HomeMy WebLinkAbout1977-07-21 P&Z MINUTES PLANNING ANT) ZONING COMMISSION MINUTES
July 21 , 1977
The meeting was called to order at 7 : 30 p .m. in the Council Chambers
by Vice Chairman John Pilote . Present were Bud Grant , Earl Priest ,
Ralph Nyblad , Pete Olesen, Bob Carpenter , Hudd Kehne , George nufur
and Mel Lewis .
The minutes of the June 16 meeting were read and approved.
John Pilote opened the public hearings for special use permit
requests . The first was submitted by Gary Shefstall to construct
two duplexes on the northwest corner of Beech and Ohio. The legal
requirements for advertising and notification of property owners
have been met . Commenting from the audience was Mr. Charles McCabe ,
former owner of the above property , who stated he was retaining the
property to the west and was satisfied that the proposed duplexes
would compliment the neighborhood . Hearing no objections to the
7-7-1 special use permit , Vice Chairman Pilote closed the hearing . A
motion to issue the permit was made and seconded by Budd Kehne and
Bob Carpenter. Motion passed .
The next public hearing was for a professional office to he located
at 111 Belmont requested by James Morfitt . Mike Morfitt , co-owner
of the property , discussed the plans for converting the existing
residence into an office comn] ex and reception area . Mr. Lewis
and Mr. Dufur agreed that the narking requirements could be met
with a few minor changes . Since there were no objections voiced ,
7-2 Pete Olesen moved that the special use permit be granted for the
professional office at the above address . Rudd Kehne seconded
the motion which , upon vote , carried .
Lasher Construction is requesting a special use permit for town-
houses on Lots 3 , 4 , 19 , 20 , 24 , 25 and 26 of Torrens and Tucker
Addition located on the hill 2 blocks south of Marble Front on
Indiana. This would be a planned unit development and therefore
would he subjected to the section of the present zoning ordinance
dealing with this tvne of development . A percentage of the property
owners within 300 feet O0°' ) approving the project is required .
The pronerty will also have to be renlatted to allow the developer
to sell the townhouses "to the walls. " In discussing the proposal ,
Commission members felt they would need more information as to how
many units were planned , if a private street is involved , whether
or not there will be two-story units and other details property
owners should be informed of when presented with a petition to sign .
Mr. Lewis said he would work with representatives of Lasher Construc-
tion to provide more data for further consideration of the development .
A special use permit request by Mrs . Winnie Connors to place a
mobile home on her lot at 611 Galveston to care for her mother
was discussed , although Mrs . Connors was not present . The Building
Official said he could not recommend granting this request because
a mobile home is considered a residence and must he placed on an
individual lot with a 50-foot frontage . It was generally expressed
by the members that to approve this would be establishing a prece-
dent for placing additional residences or mobile homes on lots
and this practice was not desirable . Rudd Kehne moved and Pete
-2-
7-7-3 Olesen seconded' the motion to deny the special use permit reauest
by Mrs. Connors . Motion carried.
Dr. Whit Jones appeared before the Commission to request a special
use permit to remodel the present residence at 17211 S . Kimball for
a professional office and for an apartment in the basement . The
present zoning is "B" Residential and this area is shown as low
density on the comprehensive plan . Proposed zoning is R-1 although
this location is across the street from the high density-professional
office R-3 zone around the hospital . A public hearing would be re-
quired before the special use permit could he issued . After a dis-
7-7- 1 cussion, Pete Olesen moved that a hearing date of August 18 be
established contingent upon Dr. Jones submitting a proper applica-
tion and paying the necessary fees . Motion was seconded by Bud
Grant and passed by the Commission.
A seminary school to be located at 1011 Linden is contemplated by
the LDS Church. A representative , 'fir . Mickelson, told the members
that the school is intended for high school age students with
classes to be conducted early in the morning and during the day.
It is anticipated that the students could park in the high school
lot and walk over. Mr. Lewis informed Br. Mickelson that schools
are a permitted use in a "B" Residential zone under the present
zoning ordinance and therefore there would he no problem with zon-
ing. The Narking requirements were another matter and should be
worked out with the Building Official as well as other require-
ments of the building code . As far as the Commission was concerned ,
the church could proceed with the project as outlined .
The preliminary plat of Park West Addition was then considered . This
proposed subdivision is located south of the old airport between Air-
port Avenue and Marsing Boulevard and is presently outside the City
limits . Annexation will be requested . Ron Plakley of Blakley
Engineers explained that two short streets have been added between
the large sections as requested by the Planning and Zoning Commission.
