HomeMy WebLinkAbout1979-04-19 P & Z MINUTES PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION MINUTES
April 19 , 1979
eiN The meeting was called to order at 7 : 30 p .m. in the Council Chambers
by Chairman John Pilote . Present were Betty Ann lodge , Starr Parish ,
John Hull , Jim Oates , Tom Ensley , Bud Grant , Bob Nicholes , Don Tolley ,
Al McCluskey , Pete Olesen and i'-lel Lewis . Also at`ending were Mayor
Pasley and Councilwoman Alta Williams.
John Pilote opened the public hearing portion of the meeting.
First on the agenda was a request from Orc ron-idatic' Lands , Inc . ,
to rezone Lots 1-5 of Caldwell Interstate No. 1 fr ' M-1 Light
Industrial to C-3 Commercial. Ross Butler of Ontario , a repre-
sentative from Oregon-Idaho Lands , Inc . , was recdrzed and stated
the original intention for the subdivision when plotted was for
commercial uses. Prior to the date of acceptance of the final plat
of Caldwell Interstate No. 1 , which was May 3 , 1977 , the property
had been zoned to C-D Commercial from F General Use upon request
of the owners . When the zoning ordinance and Comprehensive Plan
were passed in 1977 , the property somehow got changed to light
industrial and the owners would like to have it changed back to
commercial. Since there was no testimony in opposition to this
79-4-1 request , the hearing was closed and a motion made and seconded by
John Hull and Starr Parish to recommend the rezoning to the City
Council. Motion carried .
Opened next was the public hearing on a request by Jesse Knight to
^ rezone an area north of Boise Avenue between the Boise River and
" l Plymouth Street from R-2 to R-3T for a small mobile home park.
Ben Adams of 1514 Boise Avenue said he was concerned about a mobile
Home park going in there , since there is no sewer and residents in
that area have septic tanks and private wells. Betty Adams of the
same address commented that 2 trailers have been moved in, one on
Plymouth and the other on neighboring property within the last 6
months which do not meet the State code . In discussing the availa-
bility of sewer, Mel Lewis explained that it is about 3 blocks away
but the grade is adverse and the sewer could not be reached by gravity .
A pump station and 3 blocks of pressure line would be required to get
19-4-2 to the sewer that now exists . Starr Parish moved that a recommenda-
tion be forwarded to the City Council to rezone the property involved
from R-2 to R-3T with the understanding that the mobile homes comply
with City ordinances . Bud Grant seconded the motion. It was pointed
out that his system would have to meet the standards of the Southwest
Health District but he could not be required to connect to City sewer
under the circumstances . Starr Parish amended the motion to just
recommend the zoning change and the second concurred. 'lotion carried.
A public hearing was ren held on a request by Bob Wood to rezone
Lots 11 and 12 , Block 45 of the Original Townsite from R-3T to C-3T.
The property is at the northwesterly corner of 13th and Chicago.
Chicago is designated as an arterial in the Plan which was recently
changed for a half block depth on either side of Chicago to provide
for commercial zoning as property owners desire the change . Warren
Harlow of 1212 Denver submitted a petition signed by four residents
or property owners in Block 45 requesting that the area remain resi-
dential . Hearing no further testimony , Pilote closed the hearing.
-1-
-2-
71-4-3 Bob .Jicholes moved to recommend to the City Council that the zone
eRN be changed from R-3T to C-3T. The motion was seconded by Bud Grant .
The vote was 2 in favor, 4 opposed , and 1 abstained. Motion failed.
Don Tolley arrived and was counted present .
The next public hearing was for a zone change for Lots 13-21 , Block
122 of Strahorn Addition from R-3 to C-3 for Elsie Steel. Elsie Park-
hurst of 302 Everett inquired if the zone change includes her property .
She was informed it does not. The public hearing was closed and a
71-4-4 motion made and seconded by Tom Ensley and John Hull to recommend
the above rezoning to the City Council. Motion passed.
The rezoning from R-2 to R-3 of the property in Block 9 of Arlington
Addition fronting on S. Kimball near Paynter was considered next .
