel
Lewis read letters in opposition to the Plan change from Mr. and
Mrs . E. A. Henry , 124 Rudolph Street and from Dura and Mary Hopkins,
223 Felton Street . Letters written by Mr. and Mrs . Terry Woodhead,
Route 4 , and Gayle C . Bush, Route 2 , Wilder, supporting the ulti-
mate rezoning to R-3 of the property on which the Health and Welfare
facilities are located to provide for expansion of the Child Devel-
opment Center were also read. Dick Sanders , representing his father,
0. T. Sanders , spoke in behalf of the proposed Plan changes and
ems presented historical information on the land use . Iie explained that
the purpose of requesting the Plan change was to be able to accommo-
date the expansion of the Child Development Center, which cannot be
done under the existing zoning. He further stated that in response
to concern expressed about the overcrowded conditions in some of
the parking area close to the buildings , he had contacted the admin-
istrators who will issue an order requesting employees to utilize
other spaces provided farther away from the access routes . Sanders
indicated that there were no plans to open Arlington or to develop
the lots not being used. Jeff Schwartz, 219 Felton, inquired why
a medium density residential land use was requested on the above-
mentioned lots if no development was anticipated, and Sanders
responded that the intent was to provide a buffer zone between the
high density and professional office area and the low density resi-
dential area. Other testimony offered is as follows : Kert Kurpa,
121 Felton, stated he was opposed to either proposal as he had pur-
chased his property in a single family area and wanted it to remain
that way. Jeff Schwartz, 219 Felton, wanted Arlington to deadend
and not be opened to development . Betty Stanley, 2117 S. Kimball,
special education teacher for the Child Development Center, asked
that consideration be given to allowing expansion of the center
because additional space was needed for the program. Jack Carter,
1)15 Cherry , member of the Grace Lutheran Church across Kimball ,
discussed overflow parking problems at the church . Helen Powell,
2705 S. Kimball , objected to the Plan change because of the traffic
that comes out onto Kimball and inquired why the parking area is
proposed to be changed to high density residential . Others
-1-
-2-
opposing the change were Lewis Karnes , 216 Felton; ?1r. Duerock ,
815 Arlington; Mrs. Kenneth Kenagy , 121 Felton; and George Kesler ,
2006 S. Kimball. Hearing no further testimony , John Pilote closed
the public hearing and opened the issue for discussion to the
Commission . John Hull remarked that after hearing the testimony ,
it was his opinion the people would not object to the property that
is now used for a professional office to eventually be rezoned to
R-3 so the facility for the children could be expanded , but it would
seem most were against the part of the proposal that would allow a
medium density residential land use for the remainder of the subdi-
9-5-1 vision. Iie then moved that a recommendation be sent; to the Council
for a Comprehensive Plan chance from low density residential to
high density residential and professional offices for Lots 1-4 ,
Block 1 , and 1-5, Block 2 of 0. T. Sanders Subdivision . Also
included in the motion was that the area requested in Application
"B" be denied for a medium density residential Plan change .
The motion was seconded by Tom Ensley and, after a vote , carried .
The public hearing on a Comprehensive Plan change from medium
density residential to high density residential and professional
offices for Lots 1-12 , Block 28 of Dorman' s Addition on Cleveland
Boulevard between 12th and 13th Avenues was opened. Mel Lewis
read two letters from Dean Miller, attorney for Wally Frank and
Dave Beck. Cne requested that action be deferred until after a
decision was reached in District Court regarding issuance of a
building permit on Lots 1 , 2 and 3, and the other letter and
petition requested that the zone remain C-2 and the Plan be
amended to conform with that zoning. Testimony was then offered
from the audience . Speaking in favor of a residential land use
for the half block in question and also for Cleveland and Blaine
between 12th and 22nd were Don Winbicler, 1323 Cleveland ; Fred
Hurst , 1414 Blaine ; Mrs . Howard Quast, 1313 Dearborn; Ger: and
Jess Pederson, 1308 Cleveland; Debbie Polhemus , 1203 Dearborn ;
Moena Buck, 1214 Dearborn; John Carr, 1216 Cleveland ; and William
Love, 1812 Cleveland, who urged the Commission to resolve the
divergence between the Plan and the zoning ordinance as soon as
possible. Vernon Smith, who owns property at 1213 Cleveland,
informed the Commission that the residents along Cleveland and Blaine
were willing to compromise from a medium density to high density
residential land use designation for the half block where the busi-
nesses were already located but did not want any further commercial
encroachment into the residential area. Dean Miller was recognized
and, after summarizing prior actions regarding the property, requested
that action be deferred pending; District Court decision. He also
stated a compromise was being prepared to present at a later date .
