HomeMy WebLinkAbout1979-03-15 P & Z MINUTES PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION MINUTES
March 15, 1979
The meeting was called to order at 7 : 30 p .m. in the Council Chambers
by Chairman John Pilote . Present were Starr Farish, Betty Ann Lodge ,
Ralph Nyblad, Tom Ensley, Bob Carpenter, John Hull, Al McCluskey and
Mel Lewis.
Starr Farish moved to dispense with the reading of the minutes and
approve them as written. Seconded by Betty Ann Lodge . Motion carried .
John Pilote opened the public hearing for a zoning recommendation of
R-1 Residential for 10 acres requested to be annexed by Bob Feller .
The property is located east of Feller Manor at N. Georgia Avenue
and Marble Front Road. One lady in the audience indicated she did
not oppose the zoning as long as there were just homes on the pro-
perty. Mr. Lewis pointed out that other uses could go into an
R-1 zone, such as a church, but these uses would require a special
use permit. Hearing no further testimony , Pilote closed the public
9-3-1 hearing. It was moved and seconded by John Hull and Ralph Nyblad
to recommend to the City Council that Bob Feller ' s 10 acres be zoned
R-1 Residential upon annexation. Motion carried.
Opened next was the public hearing on a zoning recommendation of M-1
Light Industrial prior to annexation of approximately 11 acres situ-
ated between E. Chicago , Linden and Interstate 80N. Annexation has
been requested by Scott and Judy Myers, Bill and Maxine Gilbert , and
Patricia and Fred Uhl. Noted by the City Engineer was that the area
is in the airport flight zone so the zoning should include the air-
port overlay (AP) . Since there was no testimony, the public hearing
19-3-2 was closed. A motion was made and seconded by Starr Farish and John
Hull to recommend to the City Council that the Gilbert, et. al. ,
property be zoned M-1(AP) Light Industrial upon annexation. Motion
carried.
The public hearing on a variance request by Jack Stites was called
to order. The variance would be for a setback greater than specified
by ordinance to install a mobile home behind a residence at 2921 E.
Chicago. The mobile home would be for Mr. Stites ' son. Sewer and
water are not available so the unit would have to be served by pri-
vate systems. After a discussion, Bob Carpenter moved that the
variance be granted as there appeared to be no opposition. The
motion was seconded by John Hull and, after a vote, carried. Also
requested by Mr. Stites was a variance to obtain a second building
permit within a year for installation of the mobile home. John
'9-3-3 Hull moved that a recommendation be forwarded to the City Council
to approve the variance for the building permit . Motion was seconded
by Bob Carpenter and passed.
Considered next was a recommendation for the vacation of a sewer
easement for the Hazel Park Development at Ellis and Hazel . Mr.
Lewis explained that there is a 16-foot easement across the pro-
perty which was given by Mr. McKimmey years ago. The building
-1-
-2-
as planned would be over the easement , so the sewer will have to be
794 rerouted and the existing easement vacated. A motion was made and
'A seconded by Tom Ensley and Starr Farish to recommend the vacation
of the easement to the City Council. Motion carried.
Presented by John Howe of Alpha Engineers was the final plat of
Southside Industrial Park located between Cleveland and Arthur
near 36th. Mr. Lewis said he had reviewed the final plat and
found everything to be in order, including all of the improve-
ment requirements. The plat would be subject to completion of
the rezoning of a part of the proposed subdivision from C-3 Com-
mercial to M-1 Light Industrial and would also be subject to all
of the provisions attached to the preliminary plat . It was moved
79-3-5 and seconded by John Hull and Ralph Nyblad to accept the final
plat with the conditions stated above and to recommend its approval
to the City Council. Motion carried.
The County has asked for a recommendation by the City Planning and
Zoning Commission on the placement of a mobile home on Lot 5 of
Wood' s Acreage near the City limits on Dorman Avenue. Mrs . Irene
Darbin, who owns Lot 6 and part of Lot 5, wants the mobile home for
her grandson to live in while he helps farm the place. County regu-
lations require a yearly inspection to determine that conditions
still exist under which the original permit was granted. After a
79-3-6 discussion, Bob Carpenter moved that a recommendation be sent to the
County to approve the request for the mobile home subject to their
regulations. The motion was seconded by John Hull . Motion carried.
