HomeMy WebLinkAbout05 Hearing Examiner PLANNING AND ZONING/HEARING EXAMINER l
ITEM DATE SUBMITTED BY
PZ-1 AGENDA - Q , ( I 1 - _ ( I �' /41C
PZ_2 MINUTES Vaa-I � TWP
PZ-3 SIGN-UP SHEET(S) �_
-Q\ 'W■i
P - 1661 ��-`� e�-.^ r c�j �-fx�
d from Cat r e c-��
3C* ) 1 -3-07 /( /9 140
LhieC
4PAA° L. \ 4 G D ,eLt
,-',,.,Z, ■....' Jr _jor .0P 4/ --
0 ,-- ) ,, ,i1 I.,0
" � The Trea<'w e of the Ua/Icy V" `i
Akie lb 00.6'
CAlnweuMAYon A Caldwell Hearing Examiner agenda for Public Hearing on Wednesday, November 9,
Garret Nancolas : 2011 at 7:00 p.m., in the Community Room of the Caldwell Police Department at 110
South 5th Avenue, Caldwell, Idaho.
CITY ClEfiK
Debbie Geyer ' ' AGENDA
COUNCIL MEMBERS I. Call to Order
Dennis Calisen
:'Shannon Ozuno II. Review of Proceedings
fBobSobbo
''Jim Dakan Ill. Old Business
Rob Hopper
Jim Blacker A. Approve the Minutes of the September 13, 2011 meeting as previously signed by
Hearing Examiner Mapp.
IV. New Business
PLANNING & A. Case No. SUP-349-11 a request by United Metals LLC for special use permit approval
ZONING DEPARTMENT ' to operate a wrecking/salvage yard in an M-1 Light Industrial zone on property
/ 621 Cleveland Blvd f addressed as 219 Main Street.
Caldwell, ID 83605
V.
D Next Hearing Examiner Public Meeting Date: Tuesday, January 10, 2012 at 7:00 p.m.
r. RECTOR
k A Q�r VI. Adjourn
; z
�y
r' s Any person needing special accommodations to participate in the meeting should
x _ contact the City Office at(208) 455-4667 prior to the meeting.
`, Cualquier persona necesitando comodidades especiales para participar en la reunion
' debe contactar al as oficinas de la Ciudad o Ilame a (208) 455- 4667 antes de la
l reunion.
/i\ Q SEf .
—IDAHO ITAG
D,TA _ NM 6EST �*y.�y,,((
CITY
UNITIES l sa
v r..m..' ,.k
TRFE Ern'CY ,,
AM
City Hall • 411 Blaine St. • P.O. Box 1179 • Caldwell, Idaho 83606 C' (208) 455 3000 .= FAX: (208) 455-3003 • www.ci cc}ldwell.yom
CALDWELL HEARING EXAMINER
MINUTES
November 9, 2011
I. Call to Order— Hearing Examiner, Mr. Jerome Mapp, opened the meeting for the public hearing at
7:04 p.m.
II. Review of Proceedings—Mr.Jerome Mapp outlined the procedures for the public hearing.
Members Present: Anne Marie Skinner (Senior Planner/Development Team Leader), Brian Billingsley
(Planning Director), Robb MacDonald (Assistant City Engineer), and April Cabello (Planning Technician).
Members Absent: None.
III. Old Business:
A. Mr. Mapp approved the Minutes of the September 13, 2011 meeting as signed on
September 16, 2011 by Hearing Examiner Mapp.
IV. New Business:
A. Case Number SUP-349-11 a request by United Metals LLC for special use permit approval to
operate a metal/wrecking/salvage yard in an M-1 Light Industrial zone on property
addressed as 219 Main Street.
Testimony:
1. Anne Marie Skinner, Senior Planner/Development Team Leader, 621 Cleveland
Blvd., Caldwell, ID 83605, presented the staff report and submitted an aerial
map of the site labeled as PZ-1000.
2. Ms. Skinner reported on the uses surrounding the site. North of the subject
property is zoned M-1 and contains railroad tracks as well as another wrecking
metal salvage yard. Immediately to the south is zoned M-1 and is bare ground.
East of the subject property is zoned M-1 and is a warehouse for Caxton
Printing where they store their printing materials. West of the subject property
is zoned M-1 and that area also has a warehouse and auto body/repair shop.
3. Ms. Skinner stated there is no existing landscaping on the site. As part of the
special use permit approval it would require a landscape condition to place a
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing on November 9,2011 Page J 1
ten-foot wide street landscape buffer along the subject property's main street
frontage. The ten-foot wide landscape buffer would be a dry landscape buffer
consisting of two types of rock as ground cover and large boulders, one for
every 35 feet of frontage. Ms. Skinner further stated there are no parking
requirements because the use will not utilize any office buildings or structure.
4. Mr. Mapp inquired about employee parking.
5. Ms. Skinner explained that the parking ordinance ties parking requirements to
structures and buildings and there are no parking requirements for a
salvage/wrecking yard without a building. However, the property owner owns
the adjacent parcels to the south and it is feasible the employees could park in
that bare ground area. Ms. Skinner also stated that in an M-1 zone paved
parking is not required.
6. Ms. Skinner stated fencing will be required along the property's Main Street
frontage and is Condition of Approval 8.11 which outlines the fencing
requirement. This condition will have a minor change as per a letter of concern
that was submitted by Scott Gipson, president of The Caxton Printers LTD, this
afternoon.
7. Ms. Skinner read into the record the letter of concern labeled as exhibit PR-
3/PZ-1001. Ms. Skinner further read the proposed change to Condition of
Approval 8.11 and added a new condition 8.14 regarding limiting the height of
storage to no more than twelve feet for five days in a row.
