HomeMy WebLinkAbout1977-01-20 P&Z MINUTES PLANNING ANT) ZONING COMMISSION MINUTES
January 20 , 1977
The meeting was called to order at 7 : 30 p.m. in the Council Chambers
by Chairman Don Tolley . Present were Dean Dishman, Pete Olesen, Chuck
Banks , Starr Parish, Bob Nicholes , Ralph Nyblad, John Hull , John Pi-
lote , Bud Grant , George Dufur, Mel Lewis and Arlo Nelson.
Chairman Tolley announced that the public hearing for reconsideration
of a special use permit request by 0. T. Sanders would be rescheduled
for the February 17 meeting so that all parties affected could be
properly notified.
He then read a list of the 1977 Commission appointments and term
expiration dates .
The first order of business was the reorganization of the Board
77-1-1 and Tolley called for nominations for Chairman. Chuck Banks nom-
inated Don Tolley and Starr Farish seconded the nomination. Mr.
Farish then moved that nominations cease and the secretary be
instructed to cast a unanimous ballot . The motion was seconded
by John Pilote and carried. John Pilote was nominated for Vice
Chairman by Starr Farish. The second was made by Pete Olesen, who
then moved that nominations cease and a unanimous ballot be cast .
This motion was seconded by John Hull and passed. It was next
moved by Pete Olesen and seconded by Ralph Nyblad that the Chair-
men appoint a secretary. Motion carried and Chairman Tolley
appointed Starr Parish to serve .
The Chairman opened the public hearing for a special use
permit
as per ordinance for Hazelwood Townhouses, a planned unit devel-
opment bounded by Hazel Street and Wyoming Avenue, which would
include 8 units in a half-block area. Since all requirements
77-1-2 have been met and there were no comments from the audience , Pete
Olesen moved that the special use permit be granted . The motion
was seconded by Chuck Banks and , upon vote , carried.
Next on the agenda was a public hearing for a zoning change request
on the southwest corner of Linden and Georgia and including a 95-foot
strip down the west side of the property. Dean Dishman stated he
would abstain from voting on this matter. Dick Winder, one of the
principals of Apartments East who presently own the property, in-
formed Commission members and others in attendance that present
plans being considered were for possible retail establishments
on the corner and mini-warehouses for storage on the western strip ;
however, he said that they had received no concrete commitments to
date . Arlo Nelson was asked by Chairman Tolley to explain how the
rezoning related to the Comprehensive Plan. He pointed out that
according to Map 8 of the Plan, land use for that corner of Linden
and Georgia is shown as medium-high density residential , and there-
fore at the present time , the rezoning is not in harmony with the
proposal of the Plan. He did stress that boundaries as indicated at this
time are imprecise and adjustments can be made . Several persons
,0.444 present gave testimony in opposition to the zoning change . Mr.
Leonard Day stated he was not in favor and, when asked to give his
-1-
-2-
reasons, indicated he would not like to see warehouses in that area.
Mr. Gene Bevan of Cherry Street said he would oppose anything that
would obstruct the view of the mountains . Others who basically ob-
jected to commercial development in a residential area were Henry
Jensen, Glenn Bevan and Leonard Cordell , all of Locust Street , and
Lucille Day . After further discussion, Chuck Banks inquired if
those against the rezoning would be more willing to consider it if
they knew in more detail what would go in there . There were some
affirmative responses to this question. Mr. Winder stated that a
grocery store was being considered along. with other retail opera-
tions that he felt would be beneficial to the neighborhood and that ,
although they could construct multi-family dwellings , the rezoning
would give them more flexibility in developing the property. He
agreed that it would be possible to map out more detailed plans
(7-1-3 for the area for presentation at another hearing. Pete Olesen
moved that the hearing be continued to a later date and that pro-
per notice be given to everyone concerned . This was seconded by
Chuck Banks . The hearing was continued until February 17 at
7 : 30 p .m. in the Council Chambers and it was agreed that notices
would be sent to residents and property owners within a 300-foot
radius at no further cost to the developers . Motion carried .
Mel Lewis presented the preliminary plat of Starlight Park, Unit
2, a triangle of land lying north and east of the Lowline Canal .
The proposed subdivision is outside of the city limits and adjacent
to Starlight Park. Annexation has been requested . According to
Mr. Lewis , approval of the plat would be subject to a deed from
Dick Cleveland for the right-of-way for the north half of Spruce
Street . The developer would be required to put in curb and gutter
for Spruce and could put funds in deposit for future paving. The
area will be sewered. No letter has been received to date from
Pioneer Irrigation District regarding the irrigation plan. Bob
(7-1-4 Nicholes moved that the preliminary be approved subject to the
deed for the right-of-way and a deposit for street improvements .
Motion was seconded by Ralph Nyblad and carried . A zoning of
"A" Residential was recommended and the public hearing for the
zoning change preceding annexation was set for February 17 .
A preliminary of a plat for Caldwell Interstate No . 1 was consid-
ered next . This is a proposed industrial subdivision located off
of Franklin Road south and east of the Black Canyon Canal on pro-
perty owned by Oregon-Idaho Lands , Inc . Mr. Lewis read some
comments he had prepared in which he pointed out that all streets
should be 80 feet as required for industrial streets, including
Commercial Way along the Notus Canal. The excessive length of
the blocks could be waived because of the industrial nature of
the plat . Sewer is planned. A solution to drainage will have
to be found and Ron Blakley of Blakley Engineers said one alter-
native being considered is to drain back to the point where the
city has a crossing under the canal, if permission can be obtained .
He further stated that 60 feet of right-of-way was probably the
maximum for Commercial Way which is along the ditch bank. A 20 ' set-
back restricting building was proposed because of the circumstances.
