HomeMy WebLinkAbout2015-11-10 HE Minutes r
i
CALDWELL HEARING EXAMINER MINUTES
November 10, 2015
I. Call to order—Hearing Examiner, Mr.Jerome Mapp, opened the meeting for the public hearing
at 7:04 p.m.
II. Review of Proceedings—Mr.Jerome Mapp outlined the procedures for the public hearing.
Members Present: Jarom Wagoner(Senior Planner/Development Team Leader);April Cabello (Planning
Technician); and Robb MacDonald (City Engineer).
Members Absent: Brian Billingsley(Planning Director).
III. Old Business:
A. Mr. Mapp approved the Minutes of the September 15, 2015 meeting as previously
signed by Hearing Examiner Mapp.
IV. New Business:
A. Case Number SUP-15-12 a request by Greg Strikwerda/All Parts Brokers for a special-use
permit to operate an automotive wrecking/salvage yard within the M-1 (Light Industrial)
Zone. The subject property is located at the southwest corner of Blaine Street and 36th
Avenue in Caldwell, Idaho.
Testimony:
Jarom Wagoner, Senior Planner/Development Team Leader, 621 Cleveland
Blvd., Caldwell, ID 83505, presented the staff report and stated that the
applicant is requesting special-use permit approval to expand his
wrecking/salvage yard located at 3607 Cleveland Boulevard onto the site.
The subject property is located at 0 Cleveland Boulevard, located adjacent
to the west of 3607 Cleveland Boulevard. The applicant has indicated in the
letter of intent, that if approved he plans on erecting an 8-foot fence around
the outer edge of the property.
Mr. Wagoner stated that the subject property currently is bare ground. The
applicant owns and operates All Parts Brokers, a wrecking/salvage yard
located directly east of the subject property. The intended use is for storage
and/or dismantling of vehicles on the site. There are not buildings currently
planned for the subject property. The property was rezoned to M-1 in June
of 2015.
Mr. Mapp wondered about any code violations, max fencing height and that
this application will comply with the requirements of Pioneer irrigation.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing on November 10,2015 a 1
Mr. 'wagoner confirmed that there were no code violation on this property
and stated that the applicant had already cleaned up old trees on the
property; also confirmed the max fence height is 8'.
Mr. Wagoner stated that they had received comments from Pioneer
Irrigation in regards to the rezone application. It addressed the easement
that Pioneer maintains for the Mason Drain and not allowing landscaping
within that easement.
Greg Strikwerda, applicant, 2813 S Indiana, Caldwell, ID signed in favor of
the application and gave supporting testimony.
Mr. Strikwerda stated that this is a good use of the land, better than letting it
sit vacant. He will open the fence between the two properties and expand
storage for vehicles. Mr. Strikwerda also stated that it will allow him to have
more inventories and hire more people.
Mr. Mapp wondered if he would place an 8ft fence around both properties.
Mr. Strikwerda responded yes and that there is already an 8ft fence around
one of the properties and they will replace part of an old fence and extend it.
Mr. Mapp asked what happens to the fluids after cars are taken in.
Mr. Strikwerda responded that they have a tear down bay with a 300 gallon
oil recovery system which gets pumped almost every month and the
antifreeze gets put into barrels and sold, the gas gets put into barrel and
used the for forklift and other equipment around the yard.
Mr. Mapp also wondered about the batteries.
Mr. Strikwreda stated they have one spot on the property for batteries and
Interstate Batteries comes once a week to buy all the batteries.
Mr. Strikwerda further explained they crush tires every two to three months.
Mr. Mapp confirmed they do not crush cars.
Mr. Mapp asked the applicant if they had read the staff report and if they
agree with all the conditions set forth.
Mr. Strikwerda responded yes he had read the staff report and he agrees
with all the conditions.
MR. MAPP CLOSED THE PUBLIC TESTIMONY.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for SUP-15-12(Special-Use):The Hearing Examiner accepted the
comprehensive plan analysis as listed in the staff report.