Streets will be improved as required by the subdivision ordinance .
He pointed out that there is a problem with Marsing Boulevard in that
it is not constructed to grade requirements recommended by the City
and the slope will be difficult to build to . It could require recon-
struction of the entire roadbed and Mr. hlaklex posed the question of
who is resnonsible for the whole street if the developer is committed
to half. It is proposed that the subdivision will irrigate out of
the city water system. A preliminary street drainage plan has been
submitted and is in general satisfactory subject to use of the West
End Drain for the outfall . A sanitary sewer layout plan has been
presented . The east row of lots will he served. by gravity into the
existing line on Airport Avenue and the remaining 3 rows of blocks
by a numging station. Mr. Lewis suggested that the street names
of T'airway Drive and Halstead Street hi? changed as there is no wnv
of ever connecting those streets to the present ones . he stated
that a variance would he required ror the block lengths exceeding
(oh0 feet and was of the oninion with regard to Parsing Penlevsrd
te that some, thought might be given to fitting the land to the high
,r
�► 17-> end of the road . After further di .,nus ;ton , Pete nlesen moved that
the approval of the preliminary nl.at of Park West Addition he recom-
mended to the City Council with the variance for block lengths , with
the suggestion that the names ^airwav Drive and Halstead Street he
-3-
changed, and with the subdivision ordinance requirements being met .
The motion was seconded by Rudd Kehne and , upon vote, carried .
emN
Mr. Boyd Harris said that a letter would be furnished signed by the
record owner of the Park West Addition property renuesting annexation .
7-7-( A motion recommending that this subdivision he zoned "A" Residential
(or R-2 in the proposed zoning~) was made and seconded by Pete Olesen
and Bud Grant . A nubile hearing on the zoning will be held August 18 .
A development plan for property in Tract L of Mountain View Subdi-
vision owned by Eugene Bevan was brought in by Phil Smith . Mr .
Lewis reviewed the Plan and suggested it be changed somewhat to
allow Poplar to extend out to Indiana . There would be a possible
5 or 6 building sites . It was the concensus of the Commission that
the utilization and division of land was acceptable and Mr. Smith
should proceed with platting .
Since Mr . Lee Gamble was not present , his request for a setback
variance in the 2300 block of Bilis was not considered .
Por the Public hearing for the propos-d zoning ordinance , Bob
Carpenter indicated he would like to see as much Publicity and
advance notice as possible to inform the citizens of Caldwell
7-7-7 about the new zoning . He moved that August 15 be established
as the date for the Planning and Toning Commission ' s hearing.
The motion was seconded by Bud Grant and passed by the Commission.
eimN At this time the Chair recognized Vernon Smith in the audience who
said that a health food store had been opened at 1301 Cleveland
and to his knowledge no authorization had been obtained from the
City . George nufur, Building Official , agreed the establishment
is in violation of the existing code as no special use permit had
been sought by the owners and said he would contact them.
According to Mr. Lewis , the Council had referred two proposed policies
to the Planning and Zoning Commission for their recommendation. One
was for the acceptance of half rights-of-way and the other to estab-
lish responsibility for border streets in commercial and residential
development of land. These policies are attached as a part of the
minutes . Mr. Lewis ' discussion presenting background information
for the policies is as follows :
There are situations where we are asked to accent half or parts
of rights of way so the City then would control that land in
the event that we receive the rest of it . The fear that the
attorneys have had in the past is that the City upon accepting
these parts of right of way somehow is inveigled into getting
them opened and used as ri_P-ht of way , so we have been stringent
about not accenting them. Some situations have come up recently
where it was an advantage perhaps to accent half r-o-w. Under
the subdivision ordinance only a full r-o-w qualifies and so
we have asked developers to make arrangements to get the other
000-N half of the r-o-w . I think it has been successful . Really what
the policy was addressing was not subdivisions but parcels of
land deeded for r-o-w that were isolated and an advantage at
that time . If a police is established , I think that legally
we need to assure ourselves that half or parts of rights of way
-4-
cannot be used in the same manner as a full r-o-w; therefore it
should not be used to qualify for the issuance of a building
eiN permit . It should not be opened or would not meet the street
opening policy for an isolated r-o-w if it were only a part
r-o-w. The feeling on the Part of the property owner has some-
times been that the City is obligated to open the r-o-w for
access to his property regardless of the width. I would want
the City Attorney to at least he satisfied that the qualifica-
tions we would put on any r-o-w less than a. full one such as
I have just stated can be entered unon the minutes o' the Council
in their acceptance and thereby have a hindinrr effect on that
narcel of land. What we would be doing is acceptinr rights of
way and merely holding them without a r-o-w status . There are
some advantages in this because land rets sold and resold and
subsequent owners have different ideas about that tract of land .
