HomeMy WebLinkAbout1977-10-20 P&Z MINUTES r
PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION MINUTES
October 20 , 1977
eNN
The meeting was opened at 7 : 7,0 n .m. in the Council Chambers
by Chairman Don Tolley . Present were LaMar Bollinger, Boh
Carpenter , Starr Farish , Ralph Nyblad , John Hull , John Pilote ,
Tom Pnsley , Budd Kehne , Mel Lewis and George Dufur.
Ralph Nyblad moved and Starr Parish seconded the motion to dis-
pense with the reading of the minutes and anprove them as written.
Motion carried.
Chairman To]ley opened the public hearing for a special use per-
mit requestOby Dr. Whit Jones for a professional office at 2005
S . Kimball . Dr. Jones explained the interior would be remodeled
for an office to be used by two doctors and the basement would
be an apartment . Fight parking .maces will be provided off of
77-10-4 Hazel Street . Hearing no ob,iections , Starr Parish and Bob Car-
penter moved and seconded that the special use permit be issued
to Dr. Jones . Motion carried .
Next the public hearing was declared open for a. special use per-
mit requested by AWB Industries to construct living units for
senior citizens on property located at 19th Avenue between Blaine
and Arthur Streets . The complex is to contain 16 units ( four
4-plexes ) which would be one-story dwellings . Several persons
in the audience responded to the Chairman ' s call for testimony .
Speaking in opposition to the project on the basis that they
understood the area is presently zoned to include residences
up through triplexes were Audrey Birnbaum, 1602 Cleveland ; Abe
Soloman, 1302 Arthur ; Jess Pederson , 13WG Cleveland; Vernon
Smith , 1912 Colorado : and Rolf D. Schooler , 1622 Arthur . Com-
ments by others concerned the suitability of the location and
any changes that might occur in property taxes as a result of
constructing the housing on that site . Mr . Leroy Atwood , repre-
senting AWB Industries , explained the project in more detail to
those present . Tolley called a short recess so Mr. Atwood could
distribute pictures of similar units and answer questions . When
the hearing was brought back into session , testimony in favor of
the proposal was offered by Mr . Ray i rarrapane , who resides at
71' -1')-5 1609 Arthur. After further discussion , Bob Carpenter made a
motion that the special use permit be granted for the four 4-plexes .
The motion was seconded by John Pilate and , upon vote , carried .
LaMar Bollinger abstained .
Mr. Monte Fiala from the District III office of the State 7ighwav
Department was present to gain information on the Commission ' s
desires for pedestrian overpasses requested across the interstate
highway . Mel Lewis read a letter written by the School pistrict
on October 20 , 1977 , stating the District was interested in a
crossing at 14th and Indiana to convey children to Van Buren School .
Two other crossings requested for consideration by the City in an
r ' earlier letter were at 5th and at Kimball Avenues . Mr . Fiala
stated that 14th and Indiana would be an ideal location since the
highway goes through a grade there . Oc also informed the Commis-
sion that the two overpasses at 10th and the Poise 'liver will have
-1 -
•
-2-
walkways on one or both sides which would provide other means of
access to bicycles and pedestrians . "herefore , it was indicated
that one overnass designed exclusively for nedestrian travel would
be adequate . Mr . T'iala said he would send the City Engineer a
copy of the nl an shoji nr the men;h and Poise ??i ver overnass or-
ranr;ements . Letters will be sent to the Highway Department support-
ing the 14th and Indiana nedestrian overnass from the School District
and the Chamber or Commerce Loads and :_streets Committee as well as
the Planni nC and Zoninf7; Cor:misn ton .
A variance ren'lest by the r 3aho -ti ^rant nouncil to construct a
residence on a LO-foot lot iorotei on '_'lymouth Avenue west of
N. Illinois Avenue was considered . The lots were oric,inally
platted in 50--foot widths for mobile homes and now the Migrant
Council would like to nut a 3d-foot wide house on one of the
7 -10 -6 vacant lots . After a discussion , it was moved and seconded by
Budd Kehne and Tom Ensley that the variance for 50 feet of fron-
tare be granted. Motion carried .
Stan Smith , representing Mr . .Tames Lehman , explained the variance
being requested is to build 3 single family dwellings on the
corner of Hillcrest Lane and Georgia Avenue without platting be-
cause the area is less than 57 , r0D square feet . He would propose
to complete Georgia with curb , rrutter and sidewalk , and pave that
portion with Winn Addition navin the other half . Curb , gutter
and sidewalk would also be provided on Hillcrest . John Hull moved
to recommend to the Council that this variance he granted provided
^ the improvements as stated are completed . mhe motion was seconded
by Budd Kehne . Motion passed .
A special use permit request was submitted by Walker and Company
Real Estate for a professional office at 22nd and Cleveland in
Block 1 of Rlatchley ' s Addition. This block will be in an R-3
District in the proposed zoning and is nresentl,y zoned "A" Resi-
dential . A public hearing will be required with notification of
property owners within 300 feet . Sixteen narking spaces are
planned in the sideyard , according to Mrs . 'ran Walker. November
17 was set as the public hearing date for consideration of this
request .
Dr . Robert Peterson was present to represent Michael Clement , who
has applied for a special use permit to practice reflexology in
an existing office on the southeast corner of Tenth and Logan .