Findings of Fact for SUP-15-12(Special-Use):The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as
outlined in the staff report, public testimony,and the evidence list.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing on November 10,2015 P 2
Conclusions of Law for SUP-15-12(Special-Use):The Hearing Examiner accepted the Conclusions of Law
as outlined in the staff report.
ORDER OF DECISION FOR SUP-15-12(Special-Use Permit):The Hearing Examiner ORDERED that Case
Number SUP-15-12 IS APPROVED with the following modified conditions:
8.2-8.7 as written
B. Case Number SUP-15-13 a request by Lucus Hansen for a special-use permit to construct a mini-
storage unit facility within the M-1 (Light Industrial) Zone. The applicant is proposing to
construct a total of 768 enclosed storage units, as well as provide outside storage for RV's and
other vehicles. The subject property is located at the 5202 E. Ustick Road in Caldwell, Idaho.
Testimony:
Jarom Wagoner,Senior Planner/Development Team Leader,621 Cleveland Blvd.,
Caldwell, ID 83605, presented the staff report and testified that the applicant is
seeking approval for special-use permit to construct a mini-storage facility.The
applicant is proposing to construct a total of 768 enclosed storage units,as well as
provide outside storage for RV's and other vehicles.The applicant is proposing to
construct the mini-storage facility in 5 phases.The first phase would contain
approximately 200 storage units.
Mr. Wagoner gave background on the site and explained that the property is
currently utilized as a trucking yard,for the storage of semi and other larger type
vehicles.
Mr. Wagoner shared that the original owner has requested an administrative land
division which was recently approved but has created a flag lot with an easement
to access Ustick Road.That affects two recommended conditions, 8.8 needing 13 ft
of right-of-way dedication from the applicant.
Mr. Mapp wondered about the setback from Indian Creek and what limitations the
applicant will have for storage items.Also the type of building material to be used
building the storage units.
Mr. Mapp also wondered if the parking lot would be paved,wondered if there will
be security, lighting,fire access and fire hydrants.
Mr.Wagoner responded there are no requirements in regards to Indian Creek;
however with construction fire will enforce the general fire conditions for the fire
access road and fire hydrants.
Mr.Wagoner stated to strike condition 8.9.
Mr. Mapp stated that one condition that is important to him is some kind of buffer
from Indian Creek to prevent any storage material from leaking into Indian Creek.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
3
Hearing on November 10,2015
Lucus Hansen, applicant, 14763 Willis Rd,Caldwell, ID signed in favor of the
application and gave supporting testimony.
Mr. Hansen stated that he had done a lot of research on storage units and looked
for the right property. Mr. Hansen stated that he feels this location is a good spot
with freeway frontage.
Mr. Mapp asked the applicant if the site will be paved.
Mr. Hansen responded that the parking lot and drive way will be paved;the
buildings will be prefab metal on concrete.
Mr. Mapp wondered about security.
Mr. Hansen stated that the property will be fenced all the way around with security
cameras.
Mr. Mapp wondered if there would be a resident on the site.
Mr. Hansen responded no.
Mr. Mapp asked if there will be lights on site and how will they be positioned.
Mr. Hansen stated not sure yet but will for sure have lights by the office and on the
units.
Mr. Mapp stated that no light is to be directed onto adjacent properties.
Mr. Mapp wondered about fire access.
Mr. Hansen stated that he will do whatever the fire chief tells him to do.
Mr. Mapp expressed the concern for the proper ingress and egress for the fire
department to get in and get out.
Mr. Mapp wondered about the type of storage.
Mr. Hansen responded just personal storage items, RV's and campers.
Mr. Mapp asked how many RV's storage sites.
Mr. Hansen hoped for a couple hundred RV and camper spots.
Mr. Mapp confirmed with the applicant that they wanted to have 100 RV parking
spaces and 768 storage units and will not allow anyone to conduct business out of
any storage unit.
Mr. Hansen responded no, if it's in code they will not.