This is the property owned by Dr. Hal Mickelson and Dr. Herman
Sakimoto on which a professional office will be built . Mr. Lee
Hayes of 1306 Arlington, owner of property in back of the proposed
79-4.5 clinic , stated he and Mrs . Hayes are in favor of the office . It was
then moved and seconded by John Hull and Jim Oates to recommend ap-
proval of the rezoning to the City Council . Motion carried.
At this time Mayor Pasley presented a plaque to Don Tolley on behalf
of the Council , the Commission and the citizens of Caldwell in appre-
ciation of his service as Chairman of the Planning and Zoning Commis-
sion
^
r The public hearing was then held for rezoning of Block 10 of 3rd
Parkside and Blocks 1 and 13 of proposed Park West Addition from
R-1 to R-3; and Blocks 8 and 9 , 3rd Parkside , and Blocks 2 , 3 , 3 ,
9 , 14 , 15, 20 and 21 of proposed Park West Addition from R-1 to
R-2 . Since there was no testimony in opposition to the request ,
79-4-6 the public hearing was closed and a motion made and seconded by
Don Tolley and Bud Grant to recommend the rezoning to the City Coun-
cil . Motion carried.
Hearing was opened for consideration of rezoning a part of South-
side Industrial Park subdivision from C-3 Commercial to M-1 Light
Industrial for Lasher Construction. As there were no comments from
79-4-7 the audience, the public hearing was closed. It was moved and seconded
by Starr garish and Don Tolley to recommend rezoning of the area
in question to M-1 and forward this to the City Council . Motion
carried. This concluded the public hearing portion of the meeting.
The next item was a letter or request for a zone change regarding
the half block of Cleveland between 12th and 13th on which the Harri-
son Frank Agency is located. Mel Lewis read the letter, which was
a request from residents and homeowners in. the area immediately
adjacent to the subject half block for the Planning and Zoning Com-
mission to initiate an action to zone the half block as R-2 to bring
it into conformity with the Comprehensive Plan wili.eh designates the
area as medium density residential . The letter is attached as a part
of these minutes . John Pilote pointed out that by law zone changes
can be initiated by owners of the property involved, by the Planning
and Zoning Commission and by the City Council , or governing board.
-3-
Betty Ann Lodge inquired as to the present zoning, and Pilote re-
sponded that he considered it to be C-2. There is at present , however ,
a moratorium on building permits in the area declared by the City
eqN Council until such time as the zoning has been made to conform
with the Comprehensive Plan. Don Tolley asked whether any of the
signers of the letter were property owners in the half block and ,
if not, said he would hesitate to initiate action on somebody
79-4•-8 else ' s property without their request. He then moved that the
request for a zone change to be initiated on the part of the Com-
mission be denied. The motion was seconded by Bud Grant . Mrs .
Lodge inquired again on the present zoning since the Council in
action taken on March b , 1979 , declared null and void the action
of November 29 , 1977, zoning the half block C-2. An opinion was
requested from Mel Lewis , who stated that the last action of the
City Council by ordinance zoned it as C-2 . Al McCluskey then
explained that the Council had also forwarded a recommendation
on March 6 to the Commission for an R-3 zoning. They had denied
the Plan change recommended by the Commission for General Commer-
cial and referred it for reconsideration with a recommendation
from them for High Density Residential and Professional Offices
to be zoned R-3 in the future. After further discussion, John
Pilate called for a vote on the motion to deny the request for
the Commission to initiate an R-2 zoning. Voting was 5-2 in favor
79-4-9 of the motion. Motion carried. Starr Farish then moved that the
Commission accept the March 6 , 1979 , minutes of the City Council
which recommend that the area be rezoned to R-3 and , if necessary ,
to first change the Comprehensive Plan to High Density Residential
to accommodate that zoning. The motion was seconded by Jim Oates .
Considerable discussion followed and then a 5-3 vote was recorded
79- 1-10 in favor of the motion. It was then moved and seconded by Tom
Ensley and Starr Farish to establish a public hearing date of May
17 to consider a Comprehensive Plan change from Medium to High
Density Residential and Professional Offices . Motion carried.
