Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout05 Hearing Examiner I PLANNING AND ZONING/HEARING EXAMINER ITEM DATE SUBMITTED BY -PZ Z - - - j ,vg tr PZ-2 MINUTES (- (6 _ 1 PZ-3 SIGN-UP SHEET(S) r r_ l0_12___ PZ- f �I-- I 0-40R Pz- ----- � GpLDWEL �F tO MrAh• ---- , if" if 4d9 641A/a 0 ' 7 ir — 4"� ' ., J The Treasure of the Valley` " {� Caldwell Planning & Zoning Commission agenda for Public Hearing on CALDWELL MAYOR Tuesday, April 10, 2012 at 7:00 p.m., in the Community Room, Caldwell Garret Noncolas Police Department, 110 South 5th Avenue, Caldwell, Idaho. CITY CLERK AGENDA Debbie Geyer COUNCIL MEnnaElis I. Call to Order II. Review of Proceedings Dennis Collsen III. Old Business Shannon Ozuno_ David Clark A. Approve Minutes of February 14, 2012 meeting as signed by Chairperson Sholz. Jim Dakan Rob Hopper IV. New Business Jim Blacker A. Case Number OA-148-12 SUP-351-12 a request by the Caldwell Planning and Zoning Department to approve a Dog Park Master Plan and subsequent special use permit approval for a dog park at Rotary Pond Park. PLANNING & V. Planning and Zoning Issues, if any. ZONING DEPARTMENT 621 Cleveland Blvd. VI. Next Planning & Zoning Commission Scheduled Public Meeting Date: June 12, Caldwell,'ID 83605 2012. DIREfr°ra i., VII. Adjourn Brian Billingsley, RCP . Any person needing special accommodations to participate in the meeting should ",V 4V 4 ra contact the City Office at (208) 455-4667 prior to the meeting. I =st ` _ ,) ` " z Cualquier persona necesitando comodidades especiales para participar en la reunion debe F;&p - �� ,� contactar alas oficinas de la Ciudad o Ilame a (208) 455-4667 antes de la reunion. �rc 4'- C5l"y--mss +5 � F J1 v ��3 1Z. HER TA GE �E"'io 100BES Q ESER F cirr COMMUNMES 1 .m, MREE CITY IS! S AMERICA City Hall • 411 Blaine St. • P.O. Box 1179 • Caldwell, Idaho 83606 • (208) 455 3000 • FAX: (208) 455-3003 • www.cityof Il.c m CALG ,LL PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION MINUTES April 10,2012 I. Call to Order—Chairperson Scholz called the meeting to order for the public hearing at 7:00 p.m. II. Roll Call— Members Present: Ken Scholz, Ed Doty-Pomoransky,Dana Vance,Arvid Salisbury, Roger Page Disclosures and Conflicts of Interest:None Members Absent:None Staff Present:Anne Marie Skinner(Senior Planner/Development Team Leader); April Cabello(Planning Technician) Staff Absent: Brian Billingsley(Planning and Zoning Director); Robb MacDonald(Assistant City Engineer) Review of Proceeding—Chairperson Scholz announced the procedures for the public hearing. III. Old Business A. Approve minutes of February 14,2012 regular meeting. MOTION: Commissioner Vance SECOND: Commissioner Doty-Pomoransky Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. IV. New Business A. Case Number OA-148-12 SUP-351-12 a request by the Caldwell Planning and Zoning Department to approve a Dog Park Master Plan and subsequent special use permit approval for a dog park at Rotary Pond Park. Testimony: 1) Anne Marie Skinner,621 Cleveland Blvd.,Caldwell,ID 83605,Senior Planner/Development Team Leader,presented the written staff report and explained the dog park master plan as written, which included the location at Rotary Pond Park. Ms. Skinner further explained there are two cases being heard concurrently— one is a recommendation on the master plan which is recommending approval of the concept of a dog park for a final decision by City Council and the second is a special use permit request to have the dog park at Rotary Pond Park and that decision is made by the Commission. 2) Commissioner Vance wondered about the gravel parking area and wanted clarification that the entire dog park would be in an area that is already established as Rotary Pond Park. 1 P&Z Minutes 4/10/2012 3) Ms. Ski r confirmed that the white area south of the grass is an existing gravel parking lot which is currently utilized for Rotary Pond Park and will also be utilized for the dog park. Ms. Skinner further confirmed that the entire dog park would be an area already established as a park with existing grass and trees. The walking path will remain. 4) Commissioner Page wondered about funding. 