HomeMy WebLinkAbout1977-08-18 P&Z MINUTES PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION MINUTES
August 18 , 1977
The meeting was opened at 7 : 30 p .m. in the Council Chambers by
Chairman Don Tolley. Present were Starr Parish, Tom Ensley, John
Hull , Mel Lewis and George Dufur.
The minutes of the July 21 meeting were read and approved.
Don Tolley opened the public hearing for a special use permit
requested by Whitman Jones to operate a professional office in
the existing residence at 1724 S . Kimball Avenue and use the base-
ment for an apartment . He read a letter received from Maurice F. P.
Masar and a petition signed by neighbors on S . Kimball objecting
to any uses other than residential for the property. Speaking
against the request from the audience were Gerald Talbot , 114 W.
Elm, and A. 0. Davenport of 1702 S . Kimball, who cited traffic
problems as a basis for his objection. Hearing no further com-
ments, Tolley closed the hearing and said the applicant would be
advised later of the Commission's decision.
The public hearing was then opened for the zoning recommendation
for annexing Park West Addition. Response from the audience was
as follows : Mr. Leonard Day reported he talked with several neigh-
bors who did not object to use as residential. Art Collins, 307
Woodlawn, expressed the hope that some provision would be made
p for parks , open spaces, or play areas for the children in the new
subdivision. Recommending that the land not be annexed was Bill
Turner of 315 Palo Alto. The hearing was then closed with a recom-
mendation to be made later.
Mr. Lewis reported to the Commission and entered into the record the
following commendation by the City Council and Mayor from the August
2, 1977 , Council minutes :
The Mayor stated that he would like to publicly recognize
the tremendous amount of work that the Planning and Zoning
Board has put in in developing the City of Caldwell ' s Com-
prehensive Plan. He further commented that it was really
great that a volunteer committee would spend so much time,
along with the City Engineer, in developing this plan. The
first public hearing was to be held regarding the zoning
ordinances to compliment that plan on August 15th. The
Mayor stated that he would like the minutes to reflect the
gratitude of the Mayor and the City Council in recognition
of their work.
The final plat of Airport Industrial Subdivision was submitted for
approval . The owner has requested that an easement along the rail-
road track be withdrawn, but Mr. Lewis pointed out that eliminating
the easement would also invalidate the sewer plan. He also said
that the Fire Chief felt the property was too large for adequate
fire protection without providing accesses if sold in individual
tracts . After a lengthy discussion, Mr. Lewis suggested that
-1-
-2-
the owners investigate a legal means to covenant the property to
the satisfaction of the Fire Chief and that of the Planning and
/', Zoning Commission. Once these problems are solved of providing
easements for utilities and fire lines , the plat may be resub-
mitted for. approval .
Regarding a variance request , Mr. Lee Gamble informed the Commission
that in remodeling the residence at 2308 Ellis Avenue which had been
one foot from the property line, he is moving the wall in 3 feet which
would comply with the setback requirement and , therefore, he would
not need to obtain a variance .
The second variance was requested by the Hibbard brothers for build-
ing permits to construct 3 single family dwellings on property too
small to plat at Alder and S . Illinois. Mr. Lewis described the
property and stated that the frontages meet the code, lot sizes are
-8-1 large enough and the houses will be sewered. A motion to recommend
the granting of the variance to the City Council was made and sec-
onded by John Hull and Tom Ensley. Motion carried.
Block 9
Dennis Newbold has applied for a variance to build 3 houses on/Lots
9-l4 and one house on Lots 1-3 , on Block 10 of Golden Gate Addition.
Two of the lots lack the frontage required but have enough square
feet and the other has the frontage but not enough square feet (lots
-8-2 on Block 9) . After a discussion, Tom Ensley moved that the variance
on lot size be granted . Motion was seconded by John Hull and, upon
vote , carried.
eqN
The vacation of a sewer easement in Lot 5, Block 84 of Golden Gate
Addition has been requested by the Idaho Migrant Council so a house
can be constructed on the 60 foot lot . There is an existing 30-foot
easement , the required width being 16 feet , and the Migrant Council
-8-3 is asking that 14 feet be vacated. It was moved and seconded by
Tom Ensley and Starr Farish, that the vacation of the above easement
be recommended to the Council. Motion carried.
Several special use permit requests were considered. The first one
on the agenda for a diet counseling center at 1301 Cleveland Boule-
vard was withdrawn, according to George Dufur. Also, Dr. Blaisdell
was not present to discuss his application for a professional build-
ing at Ellis and Hazel.
Lloyd Christensen appeared before the Commission for a special use
permit to place two duplexes on the corner of Indiana and Willow.