Mel Lewis stated that the law will be followed in publishing a
notice in the local newspaper and a public service announcement
will be enlisted. The law does not require that any property owners
be notified of a Comprehensive Plan change .
Next on the agenda was a request from the First Assembly of God
Church located near the freeway at 16th Avenue for a variance to
install a lighted sign anproximately 13 feet by 30 feet . The sign
was described by a representative of the Church, who indicated they
would place the sign according to City codes. The church was
granted a special use permit for its location in 1977 but a sign
79-4-11 was not considered at that time. It was moved and seconded by
Bob Nicholes and John Hull to set a public hearing for May 17 to
consider the sign variance . Motion carried .
On the agenda for reconsideration was a recommendation to the County
on the proposed use of the Horne Dairies property for chemical storage
and. packaging by Good Day Distributing Company . Mr. Nyle Mallory ,
owner and operator of Good Day Distributing, was present and said
he had submitted an application for commercial-industrial use of
/') the property since it has been used in that capacity for dairy
processing for many years . It is his feeling that his business ,
which includes some retailing of peat moss , potting soil and laundry
detergent, would fit in with the former land use . Although the
property is not located in the City ' s impact area , it is near the
Franklin interchange which the Commission agreed should be reserved
790004V12 for highway related commercial uses. After a discussion , a motion
1 was made by Don Tolley to forward a recommendation to the County
that the area around the Franklin interchange he designated as
freeway-related commercial and that the use of the property as
outlined by Mr. Mallory is compatible with the future plans for
the area. Motion was seconded by Bud Grant and , cu er a vote , passed .
Two applications for a Comprehensive Plan change in 0. T. Sanders
Subdivision were read by Mr. Lewis. Application "1!" concerned a
Plan change from Low Density Residential to High Density Residential
and Professional Offices for Lots1-4 , Block 1 and Lots 1-5 , Block 2 .
Application "B" requested a Plan change from Low Density Residential
to Medium Density Residential for Lots 5-10 , Block 1 , and Lot 6 ,
Block 2 . Dick Sanders was recognized and explained that the even-
tual rezoning to R-3 and R-2 for the above areas was desired in
order to accomplish even a minimum expansion of the Health and
Welfare building and to make the present and intended uses conform-
79-4-13 ing. Following a discussion, John Hull moved and Tom Ensley seconded
the motion to set a public hearing on May 17 for the Comprehensive
Plan changes requested. The item will be placed first on the agenda
to keep it separate from the Cleveland issue . The same advertising
procedures will apply for Plan change notification.
A special permit application filed by Judd Lanham was reviewed . It
is his intention to place two 6-plexes or one 12-plex on the
property and sell as townhouses to individual owners . Under con-
" l sideration is acceptance of a 40-foot right-of-way for Alder Street
on the south side of the site which Mr. Lanham will dedicate . Mr.
Lanham said he would need to obtain a variance for the units to
extend 3 feet into the setback area. Every other unit would be
offset to extend three feet to the front and the others would
extend 3 feet into the rear setback. Mel Lewis pointed out that
although there is not enough area for a planned unit development ,
the townhouses could be built by platting. The zoning is R-2 and
the density will have to be determined. Another consideration is
the end of Alder which would dead-end rather than end in a cul-de-sac ,
so it would have to be approved under that condition. Mr. Lanham
was also informed that 2 parking spaces would have to be provided
for the units containing over 1100 square feet . As there were
79-4•-14 several unresolved details , Betty Ann Lodge moved that the Project
be deferred until the May 17 meeting. Motion was seconded by Starr
Farish and passed.
Application has been filed by Chuck Earn and Gene Baxter for a
special use permit to construct a professional office on Lots 9-12 ,
Block 101 of Goandu Addition at 10th and Everett . Two older homes
one- will be removed and a new*building constructed. Parking requirements
story are met . A sign will be installed 10 feet back from the property
line and will not be lighted or larger than 32 square feet . After
studying the plan , Bud Grant and Starr Parish moved and seconded
to establish a public hearing on May 17. Motion carried .