8. Robb MacDonald, Assistant City Engineer, 621 Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell, ID
83605, addressed some of the concerns about the use and proper
infrastructure in place to reduce any contaminates that may enter the ground
or soil. Mr. MacDonald stated that he spoke with Pat Large on the phone and
they discussed that the development coming in is going to be on a concrete
pad, with proper drainage facilities,which will contain all the run-off for the 25-
year storm. Any other contaminates that run down with the rainwater into the
retention basin will be treated through sand and grease separators before
entering the storm drainage system. He further stated that in his opinion,
based on the design of the site and the facilities in place for the storm water, it
appears there will be no issue with contaminates entering the soil as long as
the work is being done on the concrete pad. Mr. MacDonald further stated that
he had told Mr. Large if there were any additional concerns he would be happy
to address them.
9. Mr. Mapp wondered if Mr. Large is at tonight's hearing. Mr. Large was in the
audience but did not sign up to speak. Mr. Mapp wanted Mr. MacDonald's
comments on the record because they addressed a concern by a citizen of
Caldwell —namely Mr. Large.
10. April Cabello, Secretary, swore in the applicant's representative, Kelly Kehrer.
11. Kelly Kehrer, applicant's representative, 391 W. State St., Boise, ID 83616,
stated his name and address for the record and acknowledged being sworn in.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing on November 9,2011 Page 12 e
He stated that staff has done a good job of presenting the project and the
issues at hand and his client is in favor of the additional conditions. He further
stated his client has taken extra precautions to ensure no contaminates can get
to the subsurface with the sand and grease oil separator and emergency baffle
system and the process of having all fluids drained from the vehicles before
being brought on the site.
12. Mr. Mapp inquired what type of vehicles would be brought to the site -
automobiles or trucks.
13. Mr. Kehrer responded the site will contain larger equipment like excavators.
14. Mr. Mapp confirmed that all fluids will be drained before coming on site and
no crushing of vehicles or storage of tires will take place on the subject
property.
15. Mr. Kehrer responded that he would let Rod Ekart discuss the operational
matters.
16. Ms. Cabello swore in Rod Ekart.
17. Rod Ekart, applicant, 2310 Chapaway, Eagle, ID 83616, stated his name and
address for the record and acknowledged being sworn in.
18. Mr. Mapp asked Mr. Ekart about storage of tires.
19. Mr. Ekart stated all tires will be taken off on the site, but they will not store the
tires for long periods of time.
20. Mr. Mapp asked if the tires would be stored inside or outside.
21. Mr. Ekart responded everything would be stored outside because there are no
buildings.
22. Mr. Mapp stated he would ask staff about the storage of tires and the impact.
23. Mr. Ekart stated they will have a dumpster for the tires and once the dumpster
is full, it will be taken to the landfill on Simco Road.
24. Mr. Mapp wondered about the dismantle process.
25. Mr. Ekart explained the property is to be used to tear down big equipment like
excavators, big cat machines, and that kind of machinery.
26. Mr. Mapp inquired about the noise impact.
27. Mr. Ekart responded it is not a noise impact.
28. Mr. Mapp wondered what they are using to dismantle the items.
29. Mr. Ekart responded they would use an excavator with a grapple and a cutting
torch.
30. Mr. Mapp inquired about the hours of operation being from 7 a.m. until 6 p.m.
31. Mr. Ekart responded those are unusually long hours, but wanted to state them
anyway just in case they do need to work long hours.
32. Mr. Mapp asked where the employees would park.
33. Mr. Ekart stated the intention is that the employees will punch in at the United
Metals site across the street on the other side of the tracks, but the employees
will walk to and work on the subject property. The employees will park at the
United Metals site and walk over to the other site as needed.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing on November 9,2011 P a g e 13 f
34. Mr. Mapp asked Mr. Ekart if they agreed with the fencing requirement as
described by Anne Marie Skinner.
35. Mr. Ekart responded "yes" they preferred to have a fence.
36. Mr. Mapp stated corrugated fencing is not allowed and wondered what other
type of fencing they would use.
37. Mr. Ekart stated that they would use the same material they use to build a
steel building.
38. Mr. Mapp responded that is corrugated metal and it is not allowed.
39. Mr. Mapp suggested Mr. Ekart work with staff for the proper fencing material.
40. Mr. Mapp asked Ms. Skinner about temporary storage of tires.
41. Ms. Skinner explained that the definition of a salvage/wrecking yard in itself is
a place that allows dismantling and temporary storage of any item that is on a
vehicle and is perfectly allowable under the definition of a salvage/wrecking
yard.
42. Mr. Mapp clarified with Mr. Ekart that they would be continually moving and
disassembling material during a week.
43. Mr. Ekart responded that a large piece of equipment takes awhile to take apart
and to dismantle and could not be done in a day. To dissemble a DA CAT could
take two weeks and it will take two or three DA CATS to fill a rail car.
44. Mr. Mapp asked staff to work with Mr. Ekart regarding fencing.
MR. MAPP CLOSED THE PUBLIC TESTIMONY.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for SUP-349-11: Mr. Mapp accepted the comprehensive plan analysis
as listed in the staff report.
Findings of Fact for SUP-349-11: The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as outlined in the
staff report, public testimony, and the evidence list consisting of the written and verbal staff reports,
the case file, the sign-up sheet, Exhibit PZ-1000 (aerial photo of the site submitted by Anne Marie
Skinner) and Exhibit PR-3 also labeled as PZ-1001 (letter from Scott Gipson, president of The Caxton
Printers LTD).
