HomeMy WebLinkAbout2015-04-30 EMPLOYEE TRUST CITY of CALDWELL
EMPLOYEE BENEFIT PLAIT
TRUSTEE MEETING
HELD ON APRIL 30,2015
i
i
The meeting was called to order at 2:00 p.m.
Those in attendance: Monica Jones, EIJay Waite, Councilman Kopper (arrived later),
and Lois &Jessica from Mercer
DISCUSSION ITEM(S).
As of March 31, 2015, total assets were $1,425,698, total liabilities were $196,157,
and the fund surplus was $1,229,541. This Financial Statement was approved for
submission to the Department of Insurance.
Mercer presented and discussed the Experience Report for October 2014 through
March 2015.
Fund 84 expenses were reviewed and approved.
Fiercer will work with Monica to schedule the following presentati
MOVED by Waite, EC I EI y Kopper to journ at 3:55 p.m. The next trustee
meeting is tentatively scheduled for fuly 23, 2015 at 2:OOpm.
Those voting yes: Unanimous.
MOTION CARRIED
f
i
E
E
City of Caldwell Employee H altl�
V inan ial Statements
March 3132015
BALANCE SHEET
Assets
ash 1, 2 ,6
Receivables(Cobra r f` nd -
"I"otal Assets 1.14251698 }
Liabilities �
Accounts Payable
Claims JBNR 196,157
"r
Total Liabilities 1961157
Fund Surplus 15229,541
{
Total Liabilities&Surplus 11425,698
INCOME E STATEMi T
0clober 1,2 14 - March 31,2 1
Revenues
Employer Ilan Contributions 1,309,248
Employee flan Contributions 100,368
COBRA Promiums 95695
RX Rebate 251 1
Tom]Revenues 11421,822
Expenses
i
i
2
Actual Claims Fail 1,0653693
e
Annual Audit 4,500
t
f
Acimil Mali Adman Charges 2603798
7
[her Professi mi a.l Sera ie _ 543704
}
Total Expenses 1,385,695
Revenues over expenses 36,12
2
r
r
7
f
Jessica ShanleY
{
88o w Main Sheet,Sub 1258 #
Boise,ID-03702
MERCER +1208 333 0413
le slca,shanle MOrcer-cOm
Via ornall miones@cilyofealdwell.org
E
5
l
on1 a Jones, B.S.
Human Resources Director
City of Caldwell
411 Blaine
Caldwell, ID 03605
April 28, 2015
Subject: !DNP Valuation
Dear Monica:
At the request of The City of Caldwell Employee Benefit Plan Trust, Mercer performed an analysis
to determIno tine estlm ate d Incurred but not.paid IBNP of im Ilabi11ty for The City of Caldwell
Employee Beneflt Plan Trust's self-funded health benefit plan-as of March 31, 2016. TIlts letfer
ou(IInes our f Ind In s,the data we re cc Ived and reviewed, and tho ni eth odolog y used to derIve tha
results,
Results
The estimated I BN P and associated accruals for T lie Gi t of Caldwell Empl 0yee 13 en efit Plan
Trust h e a Ith benefits as of March 31 A 20 15 are as follows:
1 7,88 3- I N P for medical, preso ript'ron, dental, and v1sl oln banefits for Active E rnpl yees
and COBRA
,t - Estimated claims issued but not cleared the bank
24,065 -1 %Margin
11,661 Liability for Terminal AalminIstrative Foos
196P1 57 Total Liability
Data Received and l evtewed
Blue Gross of Idaho, Regence BlueShield of Idaho, and Delta Dental of Idaho provided data by
I on#h for of 'Ims incurred and paid October 2011 through March 2015. The lollowing claims data
and enrollment were proVided:
Cdloal benefits for Active Employees and those on. DIVA oontlnu. tlon
Prescription benefits for Active Employees and those on COBRA oontinu tlon
MARSH&MCUNNAN
aNSULTI N .our OURCIN Gy INVE STM ENT . COMPANIES
t
s
MERCER
i
i
Page
April 28s 2015
Monica Jones
City of calchyd
Methodology
In estimating the IQNP for medical, prescription, and dental benefits, Mercer used the
development method*This method uses previous pattorns of payments (number of months from
Incurred month to paid month)to estimate incurred claims from those paid to date. For the most
recent two or three months, the initial Incurred clalm estimates that aro produced by the
development method may Crary considerably from reasonable expectations. III such cases, an
expected value (based on prior months}costs trended forward) is blended with the initial incurred
amount f rom the development meth d.
