HomeMy WebLinkAbout1978-02-16 P & Z MINUTES PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION MINUTES
February 16 , 1978
The meeting was opened at 7 : 30 p .m. in the Council Chambers by
Chairman Don Tolley . Present were Don Tolley , Starr Parish , mom
Ensley, Bob Carpenter, John Hull , Bud Grant , Jim Oates , Bob Nicholes ,
Al McCluskey, Mel Lewis and Wayne Nielsen.
The minutes of the special meeting held February 1 were read and
approved.
Chairman Tolley welcomed Jim Oates as a new member of the Commission.
First item on the agenda was consideration of a policy establishing
guidelines for duplexes in the R-1 zone by special use permit . Mel
Lewis read a tentative draft he had prepared which is as follows :
1 . The lot or building site on which a duplex is to be
located shall be not closer than 75 feet from the lot
or building site on which a multiple dwelling unit
exists .
2 . A lot or a building site shall be defined by the legal
property description of record and shall meet the follow-
ing criteria :
a. Proposed duplex sites
p 1) Legal description with special permit applica-
tion which meets the requirements of the zoning
ordinance .
b . Sites of existing multiple dwelling units
1) Lot or building site of record if less than
14 , 000 sq . ft . in area.
2) The area of the building plus all required
setbacks and area for required parking of the
zoning ordinance if lot or building site is
greater than 14 , 000 sq . ft . in area.
78-2-4 After a discussion, John Hull moved the adoption of the policy as
written by Mr. Lewis . The motion was seconded by Starr Farish and,
upon vote, carried.
A request for a duplex to be constructed on Lot 4 , Block 5 of Syl-
van Manor submitted by Mr. and Mrs . Karl Stoehr was withdrawn prior
to the meeting and, therefore, no public hearing was held .
Tolley declared the public hearing open on a zoning recommendation
of R-1 for property to be annexed on South Tenth Avenue. The pro-
perties are those owned by Bill Crookham, Caldwell Bus Company,
Caldwell School District and Ken Kingslien. Hearing no comments
78-2-5 on the zoning, Tolley closed the public hearing. A motion recom-
mending that the Council annex the above area into the city as R-1
Residential was made and seconded by Tom Ensley and John Hull, res-
0011N pectively. Motion carried .
At this time , the Chairman announced to the audience that any deci-
sions made by the Planning and Zoning Commission can be appealed to
-1-
-2-
the City Council .
The next public hearing scheduled was for a special use permit re-
quested by Jack Noble to build a duplex on Lot 3 of proposed Spear
Subdivision located on West Oak Street . The duplex will be adjacent
to a triplex being constructed on Lot 4 and will share an access
driveway with the triplex . Hearing no testimony from the audience ,
78-2-6 Tolley closed the hearing. After a discussion, Bob Nicholes moved
and Bud Grant seconded the motion to grant the special use permit
to Jack Noble for the duplex. Motion carried. The special use
permit and building permit will be subject to acceptance of the
final plat of Spear Subdivision by the Commission and the City Council .
Next on the agenda was a public hearing for a special use permit
sought by the L.D.S. Church to use the property at 1203 Willow for
a seminary school . Mr. Lewis informed the Commission that the legal
requirements for the hearing have been met . He also stated that
parking requirements should be made a consideration of the permit
as the area for parking and the number of spaces needed had not yet
been defined. Letters were then read by Mr. Lewis written by Myron
Frazier, 2519 Washington; H . G. Peters, 1112 E. Linden; Homer L.
Hooban, 1121 Willow; Richard and Evelyn Grimes , 1209 Willow; and
Hal and Honey Rowe , 1115 Willow; and 2 petitions containing 29 sig-
natures , all objecting to granting of the special use permit for
the above-stated use of the property . Testimony from the audience
in opposition was offered by C . Robert Yost , Mr. and Mrs . Hooban,
and Lila Morgan of 1115 Linden. Speaking in favor of the project
were Hal Mickelson and Robert Taylor, representatives of the L.D.S .
Church. After further consultation , the request for the seminary
school at 1203 Willow was officially withdrawn and the hearing closed .
Tolley opened the public hearing on rezoning the property at 6th
and Galveston adjacent to the Holiday Motel from R-3 to C-3 . In
response to the call for testimony , Jack Winters and Don Billing-
ton inquired about the R-3 and C-3 zoning classifications . The
City Engineer pointed out that a property ownership had inadver-
tently been split in defining zoning boundaries in the block lying
south of and parallel with the Interstate Highway between 5th and
7th Avenues . The property owner has requested that her entire
property be zoned C-3 , and, therefore , the Commission is recommending
that this change be made on the official zoning map following the
78-2-7 public hearings prescribed by law. After a discussion, Starr Parish
moved that a recommendation be sent to the City Council to proceed
with their public hearing and adopt the zoning change . Motion was
seconded by John Hull and passed by the Commission .
Two requests for rezoning were brought before the Commission. The
first was submitted by Harley and Phil Fouts of Boise Valley Monu-
ment Works on N. Illinois Avenue for a rezoning of Block 75 of
Golden Gate Addition from R-2T to M-1T Industrial zone . It is
their intention to enlarge the office building and continue the
same use under an existing special use permit . It was the con-
census that this request should be considered and a public hearing
was set for March 16 .