Conclusions of Law for SUP-349-11: The Hearing Examiner accepted the Conclusions of Law as
outlined in the staff report.
ORDER OF DECISION: The Hearing Examiner ORDERED that Case Number SUP-349-11 IS APPROVED
with conditions as outlined in the staff report, with a revision to 8.11, as well as one additional
condition:
8.11 An eight-foot high, solid and nonvision fence (example: 6-foot high fence on top of a 2-
foot high wall) that obstructs the clear view of the materials and operations of the
subject property from Main Street and neighboring businesses shall be installed along
the subject property's entire Main Street frontage immediately behind the ten-foot
wide street landscape buffer. The following fencing materials are prohibited from being
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing on November 9,2011 P a g e 14
used: boxes; sheet or corrugated metal; broken or decaying wood; broken masonry
blocks; sheets of plywood; cinder blocks; hubcaps; any other unsightly materials. The
fence shall be solid or nonvision; the solid or nonvision portion shall be no less than six
feet in height as measured from the ground on which the fence is to be placed; shall
completely obscure from outside view the use requiring site obstruction; and, shall not
consist of any prohibited materials. The Planning and Zoning Department shall perform
an inspection of the fence after installation for compliance with these minimum
standards. The inspection must be passed before a Certificate of Compliance will be
issued. No business operations shall take place until a Certificate of Compliance has
been issued.
8.14 Any stacking, piling or storing of materials or objects on the subject property shall never
exceed more than 12 feet in height for any period of more than five consecutive days at
a time.
V. Planning Issues—None.
VI. Adjournment
The Hearing Examiner adjourned the meeting at approximately 7:45 p.m.
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BY THE HEARING EXAMINER, M. JEROME MAPP, ON THE DATE NOTED
BELOW:
.. //_ a Ii,
, / /)L94.
ATTEST:
\4
- • e Map �'
IA ■ At
i , A lit ......._
‘,.,.. ..„„iii
Anne Marie 'N'nner, Senior Planner/ De -Iopment Team Leader Date
1
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing on November 9,2011 Page 15
e..- .\./\:i()-..
SIGN UP SHEET
Please print the following required information and
in the appropriate box check whether you wish to speak or do not wish to speak.
CASE NAME: t,LAv�,t\--e VYa_A w %-e, c_A ,. (
CASE NUMBER: SL - 3`(CI-I (
IN FAVOR NEUTRAL IN OPPOSITION
Applicant or Representative
❑speak El Do not speak ❑speak ❑ Do not speak ❑speak ❑ Do not speak
L, 41,1y. Kg
Print Nne Print Name Print Name
Print Address Print Address Print Address
-:-.,e'
r�-,�1 I�;) '3'\iL
Cif State, Zip City State, Zip City State, Zip
speak /'.I Do not speak ❑speak ❑ Do not speak ❑speak ❑ Do not speak
e-,li.-7--Print Name Print Name Print Name
21 614-,,,r
Address I Print Address Print Address
City State, Zip City State, Zip City State, Zip
❑speak 0 Do not speak ❑speak ❑ Do not speak ❑speak ❑ Do not speak
'3
rT-
Print Name Print Name Print Name
Print Address Print Address Print Address
City State, Zip City State, Zip City State, Zip
;229
.....�
it N
S U p - 349 - 1 1 , ,,,,,,..4-,,` -.:,- -.L-,T4(c..:--'"--A0 '
, --,--„,--,-....,_,-.-.b-_,,,..-.---,..--„--_,-- ,,,.. ./. ,r. , , ,...,,, „..4.i's'Ir".:4';
-, if , -=- `! _.....-- "',4‘`,":\ -,%-:-ftiltf-4.'-',*-7-i-,417.1,!:--„,4----, ,,,,,,,. --,;-,,,....- ,, .. '.;:„. i 4 ., .:-„,4,---- ...,...,Nk,- ;.-t-ft_ig',-'''''N,7 V.;::„-,7,---;,, ;',2'-'',I., ., :. .! '''''' 1, •ie.,it,..'4-,A4.,, '"likr
� �. t °� � �r � ;,tea "�' ,.� � � �` �'
Nsk...
i if
— p°sue 1,,�` u/ ,t .r`4' .:x-"i. r i r� d ` �; 4 '% '_" k 4 tv
.9 �,„ lij, .„,-..41,-,.....1\ - „ 4,,,,-,„,--rri,,,,,.. -\,,,,...„.4 ,, \ „F.., it.„_-__ ii.-. .,44...-/,,,s41
' t - ','/:';----'" ' i / '''"'I' '\":,' - <3.,:' '-'!•-• --1 ' "" \i':;,' ' g.' tg,--: -- -,-' ,,,,&-::"4,.,-7 --;--i.„-oks.,
. ' xx�» , \-.,:.•:„.# �``�.� qty S�7!,:'
L
� � � v, KIMSE�ST � �� �� +,- ,,,,-"\ '..w >- 3' r k,-17:-."-?.-17 4 `�' '► �'` /
�- J � fib' �Q� , 4�"<'sr
t� SIMPLOT BLVD \;
� u — �,, \VAS
J t'i'l,..)'.\</ \\\\- , 4*, "\-.:''''*\/', , .4' .‘-'1,,, __ '''--,
7\k/V". .`-:,,7,,,--,\: :,•-•iiiAs.- 41p,4
,::.„/„.��� „44.., "OP` s s. } ti° ”, PJ �� �. ,, ,:,;-,,,,-,_4 ,`'' .