Mr. Mapp stated it is not in code but wants to see it as a condition, no running
businesses from the storage units.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
4
Hearing on November 10,2015
Mr. Mapp asked the applicant if they had reviewed the staff report.
Mr. Hansen responded yes and stated that there is an easement that goes next to
Indian Creek which allows access for the other properties that he cannot build on.
Mr. Mapp stated that they need the requirements of the Bureau of Reclamation.
Mr. Mapp asked staff about the site obscuring fencing and that a 6'fence will not
screen an RV and maybe in some areas the fence should be 8'.
Mr.Wagoner responded that per code it calls out for certain types of uses where a
site obscuring fence maybe required. Mr.Wagoner read the fencing code 10-02-07
into the record and a 6ft fence is typical and can go up to an 8'fence if it was felt
appropriate.
Mr. Mapp wondered about the height of the storage units.
Mr. Hansen responded about 10' at the peak.
Mr. Mapp asked staff about the landscaping plan.
Mr.Wagoner responded that city code requires along a principle arterial to be 25
foot wide buffer along Ustick Road and a 30 foot buffer along 1-84.
Mr. Mapp wants to make sure there is a condition for continual screen with trees
and fencing.
Mr. Hansen stated he is confused why he needs a 6ft privacy fence.
Mr. Mapp responded it is a privacy screening fence so people do not see in on the
other side of the fence.
Mr. Hansen responded the reason why he purchased freeway frontage is so people
will see what's on the other side. Its advertisement, he wants people to see in.
Mr. Mapp asked the applicant if he will have signage.
Mr. Hansen responded yes a sign will be put up.
Mr. Hansen also expressed his concern about trees and the screening of his
property, he needs the advertisement of this business and the trees will hide that.
Mr. Mapp asked staff the purpose of the screening privacy fence.
Mr.Wagoner responded that city code calls out certain uses that must have
screening and privacy fencing and storage is one it calls out.
Mr. Hansen responded that if the city wants him to do all the landscaping and put a
fence to block all the landscaping, it just doesn't make a lot of sense.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
5
Hearing on November 10,2015
Mr. Hansen restated this is a good location for storage and the city still needs
storage because most of the current storage units are 90-100%full of capacity.
This is also a great source of tax revenue for the city.
Mr. Mapp stated his questions are what are Napping on the property and that is
why for all his questions.
Mr. Hansen responded he wants to build a storage unit for people to bring their
stuff they need to store. No businesses will be run from the storage units; it will be
just for storage.
Betty Adams, 1114 N 1St Ave, Caldwell, ID signed neutral of the application but did
not wish to speak.
Natalie Wilhite, Po Box 663,Caldwell, ID signed in neutral of the application and
stated that she is representing Betty Adams as a friend and a realtor/rental
manager for her property that is adjacent to the subject property.
Mr. Mapp asked what is on Ms.Adams property.
Ms.Wilhite responded that the property is 4.9 acres with a manufacture home and
a shop deemed at real property. Ms.Wilhite stated that Ms.Adams has applied for
a rezone of the property to light industrial and is trying to understand what is
happening and how it will affect her property.The people who live in the home
and have till March 2016 have voiced concerns about the safety of the ingress and
egress from Nelson Lane off Ustick. It is hard to see and part of it has been paved
and is deteriorating and needs to know if there will be some road work done by
Mr. Hansen.
Mr. Mapp asked Ms.Wilhite if Nelson Lane is a public right of way or private.
Ms.Wilhite responded it is private.
Ms.Wilhite expressed the concerns of Ms.Adams being fighting, noise, number of
people coming in and out and if that would affect her property.
Mr. Mapp asked staff where the egress and ingress was located and if it affects Ms.
Adams property.