A public hearing date of March 16 was also set for consideration
of an application by Orville Rogers to rezone his property at
1202 Blaine , Lots 1-4 , Block 23 of Dorman' s Addition from R-2 to
-3-
C-2 under an extension of the C-2 zone boundary at the centerline
of 12th.
Frank Timmons has asked for a variance for two building permits on
property too small to plat on the southwest side of the intersection
of Alder and Ohio. There is curb and gutter on both sides of the
street and the lots are approximately 75 ' x 135 ' in dimension.
78-2-8 A motion was made by John Hull and seconded by Bud Grant to recom-
mend the granting of the variance to the City Council. Motion carried.
Presented next was the revised preliminary plat of Spring Meadow
Subdivision. The subdivision will have 28 lots as it has been deter-
mined the Lowline Canal will not be tiled. The City Engineer read
his report outlining provisions for street improvements and right-of-
way, easements , sewer and water, drainage , irrigation, utilities ,
and responsibilities of the developer. The report is on file in
75-2-9 the Engineer' s office. After a discussion, it was moved and seconded
by Tom Ensley and Jim Oates to accept the revised preliminary plat
of Spring Meadow subject to the Engineer' s report and recommend its
approval to the City Council . Motion carried.
The City Engineer then reviewed a preliminary of a plat of Benito
Juarez Subdivision to be located on Omaha between 1st and 3rd Avenues .
His comments are as follows :
The title of the plat should include "A replat of Blocks 76
and 77 , Golden Gate Addition. "
Lots meet dimensional requirements .
/.441 One variance will be required as the cul-de-sac is more than
400 feet long; the City owns the south half of the proposed
"Nogales" Court (cul-de-sac street) .
Five-foot easements will be required on all frontages . A
utility easement should be along the east side for irriga-
tion .
A street drainage plan has been provided .
The border policy will apply on all streets . Streets must
be improved with curb , gutter, sidewalk and paving.
Sewer extension will be provided upon payment of extension
fees by the developer. The City will design and provide
field engineering, inspection and certification.
Irrigation system must be approved by Golden Gate Irrigation.
Underground power and cables for street lighting are required .
A vacation of 14 feet of a 30-foot sewer easement is a condi-
tion of the plat for better utilization of two lots .
Subsequent to a discussion on the alternatives for development of
78-2-10 Nogales , Starr Farish moved that the preliminary plat be forwarded
to the Council with a recommendation for approval without granting
a variance for the long cul-de-sac . The motion was seconded by
John Hull and , after a vote , carried.
Val Feller was not present to discuss his request to vacate 30 feet
of right-of-way in Block 14 of Hillcrest Subdivision.
Bob Hibbard appeared before the Commission to request the vacation
eN of part of an easement in Lot 1 , Block 1 of New Country Meadows
to better utilize the building site . The portion to be vacated
would be the southerly 3 feet of the easement . After a discussion,
78-2-11 a motion was made by Bob Nicholes and seconded by John Hull to
recommend to the Council that they approve the vacation and
-4-
implement vacation proceedings . Motion carried .
/'qN March 16 was set as the date for a public hearing to consider a
special use permit requested by Leroy Atwood for the construction
of warehouse storage units on property 200 ft . long by 52 . 5 feet
wide at 18th and Main, which is in a C-3 zone . Right-of-way for
Main Street will be deeded. A piece of property behind will be
isolated from access with the proposed plan, so Mr. Atwood is trying
to acquire it and include it in the development . Setbacks will be
in alignment with an existing residence on 18th Avenue .
A request for a special use permit for an office at Kimball and
Fillmore was reconsidered by the Commission at this time . Mrs .
Altha Bish explained that she has withdrawn her property from a
rezoning of the side of Block 104 , Goandu Addition, fronting on
Kimball and wishes to have the Commission set a public hearing for
a special use permit . The Council will hold a public hearing on
February 21 on the rezoning of Lots 1-4 and 21-24 of said Block
78-2-12 104 from R-2 to C-2. Following a lengthy discussion, Starr Farish
moved to table Mrs . Bish' s request until after the Council hearing.
Motion was seconded by Bob Carpenter and, upon vote, passed.
Next Bob McGarvin presented a plan for a 4-unit condominium type
of dwelling to go on Lots 33 and 34 of Torrens and Tucker Addition.
It is his intention to sell these as individual units with a swim-
ming pool common to all. His proposal was discussed at length as
to whether it could be considered as a planned unit development in
an R-1 zone , which would require platting if area requirements could
be met, or whether a zone change should be considered . As more time
was needed to reach a decision, Mr. McGarvin said he would meet with
the City Engineer in the near future to determine how best to proceed.
The Commission reviewed plans for the expansion of Dr. Jeff Schwartz ' s
medical office building and concurred that he should go ahead under
the existing special use permit .
A public hearing date of March 16 was set for a special use permit
applied for by Bob Gushwa to construct a duplex on Lot 6, Block 4
of Monte Vista Addition located on Rice Avenue .
Al McCluskey announced there would be ajoint meeting next week
with the Mayors , Council Members and City Engineers of Nampa and
Caldwell. He then distributed information entitled, "Considera-
tions for a Common Resolution between the Cities of Nampa and
Caldwell . "
Other discussion items on the agenda were deferred until the next
meeting.
Meeting adjourned at 11 : 00 p .m.
Respectfully submitted,
eN Sylvia Robison
Secretary pro tem