HomeMy WebLinkAbout1978-09-21 P & Z MINUTES PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION MINUTES
September 21, 1978
The meeting was called to order at 7 : 30 p.m. in the Council Chambers
by Chairman Don Tolley. Present were Ralph Nyblad, Bud Grant , Starr
Farish, Betty Ann Lodge , John Pilote, Tom Ensley, Bob Nicholes , Pete
Olesen, Al McCluskey, Mel Lewis , Wayne Nielsen and Bob Carpenter.
Starr Farish moved to dispense with the reading of the August 17
minutes and approve them as written. The motion was seconded by
Betty Ann Lodge and carried.
Chairman Tolley opened the public hearing for the senior citizen
complex to be constructed on the southwesterly half of the block
on Belmont Street between 9th and 10th Avenues . In addition to
the special use permit, a variance will be needed for the outside
fire exit to extend into the setback area on 9th and for the
decks in the front setback area on Belmont . There was some dis-
cussion as to whether or not the variance should have been included
in the notice of public hearing for the special use permit and it
was decided that in future similar situations, this will be done .
Testimony was offered from the audience by Paul Oakes, who inquired
about parking, and by Virginia Manwell, who stated she was in favor
of the complex and it would be an asset to the community. The
'8-9-1 public hearing was closed and a motion was made and seconded by
Bob Nicholes and Bud Grant to grant the special use permit . Motion
carried.
eiN Next Tolley opened the public hearing for a special use permit requested
by Drs . Mickelson and Sakimoto to construct a professional office on
S. Kimball Avenue between the Memorial Park Baptist Church and the
Migrant Council Clinic in Block 9 of Arlington Addition. The zoning
is presently R-2 but the Commission has stated its intention to change
both the Comprehensive Plan and the zoning to accommodate professional
office in this vicinity. Their action would be based on this inten-
tion. Mr. Lewis presented petitions containing the signatures of
9 residents on Arlington and S. Kimball Avenues . The petitioners
expressed their concern over the on-street parking along the block
and increasing traffic in the area and opposed the clinic for this
reason. Lee and Virginia Hayes were recognized and said they were
satisfied with the clinic plans with the provisions that there would
be no interference with their garbage collection, there would not be
any pedestrian traffic across their property and that some fencing
would be installed between the properties . It was pointed out that
a variance may be needed to encroach 10 feet into the rear setback
and the Hayeses indicated they would attend the public hearing set
for consideration of the variance and discuss it in more detail
at that time . They further stated that they would go along with
the special use permit but were opposed to an R-3 zoning along Kim-
ball. After a discussion, the public hearing was closed. John
Pilote moved the request be tabled for study. The motion died for
8-9-2 lack of a second. Pete Olesen then moved that the special use
permit be granted. Ralph Nyblad seconded the motion, which carried
with a vote of 5 in favor and 3 opposed .
The final plat of Nottingshire North at the corner of Georgia and
Locust ( former Elks ' property) was submitted. The City Engineer
-2-
told the Commission he would recommend they approve the plat sub-
ject to the filing of association documents and to the written
approval of the irrigation plans by Pioneer Irrigation District .
8-9-3 Starr Farish moved that the final plat of Nottingshire North be ac-
cepted and a recommendation for its approval be sent to the City
Council with the stipulations attached by the City Engineer. The
motion was seconded by Tom Ensley and passed.
Discussed next was a proposal for a subdivision containing 8 acres
to be located on S. Kimball south of Amber. According to Dean Dish-
man, this will be a form of planned unit development with very light
density ( 5 units per acre) and 20% commercial shops in front of the
residential area. It will be a total security complex enclosed by
a fence and the streets will not be dedicated. Dishman indicated a
lift station will be needed but sewer and water plans will not be
prepared without a favorable reaction from the Commission on the
project . Annexation will be requested but since the land is not
contiguous to the City limits, an investigation is needed to deter-
8-9-4 mine in which direction to proceed. After a discussion, a motion
was made and seconded by Bob Nicholes and Starr Farish to recommend
that the developers proceed with the project . Motion carried. A
letter will be sent to the County Planning and Zoning Commission
stating that the City Commission agrees in concept with the proposed
subdivision.