John Pilote then closed the public hearing. After a discussion ,
9-5--2 a motion was made and seconded by Starr 'garish and John Hull to recom-
mend to the City Council a Comprehensive Plan change from medium den-
sity residential to high density residential and pr'of'essional offices
for Lots 1-12, Block 28 of Dorman ' s Addition. fir. r'arish added that
the Commission should look favorably upon a special use uermit
for a professional office or Lots 1-3 if requested in the future .
Consideration of parking requirements was also discussed. John hull
/"� called for the question and, after a vote , the motion carried .
-3-
held next was a ,lublic hearing on a variance requested by the First
Assembly ( f sod _'„arch to install a lighted sign which is 13 feet by
eqN 30 feet on ,2.:,,rcn property near I-80G. In an R-2 zone , the ordinance
permits a sign identifying a special use to be 32 square feet in area
and the sign must be situated at least 10 feet from the property line.
Gel Frazier and George Beavers , representing the church , described
the sign as having a clock and temperature indicator. It will be
facing east and west parallel with the freeway . Since no objections
7) -3 were voiced from the audience , it was moved and seconded by John Hull
and Starr Faris h to grant the variance . Notion carried with one oppos-
ing vote .
John Pilote then opened the public hearing for a special use permit
to construct a professional office on Lots 9-12 , Block 101 , Goar:du
Addition at 10th and Everett . The application and plans were filed
by Chuck Karn and Gene Baxter. Setback and parking requirements
have been met. Speaking in favor of the proposed office were Jack
Carter, owner of property at 1010 Everett , and Owen Moore, next door
neighbor to the Earn-Baxter property. No further testimony was of-
7J--5--4 fered and the public hearing was closed. It was moved and seconded
by Tom Ensley and Bob Nicholes to grant the special use permit .
Motion carried.
Under consideration next was a special use permit for a retirement
center to be constructed on S. Florida Avenue between Cherry and.
Beech. Lasher Construction intends to use the entire 10 acres and
will develop in phases . There will be no rights of way through
toe development'; therefore , Mr. Lewis has notified by letter the
owners to the west who are going to be affected or cut off from
access to Lihe bacl; of their properties . Present in the audience
were John Scott Veiiwick , 3001 S . Georgia , Paul Westerberg, 3011.
S . Georgia , and Betty Collins , 26l4 Cherry . Concerning; Mr. Fen
wick and Mrs . Collins was the possibility of tying into the sewer
which would serve the retirement center, but Mr. Lewis said sewer
would have to come in from a gravity line up Cherry. Mr. Wester-
berg questioned the effect of the development on the disposition
of his wastewater drainage . Although the development will not
interrupt his drainage , it may become a problem with future street
development , according to Mr. Lewis . He further stated that some
decision has to be reached about wnere streets are going to be
so adjacent owners ' properties can be served. It was his recommen-
dation that a 28-foot half right of way should. be preserved on the
west side of the development for at least a block out to Cherry.
Some consideration would have to be given for setbacks as the ends
of the buildings shown on the plan are within. 20 feet of the pro-
perty line . Not known at this time was whether or not the property
owner immediately adjacent would be willing to give the other 28 feet .
Betty Ann Lodge moved that the special use permit be tabled until
the property owner to the west is contacted . The motion died for
lack of a second. John Hull then moved that the special use permit
for the retirement center be granted provided the drainage problem
could be worked out with the City Engineer, either by right-of-way
acquisition or easement . The motion was seconded by Bob Nicholes .
After Curtner discussion, the motion and second were withdrawn and
Bob Carpenter moved to approve the retirement center with a 28-foot
right-of-way for half of the westerly edge of the property and to
request that an effort be made to secure 28 feet from the property
+nalf rights-of-way will be dedicated fo.r Cherry and. Florida.