A te . `� �"\ f '/" •�A , E e ~'Ns..? {,... l N , ' $ `, ,
�' ' 1--. ,`Silo �C , / ' ' 4.,` L� / f * \<'. C`/" \ :/' }, �� '� 7,•
�`�. J fg Y � ,-*// `, .�.'i< '-.'s Y �', `� N b id iv.:4',',..-,-- - '-‘1,-, --,.-A'N- - '-
.... ......---- 1 ()0
F ��- ,,,"V--NN-'-•-,\ -4-Legend _ pMEq
—Interstate —Rivers and Streams �'Taxlots „mw nom,.,o-,m,M., ,",.°,.,,,,,,,,,
Streets -----Ditches and Canals City Boundary ...ii. w N�a °Po a°avnOane'°'"`°'”°"`°'°°"'"° r"°E""""""°'°°"OR
<10(
Rail Road -Case No,.SUP-349-11 Impact Area '*-.- 'S °°"""s s""'"""` n°'°°""'°° `�° '" ""`°"tli°"°'
11/9/2011
To: Planning and Zoning- City of Caldwell Hearing Examiner
RE: Public hearing- Case # SUP349-11 concerning United Metals special use permit
request to operate a metal/wrecking/salvage yard on property addressed as 219 Main
Street.
The Caxton Printers Ltd. owns properties directly across from and adjacent to the proposed
metal/wrecking/salvage yard that is being considered at 219 Main Street.
Ours is one of the last office environments at the west end of Main Street in downtown
Caldwell. We have concerns about the impact that a metal/wrecking/salvage yard would pose
to our property values and to the business environment in which we have operated for more
than 100 years at our site. Additionally, the west end of Main Street, as it transitions from
Simplot Boulevard, is a significant entry point to the downtown Caldwell corridor that we have
all spent so much money restoring. Our concern is also for what the existence of a salvage
yard at that entry point might mean for future development of downtown Caldwell.
Despite these concerns we believe that the proposed special use of the property at 219 Main
Street can operate without undue negative impact to Caxton and the rest of downtown
business and future development should a few restrictions be placed upon the use of said
property.
United Metal currently operates a similar metal/wrecking/salvage yard about 200 yards on the
other side of the rail line and opposite our front door. Thus, we are well aware of the noise and
visual impact that is caused by the operation of such a facility in a downtown environment.
We have spoken with United Metal's Rod Eckart. He walked us around the proposed site and
answered many of the questions and concerns that we have about this project. He explained
his desire to erect a 6 ft. fence on top of a 2 ft. concrete wall thus shielding Main Street traffic
from the operation of the proposed site. He explained that United Metal's intent is to utilize
this second site (219 Main) as a site for demolishing large equipment for scrap metal and then
loading it onto train cars for transportation, not for long term storage of scrap metal. He
explained that the size of the "pile" should never approach that of the pile on the other United
Metal site and that, in fact, the addition of the 219 Main Street site should work to reduce the
size of the existing pile. After the meeting with Mr. Eckart we still had concerns but we walked
away trusting that Mr. Eckart's honest intention was to continue to work as a good neighbor in
the downtown area and to minimize any negative impacts that the 219 Main St. project might
create for those of us that currently operate businesses in the subject area.
Our concern however isn't with Mr. Eckart and United Metal's intentions. Our concern is with
the potential for future utilization of the property by future owners and users should the site be
approved without significant safeguards. In short-we trust United Metal and Mr. Eckart but
we cannot know who or what might occupy the site in question should United Metal choose to
sell or vacate the site at some future date. It is our recommendation that the proposed
special use permit be approved but with the following conditions of approval in place.
A: A fence/barrier that obstructs the clear view of the materials and operations of the
219 Main St. site from Main St. and neighboring businesses must be erected. The
fence/barrier must be at least 8 ft. in total height (example 6 ft. fence on top of 2 ft. wall
= 8ft.) and must shield pedestrians and automobile traffic in the downtown area from the
operations on the site itself.
B: Any "pile" of material on the 219 Main St. site may not exceed 12 ft. in height for a
period of more than one week at a time.
It is our belief that, with these safeguards in place, Caxton's businesses will not be significantly
harmed, our property values will not be significantly reduced, and the future development of
the downtown corridor will not be significantly impacted. It is our sincere hope that the
imposition of these conditions of approval will not represent a significant added expense for
United Metal and that the city of Caldwell will continue to benefit from United Metal's presence
and contributions.
We thank you for considering this request.
Scott Gipson
President
The Caxton Printers Ltd.
•
vamwet
.
.a nib,./( 11 A. G.
- ,,/a o A - g _
The Ticcr<,tfie al Uallcyrliii�t++,r
(4(----:" '__ �,- _ ere ib Otte'
;?, November 22, 2011
CALDWELL MAYOR' -,'
Garret Nancolos I United Metals LLC
P.O. Box 1219
CITY CLERK Caldwell, ID 83606
Debbie Geyer
RE: Case No. SUP-349-11 (United Metals Wrecking/Salvage Yard SUP)
COUNCIL MEMBERS
Dennis Callsen Dear Mr. Eckart:
Shannon Ozuna
Bob Sobba Enclosed for your files please find a copy of the above-referenced Order of Decision as
Jim Dakan approved by the Hearing Examiner on November 9, 2011. Please refer to Section 8 on
Rob Hopper Pages 6, 7 and 8 for conditions of approval.
Jim Blacker
Please note that I have enclosed an Application for Certificate of Compliance and
Application for Business Permit, both of which must be submitted to me prior to
, conducting any business on the site. Additionally, both a Certificate of Compliance
and a Business Permit must be issued before any business may legally take place on
PLANNING & the subject property.
