HomeMy WebLinkAbout10-27-2014 CHPC MINUTES CALDWELL HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MINUTES
Meeting of October 2 , 2014 @ 6:00 PX
Caldwell Public Library— Idaho Room
1010 Dearborn, Caldwell, Idaho
I. Call to order. Chairperson Maughan called the meeting to order at approximately
6-00 p.m.
11. 111 Call
Members Present. Steve Maughan, Chuck Randolph,1ph, De Etta L. Ewing, and Elaine
Carpenter.
Members Absent. Lorene Oates and Megan Dixon.
Others Present. April Cabello, Planning Technician; and Brian Billingsley, Planning
Zoning Director and Rob Hopper, City Council Liaison
Others Absent. lone.
III. Approval of Minutes.
MOTION To APPROVE THE MINUTES of JULY 1 } 2014.
MOTION:: Chuck R. SECOND: Elaine C., MOTION PASSED.
111. Certificate of Appropriateness Interviews.
A. Case Number CA-07-14 request by Idaho Management Trust LLC, John
Hale and Mike DIV ttorio for Certificate of Appropriateness approval to' install
egress windows in the basement, replacement of all ground floor windows,
installation of storm windows and remove the failed wood fence surrounding
the backyard. The site is heated at 1704 Dearborn Street.
Testimony.-
Mike Dil ittortio, Idaho Asset Management, 1805 N. Tenth, Boise, ID, signed
in favor or the application and stated that IAMT LLC recently acquired subject
property from Fannie Mae. The home had previously been used as a rental.
It is in very rough condition, but is a beautiful house With great bores. We
are exploring options for end arse, but want to begin cleanup and upgrades
now. We intend to upgrade wiring, plumbing, flooring, cabinetry, and
windows. The hone has a classic steam heat system that we can preserve by
only replacing the boiler. It appears the basement was originally used as
servant's quarters and a great room with a fireplace. There is a set of
backstairs accessible from the back of the kitchen, and a set from the living
that goes to the great roan.
While really cool, the basement is unsafe due to lack of egress windows.
There are two staircases for exit, but we feel strongly that the bedroom
and the greatr om should have conforming egress windows to allow
fireman access. The ground floor windows are failed sing le hung wood
CHPC MeeLing, October 27,, 2014 Page I
7
windows. Most are not operable and all are energy inefficient. There is a
three foot high wood fence surrounding the backyard. The posts and
many of the pickets are rotted.
1r. DiVittorio stated that they are seeking the following permissions:
1. Install egress window in on the NE wall of the basement bedroom.
This would not be visible from Dearborn and would face the house to
the east. A window facing Dearborn is not practical due to porch.
2. Install egress window in Greatroorn in basement:
West side is preferable as it offers most natural light to the
basement and does not face Dearborn.
•
Alternative sites are east or west of the chimney on the north wall
facing Dearborn
3. Install new storm windows on all ground floor openings.
4. Replace all ground floor windows with energy efficient vinyl windows.
5. Remove the failed good fence surrounding backyard.
It is important that we start the egress windows before the
round begins to freeze.
Mr. DiVittorio thanked the commission for their consideration.
Chairman I aughan closed the public testimony.
Motion was made to approve with the following conditions;
Basement Egress Windows: nothing to show from the street, no bubble or
fancy window well to change the appearance of the house.
Ground Floor Windows: anything that preserves the appearance with
modern material is acceptable and staff is directed to review the window
design and product.
Removal of Fence: approved to remove fence.
MOTION To CLOSE TESTIMONY: Chairman Maughan SECOND:
Commissioner carpenter Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Findings of Fact for ease Number CA-07-14
MOTION: Chairman Vaughan SECOND: Commissioner Carpenter Passed:
Unanimous roll calf vote.
Conclusions of Law for case Number CA-07-14
MOTION: Chairman Maughan SECOND: Commissioner Carpenter Passed:
Unanimous roll call Grote.
CH PC feting, October 27, 2014 Page
Order of Decision for case Number CA-07-14
MOTION: Commissioner Carpenter SECOND: Commissioner Erring. The
motion for Approval was approved with unanimous vote.
V. Audience Participation. Randy Lyons, 1909 Fillmore, introduced himself and stated
his desire to be part of the Historic Preservation Commission.
111. Actions Since Last Meeting.
A. April C. reported that Case Number CA-06-14, Applicant: Stephen & Brenda
Fisher. Certificate of Appropriateness was issued for a Re-Roof of the house
and garage located at 1615 Dearborn. staff Level Approval.
B, April C. reported that Case Number CA-08-14, Applicant: Lee Sipes.
Certificate of Appropriateness was issued for a Re-Roof of the house located
at 413 S. 1 rn Avenue. staff Level Approval.
1111, old Business.
A. street side Mailboxes Update. Discussion was held and was continued to
the next CHPC meeting.
V111. New Business.
A. April C. presented the 2015 Historic Preservation Meeting Calendar.
IX. Commission & Staff Reports.
A. April C. requested to open a discussion of window replacement at 413 S. 18 1h
Avenue, asking for approval at staff level.
B. Chuck R. presented a list of properties that he would like to call attention to
since the last meeting of projects that have been completed: 1900 Fillrnore,
1 408 Everett, 1207 Dearborn, 308 B 17 1h 1716 Cleveland, 1510 Cleveland,
1423 Cleveland, 1501 Blaine, 1501 Cleveland, 1724 Blaine, and 1504
Blaine.
X. Meeting adjourned at approximately 7:36 p.m.
Respectfully submitted by April Cabello,
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BELOW BY CHAIRPERSON N STEVE MAU HAN
ON THE DATE NOTED BELOW.
'e 5 o- 2�
�j hm 0 e.� �q 1 Date
y
I or
li3
MG
ATTEST: Brian Billingsley, Planning Director Date
For detailed minutes, please request a copy of the digital recording.
CHPC Meeting, October 27, 2014 Page