The claims triangle data prepared by Regence Blu Shi id of Idaho is labeled as "paid.' The
defin1lion of`{paid"is a clalm that has been adjudicated by the close date for the end of the.month,
regardless of whether they have issued payment to the provider or requested The City of Caldwell
Employee Benefit Plan Trust to fund the claim. Therefore the estimated WNP inoludas an
estI mate-of the adjudicated but unpaid claims even though the .appear in the-olalm triangle as
"paid", This estim atGd adjudicated but unpaid clalrns amount i's equal t.o two invoices,for the tine
period of March Ord- 1 t In tine amount of$32,548,
Delta Dental of Idaho provided a Wrn data by month Incurred for claims paid through larch 201 S.
The ola irn lag tables prepared by Delta Dental label as"pasd"any claim that has been adjudicated
and included on a billing invoice, and where that Inv loo is paid within that month. Therefore,
there is no need to account for estimated olalrs issued but not cleared the bank.
As for the v1slon,incurred and paid information is una allabl . To estimate the outstanding
11abillt r, a factor of 1,4 war,applled to the average monthly paid claim 8 amount for the last twelve
months.
The estimated I BN P is a current st'l m ate of a flab!Iity for which ttie ultimate amount will be Known
only of ter 12, 1 B.,or even more months past the valuation date,We have considered the reed for
a margin for adve rse deviation froin the best estimate of I BN P based on the va rt ability of claims,
In r.1 Win th 9 effect of stop loss coverage on the ultimate not liability.W a have added a m ar in of
15 percent#or$24,065 to the a stirn ated unpaid-olalms for potential adverse devial lon,
lH& cN
COMPANIES
MERCER
Pago
April 28,2016
Monica gone
City of Caldviall
Certification
These al ula#ions wore prepared using generally accepted actuarial methods and p ro edures,
The information presented in this report is based on actuarial assumptions and reasonable
expectations,which represent our best estimate of andolp ted experience under the plans.
Tease note that all estimates, based on the hif r ation and data available at a point In
lire, re subject to unforeseen and random events. Vi r f r , any projection gust be
interpreted as ra lrr 11k l range of varlablllty from the estimate,
}
We are available to n er any questions on this materlal contained its this letter, or to provide
explanations or further details, as may be appropriate.
f
{
Sincerely,
x
Jessica Shanley
The information oontained in thla document meat(InOkidin any ttach ent Is not Intended by t r er
to be cased,and it cannot be used,for the purpose of avoiding enaltles tinder the Internal Revenue
Code that may be Imposed oil the taxpayer=
MARSH&MUENNAN
COMPANIES
}
e
1
i
}
r
5
4
i
3
3
s
7
o-
{
4
4
i
y
[T I
�bl
uu
Rogow
Fjj
:k
...........
"
n
ry
".b
l
-
--
rn
nM
::
non
Yi w v..
0..
- F
wmrymn#v .
AMW Y -.... =:
-
47-#ry
- -
- - u... �•. •
-
=:Y - ry:
...........
:=
� ry
..............
..........
............
-----------
�--�-
.......... ...........
- . ... :.. w
i
1
}
}
E
m > ;
_ , ,.. ;
m �.� 0
]] —� 0 > 0
co
0
� '^` r
,.. ',
7
CD
� �ic �+ �( BCD-*.oa C C �.