ZONING_DEPARTMENT-
621 Cleveland Blvd.::: Please note the following as per Idaho State Code, Section 67-6519:
i.
bIdwell, ID 836Q'
The applicant has the right to request a regulatory taking analysis pursuant to
q" ' Section 67-8003, Idaho Code. Additionally, an applicant denied an application or
I � aggrieved by a final decision, or an affected person (one having a bona fide interest
V' ; in real property which may be adversely affected by approval, denial or failure to act
upon an application for a subdivision, variance, special use permit; or, approval of
an annexation; or, approval or denial of a rezone) aggrieved by a final decision,
may, within 28 days after all remedies have been exhausted under local ordinances,
' ` seek judicial review under the procedures provide by Chapter 52,Title 67, Idaho
Code.
H* If I can be of any assistance or if you have any questions, please call me at 455-4662.
- incerely,
1 (
A n = - ,�nn-
Senior Plan er/Dev- opment Team Leader
Enclosure
Cc: Case File
KM Engineering, Kelly Kehrer, 391 W. State St., Ste. A, Eagle, ID 83616
IDAHO. 100BEST 1::::-`3:,
HERITAGE-
CITY C MMUNITI6S
4 - AME 1CA
TREE an'us,
City Hall . 411 Blaine St. e P.O. Box 1179 ® Caldwell, Idaho 83606 6 (208) 455 3000 a FAX: (208)455-3003 6 www.c ty ujy,4 . m
ORDER OF DECISION
,k0if
BY THE HEARING EXAMINER
CITY OF CALDWELL, IDAHO
PUBLIC HEARING HELD NOVEMBER 9, 2011
Subject: Case No. SUP-349-11 (United Metals Wrecking/Salvage Yard SUP)
THE FOLLOWING LAND USE ACTION IS THE PRIMARY FEATURE OF THIS APPLICATION:
• SPECIAL USE PERMIT REQUEST FOR A WRECKING/SALVAGE YARD
TABLE OF CONTENTS:
I COURSE OF PROCEEDINGS
II GENERAL FACTS
III TESTIMONY
IV APPLICABLE LEGAL STANDARDS
V COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ANALYSIS
VI FINDINGS OF FACT
VII CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
VIII ORDER OF DECISION
I COURSE OF PROCEEDINGS
1.1 The Caldwell Planning and Zoning Department issued a notice of public hearing on application
SUP-349-11 to be held before the Caldwell Hearing Examiner on November 9, 2011. Public
notice requirements set forth in Idaho Code, Chapter 65, Local Planning Act, have been met.
On October 21, 2011 notice was mailed to all property owners within 300 feet of the project
site and to all political subdivisions providing services to the site; on October 23, 2011 notice
was published in the Idaho-Press Tribune; and, on October 27, 2011 notice was posted on the
site.
1.2 On November 9, 2011, the Caldwell Hearing Examiner approved the special use permit
request.
1.3 Files and exhibits relative to this application are available for review in the Planning and
Zoning Department, 621 Cleveland, Caldwell and at applicable public hearings.
II GENERAL FACTS
2.1 PROPERTY OWNER: United Metals, LLC, P.O. Box 1219, Caldwell, ID 83606.
2.2 APPLICANT/DEVELOPER/BUSINESS OWNER: United Metals, LLC, P.O. Box 1219,
Caldwell, ID 83606.
SUP-349-11 (United Metals Wrecking/Salvage Yard SUP) ;- . NIN
rt Page 1 of 8
ORDER OF DECISION ��
„)"\-\
2.3 REQUEST: The property owner/applicant/developer/business owner is seeking approval for a
special use permit for a wrecking/salvage yard located in an M-1 Light Industrial zone. The
subject property is located on the north side of Main Street and the south side of the Union
Pacific railroad tracks, approximately three hundred feet west of Fourth Avenue. The subject
property is located where Main Street dead ends and is addressed as 219 Main Street.
2.4 BACKGROUND: The subject property is currently bare ground. It was previously occupied by
the Land O'Lakes Purina factory until it was destroyed by fire and subsequently demolished.
2.5 LEGAL DESCRIPTION: A legal description for the site was not submitted and is not necessary
for this application.
2.6 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN DESIGNATION: The Caldwell Comprehensive Plan Map
designation for the site is Industrial.
2.7 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN COMPONENTS APPLICABLE TO THE REQUEST:
2.7.1 Land Use: The subject property is surrounded by the following:
The subject property is zoned M-1 Light Industrial which is suitable for the manufacturing,
processing, assembling, packaging or fabricating of previously prepared materials; research
and development activities; and warehousing.
The proposed use is allowed under the zoning ordinance with special use permit approval.
Direction Zone Comprehensive Plan Map Use
Site M-1 Industrial Bare Ground
North M-1 Industrial Railroad tracks and
Salvage yard
South M-1 Industrial Bare Ground
West M-1 Industrial Auto Repair/Storage
East M-1 Industrial Printing Warehouse
2.7.2 Transportation/Connectivity: The subject property has frontage on Main Street. One new
approach is being proposed in addition to the existing approach.
2.7.3 Public Services, Utilities and Facilities: The engineering department, fire plans examiner,
building department, police department, Caldwell School District, Vallivue School District,
Idaho Transportation Department, Valley Regional Transit, Caldwell Lateral Irrigation, Pioneer
Irrigation and Union Pacific Railroad were all sent a request for comment on October 10, 2011.