77f }5 Pete Olesen moved that the preliminary be approved with the 60-foot
right-of-way and 20-foot building setback and subject to the various
-3-
considerations outlined in the Engineer' s comments. The motion
was seconded by Chuck Banks and passed. The approval will also
be subject to avigation easements.
Industrial Site No. 4 preliminary plat was then presented. The
Engineer stated that the plat should indicate it is a replat of a
part of City View Tracts and approval should be subject to vaca-
tion of rights-of-way dedicated in the City View Tract plat .
Private disposal systems are proposed. Street drainage would
require the same consideration as Caldwell Interstate No . 1 and
all streets should be 80 feet . Avigation easements will be re-
quired. Discussion centered mainly around sewer development
plans and it was the feeling of the Commission that more investi-
gation should be undertaken to determine if it would be economic-
77-1-6 ally and physically possible to sewer the area. A motion was made
and seconded by John Pilote and Ralph Nyblad to have the developer
obtain more information on the above. Motion carried . Bob Nicholes
and Starr Farish abstained from voting.
Mr. Lewis brought the members up to date on the preliminary plat
plat of Airport Industrial Subdivision. He read a letter he had
written on September 17, 1976, as directed by the Commission to
Mr. Earl Barnard agreeing on a 20-rather than 40-foot setback on
Marsing Boulevard and requesting 20 feet additional right-of-way
on Laurel Street . He then read a letter received from John Howe
of Alpha Engineers, dated January 5, 1977 , stating that Mr. Barnard
wished to have the plat resubmitted with the original 50-foot right-
of-way. In discussing this , most of the members felt that they
could not accept the plat without the 20 feet requested along the
south side of the lots on Laurel, as Laurel is designated a col-
77-1-7 lector in the Comprehensive Plan. A motion was made by John Pilote
and seconded by Ralph Nyblad to deny the request for approval of
the plat based on the Laurel Street right-of-way. Five voted in
favor of the motion and one against . Motion carried.
Regarding the request for a variance for a building permit to
construct another house within the one-year restriction on pro-
perty he had purchased from Mrs . Burger on Savannah Street and
Rice Avenue, Bert Olsen informed the Commission that he had talked
with Mrs . Burger and she was not interested in platting. He and
Jack Noble , who had also purchased a portion of the original tract ,
did not feel they wanted to take on the expense of platting if there
was another alternative. It was the City Engineer' s opinion that
the situation did not present special or unusual circumstances that
77-1-8 would warrant a variance in this case . After a discussion, Pete
Olesen moved that the variance not be granted . The motion was
seconded by John Pilote and, upon vote, passed.
A variance request by Mr. Schmidt and a special use permit request
by David Lee were not considered because neither party was present .
The managers of Nick ' s Mobile Manor, representing Mr. Sherman Bart-
lett , attended the meeting to discuss the possibility of putting
12 apartments on the lot north of the mobile home park on S . Indiana
to accommodate college students . Mr. Bartlett will grant his right-
of-way for the extension of Alder but could get no definite answer
-4-
from the parties in back as to whether or not the road could go
through. Mr. Lewis said that the 40-foot right-of-way from Mr.
Bartlett could be accepted with a standard cul-de-sac at the end
and that Mr. Bartlett should understand he will have to get a
special use permit to build anything more than a triplex . Pro-
cedures for obtaining a special permit were outlined to the managers ,
who said they would convey the information to Mr. Bartlett . Bob
77-1-9 Nicholes then moved that the City accept the right-of-way for the
extension of Alder with a standard cul-de-sac on the end. The
motion was seconded by Ralph Nyblad and carried.
The final plat of Starlight Park was presented for approval . Since
all requirements have been met , a motion was made and seconded by
(7-1-10 Starr Farish and Ralph Nyblad to recommend to the City Council ap-
proval of the plat . Motion carried.
According to Mel Lewis , the final plat of Nottingshire Subdivision
was ready for approval except for receipt of the executed associa-
tion by-laws . The units had been reduced from 24 to 21 as requested
(7-1-11 and an easement will be acquired for sewer. It was moved by Starr
Farish and seconded by John Hull to recommend approval of the final
plat subject to the by-laws . Motion carried.
Chairman Tolley requested at this time some kind of recommendation
from the Commission regarding a fee system for researching titles
for notification procedures . This would apply to special use per-
mits , non-conforming use permits and vacations . The procedure
for special permits is for a fee of $10. 00 to be paid when a party
picks up an application and an additional $90 . 00 fee for the title
-12 search when he brings in the completed application. A motion rec-
ommending this procedure to the Council to establish this fee
where title searches are involved was made by Bob Nicholes and
seconded by John Pilote. Motion carried . A letter is to be sent
to the Mayor and Council stating this action.
Arlo Nelson informed the members that maps have been prepared to
a certain level of zoning around the City in the impact area and
he would like to schedule a special meeting_ to explain the dis-
tricts the County has set up . The meeting will be held Tuesday,
January 25 , at 7 : 30 p .m. in the Council Chambers .
Action taken on a variance request by Wayne Bishop for a duplex
77-1-13 located at Washington and Logan was as follows : Dean Dishman
moved that the Commission recommend the City Council grant the
variance for the duplex to be built on the corner lot which con-
tains 7 , 234 square feet . Pete Olesen seconded the motion. Four
voted in favor of the motion , 1 against and 1 abstained. Motion
carried . An opinion from the City Attorney was recommended by
Don Tolley.
Meeting adjourned at 11 : 00 p .m.
Respectfully submitted,
Sylvia Robison
Secretary pro tem