HomeMy WebLinkAbout05-13-2014 HE MINUTESCALDWELL HEARING EXAMINER MINUTES
May 13, 2014
Call to Order — Hearing Examiner, Mr. Jerome Mapp, opened the meeting for the public hearing at
7:00 p.m.
11. Review of Proceedings— Mr. Jerome Mapp outlined the procedures for the public hearing.
Members Present: Jarom Wagoner (Senior Planner /Development Team Leader); April Cabello (Planning
Technician); Robb MacDonald (Assistant City Engineer).
Members Absent: Brian Billingsley (Planning Director).
111. Old Business:
A. Mr. Mapp approved the Minutes of the March 11, 2014 meeting as previously signed by
Hearing Examiner Mapp.
IV. New Business:
A. Case Number SUP -05 -14 a request by AIRGAS USA, LLC for a special -use permit to operate a
distribution center within a C -3 (Service Commercial) zone. The subject property is located
at 5318 E. Cleveland Boulevard in Caldwell, Idaho.
Testimony:
1. Jarom Wagoner, Senior Planner /Development Team Leader, 621 Cleveland
Blvd., Caldwell, ID 83605, presented the staff report as written.
2. Mr. Wagoner stated that the applicant is requesting special use permit
approval to operate a distribution center in the C -3 (Service Commercial) Zone
within an existing building and the site is surrounded by C -3 zoning.
3. Mr. Wagoner further stated that the applicant must meet current landscaping,
and signage code requirements.
4. Ryan White, applicant representative, 5318 E. Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell, ID,
testified in favor of the application and stated he is representing Airgas USA
and is requesting special use permit approval to re- occupy a building they
occupied for 7+ years, from a corporate standpoint 12 months ago they opted
to move out of this location and into the Boise market.
S. Mr. White stated that he came to Caldwell last April and started conversations
with his management group to re- occupy this facility. It was very apparent
when Airgas left this location the people in the surrounding community wanted
Airgas back in Caldwell.
6. Mr. White further explained that he has worked through internal Airgas
channels and got the corporate Airgas to accept his request to move back to
Caldwell and now is before the Hearing Examiner to receive approval to re-
occupy the facility.
7. Mr. Mapp confirmed Airgas is moving back into the same location.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing on May 13, 2014 P a g e 1
8. Mr. Mapp asked the applicant if they had reviewed and agrees with the staff
report.
9. Mr. White responded yes.
10. Randall J. Robertson, 15809 Canyon St., Caldwell, ID, signed in favor of the
application but did not wish to speak.
11. David Waddell, 5318 Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell, ID, signed in favor of the
application but did not wish to speak.
MR. MAPP CLOSED THE PUBLIC TESTIMONY.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for SUP -05 -14 (Special Use): Mr. Mapp accepted the comprehensive
plan analysis as listed in the staff report.
Findings of Fact for SUP -05 -14 (Special Use): The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as
outlined in the staff report, public testimony, and the evidence list.
Conclusions of Law for SUP -05 -14 (Special Use): The Hearing Examiner accepted the Conclusions of
Law as outlined in the staff report.
ORDER OF DECISION FOR SUP -05 -14 (Special Use Permit): The Hearing Examiner ORDERED that
Case Number SUP- 05 -141S APPROVED with conditions:
8.2 - 8.5 as written
B. Case Number SUB- 02(P) -14 a request by Howell- Murdoch Development Corporation for
Preliminary Plat approval of Sienna Hills Subdivision, Phases 3 -11, consisting of 75.6 acres
to be subdivided into 218 residential lots and 16 common lots in an R -1 Low Density
Residential zone. The subject property is located at the northeast corner of Indiana
Avenue and Orchard Avenue in Caldwell, Idaho.
Testimony:
1. Jarom Wagoner, Senior Planner /Development Team Leader, 621 Cleveland
Blvd., Caldwell, ID 83605, presented the staff report as written.
2. Mr. Wagoner reviewed the history of the subject property. Sienna Hills
Subdivision was annexed into the City of Caldwell in 2006 (SUB-141P-06/ANN-
114-06). The City Council approved a final time extension in June of 2011.
That time extension expired in June of 2013.
3. Mr. Wagoner further explained that the subject property is zoned R -1 (Low
Density Residential) with Low Density Residential designation on the
Comprehensive Plan Map. The preliminary plat calls for 218 residential lots
ranging in size from 8,000 square feet to 16,541 square feet.