5) Ms. Skinner explained the committee has a number of thoughts on fundraising. Ms. Skinner stated one of the committee members is a veterinarian and he is positive he will be able to obtain donations from fellow veterinarians. Additionally,brick pavers,benches and trees will be offered for sale for sponsorship.And, fmally,to establish the dog park the only thing that needs to take place is installation of fencing,posting of the rules and installation of a few sanitation stations. 6) Commissioner Vance wondered if a study had been done as to utilization of the current park. 7) Ms. Skinner responded no such study had been performed. 8) Chairperson Scholz wondered about what type of park Rotary Pond Park is. 9) Ms. Skinner stated the proposed area is just an open,grassy area. 10) Commissioner Salisbury wondered about security and policing of the area.He was further concerned about funding of the project and getting it started and then running out of funds prior to completion. 11) Chairperson Scholz wondered about the operations of the park,whether or not pitbulls could be present. 12) Ms. Skinner responded that types of animals are addressed in the rules and everyone has to abide by the rules.Ms. Skinner explained that dog parks around the nation are self-regulated and that she has been told that the types of people who bring dogs to dog parks are very well-behaved and law-abiding citizens and there have been no issues with violent dogs or breaking of the rules with any of the dog park administrators she spoke with. 13) Chairperson Scholz noted the dog park rules on page 5 of the Dog Park Master Plan and also wondered about enforcement and wanted to make sure they would be posted. 14) Ms. Skinner stated the rules would be posted. 15) Commissioner Doty-Pomoransky wondered if the committee had any discussion about the dog park's proximity to the gun range. 16) Ms. Skinner stated no one on the committee seemed to think that was an issue. This site was the most desirable out of all the parks in the city. Dog parks shouldn't be next to fire stations, large residential subdivisions/neighborhoods,schools and/or playgrounds. This area is not next to any of those things. 17) Commissioner Doty-Pomoransky wondered if there were any plans to construct restrooms. 18) Ms. Skinner responded that was part of the city's future master plan, but presently sewer is not available at this area and Ms. Skinner did not have a timeframe for restroom construction at Rotary Pond Park. 19) Commissioner Salisbury wondered about enforcement. 20) Ms. Skinner stated it's just like any other park, so enforcement would come under the Police Department. 21) Commissioner Page wondered if installation of the dog park would increase the amount of police officers. 22) Ms. Skinner stated she was told there would be no need for additional police officers if the dog park is installed. Dave Wright, who is over animal control, has been apprised of the plan and he did not indicate that an increase in force would be warranted. 23) Commissioner Vance wondered about the applicant. 24) Ms. Skinner stated the applicant is the City of Caldwell. 25) Commissioner Vance stated the park would ultimately become the responsibility of the City. 26) Ms. Skinner stated the City maintains the park now and that wouldn't change with the addition of the dog park. 27) Commissioner Vance stated more use of the park might actually clean up the park. 2 P&Z Minutes 4/10/2012 28) Comri. sioner Salisbury stated the price estimate is mostly items relating to human usage and is still concerned about fund raising. 29) Kellie Forman,21395 Chicago Street, Caldwell, ID, 83605, spoke in opposition of the application. She has the following concerns:the number of people this dog park will bring to the area;negative impact on homeowners and landowners and the ambience of the area and natural habitat;negative impact on the cows she pastures immediately adjacent to the proposed area;always been implied that the park is for sportsmen—bird watching,nature walks and fishing,considered wilderness and natural;children use this area for flying kites all the time in the spring time and summer time;people out there all the time;this is a busy park with fishing and walking dogs. The parking lot is not very big at all. People will stir up dirt because the parking lot is gravel. Infrastructure does not accommodate additional activity. There is only one port-a-potty to handle the entire pond. There is no lighting in this park. She laughs at the rules and regulations because there is no way to enforce those. Who is