A public hearing date of October 19 was set for consideration of a
request to plat an existing triplex at 1916 Montana into townhouses
for sale of individual units. These will be called El Mon Townhouses.
Association documents will be recorded that will control common areas
and uses. Since the area under consideration is too small for a
planned unit development , the platting is being done under the condo-
minium law and the units will separate on common walls . The public
hearing will be for a special use permit .
Regarding a variance request for a second building permit to install
two mobile homes on property too small to plat at 4th and Joliet,
the City Engineer explained that the building sites meet the dimen-
sional requirements for mobile homes on individual lots. The area
is zoned appropriately and water and sewer are available. Nell Wolfe,
representing the property owner Ray Lenz, also mentioned a variance
for an adjacent 58 ' lot that she had discussed with Dave Baker of
the Engineering Department. She was asked to provide more informa-
tion on this request to the City Engineer at a later date and then
8-9-5 return to the Commission with a specific request . A motion to recom-
mend the granting of the variance for the second building permit to
the City Council was made and seconded by Tom Ensley and Bud Grant.
Motion carried.
A request to rezone property on West Plymouth near the old iron
bridge on the Boise River from R-2T to R-3T was submitted by the
owners, Mr. and Mrs . Pasco, and the buyer, Jess Knight . Mr. Knight
wants to purchase the Pasco' s mobile home and property, bring in
his own mobile home to live in, and arrange 5 or 6 more on the
property to remain under one ownership. This would be classified
as a mobile home park which would require a special use permit in
an R-3T zone. Sewer and water are not available at this time so
the property is dedicated to either underground or on top of the
ground disposal sites approved by the Southwest Health District .
-3-
Mr. Knight was informed that his request would require a Comprehen-
sive Plan change as well as a rezoning and this would take several
months to accomplish. He indicated he would not be ready to move
in all of the mobile homes before winter and that he would be will-
ing to wait . In the meantime, Mr. Lewis would be authorized to
allow him a building permit to move in his own home and an additional
mobile home. A public hearing for a special use permit will be set
for the mobile home park when the needed changes are made .
Kent Johnson was not present to discuss his request to store materials
on a lot at Main Street and the overpass .
Gary Morgan appeared before the Commission to request a variance to
move a house on a lot at 2nd and Elgin that is 75 ' x 60 ' (4 ,700 sq.
ft . ) . The house will extend 15 feet into the rear setback area.
Bob Carpenter asked that he be disqualified from action on this
request as he is involved with the property. A public hearing will
be required for the two variances requested, one for lot size and
8-9-6 one for the rear setback. Bob Nicholes moved that a public hearing
be set for October 19 . The motion was seconded by Bud Grant and,
after a vote, passed.
Next Mr. Lewis reported on his consultation with the City Attorney
regarding the Sperry Grocery at 18th and Cleveland. The City Attor-
ney issued a memorandum opinion which stated that the two uses,
a grocery store and an antique store, are enough compatible that if
the non-conforming use were not expanded, no violation of the law
would occur. The two uses could be interchanged and off-street
, - r9-7 parking requirements would be the same . A motion to accept the
City Attorney ' s opinion which would permit Mr. Sperry to sell the
grocery store to the antique dealer was made and seconded by Bob
Carpenter and Bud Grant. Motion carried with one opposing vote .
Boyd Harris has requested a special use permit to construct duplexes
on six lots separated by at least 75 feet in Third Parkside Addition.
The sites are as follows : Lot 1 and the East 40 feet of Lot 2, and
Lot 10 and the West 20 feet of Lot 9, both in Block 10 ; Lot 20 and
the East 40 feet of Lot 19 and Lot 11 and the West 20 feet of Lot
12, both in Block 9 ; and Lot 20 and the East 40 feet of Lot 19, and
Lot 11 and the West 20 feet of Lot 12, both in Block 8 . October 19
was established as the date for a public hearing on this special
use permit .
8-9-8 A recommendation to the City Council to grant a variance to Tom Hag-
gerty and Gary Carpenter for obtaining an additional building permit
on property too small to plat at W. Oak and Parker for a single
family residence was moved and seconded by Bud Grant and Bob Car-
penter after a brief discussion. Motion carried.
Darwin Feller was not present to discuss a special use permit and
variance needed for a structure at 14th and Denver.