4. Mr. Wagoner stated the applicant is proposing one new access on Indiana
Avenue and no new accesses onto Florida or Orchard Avenue. Originally the
applicant had proposed a connection to Orchard approximately 250 feet east
of Indiana Avenue. Staff felt it may be more appropriate to move that to
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing an May 13, 2014 P a a. e 12
Indiana Avenue where there would be more separation distance between the
intersection and new road.
5. Mr. Wagoner stated that staff recommends approval with conditions as
outlined in the staff report.
6. Mr. Mapp confirmed the changes to this plat are to comply with the current
code.
7. Mr. Mapp wondered if there were any increases or reductions of lots.
8. Mr. Wagoner responded that there was a reduction of the lot count and the
applicant can clarify.
9. Scott Stanfield, applicant representative, 826 3 r Street South, Nampa, ID
83651, testified in favor of the application and stated he felt Mr. Wagoner did a
good job recapping the history of the subdivision.
10. Mr. Stanfield also noted that the developer had installed several amenities in
the first 2 phases, pathways, clubhouse, swimming pool, basketball court,
active and passive landscaping.
11. Mr. Stanfield stated the developer will continue the same theme of
landscaping to the south as it is being developed.
12. Mr. Stanfield stated the developer is the same, different entity name but the
same partners who have no desire to sell this off to someone else.
13. Mr. Stanfield submitted a new site plan labeled as exhibit PZ -1002.
14, Mr. Mapp wondered about the neighborhood meeting.
15. Mr. Stanfield responded they held the neighborhood meeting and had no real
feedback or negative feedback.
16. Sheila Jantz, 13569 Paoletti Street, Caldwell, ID 83607, signed in favor of the
application but did not wish to speak.
17. Gary Lee, 4822 N. Rosepoint, Boise, ID 83713, signed in favor of the application
but did not wish to speak.
18. Jim Gucks, 15239 S. Florida Avenue, Caldwell, ID 83607, signed in neutral of the
application but did not wish to speak.
19. Cara Bruett, 15400 S. Indiana Avenue, Caldwell, ID 83607, signed in neutral of
the application but did not wish to speak.
20. Richard Matkin, 13739 Chrisholm Road, Caldwell, ID 83607, signed in
opposition of the application and submitted an aerial photo showing weeds
labeled as PZ -1003.
21. Mr. Matkin testified that his goal is to present information in opposition of the
application. Mr. Matkin expressed his concerns about deletion of a
requirement, requiring the placement of signal lights and problems with
weeds.
22. Mr. Mapp wondered if ITD was notified of this preliminary plat.
23. Mr. Wagoner responded yes but no response.
24. Mr. Mapp stated ITD would need to direct that a signal is required.
25. Mr. Matkin responded that the City made the promise with Sienna Hills No. 1
that a signal would go in.
26. Lucile Wills, 15287 S. Florida Avenue, Caldwell, ID 83607, signed in opposition
of the application and submitted letters and photos labeled as PZ -1004, PZ-
1005, PZ -1006, and PZ -1007.
27. Ms. Wills testified in opposition of the preliminary plat because when the
property sold, they leveled the irrigation ditches. All of the ditch was closed off
and have refused to allow them to have water. Ms. Wills stated that she tried
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing an May 13, 2014 P 3 g e 13
to work with Howell showing them the head gates and ditch. Ms. Wills also
stated that she pays water irrigation yearly but does not get water.
28. Mr. Mapp asked for documentation from Ms. Wills showing the water rights.
29. Ms. Wills stated she did not bring documentation showing water rights but that
the letter from her attorney stating they researched that she had the water
rights.
30. Ms. Wills stated that she was promised by the City of Caldwell Engineering
Department that they would not sign off on phase 2 of Sienna Hills because
they were out of compliance of not giving her water.
31. Mr. Mapp read the letter dated 2007 from Ms. Wills's attorney which stated if
the irrigation is not returned to its original condition within 10 days of this
letter the attorney will assume the developer is unwilling to cooperate and the
client (Ms. Wills) will be left with no choice but to take further legal action.
32. Mr. Mapp stated that was 7 years ago and asked Ms. Wills if she took legal
action.
33. Ms. Wills responded they tried to work with the developer.
34. Mr. Mapp stated this is a matter outside of his jurisdiction.
35. Ms. Wills responded that the developer is not in compliance of Sienna Hills
phase 2 for the City to sign off because they have not met the conditions of
putting the irrigation back. That is what the City of Caldwell Engineering
Department told her.