going to enforce those rules and regulations?There is no law enforcement in the area. Dispatch is confused as to whether it's city or county. Dog parks are a haven for disease. Dogs and people get mauled in dog parks. She is concerned with the noise pollution in the area and some dogs are skittish with noise, which will make them uncontrollable.The solution is Mallard Park although it is very far out. Another solution is Whittenberger Park which has a much better and larger parking lot which is paved. It also has a brand new bathroom facility. Ms. Forman pointed out the flooding areas and showed the remainder of the area that could be used as a dog park and that Whittenberger Park has no official designation, and that it's easier access to residents and tourists. 30) Commissioner Vance wondered about the"haven for disease"statement made by Ms. Forman and wondered if Ms. Forman had done any research regarding this issue. 31) Ms. Forman stated she had not. She had just discussed the issue with people who had experience with dog parks. 32) Chairperson Scholz stated that he thought Ms. Forman thought the dog park would be a detriment to wildlife in the area and that it would bring in an undesirable element. 33) Ms.Forman stated the undesirable element is already present. However, she is very concerned with the impact on the land. She stated Nampa's dog park is ugly and she is fearful that is what will happen here. 34) Chairperson Scholz stated maybe the introduction of another element would eliminate some of Ms. Forman's concerns. 35) Commissioner Salisbury felt Ms. Forman has a very valid concern with the cattle. 36) Gail Conway,21347 Chicago Street,Caldwell, ID 83605, spoke in opposition of the application.Ms. Conway stated she lives right next to Rotary Pond Park. She further stated her biggest concern is her privacy. Since Rotary Pond Park was installed,she has no privacy. A privacy fence was installed, but it only goes halfway down her property line. She lives alone and there is no supervision in that park and it's never patrolled.People are in the park all hours of the night.People already come and walk their dog there. Ms.Conway suggested Luby Park as an alternative location. She further suggested the area to the west of the proposed area that has a peninsula going into the pond. 37) Russ Foreman,21395 Chicago Street,Caldwell, ID 83605,spoke in opposition of the application. Mr. Forman wanted to stress the lack of policing of the area and further reiterated the amount of graffiti that takes place in the area and then has to get sprayed over with black paint. His main concern is darkness. With darkness there is crime. Policing is the problem. 38) Chairperson Scholz commented that it appears there are two issues and the first is about the lack of police enforcement to the area. The second issue is the location of the dog park itself. He feels the dog park will bring in more people to the area who might help with the problems going on there. Chairperson Scholz stated he will write a letter to the Mayor on Mr. Forman's behalf regarding the lack of policing in the area. 3 P&Z Minutes 4/10/2012 39) Com,-. .. inner Salisbury wondered if there was one thing that would make a difference to Mr. Forman in having the dog park located in the proposed location. 40) Mr. Forman stated a buffer zone would be a good idea if the park were to be placed in the proposed location. He further stated Whittenberger Park would be a better location or the area to the west of the proposed area where the peninsula is. 41) The commission held a discussion regarding the positives and negatives of the dog park's proposed location. MOTION TO CLOSE TESTIMONY:Commissioner Vance SECOND: Commissioner Salisbury Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Evidence List for Case Number OA-145-12 SUP-351-12-Consisted of the case file,the written and verbal staff reports,the sign-up sheets and Exhibit PZ-1000(aerial photo of the site submitted by Anne Marie Skinner). Comprehensive Plan Analysis for Case Number OA-147-12 SUP-351-12—MOTION: Commissioner Vance SECOND: Commissioner Page Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Findings of Fact for Case Number OA-147-12 SUP-351-12- MOTION: Commissioner Doty- Pomoransky SECOND: Commissioner Page Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Conclusions of Law for Case Number OA-147-12 