HomeMy WebLinkAbout1978-11-16 P & Z MINUTES PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION MINUTES
November 16 , 1978
The meeting was called to order at 7 : 30 p.m. in the Council Chambers
by Vice-Chairman John Pilote. Present were Ralph Nyblad, Starr Far-
ish , Pete Olesen, John Hull, Jim Oates , Mel Lewis and Wayne Nielsen.
Don Tolley arrived later.
Discussed first was the right-of-way problem on property now owned
by Mr. Norman Rutzen which is located east of Georgia Avenue and
south of Lincoln Street. Planning Commission members looked at the
area in 1974 and determined that a full right-of-way of 50 feet at
that time would narrow the building sites on the rim to a point that
they would require special designs for houses. It was their recom-
mendation at that time that the Council accept a narrower right-of-
way than specified by ordinance ( 38 feet ) which would allow construc-
tion of a standard roadway with not much right-of-way behind the curb .
Since that time the roadway width standard has been increased to 56
feet so the narrow r/w on the hardship basis would be 40 feet . Mr.
Lewis said he has discussed this with Mr. Rutzen with the stipula-
tion that a full 90-foot cul-de-sac be provided. Subsequent inves-
tigation led to the fact that there was a right-of-way deed signed
by Mr. Hire, former owner of the property, as a part of another deed
in which he dedicated some of that land 30 feet wide to the public .
Part of it is on the ownerships which were later deeded to Mr. Bistline
and Mr. Hicks , who strenuously object to the City' s accepting the
narrower right-of-way for development of Mr. Rutzen' s lots . The
City Attorney issued a memorandum opinion on Sept . 14 stating the
City could rely upon the right-of-way given to the public in the war-
e), ranty deed by Mr. Hire and is in a position to accept additional
property from Mr. Rutzen. It was the City Engineer' s opinion that
the situation should be reviewed by the Planning and Zoning Commission
and the City Council to reaffirm their position. John Pilote appointed
Jim Oates , Bob Carpenter and John Hull to a committee to meet with Mr.
Lewis , view the site and submit a recommendation at the January meeting.
Vice-Chairman Pilote then opened the public hearing portion of the
meeting. Scheduled first was a public hearing on a proposed ordinance
change to limit the heighth of outbuildings in the R-1 Residential
8-11-1 Zone to 15 feet except by special permit. Hearing no testimony,
Don Tolley moved that the ordinance change be recommended to the City
Council . Motion was seconded by Ralph Nyblad and, after a vote,
carried.
Opened next was a public hearing for a special use permit to locate
a mobile home park at 21st and Chicago in the M-1 Industrial Zone.
Responding to the call for testimony were Jeff Supinger, representing
Idaho Meat Packers; Dick Weeks , representing Treasure Valley and
Boise Valley Livestock Companies ; Ralph Brucey, Motorola; Mike
Van Lith, Treasure Valley Livestock. These parties opposed the
granting of the special use permit as the entire area is surrounded
by feed lots and they felt the location is inappropriate for resi-
dential development . Besides cattle-related activities which could
prove hazardous to residents and children in a M.H. Park, concern was
also expressed that the industry existing in the area could be
jeopardized should it be termed a nuisance by inhabitants of the park.
After considerable discussion, John Hull and Don Tolley moved and
-2-
)-11-2 seconded that the special use permit be denied. Motion carried .
Ralph Nyblad abstained.
Public hearing was then opened for a special use permit to replat
Lots 33 and 34 of Torrens and Tucker Addition for sale of a 4-unit
dwelling as individual units with common areas and interests . The
permit is to allow building of the 4-plex and to separate ownerships
subject to platting to define the property lines and subject to
administration of the common area and interests by association docu-
ments to be filed with the final plat . This also allows the units
to be located with not all of them fronting on the right-of-way .
Tolley stated that since the building of the dwelling has been
thoroughly discussed and the zoning changed to accommodate it , he
i-11-3 would move that the special use permit be granted. Motion was
seconded by John Hull and carried.
Pilote opened the public hearing regarding the inclusion in the
"T" overlay zone of part of the old airport property north of
Laurel Street and west of Kit Avenue. The area has been presented
as a preliminary plat for a mobile home subdivision. A strip of
approximately 300 feet on each side of the proposed subdivision
will remain as industrial . Since there were no objections to the
-11-4 rezoning, Starr Farish moved that the parcel platted preliminarily
as Laurel Mobile Estates Subdivision be recommended to the Council
for addition to the "T" overlay zone of the City . Motion was seconded
by Don Tolley and passed with a vote of 5 to 1.
Considered next was a special use permit for a mini-warehouse complex
to be located northeasterly of Taco Time on Blaine Street near
/ Georgia Avenue . The zoning is C-2 Commercial . As there was no
testimony for or against the request, the public hearing was closed .
