HomeMy WebLinkAbout1977-05-19 P&Z MINUTES PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION MINUTES
May 19 , 1977
The meeting was called to order at 7 : 30 p .m. in the Council Cham-
bers by Chairman Don Tolley . Present were Tor; Ensley , Bob Nicholes ,
Ralph Nyblad , John Hull, Bob Carpenter, LaMar Bollinger, Mel Lewis ,
and George Dufur. Also attending were City Attorney Ken Roberts
and Planner Arlo Nelson .
The minutes of the April 21 meeting were read and approved .
Chairman Tolley opened the public hearing for a special use per-
mit requested by Del Bright for an auto body shop to be located
on Lot 1 of Lafferty ' s Addition on E. Cleveland Boulevard . Since
no one present opposed the special permit , a motion was made by
77-5-1 John Hull and seconded by Tom Ensley that it be granted . Motion
carried.
Next a public hearing was held for a special use permit requested
by Joe Frost to construct six duplexes on Lots 13-24 , Block 1 of
Frost ' s Addition. Marion Rumbaugh of 1508 Parker asked about the
exterior design of the structures , but stated he had no objection.
Mel Lewis discussed the setbacks and noted these would be investi-
gated before a building permit is issued . Since there were no
77-5-2 other comments , Ralph Nyblad moved and John Hull seconded the mo-
tion that the special use permit be granted . Motion carried .
` After a public hearing, a special use permit was also granted to
Dr. John Blayney to operate a veterinary clinic at 3825 F . Cleve-
?7-5-3 land Boulevard. The motion to grant the permit was made and sec-
onded by Tom Ensley and Bob Carpenter, respectively) and passed by
the Commission.
The public hearing for zoning preceding the annexation of Country
Meadows was then held. There was no response from the audience .
77-5-4 A motion to recommend to the City Council that Country Meadows
be zoned "A" Residential upon annexation to the City was made by
John Hull . Bob Nicholes seconded the motion which, upon vote ,
carried .
Since Howard Olson was not present to discuss his request for a
special use permit to place two mobile homes on the 2900 block
of S . Indiana, the request was not considered.
William Ferro of 2813 S . Indiana appeared before the Commission
to ask permission to circulate a petition for a special use per-
mit to repair television sets in a garage at his home . He stated
he had no plans at present to sell new sets through. his business
but that any future expansion or addition to the existing use
would be brought to the Commission for their consideration. Mr.
Ferro was informed he would need approval of 75% of property owners
within a 300 ' radius and the City Engineer pointed out it would
,/� be necessary to identify the boundaries of his property from which
-5 the 300 ' would be figured. After a discussion, John Hull moved
that Mr. Ferro be given permission to circulate a petition and that
-1-
-2-
the site be designated as approximately 160 ' by 160 ' (to be deter-
00.40 mined exactly by the Engineering Department ) . Motion was seconded
by Bob Carpenter and passed .
Don Vassar, representing John Holton , submitted a special use permit
request to operate a dental office at 1913 S . Kimball Avenue . It
was specified by the Building Official that no petition would be
necessary , but a public hearing would be required with notification
of all property owners within 300 feet . After a discussion, Tom
77-5-6 Ensley moved that a public hearing be set for consideration of the
dental office on June 16 . Bob Nicholes seconded the motion and it
carried .
Bill Nicholson was present to discuss his request for a special use
permit to sell automobiles at his home at 1521 Boise Avenue . He
said that a former trailer repair business had occupied the site
and an office building was there which he intended to use . This
77-5-7 area is zoned "B" Residential . Bob Nicholes moved that Mr. Nichol-
son be allowed to circulate a petition but felt the members should
look at the property before final approval is given. Ralph Nyblad
seconded the motion. Motion carried .
A special permit request was then considered which was presented
by Pastor Gerald Crownover on behalf of the First Assembly of God
Church. Their wish is to construct a new church on six acres lo-
cated between the Interstate , the Oddfellows home , and 14th and
iN 16th Avenues . George Dufur explained that this permit would not
require a petition but could be granted after a public hearing
and notification of property owners within 300 feet . Mel Lewis
discussed with Pastor Crownover problems with access and drainage
and what will be involved in the development of the area. Sewer
will be required through the property to serve Property to the west
and a 20-foot easement along the right-of-way of the Interstate is
77-5-8 needed . After further discussion , Bob Nicholes moved a public hear-
ing be set for the 16th of June and that the special permit be sub-
ject to building approval and the Engineer ' s recommendations . The
motion was seconded by Ralph Nyblad and , upon vote , carried.
Lynn Prohaska submitted a request to add six additional units to
the Royal Manor apartments , 921 S . Kimball . The addition to the
existing 8 apartments requires a petition with 60% of the property
owners within 300 feet approving. The City Engineer reviewed the
proposal and determined that the 3000 sq . ft . per unit reouirement
could not be met in the plan as it was presented by Mr. Prohaska,
who said he would make some adjustments in the design and submit
the request again.