Dr . Peterson explained it was the young man ' s intention to rent
his office on Saturdays for three months on a trial basis . During
this time , :sir. Clement would also be studying vision training which
is part of Dr. Peterson' s practice . After a discussion, it was
agreed that circumstances would not deem it necessary for a new
77--10-6 special use permit to be issued . Bob Carpenter moved that Mr .
Clement be allowed to proceed under the terms of the original
permit granted to Dr. Peterson . Motion was seconded by Budd Kehne
and , upon vote , carried . Abstaining was Starr Parish .
At this time a request for a mobile home in th' City ' s impact area
southeast of the Jefferson Junior High School was reconsidered on
-3-
an appeal by Mr. and Mrs . Charles Rogers . The mobile home would
be for Mabel Cooper, Mrs . Rogers ' mother, who is in poor health.
Mr. Rogers explained that it was not the intention for the trailer
to become a permanent residence on the property. Some discussion
followed on the definition and enforcement of a mobile home placed
on a temporary basis . Bob Carpenter made a motion to recommend to
the County they grant the request with the understanding that a
definition of temporary be supplied and a Procedure for enforce-
77-10-9 ment be Outlined . There was no second to the motion Tom Ensley
then moved that the request be denied and the second was made by
John Pilote . The vote was as follows : in favor , 2 opposed and
2 abstained . Motion carried .
The final plat of Joliet Addition , a Resubdivision of a Part of
Block E, of Colden rate Addition , was presented to the Commission
by Mel Lewis . He stated that sidewalk would he required on Joliet
and Kearney Streets and curb , gutter and sidewalk on Hifth Avenue .
Underground utilities will be provided and sewer is available .
One correction on the plat itself , as pointed out by Mr . Lewis ,
would need to be made in the dedication for streets and easements .
With this being done , he would recommend that the Commission approve
the final plat and forward it to the Council . it was then moved and
'7--10-10 seconded by Tom Ensley and Starr Parish to approve the plat subject
to changing the dedication to the satisfaction of the City Engineer
and to recommend its anproval to the City Council . Motion carried .
The developers of Park West Additio:, have asked for the vacation
of a sewer easement in order to complete the subdivision as it is
platted . The vacation of the easement would be subject to the
rerouting of the sewer and supplying additional right-of-way through
'7-10-11 the plat on which the new sewer will he located . A motion recom-
mending to the Council to nroceed with the necessary steps for
the vacation with the approval of the Planning and Zoning Commis-
sion was made by Tom Ensley and secoried by Ctarr parish. Motion
carried .
Another vacation was requested by the ,Wove develoners to vacate
a part of the present right-of-wav on Marsing Cnulevard on the
proposed plat and east of the section line and dedicate J0 feet for
the road requirements in that a„ea . Accnr.dine to R,on Blakley of
Blakley Cngineers , the same owner controls both sides of the road
and could dedicate !10 feet on each side . It was the opinion of
the City Engineer that PO feet would be too narrow for Marsing
Boulevard which is an arterial . Mr . Rlaklev said that some arrange-
ments might be worked out for dedicating 100 feet of right-of-way ,
but there was some concern for the lots on the east side of the road .
It was suggested by the City I'nmineer that 5n feet east of the cen-
terline he considered with a restriction that no houses are to be
faced on ;larsinC Boulevard . vurther details will be determined
by the parties involved and the vacation request will be resub-
mitted at a later date .
none Craves has recuested the vacation of the easterly l ) feet of
pig a Th--foot eastment through which the ,iphaw main runs to better
utilize the lots in Sylvan Manor on which the easement exists . The
drain has been tiled and the pipeline will be on the 20 feet remain-
ing. It was felt that a written release fr )m Pioneer Irrigation
-4-
District stating, they either no longer n.e`de ' the easement or would
not object to the vacation of a portion of it would be necessary to
emN proceed with the va_r'.ntion on the cart of the city . A motion was
-10-12 made by Tom Enslev to recommend the vacation to the City Council
contingent upon a written releasA from Pioneer . mhe motion was
seconded by John Hull and passed by the Commission.
Elsie Steel appeared before the Commission to discuss permission
to put mobile homes on lots in the southwesterly half of Block
122 of Strahorn Addition. She would like to install one for
herself and sell lots or parcels to others for mobile homes .
The block is presently zoned commercial and would be R-3 in the
proposed zoning. It is not located in any of the areas in the
City desirrnated for mobile homes on innivid>>al lots . In review-
ing the situation , Mr. Lewis said that a recommendation to the
Council that the area be changed to accommodate that type of
structure could be made if Mrs . Steel and the Commission wished
to pursue that course of action . After further deliberation,
Mrs. Steel decided not to act at the present time but would
consult with the City Engineer and the Building Official .
Mr . Lewis briefly discussed the number of building permit appli-
cations presently pendin.-, with the city for triplexes to be
constructed in what will be single family residential areas
under the new zoning. He referred specifically to triplexes
contemplated on Lots 4 and 5 , Block 1 , ;Montana Manor Subdivision
as an example of the Problems being dealt with under the present
ordinance .
Discussions on Policies for homes and zoning within the
impact area were deferred until tee next meeting.
Meeting adjourned at 10 : 20 p .m.
Respectfully submitted ,
Sylvia Robison
Secretary pro tem