-11-5 It was moved and seconded by Don Tolley and Ralph Nyblad that the
special use permit be granted. Motion carried.
Public hearing was held on a variance request filed by Mrs . Isabelle
Bloomfield to divide off the east 60 feet of Lots 13-16, Block 130
of Strahorn Addition ( 722 S. 5th) for the purpose of sale for con-
struction of a single family or two-family residence. The variance
is for the remaining 6, 000 sq. ft. corner lot on which Mrs . Bloom-
field ' s house is located which is less than the 7 , 500 sq. ft . required
by ordinance for a corner lot . Dean Abrahams and Mrs . Bloomfield' s
daughter spoke in favor of granting the variance . Hearing no adverse
comments , Pilote closed the public hearing. Don Tolley and John Hull
-11-6 then moved and seconded that the variance be granted. Motion carried.
Next on the agenda was a public hearing for a special use permit
requested by Darwin Feller to store chemicals in a building at 14th
and Denver in the M-1 Industrial Zone and also for a variance to
construct an office building next to the existing building to the
property line . Mattie Edwards , who lives across the street on Elgin,
inquired as to the type of chemicals that would be stored. Mr. Cam
Gepner indicated the chemicals would be packaged but that alcohol
would be stored in drums which could be flammable . Mrs . Edwards
and Leo Holmes stated they would object to that . Since no infor-
11-7 oration had been obtained from the Fire Chief, Don Tolley moved to
table action on the request pending the Chief' s opinion. Motion
-3-
-11-8 was seconded by John Hull and passed. Starr Farish abstained and
asked that the minutes show he would vote for granting the request
subject to the approval of the Fire Chief.
prqN The final public hearing scheduled was consideration of the Airport
Hazard Zoning Ordinance for the Caldwell Industrial Airport . Mel
Lewis explained this document was prepared by Arlo Nelson during
the planning stages of the airport. The ordinance delineates zones
around the airport based on FAA regulations (maps accompany the
ordinance) and defines height limitations, clear zones , noise
impact and sound control zones . There was no testimony from the
-11-9 audience on this issue . Don Tolley moved that a recommendation be
sent to the City Council to adopt the Airport Hazard Zoning Ordi-
nance . Motion was seconded by Starr Farish and, after a vote ,
carried.
The preliminary plat of McGarvin Condominiums was then presented
by Mel Lewis . The plat will define four building sites with
their anticipation of four separate ownerships and an association
through recorded legal documents to administer the common area and
other common interests. Lot sizes and dimensions of less than re-
quired by the subdivision ordinance will be approved by a variance
as provided for in the ordinance. Improvement requirements are
as follows : Concrete curb , gutter and sidewalk; pavement under
the border street policy; water main extension policy; statement
from Caldwell Irrigation District approving irrigation system;
underground power and telephone ; drainage of culdesac to existing
drainage ditch on south side of Marble Front Road ; and sewer which
is now available. The Engineering Department has designed the
egN street except for the drainage pipeline from the culdesac and will
provide field work and inspection for the street improvement . The
plat shall dedicate all of the right-of-way of the culdesac . Mr.
Lewis said he would recommend acceptance of the preliminary plat
i-11-10 under those stipulations. Jim Oates moved and John Hull seconded
the motion to recommend the approval of McGarvin Condominiums
preliminary plat to the City Council subject to the conditions
outlined by the City Engineer. Motion carried.
Introduced next was the preliminary plat of Allen Estates located
on Canyon Hill approximately between Nixon and Lincoln Streets and
Teton and Georgia Avenues . The preliminary plat meets the dimen-
sional requirements for the distances shown. Provisions of the
Engineer ' s Report are as follows: Concrete curb , gutter and side-
walk on Skyline Place to be provided and paving to City standards;
change existing curb and gutter on south side of Nixon to provide
Skyline Place connection; provide drainage pipeline system for the
culdesac at the end of Skyline Place; provide for any irrigation
wastewater which now wastes into the platted area to meet the
satisfaction of owners involved; sewer is available and lateral
extensions are required to serve the platted lots ; water main
extension policy shall apply ; approval of Caldwell Irrigation
District required; telephone and electric power facilities shall
be underground where possible . Responsibilities of the developer ' s
engineer were also outlined. Mr. Lewis informed the Commission that
he had contacted Si Williams , Bertha Perry and Mr . Davidson, adja-
cent property owners , to make them aware of the proposed plat .