- - :y 0)
� � CD (D CD CD CD 0
C4.1 m LT ch — c
� CD c
0(� {li
� p-, C
CS
< (D
' co 0
U) 0 CD
(D
CL cL
M
cy
�..
•-=�
}
0- ( CL -Is CL
0 r-v : -4.1 71 (U a =1 c
0) It
,� �A.} U CD (,a (D
V/ �R i ;
In o [ ` - co C-
`
C•
D( .�
r+ -U -r � m 2
. ' ' t .
CD� (D
�ID
tz
PI �
P -
< .�-.
m N) CL crwo
n.CL :3 t .�
� (D BCD �, o 3 A-1- CD
CD 3 a- cn 0
i
CD CO C� CD 0 -0 u
rD {
0 w La '°
. 0 �
73 `T
-p -•W
W •, ,..,
-0 ( �
' 'wO W�' CD 0 0
T. a `-<
0 < fD ,
' 1 1
- 0
�'
(D 0 ,
"t
' j! m
(ID , +
•O
17 +
O r+ CD
b
pip CL
NMI
��
0
rn F*L
0 FA
ML
AA
P
-W
to
44
0 kin
m
01
Ul
OL
Xr_=ftl.........
pop,
FR M
+ +
n
fA
"13
is
.................
let I
In--- v -A
Y rye.
Ito
Me
0
Ol
+
0 -n (n
11�
000,
ni
u
M
0 Fib
Fe
kz'I
ul
C.)
ro
F
tog 99 9 9 Q m
..............
'IV
.. .........
.............
41
s
4
f
I
i
i
7
s
S
I
s
s
'r
c
r
b
i
}
i
c
c
f
I
I
1
1
f
e
c
I
e
i
r i i �+.� •Y�j .L+V� fk1 yam. S Vy 1 L�-kyR M1
CL
M sy}dam} # S.J 'V. V L+ .V .LJ iff
co
cm 1 1 1 Y/ n, �1'.-X �1.-7�. •__4 ■ �1 4A J .-k'.--k .--i -X .-�L y 1 '
.c®Y j
r �. m
WR V #
*#
ron" xs
OL
�ryk� :. dry¢
.. �4
v .. m .x -
CL
°. hV '� Y M
AA
x. p� v:t
f N all
`gam i
a _ f
E
s... "' `
on
ftn
i ■ _
co
smij
_1777 Af
7.
n..
} .
.::. [:-:'.:. :Y �...:.:
.: n = _ v
;wryry. Y
5: yY: n. v ca
cn
ed
MM
too
c� ?�_ � -��� ' ryry w"t�.
CA
n. ps
ryry �:.
ta
ilk
rn {
to 4
CO
AS
lot
<n he Ora
7.
.... x. : _ v.-. ..
_ dry.-:.: _
IRS T
4s ID
low
tz
w i-, [i.
'4012. J6,
CB
+ ; F !U4 Ul ? E ] [i} FJp7� {J1lk Vl a
lid Ut 011 4,
4
V+- I 7.
ZVI
ca ... dry:.
41 tv
�J
00
W
. j,) t om
t ,
C)
cn w t 4 cj\ 00
; + o
W . ,, t o '
(D a
C
U) C*
WN
coo 00
� . ,
c1
t
e
E
v _ }
LA ko
U) U) °`
ON
i
}
00
VA.x.a
tJ F
CY) Y
(D
C)
�b 0
p
lir
c-
m
4'
2A)
7
...... 4o I" PO
33
■ rqj
0 :0
fo
01% . C) C) �x
—P
co
wY
4s 4�k
u
..........
..........
.........
...... ........
7
77
....... ....
..... ........ ft�7
42
0 o .• * -�►�tF
Q)
4�O
(Ln
-.7. AM C)- co
(D
gill ......
V im 4
0 0)
..(YY
C)
C3
C3
T7 7=
...........
'7n
Z�
PO
0) �4-�L4 co
21 UI w Im co
Aco
77, .........
....... .......... ......
7. .......
