HomeMy WebLinkAbout03-11-2014 HE MINUTESCALDWELL HEARING EXAMINER MINUTES
March 11, 2014
I. Call to Order — Hearing Examiner, Mr. Jerome Mapp, opened the meeting for the public hearing at
7:02 p.m.
II. Review of Proceedings— Mr. Jerome Mapp outlined the procedures for the public hearing.
Members Present: Jarom Wagoner (Senior Planner /Development Team Leader); April Cabello (Planning
Technician); Robb MacDonald (Assistant City Engineer).
Members Absent: Brian Billingsley (Planning Director).
III. Old Business:
A. Mr. Mapp approved the Minutes of the February 11, 2014 meeting as previously signed by
Hearing Examiner Mapp.
IV. New Business:
A. Case Number SUP -01 -14 a request by Technology Associates for a special -use permit to
construct a wireless communications facility in a C -2 (Community Commercial) zone. The
subject property is located at 4007 S. Montana Avenue in Caldwell, Idaho.
Testimony:
1. Jarom Wagoner, Senior Planner /Development Team Leader, 621 Cleveland
Blvd., Caldwell, ID 83605, presented the staff report as written and submitted
exhibit PZ -1001 a revised site plan of the project showing the location of the
cell tower and showing the measurement of 120' -2" tower setback from the
property line to the east which was not called out on the original site plan.
2. Mr. Mapp wondered because of the changes to the site plan if there are any
changes to the conditions.
3. Mr. Wagoner responded there is one additional condition 8.8, the construction
of the cell tower shall be in compliance with the submitted site plan exhibit PZ-
1001.
4. Mr. Wagoner further stated that the subject property is zoned C -2 Community
Commercial.
5. Mr. Wagoner stated that staff recommends approval with conditions as stated.
6. Doug Kofford, applicant representative, 5701 S. Green Street, Murray, UT
84123, testified in favor of the application and stated he is representing
Verizon Wireless and is requesting special use permit approval to construct a
100 -foot tall monopole cell tower with 12 antennas located within the existing
Valley View Self Storage facility due to the current use of cell and smart
phones.
7. Mr. Mapp asked if all the antennas were for Verizon.
8. Mr. Kofford responded yes.
9. Dawna Jenkins, singed in neutral of the application but did not wish to speak.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing on March 11, 2014 P a � e 1
MR. MAPP CLOSED THE PUBLIC TESTIMONY.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for SUP -01 -14 (Special Use): Mr. Mapp accepted the comprehensive
plan analysis as listed in the staff report.
Findings of Fact for SUP -01 -14 (Special Use): The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as
outlined in the staff report, public testimony, and the evidence list.
Conclusions of Law for SUP -01 -14 (Special Use): The Hearing Examiner accepted the Conclusions of
Law as outlined in the staff report.
ORDER OF DECISION FOR SUP -01 -14 (Special Use Permit): The Hearing Examiner ORDERED that
Case Number SUP -01 -14 IS APPROVED with conditions:
8.2 - 8.8 as written
B. Case Number SUP -02 -14 a request by Technology Associates for a special -use permit to
construct a wireless communications facility in an M -1 (Light Industrial) zone. The subject
property is located at 203 N. 21" Avenue in Caldwell, Idaho.
Testimony:
1. Jarom Wagoner, Senior Planner /Development Team Leader, 621 Cleveland
Blvd., Caldwell, ID 83605, presented the staff report as written.
2. Mr. Wagoner further stated that the subject property is zoned M -1 Light
Industrial.
3. Mr. Wagoner stated that staff recommends approval with conditions as stated.
4. Doug Kofford, applicant representative, 5701 S. Green Street, Murray, UT
84123, testified in favor of the application and stated he is representing
Verizon Wireless and is requesting special use permit approval to construct a
100 -foot tall monopole cell tower with 12 antennas and 2 microwave dishes
located within a 50'x50' chain linked area at 203 N. 21`t Avenue.
5. Mr. Mapp wondered about the microwave dishes.
6. Mr. Kofford responded that the microwave dishes, if needed will be at a future
date.