We do not buy rights of way and have been reluctant to buy even
when we considered them in the public interest . certainly
right of way that develops land is in the interest of the dev-
elopment of that .land and not necessarily in the interest of
the public per se . I would say that certainly considerations
could be riven to a policy in which r-o-w or land could he
held for r-o-w but not as r-o-w itself. Referring to the
submitted policy , I would agree with the accentance of
voluntary rifts of r-o-w being in the best; interest of the
City . I would think that where it states it shall be the
policy of the City to accept any and all half rights of way
so longi; as the acceptance of the same does not create a lia-
e") bility, the definition of liability has to be stated in clear
terms . This policy should also exempt those rights of way
that are now opened and being used - so-called usaa_;e rights
of way that are undefined . I would add to it any thinking
you , the Commission members , have .
The border street is a problem that is created by accepting
plats that are on roadways that are now in use and improved
in some manner. An example of that would be on Marsin ; Roule-
yard as pointed out by Ron Rlakley. If the road is rood and
it fits , all that needs to he done is to fill in from the lip
of the cutter and the existing oil . There are situations
where they don ' t fit and the roads have to be rebuilt in some
way . There are also border streets that are not now open where
one party doesn' t intend to develop half. In the nast local im-
provement districts have solved some of these problems but a
number of plats accepted recently have had border street diffi-
culties . The Council would like your consideration and recom-
mendation on a policy to deal with the opened street that in-
volves construction and the unopened street . I have no recom- where
mendation at this time except negotiation with the developer/ there is
It appears to me somewhat unreasonable in the case of Marsin ; a street .
to make one subdivision on one side rebuild Marsing for a quarter
of a mile . One consideration would be to require the developer
to put in his half plus 8 feet more so we would have a paved
street that we can use . Half of an 18-foot width pavement is not
enough but a 26-foot width pavement is enough. The other alter-
native is the deposit system. but this doesn' t solve the lgth-
-5-
Marsini type of situation.
00) In lieu of a discussion at this time , Mr. Lewis sur7ested he
write up some ideas on both policies and distribute them to the
members before the next meeting;.
Bud Grant was appointed by Vice-Chairman Piot as actin
secretary to sicrn the final plat of Hillcrest Subdivision ,
Bishop ' s Replat of a part of ^ract 6 .
Meeting adjourned at 9 : -I5 p .m.
Respectfully submitted ,
Sylvia Robison
Secretary pro tem
A
CITY OF CALDWELL
eiN
ACCOUNTING POLICY AND PROCEDURES MANUAL
Title of RIGHT-OF-WAY
Procedure
POLICY THE PURPOSE AND SCOPE OF THIS POLICY SHALL BE TO DETERMINE
NO. THAT ACCEPTANCE OF VOLUNTARY GIFTS OF RIGHT -OF-WAY ARE IN
THE BEST INTEREST OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL .
It 'shall be the policy of the City of Caldwell to accept
any and all 1/2 right-of-ways so long as the acceptance
of same does not create a liability to the City of Caldwell
and further that the City of Caldwell does xaot purchase
said parts and pieces of real property .
Procedure No. :
Page of
Effective Date:
This Revision:
CITY OF CALDWELL
ACCOUNTING POLICY AND PROCEDURES MANUAL
Title of SUBDIVISION DEVELOPMENT
Procedure
POLICY THE PURPOSE AND SCOPE OF THIS POLICY IS TO ESTABLISH
NO. REQUIREMENTS FOR THOSE WHO DEVELOP LAND FOR RESIDENTIAL,
OR COMMERCIAL PURPOSES AND THEIR RESPONSIBILITY WITH
RESPECT TO BORDER STREETS ,
DEFINITION OF BORDER STREET:
For the purposes of this policy the term 'border street '
shall mean any and all streets that border an area that
is or will be developed into a subdivision, planned unit
development , or a commercial area . That area (border
street) may or may not have been paved prior to develop-
ment . •
It shall be the responsibility of those who engage in land
development to see that border streets are constructed as
follows :
1 . Any unpaved street shall be paved by the subdivider •
in it ' s entirety , not to include curb and gutter
situated on property not owned by the subdivider .
2 . Any paved street shall be placed in the same
condition as it enjoyed prior to development
with the exception of those situations where
grade lines have been altered. In that case
the existing pavement shall he redonelto coincide
with said grades.
Procedure No . :
Page of
Effective Date :
This Revision :