Robb MacDonald,City Engineer responded stating that the ingress and egress to
the site is shared between Ms.Adams property and where the storage units will
be. Engineering did look closely at improvements that could be required on Ustick
Road and because of the physical characteristics of the road and because of the
overpass over the freeway,the overpass over the canal there really is not much
that can be done without a huge expense.The site visibility coming out of the
property to the left is limited but the short of it is there is nothing that can be done
on Ustick Road to mitigate this situation. It is not feasible to put in turn lanes or
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing on November 10,2015 6
widen Ustick Road because of the physical characteristics of Ustick Road at that
location.
Mr. Mapp asked Mr. MacDonald if there will be a controlled access that Ms.Adams
can utilize her property without being burdened with this new business.
Mr. MacDonald responded that Ms.Adams access to the property will be in
conjunction with the access to the new business. There will be no controlled
access on Ustick as it is a through road; no stop signs will be added except for
coming out of the property.
Ms.Wilhite wondered how far down the easement will the cars being going to
access the storage units.
Mr. MacDonald showed on the map about where the access will be for the storage
units.
Mr. Mapp confirmed the concerns of Ms.Adams is access,what is going to be
stored, noise and lighting.
Mr. Hansen gave rebuttal testimony stating that current access to the property is
not as small as it sounds;the current renter is bringing in 53'semi trailers with
their trucks in and out of the property all the time. They are already bringing big
stuff in and out and his business will not be bringing in big trucks. Lighting will not
be shining down on other people's property; it will be security lighting so if
someone is in the property then they can be seen running around on the property.
The lighting will be facing inside and down. As for the noise, it is a storage unit and
they are normally dead. People put their stuff in the storage and forget about. It is
not a business that will be running and the noise will be minimal.
Mr. Mapp asked the applicant if there will be a clause stating no repairs to be on
site.
Mr. Hansen responded yes.
Mr. Hansen also stated there will be no hazardous materials on site and no person
will be living on the site.
Mr. Mapp asked the applicant what size units he will have.
Mr. Hansen responded that he will start out with 12 x 24 split down the middle
making 12 x 10 units.They will have multiple sizes and smaller sizes.
MR. MAPP CLOSED THE PUBLIC TESTIMONY.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for SUP-1S-13(Special-Use):The Hearing Examiner accepted the
comprehensive plan analysis as listed in the staff report.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing on November 10,2015 n 7
Findings of Fact for SUP-15-13(Special-Use):The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as
outlined in the staff report, public testimony, and the evidence list.
Conclusions of Law for SUP-15-13(Special-Use):The Hearing Examiner accepted the Conclusions of Law
as outlined in the staff report.
ORDER OF DECISION FOR SLIP-15-13(Special-Use Permit):The Hearing Examiner ORDERED that Case
Number SUP-15-13 IS APPROVED with the following modified conditions:
8.2—8.7 as written
8.8 with corrections of right of way to total 53 feet from the property line
8.9 -strike
8.10—8.11 as written
Addition of the following conditions:
Mr. Mapp stated that Engineering is to work with Ms.Adams and the applicant so
no issues with egress or ingress.
Parking lot,egress and ingress is to be paved.
No storage of hazardous materials.
No auto repair on site.
Lighting has to be directed into the site and should not impact neighboring
properties.
Hours will be from 6am to 12pm,7 days a week
Must meet the Bureau of Reclamation requirements for Indian Creek.
No sewer,no water, no electricity.
No businesses on site,strictly for storage,
C. Case Number SUP-15-14 a request by Lucus Hansen for a special-use permit to construct 3 off-
premise signs (billboards) within the M-1 (Light Industrial)Zone. The subject property is located
at the 5202 E. Ustick Road in Caldwell, Idaho.
Testimony:
carom wagoner,Senior Planner/Development Team Leader,621 Cleveland Blvd.,
Caldwell, ID 83605, presented the staff report explaining that the applicant is
requesting to special use permit approval to construct 3 off-premise signs
(billboards)within the M-1 (Light Industrial)Zone. Each sign will be approximately
670 sq ft in size, 14 x 48 feet wide and spaced approximately 500 ft apart as
required by Idaho Transportation Department.