There was considerable discussion on how the plat would affect the
• -4-
adjacent properties , particularly that of Mrs . Perry . It was the
Engineer ' s concern that she would have no access to develop the
back of her property which is partly on the slope. One alternative
would be for the platters to extend the culdesac of Skyline Place
over far enough to serve her lots , but this would cost them at least
one lot . Another alternative would be to use the narrow right-of-way
which would be N. Georgia extended north of Lincoln and to make it
of record through recommendation to the City Council that they accept
the narrow 40-foot right-of-way for the property for future develop-
-11-10 ment when needed. After further discussion, it was moved and seconded
by John Hull and Ralph Nyblad to recommend approval of the preliminay
plat of Allen Estates to the City Council subject to the Engineer ' s
report and to also recommend that the City Council accept a 40-foot
right-of-way from Mrs . Perry at such time as she desires to deed it.
Motion carried.
Roger Cantlon appeared before the Commission to request a special
use permit to construct a mini-warehouse complex on the northeast
corner of the intersection of Linden and Cleveland. The zoning is
C-2 Commercial . The plan, according to Mr. Cantlon, is to save
the frontage for commercial and build the warehouses on the back
of the property. He also indicated that should this property be
approved, it may be substituted for the proposed mini-warehouse
complex behind Taco Time. Mel Lewis pointed out that one considera-
tion would be if the property is in the corridor that has been
tentatively defined from Linden south and east along Arthur as a
1 planning concept. This could affect future development of the
property. After some discussion, it was agreed to set a public
hearing for December 21, 1978, for consideration of the request.
Prior to that time Mr. Cantlon is to furnish the Engineering De-
partment with a plan showing building arrangement.
Discussion on proposal to require design of a professional office
building with a request for a special use permit was postponed.
Meeting adjourned at 9 : 45 p.m.
Respectfully submitted ,
Sylvia Robison
Secretary pro tem
ems
CONTINUATION OF PUBLIC HEARING
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN CHANGES
/A Continuation of the public hearing to consider Comprehensive Plan
1 changes was opened at 7 : 40 p.m. in the Council Chambers by Vice-
Chairman John Pilote . Present were Starr Farish, Ralph Nyblad,
John Hull , Bud Grant , Bob Carpenter, Jim Oates and Mel Lewis .
Advertised for consideration at this hearing was a request by 0.
T. Sanders to designate all of Sanders ' Subdivision as High Density
Residential. Jerry Weston, attorney representing Mr. Sanders, was
recognized and presented a historical account of the use of the
property . In summation, he asked that the property be zoned con-
sistently with the way it has been used for years. As there wasn 't
a quorum present , action was deferred on this request .
Mr. Roark, who owns property on the corner of Kimball and Paynter
in the R-1 Zone , appeared before the Commission to request a Plan
change to High Density Residential for his parcel of land that
extends almost to Airport Avenue . The slopes and terrain would
require innovative planning to use the land to the best advantage ,
and Mr. Roark ' s intention was to find out what options would be
possible . Adequate access to the property will have to be inves-
tigated. After some discussion, the Commission informed Mr. Roark
that they would be unable to consider his request at the present
time as further advertisement would be necessary to continue the
public hearing and they were hoping to forward a recommendation
to the City Council in the near future . It was pointed out he
could appear before the Council to see if they would want to con-
sider his request with the other Comprehensive Plan changes .
If not , it would be placed on the next available time for Plan
changes in 6 months. John Pilote then closed the public hearing
on the Comprehensive Plan.
Since there were now enough members present to comprise a quorum,
discussion was resumed on Sanders ' Subdivision. Following comments
regarding the traffic situation on S . Kimball and what future
development plans Mr. Sanders had for his property, Bob Carpenter
moved that Sanders ' Subdivision be changed from Low Density Resi-
dential to High Density Residential and sent to the Council with
the other Plan change recommendations. The motion was seconded
by John Hull and passed with a 3-2 vote and one abstention.
Starr Farish requested that his proposal for submission of designs
when application is made for a special use permit be considered at
this time . He explained that when the Commission approves a special
use permit not just for professional offices but all-inclusive for
other structures , the applicant should furnish a copy of the general
plan to the City Engineer' s office so that the Building Department
can refer to the design when issuing a building permit and check to see
that the plan has not been changed. It was agreed that a paragraph
would be added to the Special Use Permit application requiring a
site plan and design be turned in to the City Engineer ' s office
no later than 5: 00 p.m. the Monday preceding the regularly scheduled
meeting. Anything submitted after that time will not be considered
until the next regularly scheduled meeting. The application,
-2-
narrative statement and plan must all be filed with the City Engineer
by the above date and shall be retained by the City Engineer. The
above additions to the application were moved and seconded by John
Hull and Starr Farish. Motion carried.
Meeting adjourned at 9 : 40 p.m.
Respectfully submitted ,
Sylvia Robison
Secretary pro tem
'