HomeMy WebLinkAbout1977-11-17 P&Z MINUTES • PLANNING AND ZONING CO_NNISSIO" MINUTES
November 17 , 1')77
The meetint; was called to order at 7 : J n .m. in the Council Cham-
bers by Chairman Don PolIov . Prn aoit were oh Carnenter, Budd
Ketene , Starr Parish , halon .Jyblacl , Tom Ensley , John pilote , LaMar
Bollinger , George Dufur and Mel Lewis .
The minutes of the October 20 meetinrr were read . Tolley asked
that motion 77-10-0 he amended to read that a recommendation be
made to the County Planning -aur? Thni s_r, office to deny the renuest
Cor a mobile home in the i:;'.')uzct area . The minutes were then an-
proved as corrected .
First on the agenda was a public hearing, for a special use permit
requested by Walker and Comnanv for a orofessional office to be
located at 2123 Cleveland Doulevard . Tolley opened the hearing
and called for testimony regarding the request . Grant Eldredge
of 2119 Cleveland read a. _Letter addressed to Starr Parish , Secre-
tary of the Planning; and Zoning Commission , and signed by Grant
and Charlotte T?ldred'7e Harold and Helen Doan , 2103 Cleveland ;
and John and Nellie Squibb , 2116 Cleveland . The letter stated
their objections to the proposed use of the property and is at-
tached as a oast of these minutes . Bearin^' no further comments ,
Chairman Tolley closed the hearing and announced that action
would be taken later in the meetinn.
A A special use permit is bein r scuR7ht o J m and T Construction for
`� an office building in an existin; structure which was the First
Southern Fantist Church on the cornu of 16th and Cleveland .
Everett Purcell , representing Ti and neesented a plot plan and
parking nlan for the anti cin.ote : urn, t ect . Tie stated that an
older residence on the nronerty ,'nrld be removed and at least 21
parking spaces Provided . Commission members indicated they would
like more information on the number end tvne of offices that would
occupy the building . A rublic rieerins. on the special use permit
request will be held on December 1': , 'T(7 .
Eugene and Anita Sanchez anpeared before the Commission to request
a special use permit, to on-rats_, a beauty shon in their home at
101 Cleveland Boulevard . M., . ".anches , upon questioning, thought
he could probably Provide only two off-street parkin; spaces . The
number required would he 3 1/ with the one chair he would install .
It was surrested that he get together with Mr. Lewis or Mr. Dufur
and work out the parking to see if it would be Physically possible
to have the occupation at that location .
Next Jim Dakan asked the Commission for th"ir oninion on the dis-
position of his residence on the northwest corner of Logan Street
and Fairview Avenue . lie would like to sell the property for use
as a doctor ' s office since it is Located close to the hospital .
Under the oronosed soni:)-. i s nronerty wn il H be in an 2-2 zone
so he will recuest; of the Cit7 Co 7Y'c 1 a zonin7 Cl an,'e to to
eN accommodate a o oPOs`l1Onal offlr'e o m . '-h' of °Iee would faJ3 on
!,o7an an(1 an arlesate numb" of i s` a e be i e
�� c s cool nrov_d
"r'. nal/an stated h- ha-1 not cons't1 +e,1 ^11 n{' hi ; nei-hhor 9 but
the iaroloertv owner nd,i acent was not o?�pos '�f . It 1:!n :1 the oOncensus
Of the Co"1^'1iSsion a- 4- 'h-' . Tl.r lean should Procee.7 with the re7onin...
recue3t to th COnn i 1 ar d 2001 ,t fon a sr,ecia.] 11 3 `1rrMit
later date for a s^ee1 'ic
eauestin— a variance on Trots 7' a„(l 2 ' 01' morrens and r'-icer Ad -
dition was rery T ”, i"r o' ronet_ruction . F' ex-nl_aine-I thet
t-hn two lot's ,Ire 7.3 f'-of 1t•7 ' .rn�o '7',1(1 fent; . Wr-)r}r heen started
on two ri .-,l exes o-., the fronts o" the Tots and It is his intention
to construct two more on t'-1'' bah- portion Of the lots wi`-.° e
1
nrlv;ate lane for ac ess . Ce..rar •,r' 11_ h - ' rnur' 1t ite In liana to
serve the unitsan,l city water will he
`rovid d "Tr . Lewis fur-
ther ylained .tic,t the vari no,, rC„ '1" '* n would he i'or none
than the nornal Set.:',,: for. tb ' two rinlexes behind and also
that Present r n , n.' s l t. h
�t 'J i.n^ ='(`L11rt' all )'-11. 1 ;� i nor,, to O on a public
r! -ht -o" way . /1-ction would be a ren . nd-ation to the Cit Coun-
cil .