Mr. Lewis said there was more than enough area to meet the square
foot per living unit requirements and that sewer and water are
available . He further explained that Mr. Christensen would need
a variance if he planned to build both duplexes within a year on
the property which is too small to plat . A motion was made to
-8-4 allow Mr. Christensen to circulate a petition for the special use
permit and to approve a variance for a second building permit, if
neccessary , by John Hull and seconded by Tom Ensley. Motion carried .
Permission to circulate a petition for a beauty shop to be located
in her home at 3523 College Avenue was sought by Kay Price . The
I
-3-
City Engineer discussed parking requirements with Mrs. Price and
eIN it was agreed that the Commission would like to look at her property
as well as a map of the entire area before making a final decision.
She was given permission to circulate the petition, however, and
agreed to work out the parking plans with City officials . A motion
7-8-5 granting permission for the petition was made and seconded by Tom
Ensley and Starr Farish. Motion carried .
In behalf of Carl Wallace who is looking at 5th and Harrison to
locate a 4-plex, Rod Trumbull of T and T Construction presented
plans and requested a special use permit for the four 2-bedroom
units . Mel Lewis pointed out there are only 9 ,000 plus square
feet in the property involved which at 3 ,000 sq. ft . per living
unit would only accommodate a triplex . After a discussion, John
7-8-6 Hull moved and Tom Ensley seconded the motion to allow Mr. Wallace
to circulate a petition but recommended that members look at the
site before a special use permit would be issued. Motion carried.
At this time Commission members agreed to consider two items that
were received late for the agenda.
One was for a variance to divide a corner lot located at Oak and
College owned by Mr. and Mrs . Turner and construct a small house
on the back of the lot . Speaking for Mr. and Mrs . Turner was
Everett Purcell of T and T Construction. With the division, there
would be 6 ,940 feet for the corner lot and 5,890 feet for the pro-
p posed new residence . It was the consensus that any decision should
be deferred until the members could inspect the Turner property.
Mr. Purcell was informed that his request would be put on the agenda
for the September 15 meeting.
Mr. Lewis read a letter he had received from George Ottens of the
County Planning and Zoning office requesting a recommendation from
the City P and Z Commission on a church to be located on the south
side of Ustick Road approximately 1/4 mile east of Florida on Lot 3
Block 4 of Upland Park Subdivision. The church is in the City im-
pact area and Mr. Ottens would like to have the approval of the
City Commission before a public hearing is set for the special use
permit requested by the Midway Bible Missionary Church. Mr. Lewis
told the Commission that he would subject any approval to the ac-
quisition by the County of the 40-foot half right-of-way for Ustick
Road . He said he would meet with representatives of the church and
go over their plans with them. John Hull moved that the County P and
7-8-7 Z be informed that the City would approve the building of this church
contingent upon the final approval of the City Engineer . Tom Ensley
seconded the motion which, upon voting, was passed by the Commission.
Another item to be considered for a recommendation to the City Council
was discussed by Mr. Lewis . This involves development of a street (N)
as yet unnamed between Madison and Omaha Streets and 1st and 3rd
Avenues . The City owns the south half of the property bounded by
the above streets and the Migrant Council anticipates building on
eN the east half of the north half of the land . A street bisecting
the two sections will eventually be needed and Mr. Lewis explained
what the alternatives would have to be as far as alignment is concerned .
I
-4-
Don Tolley expressed the opinion that the road should be extended
through, even if it had to angle around a house that is presently
eqN located where the road would emerge onto 3rd Avenue. Mr. Lewis
asked the Commission to be thinking about the best course to follow.
Mr. Perk Coffey said at this time he was representing the present
owners of the house at 1724 S . Kimball Avenue and would like to
speak in favor of the professional office being located there .
He also commented that no heavy traffic would result from this
type of psychological counseling situation.
Upon request , Mr. Dale Anderson was present to discuss the sign
regulations of the proposed zoning ordinance . The only major
objection he had was the basis of using frontage for the criterion
of sign size. He stated he would work up some suggestions for
the special session which would be held before the next hearing.
Mr. Lewis then read and discussed two policies for a recommendation
to the City Council . One concerned rights-of-way and the conditions
under which they should be accepted by the City. The members gen-
erally agreed that rights-of-way should be accepted when offered
and held in the case of half rights-of-way until the full r-o-w is
acquired. It was suggested that No. 1 be rewritten to state clearly
that no building permits will be issued on half rights of way. With
-8-8 this change , it was moved by John Hull and seconded by Starr Farish
to recommend adoption of this policy to the City Council. Motion
carried.
The next policy was to designate responsibility for improving border
streets created as a result of new platted subdivisions. After a
discussion, the adoption of this policy by the City Council was
-8-9 also recommended in a motion made by John Hull and seconded by
Starr Farish . Motion carried.
Meeting adjourned at 10 : 30 p .m.
Respectfully submitted ,
Sylvia Robison
Secretary pro tem