J ..... S i
t -Go
4h
C)
sn ro 0)
CF) CD m 4 (ID (n
ro Ln
to 0
------- ---
..........
-)a ko 0)
4L
P, TO
0)
co
:7
777
OD
D
M%
pa rQ
C) (ZP 0
N ro ti -.0 0 0
C)
0
C:)
dk
7,:r
7,
7.
�.' ryti }
= ix : �:.t
M1+M1:drys.
VC IL
131 tm3l%'�:
7 0
q
-4GII U) Ira
f, ft kp
UN
P (oil
VM
Q (10
4P&
C)
.."R
CD
.'s
7"
(n
(01)
ow
L
0
_77.
r1a
01
ro.
_b� _Co-0) -4=mss:t l 40 n
03 co
(A
17%
7,
41,
0 C)
(7)
7.7
' Za .Q E
co
01
A 0_. CIO (a
S_
0
7% ......
v)
4w 0 11a 0
..... .....
tj-
(A
ro
_C) CIO
b o
0)
w
2.7.
.2.
X
.7. n?
60 V) (n
C3
0 0
Q fir.
71 Z-�77:
7,
7.1
1L f
.......
(too
(D (o
coot CjL) (D
TA
0
Ln
ul 0)
C)
7. 77
-.7
4V)
4w.
CD Oi C) 44 _L
ro )I
Al
........ 01
7 to
OD
0 CA w
Q).
A v I
cr) ......
.'7"
S
I
###
1
M
i
i
I
s
f
f
f
I
S
{
I
e
F
t
�€
I
i
i
x
'z
c
i
's
I
3
r
t
i
E
e
e
t
s
S
i
CD
-.2
Pm
..... 7-7.
07n.
CO
ni I tutyr
141
PR
his
N) R)
cy ---.L�J-L -L
-+ --L'-:�ff� CO
0 Go�_
01,
cr,
A4
00 nn
ITT
fill
ion:
7IZ—,
KI
HK ......
its
()0
R 1
too, L
xx
0
P14
"I fill
0
(3)
oil
�M1� a
Ln -I En
r
I
'-.'':�-�v i �.-µx' �'�.V x•.�ry kf lr�pr�Jy [
..........
own
..........
Ell
"no .-1--- ■ (D
Rio -1,-,A�
In Q.
-A ISO
NEW,
■ 4,n k
0 4�-
CO 0)
03
(WO J�k- �E=max J
-4
R
7.
E-1
T-
f
Zk
(3) IMP
CF)
Cr) M '-4
.1105 00 -
I,3 .-..
C)
C)
C)
0 0""14
(D
--V 0)
0� coo)
--- .......
KI: SO fig
ul
Mai
no 4A
-A
-& 00
(0 00 CO
4
b
• ;�.k -A J-, (n
4�,
-4
F
7 148
fill
13
2,-:04. L-4 1:- 0 10
OD
21
(.n
-A
-0
0-
A
7
112.
LO
(D. 0 p
-all T -I--
V(D
A
0
-Y11 lion:
■
07
...... ........
J1
-04
rQ TO
to .
16
(-n 4�%
p cr)
0
0
1M co 0)
0 '01 (0 t 00
_0
o.:
L
(y) to Gq
W
d
A
it fr LA,
C5
told AL CO
00 CD ro 00
CO
pa.+}.l
L .1
i
1�
I
y[
}
5k
2
{
I
i
I
J
i
c
Uj
G) i
i
Mimi
I
3
s
E
a
i
RAN
cf)
m
J)
(D 'a
- --I r
CD Ill Ell r
0 An, -10,
PO pa
to,
M
0,CD
—L - . znl
cno;0 R I-. --k
WL
U
4UI 4�,
cn I-�%
am En
7n
co PO 0 C) a
1 p
to P6 -L
M3
Pn 6 Q IF COL
C) 0
0 ro
'7
psi 1 ILI
zoo,
01
U)
A3
ro 01
ins
co
a
Qn.
u
07 W=
IA
ago
p.) PMO Mz:
PO
14 C:)
:-4 (D C)
u
c
Now 0)1 Z4
ml "4 L oo
p
P. 441�,J
�3 1-4 co 0 -4 410, ke
Cn
I Ir 4D.I(n
ZO.