SUP-351-12—MOTION: Commissioner Salisbury SECOND: Commissioner Doty-Pomoransky Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Recommendation on Case Number OA-147-12—MOTION:Commissioner Salisbury SECOND: Commissioner Doty-Pomoransky. The motion to recommend Approval Passed,with a majority voting in favor: Salisbury;Doty-Pomoransky;Vance; Scholz;and,one voting opposed: Page. Order of Decision on Case Number SUP-351-12—MOTION TO DENY: Commissioner Doty- Pomoransky SECOND: Commissioner Salisbury. The motion to Deny Passed,with a majority voting in favor: Doty-Pomoransky: Salisbury; Page; Scholz; and,one voting opposed: Vance. The special use permit was denied because of the nuisance and detriment that will be realized to the properties to the east if the dog park is installed in the proposed location. Applicant was advised to utilize either the triangular area in Rotary Pond Park to the west of the proposed location or Whittenberger Park as alternate locations or re-submit for the current location with an improved plan to address the dog-cow issue with the adjacent property owner to the east with perhaps privacy fencing and/or a buffer zone. V. Planning Issues— A. The next regularly scheduled Planning and Zoning Commission hearing is June 12,2012. VI. Adjournment The meeting was adjourned at approximately 8:35 p.m. MINUTES APP• (ED AND SIGNED BY CHAIRPERSON KEN SCHOLZ ON THE DATE NOTED BELOW: �- Kn Scholz G. ATTEST: ' , ', 1 �•' W V!'1111il■- Anne a 'inner, ,,rl aev. '.m Leader 4 P&Z Minutes 4/10/2012 SIGN UP SHEET Please print the following required information and in the appropriate box check whether you wish to speak or do not wish to speak. CASE NAME: Dog Park Master Plan CASE NUMBER: OA-148-12 / SUP-351-12 IN FAVOR NEUTRAL IN OPPOSITION Applicant or Representative ❑speak ❑ Do not speak ❑speak ❑ Do not speak ❑speak CI Do not speak r ! ,nu ,mi• y..iL -i-r )%(/i Print a'I, Print Name Print Name e 1,0 51. Print ddre Print Address Print Address City State, Zip City State, Zip City State, Zip speak ❑ Do not speak ❑speak ❑ Do not speak 0speak ❑ Do not speak '1114)C) )) ; I (10 (LA vc Pri Na 1� Print Name Print Name t9 \ � `C P, r(J � Cac-v •rint d ress,� Print Address Print Address 4 Li_14 ---7TC-111 g-T6c7 i i ti City State, Zip ity State, Zip ❑speak ❑ Do not speak ❑speak ❑ Do not speak 16..peak ❑ Do not speak i Print Name Print Name Print Name Print Address Print Address Print Address CA-elk&L � 7 City State, Zip City State, Zip City State, Zip `2 L-3 1 OA - 1 48 - 1 2 / SUP - 35 1 - 1 2 r 1 , ,, .i , ) 1, • Tr- t , ms• \ t r � ?3,, .. ��>, \t �•- t Vi= -----N , .. , 2, f., T. �. S t lh ‘,.' .-tam i � v a .a� ,ty �' t"."4".... •� s• 4 ti r +�T -------"- - --,4 ,--` i . `.., 1 "‹,-"" '', ' 1 ' lf[ -- '411t.',11.-,:..,;:,:p. b.,..--$;-,,: v.i.,-::;:--,;-..,„_;_l , : , , L,. r.,. : 1 , , u ear (JE. 9. :.r -g.,�,, •: . j 1 . i ,-, , : _,, . ,,4 ' , ..i* `, .■• .4s, ,''''`''ate < ;4 * ?T1' - /'s,.x ��E++ \.'•l iLilii 1 �� kt.S. M Yr . ; jr ELI‘j Jo:I ' *177.''';''''''e-.`...'14#4,..;•.'.*4:4‘L:: \rIA'''.. 401 , . ' . ; * " - , 4,---.9orr-r::--,-, N\\_:, *AI q,',,i ,000.0kvs,—,,,_...., .-40...„.4., ,,,,k, .. , .,, , ,.. Nks„,. I ,,,,,y1 „,..,:-.i,-1*, ..%,44)* 1 4*.4.4%.S.4 9. �� Q� JOHNSON LN I k n `l 14. - , „. : ..-...,4,4. /.. —.4,--"":--,-. ,./...,. '9'''''4:;)` "to'III',/,' tS �a t } rat r � : r ; 0 1 4. Legend °tLI"7 -s- DISCLAIMER IM Mended use s as a Interstate -Rivers and Streams Taxlots M alw�,aaoa r.P.a*.w.a A.wm.Wmww.w. or..,......, sQ np raouru ror mac wca ,ymc,mI maaw�P epraaenution arwarmy woaua -Streets ••^Ditches and Canals i City Boundary '+ 0.1•X aa,M.a ar,,�,�,r Ec::o.&`srya ouc wmR,rm.r:�sE op �� �" W E THE GTY OF CALCWEL SC � 4iJ same ASS WITH A,F LiS.anG axumesa resaons eGary brmeusamweolPFO Gaaeeu me ----Rail Road 0 Case No.OA-148-12 Impact Area s () 2 --i CO 0 RECOMMENDATION AND ORDER OF DECISION BY THE PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION CITY OF CALDWELL, IDAHO PUBLIC HEARING HELD APRIL 10, 2012 Subject: Case No. OA-148-12 SUP-351-12 (Dog Park Master Plan and SUP) THE FOLLOWING LAND USE ACTIONS ARE THE PRIMARY FEATURES OF THIS APPLICATION: • SPECIAL USE PERMIT REQUEST FOR CITY OF CALDWELL DOG PARK AT ROTARY POND PARK. • REQUEST FOR RECOMMENDATION OF DOG PARK MASTER PLAN. TABLE OF CONTENTS: I COURSE OF PROCEEDINGS II GENERAL FACTS III TESTIMONY IV APPLICABLE LEGAL