Another item referred by the County for a recommendation was the
proposed use of the former Home Dairies property by Good Day Distrib-
uting Company. It is their intention to use one of the buildings
for a chemical distributing outlet . Although the property is not
in the impact area, it is near the Franklin interchange and a recom-
mendation is enlisted on that basis. John Pilote mentioned at this
time that since there is some growth interest in that area as well
as in others bordering the City, he would like to discuss later in
the meeting the possibility of expanding the impact area in that
direction. Since no one was present to answer the questions Com-
79-3-7 mission members had concerning the chemical outlet, John Hull moved
and Betty Ann Lodge seconded the motion to postpone action until
the next meeting so a representative could attend. Motion carried.
Judd Lanham was not present to discuss proposed 6-plexes on S.
Indiana.
April 19 at the next regularly scheduled Planning and Zoning Commis-
sion meeting was established as the pubic hearing date to consider
zone changes in accordance with recent Comprehensive Plan changes.
79-3-8 These rezonings are as follows:
1. Lots 1-5, Caldwell Interstate No. 1 from M-1 Light
i Industrial to C-3 Commercial. Moved by John Hull ,
seconded by Tom Ensley. Motion carried.
2 . Area on Plymouth Avenue near the Boise River and north-
westerly of Boise Avenue from R-2T to R-3T for a small
mobile home park, requested by Jesse Knight . Moved by
John Hull, seconded by Bob Carpenter. Motion carried.
-3-
3. Lots 11 and 12, Block 45, Original Townsite, (13th and
Chicago) , from R-3T to C-2T for Bob Wood. Moved by Tom
, te Ensley, seconded by Bob Carpenter. Motion carried.
4 . Lots 13-21, Block 122, Strahorn Addition, from R-3 to
C-3 for Elsie Steel. Moved by John Hull, seconded by
Tom Ensley. Motion carried.
5. Mickelson-Sakimoto property in Block 9 of Arlington
Addition from R-2 to R-3 for a professional office .
6. One half block north of Sunnyside in 3rd Parkside and
proposed Park West from R-1 to R-3 and two blocks between
Woodlawn and Sunnyside in 3rd Parkside and proposed Park
West Addition from R-1 to R-2, requested by Boyd Harris .
Moved by Ralph Nyblad, seconded by Bob Carpenter. Motion
carried.
7 . Part of Southside Industrial Park from C-3 Commercial to
M-1 Light Industrial for Lasher Construction. Moved by
Ralph Nyblad, seconded by John Hull. Motion carried.
Subsequent discussion concerned the two Comprehensive Plan changes
proposed for Sanders Subdivision and the half block on Cleveland
between 12th and 13th which were referred back to the Commission by
the City Council. The City Council ' s action on the Cleveland issue
is as follows:
Past action taken by this body on November 29 , 1977 on Area
No. 7 is declared null and void. The recommendations of the
P and Z Commission on the proposed change are to be denied and
eqs this item will be returned to the Commission for reconsidera-
tion with a recommendation that the land use be changed to
High Density Residential and Professional Offices with the
intent to eventually be zoned R-3 . A moratorium is declared
on development within Area No. 7 for building permits until
the zoning has been made to conform with the Comprehensive Plan.
for High Density Residential and Prof. Offices
Sander' s request/was also denied in a separate motion and returned
for reconsideration.
John Pilote explained that, according to the Local Planning Act of
1975, the Planning and Zoning Commission is restricted to making a
recommendation to the City Council on Plan changes once every six
months . Officially) the Commission' s recommendation was made on
November 22 , in which case a recommendation could legally be made
to the City Council on May 22. It was his thought that there are
several areas that need to be looked at and possibly included in
the next Plan change proceedings, particularly with respect to the
impact area. If the two areas in question were brought to public
hearing and a recommendation made on May 22, the other areas would be
put off for another six months . He further stated he was looking for
guidance on how best to handle the situation, whether by committee
appointed to study the issues or otherwise. Considerable discussion
followed among Commission members, with the majority indicating they
would prefer to resolve the matter in the near future. Al McCluskey
informed the Commission it was his opinion that action on all of the
proposed Plan changes wasn't completed since the two areas were not
officially denied, but were denied and returned to the Commission.
He feels that the Plan changes will not be closed until the two are
taken care of; presentstatus is a continuation of the same action.