Mr. Wagoner further reviewed the use of the subject property being utilized as a
trucking yard,for the storage of semi and other larger type vehicles.
Mr. Mapp asked if there is distance requirement between each set of signs.
Mr.Wagoner responded that city code does not require a distance between signs
but it is his understanding that ITD does along the freeway and believes it is 500 ft.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing on November 10,2015 ' e 18
Mr. Mapp asked if comments were received from ITD and if 3 signs would be
allowed and what is the distance. Mr. Mapp wants to see a condition if this is
approved to meet the distance requirements of ITD.
Mr.Wagoner responded that condition 8.6 states that the applicant must comply
with all requirements of the Pioneer Irrigation District, and Idaho Transportation
Department.
Lucus Hansen,applicant, 14763 Willis Rd,Caldwell, ID signed in favor of the
application and gave supporting testimony.
Mr. Hansen stated that he was before the body 7 months ago asking for the same
billboard request.The reason he wants the signs is because it is a prime location
along the freeway for billboard signs and will boost more opportunity for him on
his property with the signs.
Mr. Mapp asked the applicant for the height of the signs.
Mr. Hansen responded 20 to 30 ft depending on the Sign Company and ITD. He
spoke with ITD but since they don't know exactly where the signs will be placed
they asked the sign company to contact ITD with the height and location once
determined.
Mr. Mapp wondered if the signs will be one face or two faced signs, lighting, paper
face or electronic.
Mr. Hansen responded they will be double faced, illuminated, paper signs.
Betty Adams, 1114 N 1st Ave.,Caldwell, ID signed in neutral of the application but
did not wish to speak.
Natalie Wilhite, PO Box 663, Caldwell, ID signed in neutral of the application,
marked to speak but left the hearing before this case was heard.
MR. MAPP CLOSED THE PUBLIC TESTIMONY.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for SUP-15-14 (Special-Use): The Hearing Examiner accepted the
comprehensive plan analysis as listed in the staff report.
Findings of Fact for SUP-15-14 (Special-Use): The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as
outlined in the staff report, public testimony,and the evidence list.
Conclusions of Law for SUP-15-14(Special-Use): The Hearing Examiner accepted the Conclusions of Law
as outlined in the staff report.
ORDER OF DECISION FOR SUP-15-14(Special-Use Permit):The Hearing Examiner ORDERED that Case
Number SUP-15-14 IS APPROVED with conditions:
8.2-8.6as written
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing on November 10,2015 i a 19
D. Case Number ANN-15-05 a request by Jacksons Food Stores Inc. to annex 6.70 acres, more or
less, with an H-C (Highway Corridor) zoning designation, and development agreement. The
subject property is located at 20078 Middleton Road,Caldwell, Idaho.
Testimony:
Jarom Wagoner,Senior Planner/Development Team Leader, 621 Cleveland Blvd.,
Caldwell, ID 83605, presented the staff report and stated that the applicant is
seeking approval for annexation of approximately 6.7 acres located at 20078
Middleton Road,the northest corner of Middleton Road and Hwy. 20/26 with an
H-C(Highway Corridor)zoning. The applicant intends to construct a convenience
store,with gasoline on the subject property,which is an allowed use within the H-C
(Highway Corridor) zone.The applicant has provided a photograph of what the
proposed convenience store will look like.See Exhibit PR-1.
Mr.Wagoner further explained that the subject property currently contains a
residential home and bare ground.The applicant intends to remove all existing
structures.The applicant is requesting access point on both 20/26 and Middleton
Road and the access point on Middleton Road will be as far north as possible due
to the configuration of the site. The temporary full access will be an agreement
with the applicant that as is deemed necessary by ITD or the City of Caldwell that it
can be converted to a right in, right out access.Staff is in support of granting the
temporary full access at this time.The applicant will have numerous conditions if
this is approved including improvements to Middleton Road,curb, gutter, sidewalk
and roadway expanding with a landscape buffer and landscaping along 20/26 to
include an 8ft side walk with landscaping on either side total of Soft.