The following comments were received:
Idaho Transportation Department Comments:
"The Idaho Transportation Department (ITD) has reviewed the referenced special use
application. ITD has no comment on this application. The land use proposal does not appear
to impact the State Highway System. If you have any questions, you may contact Matt Ward at
334-8341 or me at 334-8377." Dave Szplett
2.7.4 Landscaping: There isn't any existing landscaping on the site. As part of the special use permit
approval, the applicant would be required to install a ten-foot wide street landscape buffer
along the property's entire Main Street frontage. Within the required ten-foot width, the
SUP-349-11 (United Metals Wrecking/Salvage Yard SUP) Page 2 of 8
ORDER OF DECISION
following items would need to be placed: one boulder for every 35 linear feet of buffer area
and a minimum of 2 different types of rock ground cover. The required boulders and rock
ground cover may be grouped according to the landscape plan designer. The entire ten-foot
width must be covered with a combination of the two or more different types of rock ground
cover and the required number of boulders. The site plan indicates a rock garden but does not
give any specifications as to type of rock, number of boulders or placement of such.
2.7.5 Parking: The proposed use, without any office buildings or other structures, does not generate
any parking requirements.
2.7.6 Fencing: Section 10-02-07 of Caldwell City Code states that a wrecking/salvage yard may be
declared as requiring a sight obstructing fence. Given the subject property's frontage on Main
Street and existing businesses to the south of the subject property, a sight obstructing fence
shall be constructed on the site. Presently the site does not have any sight-obstructing fence.
The site plan indicates installation of a six-foot high solid wall corrugated metal fencing.
However, Section 10-02-07 prohibits the following types of materials for fencing: boxes; sheet
or corrugated metal; broken or decaying wood; broken masonry blocks; sheets of plywood;
cinder blocks; hubcaps; any other unsightly materials.
As per Section 10-02-07, the required fence shall be solid or nonvision; the solid or nonvision
portion shall be no less than six feet in height as measured from the ground on which the
fence is to be placed; shall completely obscure from outside view the use requiring site
obstruction; and, shall not consist of any prohibited materials.
III TESTIMONY BEFORE THE HEARING EXAMINER, NOVEMBER 9, 2011
3.1 Anne Marie Skinner, Senior Planner/Development Team Leader, 621 Cleveland Blvd.,
Caldwell, ID 83605, presented the staff report and submitted an aerial map of the site labeled
as PZ-1000.
3.2 Ms. Skinner reported on the uses surrounding the site. North of the subject property is zoned
M-1 and contains railroad tracks as well as another wrecking metal salvage yard. Immediately
to the south is zoned M-1 and is bare ground. East of the subject property is zoned M-1 and is
a warehouse for Caxton Printing where they store their printing materials. West of the subject
property is zoned M-1 and that area also has a warehouse and auto body/repair shop.
3.3 Ms. Skinner stated there is no existing landscaping on the site. As part of the special use
permit approval it would require a landscape condition to place a ten-foot wide street
landscape buffer along the subject property's main street frontage. The ten-foot wide
landscape buffer would be a dry landscape buffer consisting of two types of rock as ground
cover and large boulders, one for every 35 feet of frontage. Ms. Skinner further stated there
are no parking requirements because the use will not utilize any office buildings or structure.
3.4 Mr. Mapp inquired about employee parking.
3.5 Ms. Skinner explained that the parking ordinance ties parking requirements to structures and
buildings and there are no parking requirements for a salvage/wrecking yard without a
building. However, the property owner owns the adjacent parcels to the south and it is feasible
the employees could park in that bare ground area. Ms. Skinner also stated that in an M-1
zone paved parking is not required.
3.6 Ms. Skinner stated fencing will be required along the property's Main Street frontage and is
Condition of Approval 8.11 which outlines the fencing requirement. This condition will have a
minor change as per a letter of concern that was submitted by Scott Gipson, president of The
Caxton Printers LTD, this afternoon.
3.7 Ms. Skinner read into the record the letter of concern labeled as exhibit PR-3/PZ-1001. Ms.
Skinner further read the proposed change to Condition of Approval 8.11 and added a new
SUP-349-11 (United Metals Wrecking/Salvage Yard SUP) Page 3 of 8 L
ORDER OF DECISION9.;
condition 8.14 regarding limiting the height of storage to no more than twelve feet for five days
in a row.
3.8 Robb MacDonald, Assistant City Engineer, 621 Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell, ID 83605,
addressed some of the concerns about the use and proper infrastructure in place to reduce
any contaminates that may enter the ground or soil. Mr. MacDonald stated that he spoke with
Pat Large on the phone and they discussed that the development coming in is going to be on
a concrete pad, with proper drainage facilities, which will contain all the run-off for the 25-year
storm. Any other contaminates that run down with the rainwater into the retention basin will be
treated through sand and grease separators before entering the storm drainage system. He
further stated that in his opinion, based on the design of the site and the facilities in place for
the storm water, it appears there will be no issue with contaminates entering the soil as long
as the work is being done on the concrete pad. Mr. MacDonald further stated that he had told
Mr. Large if there were any additional concerns he would be happy to address them.
3.9 Mr. Mapp wondered if Mr. Large is at tonight's hearing. Mr. Large was in the audience but did
not sign up to speak. Mr. Mapp wanted Mr. MacDonald's comments on the record because
they addressed a concern by a citizen of Caldwell — namely Mr. Large.
3.10 April Cabello, Secretary, swore in the applicant's representative, Kelly Kehrer.
3.11 Kelly Kehrer, applicant's representative, 391 W. State St., Boise, ID 83616, stated his name
and address for the record and acknowledged being sworn in. He stated that staff has done a
good job of presenting the project and the issues at hand and his client is in favor of the
additional conditions. He further stated his client has taken extra precautions to ensure no
contaminates can get to the subsurface with the sand and grease oil separator and emergency
baffle system and the process of having all fluids drained from the vehicles before being
brought on the site.