A public hearing will also be held on October 19 for a special use
permit for a senior citizen housing project anticipated by Hazel
Park Associates which will be 3 stories high and contain 40 units .
The area involved for the project would only accommodate a density
of 20 units but this density can be exceeded by special permit .
-4-
Tom Sanders appeared before the Commission to discuss the expansion
of the Health and Welfare building for child care purposes . Plans
A are to enclose a carport and patio to provide more floor space for
l the facility. Mr. Wahob from the Health and Welfare office informed
the Commission that the child development center is too small for
the number of activities that are performed. He also stated that
there would be no increase in staff, cars or clients and added that
11 staff members had been transferred to Homedale. At present the
facility serves 12-16 children of preschool age with handicap condi-
tions . Considerable discussion ensued, during which it was pointed
out that the child care building was formerly a commercial building
remodeled into office space and that the other Health and Welfare
buildings were there by special use permit granted prior to passage
of the zoning ordinance last December. Their present status is that
of a non-conforming use which can be neither changed nor expanded.
The zoning is R-1, single family residential . John Pilote inquired
as to whether or not this could be considered a public or semi-public
building that could be expanded by special permit procedures . There
was also some question as to whether enclosing the patio and carport
could be considered as an expansion but it was determined that the
-9-9 remodeling would alter the outside structure. Bob Carpenter stated
that perhaps the request should be tabled but it would appear to
him that the request as presented would be in violation of the
ordinance and he would therefore make a motion to recommend that
Mr. Lewis deny the building permit for changing of the structure of
a non-conforming use. The motion was seconded by Bud Grant . Five
voted in favor of the motion and 4 were opposed. The motion carried.
Don Tolley informed Mr. Sanders that he could appeal the decision
of the Planning and Zoning Commission to the City Council.
Bob Carpenter was appointed by Chairman Tolley to serve on a committee
formed to work on the subdivision ordinance as it applies to industrial
properties and development improvements. Other committee members are
Al McCluskey , Pete Olesen, Don Tolley and Mel Lewis .
Mel Lewis read a letter he had written to the County Planning and
Zoning Administrator on a zoning interpretation for property located
near the Notus interchange in the impact area. If the area were in
the City limits , it would be highway-related commercial defined as
a C-4 . Mr. Al Heck wants to operate a mobile home sales office,
real estate office and animal fur sale office (retail sales and offices
would be permitted) on the site. He also would like a warehouse for
storage of fireworks which would require a special use permit under
City zoning.
It was decided to hold a public hearing on comprehensive plan map
changes the 26th of October. Notification procedure will be to
publish a legal notice in the local paper and to request a news
story and publication of suitable maps.
Other areas added foie consideration were:
A buffer strip of High Density Residential from Sunnyside north
and the north row of lots in proposed Park West Addition. Medium
Density Residential from Woodlawn to Sunnyside in Third Parkside
and proposed Park West . The remainder of Park West and 3rd Park-
side will stay as Low Density Residential.
-5-
An area behind the Outlaw Inn between Cleveland and Arthur
for industrial use.
1 120 acres near the Interstate, Indian Creek, the railroad, and
Ustick Road to High Density Residential for a possible mobile
home subdivision.
The area on Plymouth to High Density Residential for a mobile
home park.
Two items were added to the agenda for discussion at this time.
One was a request by Don Tolley for consideration of changing the
height requirement in the ordinance for the R-1 residential zone .
He pointed out that although there was a maximum of 600 square
feet for outbuildings in the rear setback, the building could be
25 feet in height. He would, therefore, propose that Section
6-3-1( 4 ) be amended to state that outbuildings in the rear setback
not used for dwellings cannot exceed 15 feet in height except by
special use permit. Mr. Lewis said the proposed change would be
drawn up in the appropriate language and presented at the next
meeting for a public hearing to be set .
The other topic was introduced by Bob Carpenter who was concerned
with the justification of requiring a 20-foot rear yard. It was
his feeling that there are some situations where enforcing this
requirement is not warranted and some reason other than just
promulgating an " pen space" concept should be given. There was
some discussion / is as well as the requirement of a 20-foot
front setback in the industrial zones. More time will be devoted
to discussing setbacks at a later date.
Meeting adjourned at 10 : 50 p .m.
Respectfully submitted,
Sylvia Robison
Secretary pro tem