-4-
immediately adjacent . The motion was seconded by John Hull and passed.
The public hearing for a special use permit requested by White-
egN Riedel for a professional office at S . Kimball and Paynter was opened .
A variance has been requested to utilize part of the front setback
area 10 feet uehind the property line for parking. Twenty-one
spaces will be provided. The plan has been revised showing the
building location feet from the two rear property lines , which
would require a variance for the rear setback . The office will be
two stories high. YIr. Lewis also stipulated no vehicular access
from the alley . John Montgomery , 109 Morrison, noted that a view
of his backyard would be possible from the 2-story structure . He
also expressed a desire for the City to vacate or permanently
close the alle at the corner of his property. Mr. Kesner, whose
residence foss on Arlington, inquired about access to his garage .
7,-)-6 After a di5c..ssiou , Bob Nicholes moved the special use permit be
granted with a variance to park ( 4 spaces) in the front setback,
a variance to place the building 15 feet into the rear setback,
and subject to no windows on the back south side . The motion was
seconded by Tom Ensley, and after a vote , carried.
At this time it was moved and seconded by Betty Ann Lodge and John
Hull to adjouen the meeting after the last scheduled public hearing
and reconvene with no additional agenda items on May 24 . Motion.
carried.
On the agenda next was a public hearing for a professional office
to be located in the residence at 802 Everett Street . The request
was filed by Aesbitt and Associates, realtors. A variance would be
needed in. order to provide the 3 parking spaces required out of the
setback areas . The garage would he removed to provide two spaces ,
but it would be necessary to park one car behind another for the
other space . There are four employees . Testimony in opposition
to the request was voiced by Mr. Haskell , 808 Everett , and Mrs .
'daily , next door on Kimball, both citing parking problems and the
closeness of the properties as reasons for their objections . After
a discussion, Tom Ensley moved the request be denied because of the
parking situation. The motion was seconded by Betty Ann Lodge .
Motion passed .
Bob Hibbard was recognized and asked that his request be considered
as it was referred by the Council and. he needed a recommendation
from the Commission by the next Council meeting. Mr. Hibbard was
seeking permission to begin construction on a duplex on Lot 8 , Block
2 of Chaparro Estates on S . 10th Avenue prior to the time a public
hearing could be held for the special use permit required in an R-1
zone. He has obtained on a petition the names of several of the
property owners within 300 feet stating they do not object to the
duplex. Hibbard would also stipulate that if the special use permit
were denied, he would convert the duplex into a single family resi-
dence . Under these conditions , he would like a recommendation to
the City Council to approve issuance of a building permit . Following
a discussion, bob Micholes moved that a recommendation be sent to the
City Council to issue the building permit for the duplex subject to
eqN the special use permit being granted and; if it is not successful ,
that it be converted to a single family residence. Hearing was set
for June 21 . The motion was seconded by John Hull and passed.
Meeting adjourned at 11 : 15 p .m.
Respectfully submitted , Sylvia Robison, secretary pro tern
COfI [i; 10;1 Y1I0UTL
May 2
PL���:d:1I'.`G Aid,) ZOy 2 ' 1.7`.
i Cour.c it Cha.nibeY's
/ ,�) � in the Hull ,
to order at ( : 3 Starr In the , John
meeting was callec, Present were Lewis .
The John Pilo:�e . Boyd henry , and Mel arding
by ChairmanBud Grant , minutes r%fore
Ralph 'ilyblad > entered into the before
a notation be Gamble appeared side
asked ti�,.i ,Ali) l',llis . Mr. on the
Lewis residence at seelcinf'', a variance J was resclved
;�1r. 1.�7 7 , Thi
the Lee Gamble August 13 residence • front
At the time n° maximufoot maximum
the Commission on of remodelin; the the �>-
�� for Va p anc r needed•
Jetbacr` variance bandthe house exceeds remodeling
without the ,r cified and since �d to permit thP The
, back was she it was decid former ordinar_ce • r
se ordinance , are contecapl
now defined by conditions °f te fans Er:�:Lneer in
under the if any furtherP of the
of the residence be reviewed t the decision Farish and
situation should to accep Starr
A motion seconded by
for the proper"y • + was made and
7 �-5-) a buildI perms
issuing Motion carried. at
John dull. owned property into
a variance to divide feet obyw 120 feet
requested dimensions °f 1` > ve20 into ,
The City has with could be divided e 50
feet .