36. Mr. Mapp asked if that was a condition of approval.
37. Ms. Wills stated it was a condition per Jeff McFredrick of the City Engineering
Department. Per Mr. McFredrick the developer would be out of compliance
with phase 2 until that irrigation issue was resolved.
38. Mr. Mapp asked the City Engineer, Robb MacDonald to respond to Ms. Wills.
39. Mr. MacDonald stated he talked to Ms. Wills a few times and it is his
understanding that the applicant has proposed to put in a pipeline to provide
water. Mr. MacDonald further stated that happened in 2006. It is his
understanding now that there is a proposal to get that fixed and put in a
pipeline that will provide water and have an overflow that would discharge
back into the ditch.
40. Benny White, 15271 S. Florida Avenue, Caldwell, ID 83607, signed in opposition
of the application and testified that he resides next to the head gate of the
irrigation in discussion tonight and this head gate was put in by the irrigation
company to provide water to them. Mr. White stated that since 2005 when
they bought their property that ditch existed and they had water out of the
head gate but since the development it has been closed off and no water.
41. Mr. White also expressed his concern about the fencing and rear setbacks and
would like an easement and buffer zone.
42. Mr. Mapp clarified that Mr. White wants access to the irrigation line and wants
an easement to access the line.
43. Mr. Mapp asked staff if a buffer was required.
44. Mr. Wagoner responded no.
45. Charles White, 15271 S. Florida Avenue, Caldwell, ID 83607, signed in
opposition of the application and testified that he agrees with all the other
testimony and the weeds are bad and now have goat heads.
46. Mr. White further expressed his concern about the traffic and that most people
drive 50 -55 mph in a 35 mph zone.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing on May 13, 2014 P 3.1 e 14
47. Mr. Mapp wondered if they had talked to ITD or the Sheriff's office regarding
the traffic and speeding cars.
48. Mr. Mapp also stated he wants a condition added that the applicant must
maintain the property.
49. Mr. Wagoner requested taking a 10 minute break allowing the applicant the
time to review the documents that were submitted.
50. Mr. Mapp stated they would take a 5 minute recess.
51. Mr. Stanfield gave rebuttal testimony responding to the oppositions questions
and concerns about weeds, signal light, speeding and irrigation.
52. Mr. Mapp stated he is requiring the applicant to meet the requirements of ITD
because the city has no jurisdiction over that.
53. Mr. Mapp wondered how many phases are in this subdivision.
54. Mr. Stanfield responded 8 phases.
55. Mr. Mapp stated the applicant should meet with the neighbors before the next
council meeting to bring resolution.
56. Mande Vose, 15287 S. Florida Avenue, Caldwell, ID 83607, signed in opposition
of the application but did not wish to speak.
57. LeAnn White, 15271 S. Florida Avenue, Caldwell, ID 83607, signed in opposition
of the application but did not wish to speak.
58. Don Wills, 15287 S. Florida Avenue, Caldwell, ID 83607, signed in opposition of
the application but did not wish to speak.
59. Jerry Bartlett, 15317 S. Florida Avenue, Caldwell, ID 83607, signed in opposition
of the application but did not wish to speak.
MR. MAPP CLOSED THE PUBLIC TESTIMONY.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for SUB- 02(P) -14: Mr. Mapp accepted the comprehensive plan analysis
as listed in the staff report.
Findings of Fact for SUB- 02(P) -14: The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as outlined in
the staff report, public testimony, and the evidence list.
Conclusions of Law for SUB- 02(P) -14: The Hearing Examiner accepted the Conclusions of Law as
outlined in the staff report.
RECOMMENDATION FOR SUB- 02(P) -14: The Hearing Examiner RECOMMENDS that Case Number
SUB- 02(P) -14 BE APPROVED with conditions:
8.2 - 8.11 as written adding conditions:
8.12 — Applicant shall meet the requirements of the Boise Project Board of Control based on
the letter submitted on April 24, 2014.
8.13 —The applicant shall meet the requirements of ITD regarding traffic issues.
8.14 — The applicant shall meet the requirements under city code regarding maintaining
weeds on the property.
V. Planning Issues — None.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing on May 13, 2014 P 3 g 2 15
VI. Adjournment
The Hearing Examiner adjourned the meeting at approximately 9:00 p.m.
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BY THE HEARING EXAMINER, M. JEROME MAPP, ON THE DATE NOTED
BELOW:
M. Jerome Ma Date
Jarom Wagoner, Senior Planner / Development Team Leader
ATTEST:
Date
For detailed minutes, please request a copy of the digital recording.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing on May 13, 2014
Pave 16