Becky McKay,applicants representative, Engineering Solutions LLP, 1029 N. Rosario
Street Ste. 100, Meridian, ID signed in favor of the application and gave supporting
testimony.
Ms. McKay stated they are representing Jackson Food Stores on the annexation
application and the property is designated Highway Corridor on the
Comprehensive Plan Map and they are asking for a Highway Corridor zoning
designation.The property is an unusual triangular shape property with an existing
single family dwelling with some accessory buildings that will be removed.
Ms. McKay stated that there will be flood plain permits and flood way permits
required through the City of Caldwell for any work within that flood plain and no
construction will be allowed in the flood way.They do not intend on altering
Mason Creek or having any improvements in that channel which would trigger a
404 permit with the Army Corp of Engineers. Ms. McKay further stated that City
received a letter from Pioneer Irrigation District indicating that the facility is under
the Core and is under the Bureau of Reclamation control. Therefore they will
coordinate with any of the applicable agencies.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing on November 10,2015 10
ti Ms. McKay reviewed the services to this site and stated that there is an existing 12"
water main line that is located approximately 17,000ft west of the site out of
Colville Court and stubbed to 20/26. It is the intent of Jacksons to design that 12"
water main and extend it to the subject property.The conditions by the Public
Works Department says that they are required to extend the water main line along
the frontage at 20/26 and Middleton Road so that it can be extend to other
properties in the future.
Ms. McKay stated that based on the Franklin Sewer study update there is a sewer
trunk line that is located just northwest of the subject property but that is not the
designated trunk.The designated truck for this property is not within a reasonable
distance at this time.Jacksons has completed a civil engineering for an interim
septic community system to be located at the intersection and that design has
been reviewed and approved by South West District Health Department and a
permit has been granted. Ms. McKay stated that they have provided a copy of the
civil design and the permit issued by Southwest District Health to the City of
Caldwell.
Ms. McKay stated as far as the long range plan they will enter into a Development
Agreement with the City of Caldwell that at such time as central sewer is available
that the subject property will be designed so that it will be abandoned according to
Southwest District Health standard. It will connect to the central sewer and will pay
applicable sewer hookup and any late comer fees.The City has stated to them that
they will need to construct a 24" sewer line in Middleton Road for future
connection or a trust fund for the design,construction and installation of that trunk
line.All these provisions will be part of the Development Agreement so that they
are planning for the future for the eventual connection to sewer.
Ms. McKay stated that Six Mile Engineer did a traffic impact study and analysis
including a turn lane.The traffic study determined that mitigation improvements
will be required by the Jacksons Company as far as turn lanes are concerned.They
will be required to install a west bound right turn lane on Highway 20/26; they will
also be required to install an east bound turn lane into the access point located at
the furthest point from the property. Idaho Department of Transportation
submitted a letter stating that they have reviewed the application and it does meet
IDAPA standards and that they have no objections. Ms. McKay stated that the
design of these turn lanes will need to be reviewed and approved by ITD and a right
of way permit issued.Another turn lane will need to be installed off Middleton
Road into the site along with curb,gutter,sidewalk and lighting along Middleton
Road. An additional 48 ft from centerline of right of way will be required to
accommodate 35 ft from center line pavement section.
Ms. McKay further discussed the traffic mitigation fee and that they have reviewed
the figure and Jacksons has indicated that they want to meet with Robb Mac
Donald because some of the improvements that Jacksons makes to the site might
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing on November 10,2015 ` 11
qualify as system improvements that will be above and beyond what is required to
mitigate for the traffic so therefore may have some credit due to them and they
understand and accept this is a condition of approval.
Ms. McKay explained that this is a low site and will have to fill the site
approximately 5 to 6 ft,a retaining wall will be required, landscaping and sidewalk
will be along Middleton Road and Highway 20/26 Corridor.
Ms. McKay stated that all lighting will be LED,they will have recessed lights within
the canopy, and any pole mounted lights will be shoebox type lights.There will be
some sidewal mounted lights.