Two variances were sought by Hicks Construction to build a house on
a lot in the 3100 block of S . Illinois . One was for a 50-foot front-
age and the other for a setback exceeding the setback of 505 of the
buildings on the block. Mel Lewis explained an irrigation pipeline
p crosses the property and recommended a survey to determine the boundary
of the property and the location of the pipeline . An easement of
16 feet with a building restriction would be required over the pipe-
line and this makes the additional setback necessary. He stated
that approval should be subject to the survey and easement . After
-3-
7-5-9 a discussion , Bob Nicholes moved and LaMar Bollinger seconded
that both variances be granted to Hicks Construction subject to
the Engineer ' s stipulations . Motion carried .
A development plan for 120 acres lying south of the old airport
between Airport Avenue , Marsing Boulevard, Dixie Drain and the West
End Drain , was then discussed by Ron Blakley of Blakley Engineers .
The land is presently outside of the City limits but annexation
will be requested . This pre-preliminary plat , called Park West
Addition, includes 432 lots and will be developed in stages , 1/5
at a time . Mel Lewis pointed out that the blocks are 1 , 320 feet
long, exceeding the 660 foot maximum length set in the ordinance .
A 60-foot right-of-way on the east-west streets and an 80-foot
right-of-way on the north-south street are provided. A lift sta-
tion will be required for sewage . After a discussion , the developers
agreed to add two more north-south streets , one on either side of
Marshall but not necessarily to go through the two long blocks
bordering each drain ditch. Commission members felt the develop-
ment plan was generally acceptable .
Val Feller conferred with the Commission on plans for property
he owns located east of Hill Avenue and north of Owyhee Lane , if
extended west . Mr . Feller wants to build a new house on the north-
east corner to replace a residence originally on the southwest end .
His problem is that the house will not front on a right-of-way and
the City will need to have for future street extensions some assur-
e) ance of how the entire property will be developed . Mel Lewis then
explained in depth the rights-of-way problems of that area and
stressed that half rights-of-way not be accepted. Mr. Feller could
build facing Hill Avenue and be on a full r-o-w. Another alternative
would be for him to dedicate the entire r--o-w for Owyhee Lane or to
approach his neighbor to the south to dedicate a part of it . Mr .
Lewis further explained that it would be the City Council ' s preroga-
tive to grant a variance for a building permit to build not on a
right-of-way , and the Commission could make a recommendation to
them on this matter . After a lengthy discussion, Mr . Feller indicated
he would investigate the possibility of getting his neighbor to deed
the other half of Owyhee Lane .
Regarding the Van Buren and Lincoln Schools fencing project , Mr .
Lewis informed the members that the Council had granted permission
for the School District to put the chain link fence 5 1/2 feet from
the curb on public right-of-way. The action of the Planning and
Zoning Commission was to grant a variance for the heighth of the
7-5-10 fence from 4 to 5 feet . LaMar Bollinger moved and John Hull seconded
the motion to grant a variance for fence height at Van Buren School .
Motion carried . The location of the fence at Lincoln School has not
7-5-11 been definitely decided ; therefore , a motion to grant the variance
for fence height subject to the location was made and seconded by
Ralph Nyblad and Tom Winsley . Motion carried.
The final plats of Starlight Park, Unit II , and Bishop ' s Replat of
a part of Tract 6 , Hillcrest Subdivision were reviewed and their
approval recommended by the City Engineer. The action is as follows :
•
-4-
7n12 John Hull moved and Tom Ensley seconded the motion that
the approval of Starlight Park , Unit II , be recommended
to the City Council subject to subdivision ordinance re-
quirements . Motion carried .
77-5-13 A motion recommending the approval of Bishop ' s Replat
subject to provisions of the subdivision ordinance was
made and seconded by Bob Nicholes and Ralph Nyblad .
Motion carried .
Lynn Prohaska returned with a revised plan for the additional
units to Royal Manor Apartments . With the adjustment , there
would be 2 , 430 sq . ft . per unit and a variance would be requested
for the 670 ' less than required. No decision was reached at
this time .
A variance for a fence for a duplex at Logan and Washington was
discussed briefly . Chairman Tolley advised the members that Lor-
raine Johnson would like to build a 12-foot section 6 feet high
for privacy. The Building Official had been consulted , and he
indicated that he could recommend a variance for only 5 feet
with perhaps a 6-foot section in front .
Arlo Nelson reported on the status of the zoning ordinance draft
and said it would be ready with the corrections for a work session
to be held on Wednesday , June 1 , at 7 : 30 p .m. in the Council Cham-
bers .
Meeting adjourned at 10 : 30 p .m.
Respectfully submitted,
Sylvia Robison
Secretary pro tem
1