STANDARDS V COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ANALYSIS VI FINDINGS OF FACT VII CONCLUSIONS OF LAW VIII ORDER OF DECISION IX RECOMMENDATION COURSE OF PROCEEDINGS 1.1 The Caldwell Planning and Zoning Department issued a notice of public hearing on application OA-148- 12 SUP-351-12 to be held before the Caldwell Planning and Zoning Commission on April 10, 2012. Public notice requirements set forth in Idaho Code, Chapter 65, Local Planning Act, have been met. On March 23, 2012 notice was mailed to all property owners within 300 feet of the project site and to all political subdivisions providing services to the site; on March 25, 2012 notice was published in the Idaho-Press Tribune; and, on March 30, 2012 notice was posted on the site. 1.2 On April 10, 2012, the Caldwell Planning and Zoning Commission recommended approval of the Dog Park Master Plan and denied the special use permit for a dog park at Rotary Pond Park. 1.3 Files and exhibits relative to this application are available for review in the Planning and Zoning Department, 621 Cleveland, Caldwell and at applicable public hearings. II GENERAL FACTS 2.1 PROPERTY OWNER: City of Caldwell, 411 Blaine, Caldwell, ID 83605. 2.2 APPLICANT/DEVELOPER: City of Caldwell, 411 Blaine, Caldwell, ID 83605. 2.3 REQUEST: The City of Caldwell is requesting approval for a Dog Park Master Plan, as well as special use permit approval for a Dog Park at Rotary Pond Park. 2.4 BACKGROUND: The Dog Park Master Plan was prepared by the Caldwell Dog Park Committee and presented to City Council at a public workshop held on February 6, 2012. Case No.OA-148-12 SUP-351-12(Dog Park Master Plan and SUP) Page 1 of 6 ORDER OF DECISION AND RECOMMENDATION 2.5 LEGAL DESCRIPTION: A legal description for the site was not submitted and is not necessary for this application. 2.6 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN DESIGNATION: The Caldwell Comprehensive Plan Map designation for the site of the special use permit is Public Open Space. 2.7 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN COMPONENTS APPLICABLE TO THE REQUEST: 2.7.1 Land Use: The subject property is zoned R-2 Medium Density Residential and is surrounded by the following uses: Direction Zone Comprehensive Map Use North County Industrial Bare ground South R-2 Public Open Space Park East County Public Open Space House West R-2 Public Open Space Park 2.7.2 Transportation/Connectivity: The subject property utilizes an existing street system. 2.7.3 Public Services, Utilities and Facilities: The engineering department, fire marshal, building department, police department, Canyon County Development Services, Caldwell School District, Vallivue School District, Caldwell Transportation and Brown Bus Company were all sent a request for comment on February 7, 2012. No comments were received. 2.7.4 Landscaping: This request does not generate any landscaping requirements as the site is part of an already-developed park. 2.7.5 Parking: The site is part of an already-developed park and, as such, parking areas already exist. III TESTIMONY BEFORE THE PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION, APRIL 10, 2012 3.1 Anne Marie Skinner, 621 Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell, ID 83605, Senior Planner/Development Team Leader, presented the written staff report and explained the dog park master plan as written, which included the location at Rotary Pond Park. Ms. Skinner further explained there are two cases being heard concurrently—one is a recommendation on the master plan which is recommending approval of the concept of a dog park for a final decision by City Council and the second is a special use permit request to have the dog park at Rotary Pond Park and that decision is made by the Commission. 3.2 Commissioner Vance wondered about the gravel parking area and wanted clarification that the entire dog park would be in an area that is already established as Rotary Pond Park. 3.3 Ms. Skinner confirmed that the white area south of the grass is an existing gravel parking lot which is currently utilized for Rotary Pond Park and will also be utilized for the dog park. Ms. Skinner further confirmed that the entire dog park would be an area already established as a park with existing grass and trees. The walking path will remain. 3.4 Commissioner Page wondered about funding. 