3.12 Mr. Mapp inquired what type of vehicles would be brought to the site - automobiles or trucks.
3.13 Mr. Kehrer responded the site will contain larger equipment like excavators.
3.14 Mr. Mapp confirmed that all fluids will be drained before coming on site and no crushing of
vehicles or storage of tires will take place on the subject property.
3.15 Mr. Kehrer responded that he would let Rod Ekart discuss the operational matters.
3.16 Ms. Cabello swore in Rod Ekart.
3.17 Rod Ekart, applicant, 2310 Chapaway, Eagle, ID 83616, stated his name and address for the
record and acknowledged being sworn in.
3.18 Mr. Mapp asked Mr. Ekart about storage of tires.
3.19 Mr. Ekart stated all tires will be taken off on the site, but they will not store the tires for long
periods of time.
3.20 Mr. Mapp asked if the tires would be stored inside or outside.
3.21 Mr. Ekart responded everything would be stored outside because there are no buildings.
3.22 Mr. Mapp stated he would ask staff about the storage of tires and the impact.
3.23 Mr. Ekart stated they will have a dumpster for the tires and once the dumpster is full, it will be
taken to the landfill on Simco Road.
3.24 Mr. Mapp wondered about the dismantle process.
3.25 Mr. Ekart explained the property is to be used to tear down big equipment like excavators, big
cat machines, and that kind of machinery.
3.26 Mr. Mapp inquired about the noise impact.
3.27 Mr. Ekart responded it is not a noise impact.
3.28 Mr. Mapp wondered what they are using to dismantle the items.
3.29 Mr. Ekart responded they would use an excavator with a grapple and a cutting torch.
3.30 Mr. Mapp inquired about the hours of operation being from 7 a.m. until 6 p.m.
3.31 Mr. Ekart responded those are unusually long hours, but wanted to state them anyway just in
case they do need to work long hours.
3.32 Mr. Mapp asked where the employees would park.
3.33 Mr. Ekart stated the intention is that the employees will punch in at the United Metals site
across the street on the other side of the tracks, but the employees will walk to and work on
SUP-349-11 (United Metals Wrecking/Salvage Yard SUP) Page 4 of 8
ORDER OF DECISION {��
the subject property. The employees will park at the United Metals site and walk over to the
other site as needed.
3.34 Mr. Mapp asked Mr. Ekart if they agreed with the fencing requirement as described by Anne
Marie Skinner.
3.35 Mr. Ekart responded "yes" they preferred to have a fence.
3.36 Mr. Mapp stated corrugated fencing is not allowed and wondered what other type of fencing
they would use.
3.37 Mr. Ekart stated that they would use the same material they use to build a steel building.
3.38 Mr. Mapp responded that is corrugated metal and it is not allowed.
3.39 Mr. Mapp suggested Mr. Ekart work with staff for the proper fencing material.
3.40 Mr. Mapp asked Ms. Skinner about temporary storage of tires.
3.41 Ms. Skinner explained that the definition of a salvage/wrecking yard in itself is a place that
allows dismantling and temporary storage of any item that is on a vehicle and is perfectly
allowable under the definition of a salvage/wrecking yard.
3.42 Mr. Mapp clarified with Mr. Ekart that they would be continually moving and disassembling
material during a week.
3.43 Mr. Ekart responded that a large piece of equipment takes awhile to take apart and to
dismantle and could not be done in a day. To dissemble a DA CAT could take two weeks and
it will take two or three DA CATS to fill a rail car.
3.44 Mr. Mapp asked staff to work with Mr. Ekart regarding fencing.
IV APPLICABLE LEGAL STANDARDS
4.1 City of Caldwell Zoning Ordinance No. 1451, as amended
4.2 City of Caldwell Comprehensive Plan, as amended
4.3 Idaho Code, Title 67, Chapter 65, Local Planning Act
V COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ANALYSIS
The Caldwell Hearing Examiner accepts the Comprehensive Plan Components as listed
below.
5.1 The proposed project is consistent with the following Comprehensive Plan Components:
GOALS AND POLICIES — Property Rights
Goal 1: Ensure that land use policies, restrictions, conditions and fees do not violate
private property rights, adversely impact property values or create unnecessary
technical limitations on the use of the property.
Policy 1-2: Identify potential takings of private property prior to a regulatory or administrative
action on specific property.
GOALS AND POLICIES — School Facilities &Transportation
Goal 1: Provide on-going opportunity for school representatives of Caldwell and
Vallivue School Districts to participate in the community planning process.
GOALS AND POLICIES — Economic Development
Policy 1-3: Encourage development that generates new job opportunity.
Policy 3-3: Promote economic development growth that is sustainable, environmentally
SUP-349-11 (United Metals Wrecking/Salvage Yard SUP) Page 5 of 8
ORDER OF DECISION 2'14
manageable, that will assist in maintaining the City's fiscal stability, and that will reduce the
need for residents to commute out of the City.
Goal 6: Recognize and promote the importance of retaining and attracting basic
industries to Caldwell.
GOALS AND POLICIES — Land Use
Goal 1: Establish land-use management policies that protect property rights and the
environment, maintain a high quality of life, provide adequate land for all types of
development, and adequately buffer non-compatible uses.
Policy 1-1: Guide the growth and development of land uses in such a way that the health,
safety, and general welfare of residents will be protected.
5.2 The request was not found to be inconsistent with any portion of the Comprehensive Plan
Components.
All adopted city ordinances, standards and codes were used in evaluating the
application. The proposed use is conditionally permitted by the terms of the ordinance,
is subject to conditions of approval, does not cause any damage, hazard, nuisance or
other detriment to persons or properties in the vicinity and is not in conflict with the
comprehensive plan. Based upon these items, staff recommends approval of the
special use permit request for operation of a wrecking/salvage yard.