oui_ -ci1 . morrens and. muche_ Addition el It ! s an old one <an(_. was ac-
cented
c-..ceeted by the lit- 1 he'orce there were auv ,u1.-division renni"e'n-".'lts .
T- 1-ht-of-way ;l 'nig",ar � wis Provided 0r)n end o' 'he lon"- lots
):at not on the other. ','ictll Tran Aveno 11 he a (-ravel road and
there will he a tot'',-1- or' 1 units wit th1P ` additional proposed,
1 nose �,
t'.ne occuaants of which -,T1- 11 se the r'—)d . rnrinlexes are permitted
1.1ndar the nrrsent ''O'i l.,n,,. hilt . ,•i the' "--1 :li_str ict roposed �'nr that
area th,, are rl(lt • "'fl 4-,fl wo11l '1 ho lunlr'vn7
With i special ner'r-'it . "ter a discion , John Pilote indicated
he would l the to view the P"'o"-'r t• t ern nai in7 a
- recor.me' datio
n .
17 'CtRer" 'OrnTal ' a rr 4ia' 'rr1 ?it for further ctuir
enr1 that a --.'1?n co,,li ttee h e ''nnt' . to „1atce that study . Tia"lar
,. c'. ,. .' 1 ,,ri ,, ,, u'' 'Tote , r _- i!r,r>OinteCl
i)
ry�r7`I tit, 1r1'13!n no sere on the o' -,ittr'a were John T'jlOtF' (chair-
an' `1,-
'he next order O" 1- '1sines. was a referral `'rom the "it•.t council
for a ?O_il?".f recorum^a'la lop hrIor to .nexatios of nronertn O`1
fl'n'lt'n '1nntana . -", -ho „n-hsnn . the rroeert,', at '3°19
S . `.^crntena aT1e"ar,n j ,,o.1,.-c ' 1 to rehuest a water service
which the Council er crani to .,,, b''-' si -. would consentnrr,
� to be
annexed . prop. 't- .r' t r ,'i,atn., :)., ,n . 1 n i feet and it i .`_` con•-
tl' ous to the City limits . Since Un er the 'eroensed sontre' the
'7-11 1` n -, ul , i,' a 'r.. ._ l
- i ,'tl _ - o 'i "` ,:- j t was "'oVE':1, a?nC1 ."?c027'?e(a
'1'r mot'. nS1e,' n' ' e'er l 1 .nd he sone_.-1 R-1 upon
anin,,x t ian . 1 Ins 7et 'or 'inn end-.nr lq77 .
he this tirnc th- l i -. 'n - ' r --'- .ra t^1-en the s'nrcial
ll - 11,3 r'er! ;t-er7 Iv ;?.l_ Ir '' `� - ye'' "a lrhb l o i nover1
,anddt rr ari st1 the ,r 0,7 the special use
a
7r�_ "iit for _. n 'e_ .. P-,� 10'n" l. '). "1 ,,P ,1 ? Cleveland n.0)-11"'Ta;'d .
at-loin d'il'l l "'7 .
done ' ''135 .O."1 1 _ J, ,7 ree-e- 11-1 - t'..,_ : 'et•'7.1 h,neat e" a tine
f'OI' t I Z'n of t i Il- 1 ?r t , nrnl T a ,ri ieIN
the new tl--'e will he snncif inei
'nub
t-1 -!,- a .. Js co.; _ ? ( n . rl,icll should .'l -ni--
A sl _ tof T ,, "t, � -:1 c+,_ t ' � . locatesouth
or t,-!P Pranlin Le"ch mr e _;n l.. � . .\c o
', P� t_ + n' l u n ^ l 1-.' l l i n-*
�n� to La_._7_e'�� , , �� � ,r _ _-� r ( .,. _ _ _ .i_t j ) i s -�rono�_..