3.5 Ms. Skinner explained the committee has a number of thoughts on fundraising. Ms. Skinner stated one of the committee members is a veterinarian and he is positive he will be able to obtain donations from fellow veterinarians. Additionally, brick pavers, benches and trees will be offered for sale for sponsorship. And, finally, to establish the dog park the only thing that needs to take place is installation of fencing, posting of the rules and installation of a few sanitation stations. 3.6 Commissioner Vance wondered if a study had been done as to utilization of the current park. 3.7 Ms. Skinner responded no such study had been performed. 3.8 Chairperson Scholz wondered about what type of park Rotary Pond Park is. 3.9 Ms. Skinner stated the proposed area is just an open, grassy area. 3.10 Commissioner Salisbury wondered about security and policing of the area. He was further concerned about funding of the project and getting it started and then running out of funds prior to completion. 3.11 Chairperson Scholz wondered about the operations of the park, whether or not pitbulls could be present. Case No. OA-148-12 SUP-351-12 (Dog Park Master Plan and SUP) Page 2 of 6 ORDER OF DECISION AND RECOMMENDATION 3.12 Ms. Skinner responded that types of animals are addressed in the rules and everyone has to abide by the rules. Ms. Skinner explained that dog parks around the nation are self-regulated and that she has been told that the types of people who bring dogs to dog parks are very well-behaved and law-abiding citizens and there have been no issues with violent dogs or breaking of the rules with any of the dog park administrators she spoke with. 3.13 Chairperson Scholz noted the dog park rules on page 5 of the Dog Park Master Plan and also wondered about enforcement and wanted to make sure they would be posted. 3.14 Ms. Skinner stated the rules would be posted. 3.15 Commissioner Doty-Pomoransky wondered if the committee had any discussion about the dog park's proximity to the gun range. 3.16 Ms. Skinner stated no one on the committee seemed to think that was an issue. This site was the most desirable out of all the parks in the city. Dog parks shouldn't be next to fire stations, large residential subdivisions/neighborhoods, schools and/or playgrounds. This area is not next to any of those things. 3.17 Commissioner Doty-Pomoransky wondered if there were any plans to construct restrooms. 3.18 Ms. Skinner responded that was part of the city's future master plan, but presently sewer is not available at this area and Ms. Skinner did not have a timeframe for restroom construction at Rotary Pond Park 3.19 Commissioner Salisbury wondered about enforcement. 3.20 Ms. Skinner stated it's just like any other park, so enforcement would come under the Police Department. 3.21 Commissioner Page wondered if installation of the dog park would increase the amount of police officers. 3.22 Ms. Skinner stated she was told there would be no need for additional police officers if the dog park is installed. Dave Wright, who is over animal control, has been apprised of the plan and he did not indicate that an increase in force would be warranted. 3.23 Commissioner Vance wondered about the applicant. 3.24 Ms. Skinner stated the applicant is the City of Caldwell. 3.25 Commissioner Vance stated the park would ultimately become the responsibility of the City. 3.26 Ms. Skinner stated the City maintains the park now and that wouldn't change with the addition of the dog park. 3.27 Commissioner Vance stated more use of the park might actually clean up the park. 3.28 Commissioner Salisbury stated the price estimate is mostly items relating to human usage and is still concerned about fund raising. 3.29 Kellie Forman, 21395 Chicago Street, Caldwell, ID, 83605, spoke in opposition of the application. She has the following concerns: the number of people this dog park will bring to the area; negative impact on homeowners and landowners and the ambience of the area and natural habitat; negative impact on the cows she pastures immediately adjacent to the proposed area; always been implied that the park is for sportsmen—bird watching, nature walks and fishing, considered wilderness and natural; children use this area for flying kites all the time in the spring time and summer time; people out there all the time; this is a busy park with fishing and walking dogs. The