A 180-unit retirement center is being
proposed by Lasker Construc-
tion for 10 acres on S. Florida between Cherry and Beech. The
center will include such services as beauty shop , gift shop ,
-5-
and laundry provisions . Mr. Lewis discussed at length drainage and
right-of-way problems and said he would contact those residents
adjacent involved in developing their property who do require right-
of-way as to how they would be affected by the development . He would
recommend that a hearing be set for the special use permit . Jim
9-4-15 Oates moved that a public hearing be set for May 17 . Motion was
seconded by John Hull . Motion carried.
White-Riedel is requesting a special use permit for a professional
office to be constructed on Lots 8 , 9 and 10 , Block 13 of Arling-
ton Addition . Tim Staggs presented a rendering of the two-story
building and a plot plan showing its location on the back corner
of the lot . There was some discussion on the parking as 9 spaces
were situated in the front setback area. Mr. Staggs indicated he
would prefer to request a variance on. the parking as a maximum
number of spaces were desired. Mr. Lewis said an investigation
would have to be made as to sight distance across in making the
curve and whether or not cars parked in front would obstruct the
view of traffic on S . Kimball. The parking could be changed if
the Commission required it, or it could be approved with a variance
-9-4-16 subject to traffic obstruction. Tom Ensley moved to establish a
hearing on May 17 to consider the special use permit subject to the
stipulations stated by Mel Lewis . Motion was seconded by Bud Grant .
Motion carried.
The Planning and Zoning Commission voted to renew a special use
permit for a duplex to be constructed on Lot 6, Block 4 of Monte
'9. 17 Vista Addition by Bob Gushwa. The permit was issued March 16 , 1978 ,
and expired a year from that date. John Hull and Starr Farish moved
and seconded the motion to renew the special use permit . Motion passed .
Orville Collins appeared before the Commission to request a special
use permit on behalf of Nesbitt and Associates to remodel the inter-
ior of the residence at 802 Everett for a professional real estate
office. A review of the plot plan previously had indicated that
two of the proposed four required parking spaces were in setback
areas and a variance would be needed if parking requirements could
not be met. There is no alley access , but a garage in the rear
would be removed. The variance would be for either fewer spaces
than required or parking in the setback area. After a discussion ,
'9-•4-18 Jim Oates moved that a public hearing for consideration of the
special use permit be set for May 17 . John Hull seconded the motion .
Motion carried.
Gary Walker was not present to discuss a pre-school at the Grace
Lutheran Church.
Jerry Ogstad had informed John Pilote that if he needed the variance
requested for parking in the downtown area, he would appear. Since
he did not attend the meeting, it was assumed the variance requested
was not necessary .
00440 The Idaho Migrant Council is hoping to purchase the Boulevard Chris-
tian. School property at Ustick Road behind Blacker ' s for a vocational
training school . Their plan is to construct additional classroom
space and a greenhouse. Since a school is not a permitted use
-t�-
in an industrial zone and since they wish to expand a non-conform-
ing use , a rezoning to C-3 Commercial has been requested . Kate
O'Neill , spokesperson for the Council, stated that the school is
presently being used as a school for approximately 75 students
grades 5 and 6. She presented a plan showing the proposed addi-
tional building for classes and the greenhouse , which would
eventually become a cooperatively owned nursery. According to
O 'Neill , approximately 90 feet of the property 1.;; now included
in the commercial zone which extends 60n feet easterly along
Cleveland and she wondered if the new building could be built
in that space. Mel Lewis pointed out that there is a transporta-
tion corridor extending all the way from Nampa through Caldwell
that would be about 80 ' of the 90 ' along the south side of the
property. Right-of-way for the majority of the corridor has been
acquired but not through the area between Cleveland and the rail-
road track that involves this property . The City would like to
preserve this corridor from any structures being built on it .