-4-
Pilote commented he considered the action completed and to reconsider
the changes would require starting the process over again. The question
,A to be decided was whether the Commission should aim for a recommenda-
tion by May 22 or to wait and consider other possible Plan changes at
the same time . After further discussion, Alta Williams was recognized
and stated one of the main reasons the Council sent this back to the
Commission was so the people could speak. They were not aware that
there had been public hearings and wanted to have a chance to talk.
It appeared to be the concensus of the Commission that the course
of action should be to set a ktblic hearing and prepare a recommenda-
tion to the Council on or 'vMay 22 , but to first receive some
clarification from the Council on whether it would be a continuation
of the hearings or a new action.
Dave Sanders was acknowledged by the Chair and requested a public hear-
ing for Sanders Subdivision to be changed to High Density Residential
and Professional Offices on the Plan. Mel Lewis said he had talked
with 0. T. Sanders on the telephone and Mr. Sanders had indicated he
would request that land use designation for Lots 1-4 of Block 1 (the
land occupied by present buildings that are now being used) and Lots 1-5
of Block 2 which includes the parking lot and the large building ad-
jacent to the house . After some discussion, Dave Sanders agreed to
consult with his father on what specific areas were to be considered
and to resubmit his request at the next meeting. He also asked that
a public hearing be scheduled at a time when other areas were not
involved so their proposal could be presented to the neighborhood
property owners for an open discussion. This suggestion was met with
some favor and Commission members agreed it might be advantageous to
hold one at one time and the other an hour or so later on the same night .
Next Chairman Pilote announced that a request to vacate the alley in
Block 6 of the Original Townsite had come in after the closing date
and he had ruled that it should not be considered. He did say, however,
that it is the prerogative of the Commission to place the item on the
agenda if they so desire. Al McCluskey informed the Commission that
the Council had discussed it at a noon meeting and there is some
urgency in starting the vacation procedures now. After a discussion,
79-3-9 it was moved and seconded by John Hull and Starr Farish to place the
item on the agenda. Motion carried.
Mr. Lewis explained that Block 6 is the former Burns Chevrolet -
B & M Equipment block which has been purchased for a project for
which the purchasers want surface rights . He further stated that
he has already discussed with them that the alley could be vacated
subject to the fact that it cannot be built upon while the utilities
are there . There is a sewer down the center with a manhole for
which the City will reserve the right , a 3-inch gas line and a
telephone burial. Arrangements will have to be made to reroute
the utilities if they want to occupy the space with buildings .
79-3-10 After a discussion, it was moved and seconded by John Hull and Starr
Farish to recommend the vacation of the alley in Block 6 , O.T. , to the
City Council subject to utility rights-of-way. Motion carried.
1 The final plat of Carol Subdivision was presented for approval . Mr.
Lewis reported that he and Ron Blakley had discussed in detail all
of the improvements and the plans should be ready by the time the
Council considers the plat. Acceptance would be subject to the
-5-
conditions under which the preliminary plat was approved. A motion
79 -11 to recommend approval of the final plat of Carol Subdivision subject
to the stipulations of the preliminary plat was made and seconded by
Starr Farish and Tom Ensley. Motion passed. The recommendation will
be forwarded to the City Council.
At this time John Pilote acknowledged receipt of a letter from resi-
dents on Cleveland and said he would schedule it for discussion at
the next meeting.
Mel Lewis then reported on the Transportation Study in which the City
is engaged, involving Caldwell, Nampa and the State Highway Depart-
ment. The study is being done in order to qualify for Urban-D funds
which can be used for highway projects within the cities, as well
as for projects such as Highway 19, Highway 30 and the Northwest
Connector. One of the elements of the study is to determine its
goals and the objectives to meet these goals. Help in formulating
the goals and objectives is being requested from the community
through the Chamber of Commerce, Planning and Zoning Commission,
City Council and any other committees relating to transportation.
A tentative set of goals and objectives has been drawn up by Nampa
and Caldwell and, once these are finalized, will be consolidated
into one document for the study as a whole. Copies of the goals
and objectives were distributed to Commission members to read.
A committee will be appointed to work with the draft and report
back to the Commission.
The Chairman stated he would like to call a work session for Thurs-
day, March 29, to consider the Transportation Study goals and ob-
jectives and also to look at the impact area.
Meeting adjourned at 9 : 50 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Sylvia Robison
Secretary pro tem