parking lot is not very big at all. People will stir up dirt because the parking lot is gravel. Infrastructure does not accommodate additional activity. There is only one port-a-potty to handle the entire pond. There is no lighting in this park. She laughs at the rules and regulations because there is no way to enforce those. Who is going to enforce those rules and regulations?There is no law enforcement in the area. Dispatch is confused as to whether it's city or county. Dog parks are a haven for disease. Dogs and people get mauled in dog parks. She is concerned with the noise pollution in the area and some dogs are skittish with noise, which will make them uncontrollable. The solution is Mallard Park although it is very far out. Another solution is Whittenberger Park which has a much better and larger parking lot which is paved. It also has a brand new bathroom facility. Ms. Forman pointed out the flooding areas and showed the remainder of the area that could be used as a dog park and that Whittenberger Park has no official designation, and that it's easier access to residents and tourists. 3.30 Commissioner Vance wondered about the"haven for disease" statement made by Ms. Forman and wondered if Ms. Forman had done any research regarding this issue. 3.31 Ms. Forman stated she had not. She had just discussed the issue with people who had experience with dog parks. 3.32 Chairperson Scholz stated that he thought Ms. Forman thought the dog park would be a detriment to wildlife in the area and that it would bring in an undesirable element. Case No. OA-148-12 SUP-351-12(Dog Park Master Plan and SUP) Page 3 of 6 ORDER OF DECISION AND RECOMMENDATION 3.33 Ms. Forman stated the undesirable element is already present. However, she is very concerned with the impact on the land. She stated Nampa's dog park is ugly and she is fearful that is what will happen here. 3.34 Chairperson Scholz stated maybe the introduction of another element would eliminate some of Ms. Forman's concerns. 3.35 Commissioner Salisbury felt Ms. Forman has a very valid concern with the cattle. 3.36 Gail Conway, 21347 Chicago Street, Caldwell, ID 83605, spoke in opposition of the application. Ms. Conway stated she lives right next to Rotary Pond Park. She further stated her biggest concern is her privacy. Since Rotary Pond Park was installed, she has no privacy. A privacy fence was installed, but it only goes halfway down her property line. She lives alone and there is no supervision in that park and it's never patrolled. People are in the park all hours of the night. People already come and walk their dog there. Ms. Conway suggested Luby Park as an alternative location. She further suggested the area to the west of the proposed area that has a peninsula going into the pond. 3.37 Russ Foreman, 21395 Chicago Street, Caldwell, ID 83605, spoke in opposition of the application. Mr. Forman wanted to stress the lack of policing of the area and further reiterated the amount of graffiti that takes place in the area and then has to get sprayed over with black paint. His main concern is darkness. With darkness there is crime. Policing is the problem. 3.38 Chairperson Scholz commented that it appears there are two issues and the first is about the lack of police enforcement to the area. The second issue is the location of the dog park itself. He feels the dog park will bring in more people to the area who might help with the problems going on there. Chairperson Scholz stated he will write a letter to the Mayor on Mr. Forman's behalf regarding the lack of policing in the area. 3.39 Commissioner Salisbury wondered if there was one thing that would make a difference to Mr. Forman in having the dog park located in the proposed location. 3.40 Mr. Forman stated a buffer zone would be a good idea if the park were to be placed in the proposed location. He further stated Whittenberger Park would be a better location or the area to the west of the proposed area where the peninsula is. 3.41 The commission held a discussion regarding the positives and negatives of the dog park's proposed location. IV APPLICABLE LEGAL STANDARDS 4.1 City of Caldwell Zoning Ordinance No. 1451, as amended 4.2 City of Caldwell Comprehensive Plan, as amended 4.3 Idaho Code, Title 67, Chapter 65, Local Planning Act V COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ANALYSIS The Caldwell Planning and Zoning Commission accepts the Comprehensive Plan Components as listed below. 