to develop only th,, northern u tract _ n" the (?j'!.^•i'1'a.l n,,nl i ...i.n<1r''J
olnt . mr .. Lewis L- vi -'*:` ;} the ;`rovi . o"., nn e.' which the ori r''i na l
r,.rpl imi 'r•, a,7 been ve' - the 'recat n f ri t
- _.. ._ n had 11 _.. aDl)r 0 � ._� , �_. _ _') O streets In '/
Vio;'J '''raets Variance_. 'or CAD root ' loc', - avic-ntioil casements '.
re'erencr-' to rani ,)'-1.1Y1' of "i. tv View meats- corlitions for drain-_
_ . ells • street irr!orovements : drainare 'z7 -n • ru l 11-ht industrial
F l i..ii ted to ner 1n no � e.crn ,trent m is are to
us �. 10 sc. s �.I z,l rove.. 'n ,�
irlclu de concrete Valley or curb an,. -utter , asphalt oa.vinc", to City
standards , and buil,iin,cr, one hal." ?Alis 7 1/2 feet a" the roar}T.ra'•1 .
ni ,?e'wal.1-- and 11t1(}ti2',•ronn,1 no.,Ier wo')ld not h r"'nu rel . Praina-e
i mai » om rm- be t the s th- ,or n_ o!�l � thatn s to �,1 ,ad a „h nrAsen+; time
before ancroval can be riven . ' 'i19'-ln" ar-Y+n''rd, to contact Tilac'r
'lanvon Canal officials a00lt dra .nin^r into the canal , after which
icn
n,o would return to the Co `lmisS '_on ..i `.b fori at ion on their ner-
'1is0ion or r" f osal. to allow it .
thistime Oa'-, en... the •Tn.,J m.-, e i » i f the
'.,�_.� o' s - •r; cll.i_r- i � in
t}
event n ,, n r.• r,9 .e
!"i � new 'O. .Ln ordinance n?r;r'n _ ', ,�� 1.., the ('pl_incilat their
n-matin in r1ir1 _Tiecer-,: er ,, ?rr. ate ', 1 t rent,-,city for a varicrce
uo'_ll_? be since I.t 1'! )01 ,1 not r-onsider , 1 Iv the Corr-
niss1on ca'-o n until Pecr^.-i'- e l r'he t• '' 1neon renhie(] that
it was his i.ntenti_nn to nr' ,cant tr` t'-) r? r'ntncil three actions that
are llendinc yarin1 ces cnec 1 l use n,,ri s an , b.li r7 n... - e rii t
/)1and obt`3. ', n a nulln n'o those action- a i %� c ar-1 time the ? 'anc:e
1 o r;.i.
is nasoed . Thi 7.ou i t
2119 Cleveland Blvd.
Caldwell, Ida'io
November 14, 1977
Mr. Star►Farish
Secretary
Planning and Zoning Commission
Caldwell, Idaho
Dear Sir:
We wish to file an objection to the granting of a Special Use
Permit to Walker and Company Real Estate for a professional office
on Lots 13 and 14, Block 1 of Blatchley ' s addition at 2123 Cleveland
Blvd.
The above property is a brick residence with a double car
garage and a cinder block shop on the alley. This property is
next door to our family residence at 2119 Cleveland Blvd.
Until recently, the entire block borJcred by Cleveland, BlainC,
st . .ta 22 st . , was strictly residential . The first encroach-
ment on this block was the corner property on Blain, across from
the bowling alley which was allowed to become an insurance office
without proper permission from neighboring property holders.
In March of this year, a pre-fab alpine type building was
allowed to be constructed in this block for a communications and
Fhoto shop. An addition to this building was an old van body
which in the past was used to haul cans of milk. This repainted
truck van was placed on the alley , apparently for storage purposes.
At the time this property was under construction, we lodged a
complaint with the city building inspector. He said that a petition
^ had been circulated in the neighborhood which allowed construction
on this property. This petition was circulated ten or more years
ago by Nancy Baxter I believe , and was for an altogether different
t\ pe of property improvement. Five of the eiwht homes in this block
• are not owned by the same people who owned them at the time that
petition was circulated.
We strongly object to the piecemeal destruction of our block
as a family residence area .
Sincerely,
•
�/ l A �. t
,
•
= ,,