Freeport and ',imball
The pr°purty feet and inside lot of
two lot,; for sale .ntlot of 7� variance.
lots or into a corner
foot 1 would be substandard and would require a
Either ways one 10{"c. ublic hearins be set for June 21 and a
re
1J John Bull moved that a p the .notion which, after a
71-5-10
\- �
recommendation be made Indicia seconded the Commission: prefers the
:
rc Starr Parish 75-50 division .'' vote , carried .
iscussion nein o-- a special use permit requested by Judd Lanham
Dtles in a part of Tract 0 of Mountain View
to construct - six-pex
Subdivision. The permit would be granted subject ;,o the fallowing:
1 . Forty-foot right of way for Alder. The border street policy
would apply .
2 . A variance from the subdivision ordinance for no cul-de-sac .
The street would dead end. space per unit (1_ instead of
3. A variance for one parking
lb required) .
1I . Platting for sale under condominium concept .
79-5-11 A motion to set a public hearing, for Jane 21 with t e conditions as
stated above was made and seconded by John hull ant. Sud Brant .
Motion carried .
Lorraine Johnson appeared before the Cc--mission regt:.es*Ing a special
use permit to divide the duple:: at 1703 `,aashinnton a�:d ;104 Loan
l'or sale to individual owners . A plat ^ survey dei'_r.ir.c- the pro-
perty in two separate units will be req ;iced. Separate water meters
and a recorded sewer maintenance agreeme:,t tha , stipu'_a ,eS the res
sibilities of both owners are to be provided, The i3 �i_ 1a Department
has reviewed the plans and reports the cange can be �_a o and the
building codes met with regard to fire walls . After Discussion, a
1.--)-12
motion was made and seconded b,, John Hul� and i�alph .ad t0 estab-
11 ;1T } unlit hearing for June 21 . Motion carried.
-'-
-2-
The vacation of 16th Avenue north of Flair Street has been requested
by u1rs . Estelle bottoms-, 1601 Main , who wishes to construct a garage
behind her house. The adjacent property owners , Ray and Esther Rock-
well , have agreed to the request for the vacation. The street is
platted through Indian Creek and Mr. Lewis explained it is doubtful
that a creek CVO6sinir, would ever be made there . He did point out
that although there are ho utilities in the right of way proposed
to be vacated , the City would want to obtain a 20-foot utility ,
irrigation and storm sewer easement 10 feet on each side of the cen-
terline . No suildinFg would be permitted on the easement . Bud Grant
7 -J-13 moved that a recommendation be sent to the City Council to proceed
with the public hearing and approve the vacation with the 20-foot
easement . The motion was seconded by Starr Farish and passed.
Val Feller and iob Hogg were not present to discuss their requests .
A public hearing was set for June 21 to rezone the Lasher property
between the Interstate Highway and Indian Creek northwesterly from
Ustick Road from M-1 Light Industrial to R-3T Residential . A motion
7)- 5-1)4 to set the hearing was made and seconded by Bud Grant and John Hull .
Motion carried.
Mr. Lewis informed the Commission that he had discussed the right of
way-setback situation for the retirement center with Gary Lasher
and they have agreed that the buildings will be set back 28 feet .
Mr. Lasher will give a 23-foot easement upon which no building can
occur. Then if the right of way is needed at a later date and the
adjacent property owner provides his half, the 28 feet will have
been preserved. A 10-foot utility easement along the south half of
the west side will also be given. Ralph Nyblad moved and Bud Grant
seconded the motion to amend the action taken by the Commission on
Pay 17 requiring dedication of a 28-foot right of way to the granting
of a 28-foot easement on the north half of the west side of the develop-
ment and a 10-foot utility easement on the south half of the west side.
This would allow the buildings zero setback to the property line .
Motion carried.
Meeting adjourned at 9 : 00 p. m.
Respectfully submitted ,
Sylvia Robison
Secretary pro tem
Fm