Ms. McKay stated that they will be meeting all ADA standards and they are in
agreement with staff s conditions of approval.
Ms. McKay further stated that this is a good project and a tough little site and
cannot think of any other use that would be more appropriate and asked for
support.
Mr. Mapp wondered about the high water table and the gas tanks.
Ms. McKay responded that the gas tanks will be located at the furthest point and
they are the latest design and they will meet EPA, IDWR and DEQ standards.
Scott Stom,applicant representative,Jacksons,3450 E Commercial Ct, Meridian, ID
signed in favor of the application and only wished to speak if called to do so.
Phil Andre, 11056 HWY 20/26,Caldwell, ID signed in neutral of the application and
asked if the annexation was continuous from the city to the subject property.The
reason he is asking is because the city wants him to give part of his land and he
feels this is the piece that they need to make it city to city, in other words
continuous and trying to find out if this is true.
Mr. Wagoner responded that the city did contact Mr.Andre in regards to an area
the city thought was prescriptive right of way located on Middleton Road. Mr.
Wagoner contacted the county assessor to find out if it was right of way. Per the
county assessor back in 2006-2007 they assigned this piece of land that had no
ownership to the nearest property owner whom is Mr.Andre. The city contacted
Mr. Andre about acquiring that portion of the property that the city thought was
right of way,which did not happen and contacted another property owner across
the street and will annex that portion of land along with the Jackson annexation to
provide the connection for the city.
Mr. Mapp confirmed that Mr.Andres property was not needed to be contiguous to
the city;they used another piece of property.
Mr. Wagoner confirmed.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing on November 10,2015 P 12
Mr.Andre stated they need to look into the water table very seriously because
when his neighbor irrigates his property floods.
Mr. Mapp confirmed that Southwest District Health, Bureau of Reclamation and
Army Corp or Engineers have a responsibility to verify.
Ms. McKay gave rebuttal testimony and stated that they are not annexing any
portion of Mr.Andre's property in order to be contiguous to the city limits.There is
prescriptive right of way of where Middleton Road exists. Mr.Andre indicates that
he has never dedicated the property nor has his family dedicated it but it is none
the less prescriptive right of way.The applicant has dealt with the level trust as far
as the prescriptive right of way in getting that point to point being contiguous. As
far as the ground water,the applicant had to do a test toll in order to submit their
design to Southwest District Health and the tanks themselves they are in a
concrete chamber,the tanks are attached and bolted into those chambers.The
storm drainage,the site is over sized for the c store use so in the event that they
still have to get the 3ft separation from the high seasonal ground water for their
storm drainage retention area,they have ample room for swell or well retention
pond.All drainage has to be retained on site because this is a commercial use.
MR. MAPP CLOSED THE PUBLIC TESTIMONY.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for ANN-15-45 (Annexation): The Hearing Examiner accepted the
comprehensive plan analysis as listed in the staff report.
Findings of Fact for ANN-15-05 (Annexation): The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as
outlined in the staff report, public testimony,and the evidence fist.
Conclusions of Law for ANN-15-05 (Annexation):The Hearing Examiner accepted the Conclusions of Law
as outlined in the staff report.
RECOMMENDATION FOR ANN-15-05 (Annexation): The Hearing Examiner RECOMMENDED that Case
Number ANN-15-05 IS APPROVED with conditions:
8.2—8.15 as written
V. Planning Issues—None
VI. Adjournment
Hearing Examiner Minutes II
Hearing on November 10,2015 1 13
w
The Hearing Examiner adjourned the meeting at approximately 9:10 p.m
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BY THE HEARING EXAMINER, M.JEROME MAPP,ON THE DATE
NESTED BELOW:
AA ATTEST:
/.J rome Map Date
Jarom Wagoner,Senior Planner/Development Team Leader Date
For detailed minutes,please request a copy of the digital recording.
Hearing Examiner Minutes _ ZF
Hearin g on November 10,2015 14