Also discussed was the fact that a Plan change would be required
before the zone could be changed to C-3. The Commission agreed
79-4--19 in a motion made and seconded by Tom Ensley and Jim Oates to
establish a public hearing to recommend a Plan change if O 'Neill
could obtain and submit to the Engineer' s office a request from
the present record owners of the property within the next five
working days. Motion carried. The hearing will be May 17 if the
written request is received in time for publication.
/'N Mel Lewis reported on the Transportation Study Goals and Objec-
tives. lie said the committee had met and basically emphasized
truck routing and coordination of the goals and objectives with
the Comprehensive Plan. lie distributed copies of the draft
which Steve Loop of. the Highway Department had prepared by com-
bining proposed goals and objectives from both Nampa and Caldwell
and enlisted any comments the members might have for the next
Commission meeting.
Meeting adjourned at 10: 50 p.m.
Respectfully submitted ,
Sylvia Robison
Secretary pro tem
March 27, 1979 .Cr/r1
Planning and Zoning Commission
cio Mr. Melvin G. Lewis
Engineering and Planning Director
City of Caldwell
704 Blaine Street
Caldwell, Idaho 83605
SUBJECT: CLARIFICATION OF REQUEST THAT THE COMMISSION INITIATE AN
R-2 ZONING ACTION FOR THE HALF BLOCK SOUTHWEST OF CLEVELAND BLVD.
BETWEEN 12TH AND 13TH STREETS
The view has been expressed that our letter. of March 14 regarding this
half' block was not sufficiently precise as to the action requested. We
therefore submit this clarification.
ACTION REQUESTED:
We the undersigned, residents and homeowners in the area immediately
adjacent to the subject half block, request that the Planning and Zoning
Commission initiate an action to zone the half block southwest of
Cleveland Blvd. between 12th and 13th Streets as R-2, thereby bringing
it into conformity with the existing Comprehensive Plan 2000 which
designates the entire area around and including the subject half block
as medium density residential.
DISCUSSION
The reasons cited in our letter of March 14, 1979, can be concisely
summarized as follows:
1 . Some zoning action is essential to eliminate confusion as to this
half block's status and to end the concomitant potential for liti-
gation.
2. An R-2 action would end the need for a building permit moratorium.
3. An R-2 action would not require a Plan change; there is no need to
wait for the six-month period to elapse.
4. Subject half block is already surrounded by an R-2 zone on three
sides.
5. R-2 will protect the existing residential character of the neighborhood.
Planning and Zoning Commission 2 March 27, 1979
'#."411 6. No party would suffer real harm from R-2 since existing, valuable
uses can continue indefinitely.
7. There is no reason to change the Plan; nothing has changed since
the extensive debate of 1977.
8. R-2 contributes to achievement of stated purposes of the zoning ordinance.
9. Necessary improvements for R-2 uses are already in place.
10. R-2 is preferred by a substantial majority of those living in the
neighborhood (residential area 5 in the Plan) .
11 . Anything other than R-2 would encourage petitions for other changes.
To reasons previously stated we add:
12. Anything other. 'than R-2, say C-2, would contribute to the scattering
of retail businesses along a major artery, the avoidance of which
is one of the express policies of the Comprehensive Plan.
13. Zoning other than R-2 would facilitate undesirable strip commercial
development and other aberrant land uses, and in the process draw
away from the central commercial area of Caldwell.
We therefore strongly urge your Commission to leave the Comprehensive
'61 Plan unchanged and to initiate an R-2 zoning action for the indicated
half block.
r‘ `
lei r-C ' ,'- ; i ;
f/
-STEVEN E. POLHE}'[US , SID BUCK
(Mrs.) DEBRA L. POLHEMUS (Mrs.) MOEENA BUCK
1203 Dearborn Street 1214 Dearborn Street
Caldwell, Idaho 83605 Caldwell, Idaho 83605
J WM. H. TROSTLE J. M. PEDERSEN
•
!7', L._ .l jl. ;
(Mrs.) NAOMA E. TROSTLE (Mrs.) GEN PEDERSEN
1205 Cleveland Boulevard 1308 Cleveland Boulevard
Caldwell, Idaho 83605 Caldwell, Idaho 83605