0 0 C)
rO 41—
WP
W
C)
ED C) (3) 00
Uk
vow
vo
100
PO r%)
� � nv
Man%,
{
t
i
e
i
1�
L
f
i
� �
'e
t
t
f
{
1
i
i
i
i
i
{
i
i
I
i
i
i
iI
1
_ 1
nw ) ( m Sri 0 E� P�O a 0 0 0 0'D r-0 g
fit 0 0 0 0 can
CD
C3 C ' ' Co ' rl (7 0
�`#•
ON Ch ��..yy,,�� C, O {yam
� I.-� J 1-- Q—
C.71 J1 Ut J1 J a l J lJ1 LA l lti LA 1 U`l Jl l I `1 DTI lIl
0 CD
CN l!ti LA
o 00
;
o po w C> -A ' J)
t
{ , 0 0 0 0 0
rj
eo
CA
10 03�.' 0 0
Le
fo
16 , ' e W (+ #
cn ? cn C °p
' y
o A 0 � '
C-f �•f P r-) L Y Ni V 4 0 y 4•J , 2
cli
' C {D 0
oS [
0 # C [3 C i
P, C, 0 � 0 0
f
� �� q �
SJ f•1 �Y �K � Ld
e
tn
1
*-i
# 0
r
O
4�1 OIL 00 1J ►—' X11 ] 4 ►A 00 -�F{1 00 Ch 0 W VD loll
p
A.
r ! .J pa
-L-LJ•
{
a
s
3
}
s
t
5
}
a
5
e
e
i
i
I
t
E
vi
s'
e
i
e
r
i
?3 m r
o 0
r }
' i
_ ,
�F CL 0-(p -0 (D
( _ is �
/ (D �-. /y
/.. -0 OF 3
0 0 (D CD -:3 (D
' (Q=5
cr 0 73
fD U) (C)
. `' 0 .
ri (D
' �- 3 .
cr
0 CD
:3 U) 0 iU �ui
9: o
A (D 0 3 0- --1
i {D r _
0 CD
�.._ m (D '0 :3
L Cr CD � I C 0
051-n a c
CL 0
CD
cr
C)
�.
cry [ 0 a 0 ] r-t-
0 J qk -0
.0
(D €
D
N) (D
�.
� <D w 0
CL
k
0
(D 0�
_ cr m m s
CD
•
}
r+
N CD :7
0 cr
r-q,
(D ,
73 0
..
(D .i1 0
CD cn
D
"�, (D D
D
o
CLI(D
_
"(D 1 0 _
M 7
A o 0 7' a- T
' ~+( g: o0311)
Jt< (1) 0
� � [D s (D ;
.. Il � �
�I ( [D'
, - (D "N
� ll
� --
' a �" � �� .
=F C-L
0 20- W ' :5 --�,
BCD � y �U� � II �
�, j ,
BCD _ F Ca _
PD c ,
3 'D CD
O
tt 0 � 0) ) v o CL cr zr " `
-U
(n :3. 0 �, i
3 ,
�-- (D (D
kD
( >< f,PW- 1 z(D
0 CD a (p CL
- :3- �l 3 F
2
' c CD
m m CL (a =1 0 3
(D � CL
3 0 y -
.l
0 -'
0 CL 0 (D >C)
0
(D
! _
e
(D E
° - ..0� CD C
71
r� (v 0 w
0 ll< 0 -j
c ' }
( {
` ` � ' _0 0 (D
F mss,WIT
VA-
{ r-4' ,
? �.
(D
U5.
(D
�D
C7�
CD
A
cri
f�l
Q
00041 I
ff
1
I
r
i
's
f
7
i
e
e
t
e
1
}