VI FINDINGS OF FACT
6.1 The Caldwell Hearing Examiner accepts the facts outlined in the staff report, public testimony
and the evidence list. All adopted city ordinances, standards and codes were used in
evaluating the application. The proposed use is conditionally permitted by the terms of the
ordinance and is subject to conditions of approval.
VII CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
7.1 The Caldwell Hearing Examiner has the authority to hear this case and order that it be
approved or denied. The public notice requirements were met and the hearing was conducted
within the guidelines of applicable Idaho Code and City ordinances.
VIII ORDER OF DECISION
8.1 Based on the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, the Caldwell Hearing Examiner hereby
orders that Case No. SUP-349-11, a request by United Metals LLC for special use permit
approval to operate a wrecking/salvage yard in an M-1 Light Industrial zone on subject
property addressed as 219 Main Street is approved with the following conditions of approval:
8.2 The specific terms and conditions placed on the Special Use Permit shall run with the land or
until such time as the Permit may be revoked, become invalid or replaced with another
approved permitted use or a different approved special use or the property is developed.
8.3 The special use permit shall not be considered as establishing a binding precedent to grant
other special use permits.
8.4 The special use permit is not transferable from one (1) parcel of land to another parcel of land.
SUP-349-11 (United Metals Wrecking/Salvage Yard SUP) Page 6 of 8
ORDER OF DECISION
8.5 A Certificate of Compliance shall be obtained prior to onset of any business activity. The
application for the Certificate of Compliance must be submitted within twelve months of the
signature date on the approving Order of Decision. Within twelve months of the submittal of
the Certificate of Compliance application for the wrecking/salvage yard, the Certificate of
Compliance shall be obtained. If the Certificate of Compliance is not obtained within the
required timeframe, the special use permit approval shall become null and void and another
special use permit approval will need to be received. A three-month administrative extension
may be granted by the Planning and Zoning Director, after completing the administrative
extension request form, allowing an additional ninety calendar days to obtain the Certificate of
Compliance.
8.6 The property owner/applicant/developer, and any future assigns having an interest in the
subject property, shall fully comply with all conditions placed upon the Special Use Permit.
8.7 No change(s) to any conditions of approval of the Special Use Permit, as approved, shall be
undertaken until the Planning and Zoning Director has reviewed the proposed change(s) and
determined whether or not the change(s) is substantial. If the change(s) is determined to be
substantial, the change(s) shall only be allowed if approval is received through the public
hearing process.
8.8 Any violation of the terms and conditions of the Special Use Permit shall be deemed a
misdemeanor and subject to the provisions set forth in Idaho Code, 18-113. Each day's
continued violation will be deemed a separate offense.
8.9 The property owner/applicant/developer shall fully comply with all provisions of the special use
permit ordinance Section 10-03-04.
8.10 A ten-foot wide street landscape buffer shall be installed along the subject property's entire
Main Street frontage and, contained within that buffer, shall be a minimum of two different
types of rock ground cover covering the entire buffer area as well as one boulder for every 35
linear feet of frontage area. The Planning and Zoning Department shall perform an inspection
for compliance with these minimum standards. The inspection must be passed before a
Certificate of Compliance will be issued. No business operations shall take place until a
Certificate of Compliance has been issued.
8.11 An eight-foot high, solid and nonvision fence (example: 6-foot high fence on top of a 2-foot
high wall) that obstructs the clear view of the materials and operations of the subject property
from Main Street and neighboring businesses shall be installed along the subject property's
entire Main Street frontage immediately behind the ten-foot wide street landscape buffer. The
following fencing materials are prohibited from being used: boxes; sheet or corrugated metal;
broken or decaying wood; broken masonry blocks; sheets of plywood; cinder blocks; hubcaps;
any other unsightly materials. The fence shall be solid or nonvision; the solid or nonvision
portion shall be no less than six feet in height as measured from the ground on which the
fence is to be placed; shall completely obscure from outside view the use requiring site
obstruction; and, shall not consist of any prohibited materials. The Planning and Zoning
Department shall perform an inspection of the fence after installation for compliance with these
minimum standards. The inspection must be passed before a Certificate of Compliance will be
issued. No business operations shall take place until a Certificate of Compliance has been
issued.
8.12 All existing and new approaches to the site shall meet City of Caldwell's standards and
specifications, including any required inspections and record drawings.
SUP-349-11 (United Metals Wrecking/Salvage Yard SUP) Page 7 of 8
ORDER OF DECISION /� i
8.13 The City of Caldwell's Storm Water Management Manual shall be adhered to for any
development on the site requiring a storm water plan.
8.14 Any stacking, piling or storing of materials or objects on the subject property shall never
exceed more than 12 feet in height for any period of more than five consecutive days at a
time.
CASE NUMBER SUP-349-11 WAS HEARD BY THE CALDWELL HEARING EXAMINER AT A
PUBLIC HEARING HELD NOVEMBER 9, 2011.
THE FINDINGS OF FACT, CONCLUSIONS OF LAW, AND ORDER OF DECISION WERE
ADMINISTRATIVELY APPROVED AND SIGNED BY THE CALDWELL HEARING EXAMINER ON
THE DATE NOT- % CAA .
..40,714r9) ,
M. ome app, -aring a'miner sA ,
Date Anne arie Skinne , l'or " anner/Development Team Ldr.
SUP-349-11 (United Metals Wrecking/Salvage Yard SUP) Page 8 of 8
ORDER OF DECISION �/