5.1 The proposed project is consistent with the following Comprehensive Plan Components: GOALS AND POLICIES— Property Rights Goal 1: Ensure that land use policies, restrictions, conditions and fees do not violate private property rights, adversely impact property values or create unnecessary technical limitations on the use of the property. Policy 1-2: Identify potential takings of private property prior to a regulatory or administrative action on specific property. GOALS AND POLICIES—School Facilities &Transportation Goal 1: Provide on-going opportunity for school representatives of Caldwell and Vallivue School Districts to participate in the community planning process GOALS AND POLICIES— Economic Development Case No. OA-148-12 SUP-351-12 (Dog Park Master Plan and SUP) Page 4 of 6 ORDER OF DECISION AND RECOMMENDATION Goal 3: Create neighborhoods where citizens can live, work and play. Police 3-5: Encourage mixed-use developments. GOALS AND POLICIES— Land Use Goal 1: Establish land-use management policies that protect property rights and the environment, maintain a high quality of life, provide adequate land for all types of development, and adequately buffer non-compatible uses. GOALS AND POLICIES— Recreation Policy 1-1: Provide increased recreational facilities and opportunities for all citizens. Goal 2: Support public and private parks and recreation systems that promote healthy lifestyles by offering active and passive recreational opportunities. Policy 2-3: Encourage new public and private recreational features through the special use permit process. GOALS AND POLICIES—Tourism Goal 1: Expand tourism services throughout the city. Goal 2:Increase tourism opportunities. 5.2 The request was not found to be inconsistent with any portion of the Comprehensive Plan Components. VI FINDINGS OF FACT 6.1 The Caldwell Planning and Zoning Commission accepts the facts outlined in the staff report, public testimony and the evidence list as approved through a previous motion. All adopted city ordinances, standards and codes were used in evaluating the application. The proposed use is conditionally permitted by the terms of the ordinance and is subject to conditions of approval. VII CONCLUSIONS OF LAW 7.1 The Caldwell Planning and Zoning Commission has the authority to hear this case and order that the special use be approved or denied and the master plan be recommended for approval or denial. The public notice requirements were met and the hearing was conducted within the guidelines of applicable Idaho Code and City ordinances. VIII ORDER OF DECISION 8.1 Based on the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, the Caldwell Planning and Zoning Commission hereby orders that Case No. SUP-351-12, a request by the Planning and Zoning Department for special use permit approval for a dog park at Rotary Pond Park is denied because of the nuisance and detriment that will be realized to the properties to the east if the dog park is installed in the proposed location. 8.2 Applicant was advised to utilize either the triangular area in Rotary Pond Park to the west of the proposed location or Whittenberger Park as alternate locations or re-submit for the current location with an improved plan to address the dog-cow issue with the adjacent property owner to the east with perhaps privacy fencing and/or a buffer zone. Case No. OA-148-12 SUP-351-12 (Dog Park Master Plan and SUP) Page 5 of 6 ORDER OF DECISION AND RECOMMENDATION IX RECOMMENDATION 9.1 Based on the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, the Caldwell Planning and Zoning Commission hereby recommends to the Mayor and City Council that Case No. OA-148-12, a request by the Planning and Zoning Department for approval of the Dog Park Master Plan, be approved. CASE NUMBER OA-148-12 SUP-351-12 WAS HEARD BY THE PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION AT A PUBLIC HEARING HELD APRIL 10, 2012. THE Fl DI S OF FACT, CONCLUSIONS OF LAW AND ORDER eF DE ISION WERE ADMI F LY APPROVED AND SIGNED BY THE PLANNING ANI ZONI c �'HAIRPE`° .ON ON THE DATE �;� i j•� .. , t*Ak `-�� �'�4 ATTEST: \ , I . � Ken Scholz, Chairperson Date Anne Marie Ski'vne' e�for Pla"w Case No. OA-148-12 SUP-351-12 (Dog Park Master Plan and SUP) Page 6 of 6 ORDER OF DECISION AND RECOMMENDATION