MR. MAPP CLOSED THE PUBLIC TESTIMONY.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for SUP -02 -14 (Special Use): Mr. Mapp accepted the comprehensive
plan analysis as listed in the staff report.
Findings of Fact for SUP -02 -14 (Special Use): The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as
outlined in the staff report, public testimony, and the evidence list.
Conclusions of Law for SUP -02 -14 (Special Use): The Hearing Examiner accepted the Conclusions of
Law as outlined in the staff report.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing on March 11, 2014 F a g z 12
ORDER OF DECISION FOR SUP -02 -14 (Special Use Permit): The Hearing Examiner ORDERED that
Case Number SUP -02 -1415 APPROVED with conditions:
8.2 -8.7 as written
C. Case Number 2ON- 01- 14/SUP -03 -14 a request by Ida Properties, LLC and Ashley Manor for
a comprehensive plan map change from Low Density Residential to Medium Density
Residential; a rezone of 0.22 acres, more or less, from R -1 Low Density Residential to R -2
Medium Density Residential; and special use permit approval to operate an assisted living
facility for up to 13 beds. The subject property is located at 3123 Arlington Avenue in
Caldwell, Idaho.
Testimony:
1. Jarom Wagoner, Senior Planner /Development Team Leader, 621 Cleveland
Blvd., Caldwell, ID 83605, presented the staff report as written and further
noted the subject property currently contains a single - family residence. The
dwelling has been used in the past as an assisted living facility with up to 12
beds. There is no documentation showing that the use was properly
permitted. According to Idaho and City Code, a single - family dwelling may be
utilized as an assisted living facility with up to 8 beds. In order to be compliant
with city standards the applicant is requesting the rezone and special -use
permit, as an assisted living facility with more than 8 beds is not allowed in the
R -1 zone.
2. Mr. Wagoner identified the surrounding uses as residential.
3. Mr. Wagoner further explained that the subject property has frontage on
Arlington Avenue and Spruce Street, both classified as local streets. The
driveway for the residence is located on Arlington Avenue.
4. Mr. Wagoner stated that the engineering department, fire marshal, building
department, police department, and Caldwell School District were sent a
request for comment on February 11, 2014 and the police department stated
that they have no opposition to this request (see PA -2). The Engineering
Department is requiring that the applicant construct the corner ramp to ADA
standards and that the existing right -of -way that encroaches on the site be
corrected. The Engineering Department is willing to assist the applicant on the
right -of -way legal descriptions (see PA -1).
5. Mr. Wagoner stated that a landscape plan was not required with this
application.
6. Mr. Wagoner stated that the proposed use will require 6 parking spaces. The
existing garage and paved driveway on Arlington Avenue will provide 4 parking
spaces. The existing gravel driveway on Spruce Street will provide 2 parking
spaces. The applicant should be required to pave the existing gravel driveway
on Spruce Street.
7. Mr. Wagoner read into record a letter received from Paul Aldridge in favor of
the application.
8. Mr. Mapp confirmed that the city ordinance reads that the in a R -1 zone having
an assisted living facility with no more than 8 residents not including the
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing on March 11, 2014 P 3 Z 3
attendants is allowed but if there are more than 8 residents the zoning must be
R -2 zoning.
9. Mr. Wagoner responded he did not believe there is a maximum number in the
R -2 zone but up to 8 residents are allowed per Idaho Code in any residential
zone and would be seen as a single family residential home. With more than 8
beds it would qualify and classify as an assisted living facility which is allowed in
an R -3 zone but did not feel the R -3 zone would be appropriate for this area
and recommends rezoning to R -2 with a special use. Within the ordinance in
the definition section of city code there is no limit as far as the number of
people that qualify for an assisted living facility.
10. Mr. Mapp confirmed that in an R -2 zone a special use can be requested for a
20 -30 -40 unit facility.
11. Mr. Wagoner responded that it may be requested through the special use
process.
12. Mr. Mapp confirmed with staff that the rezone of this property to R -2 will be
surrounded by R -1.
13. Mr. Map wondered about placing conditions on the rezone in regards to that
zoning is based upon use and if the use changed then it would have to go back
to the previous zone classification.
14. Mr. Wagoner confirmed a condition could be added to the Order of Decision, if
the use was to change from assisted living the zone would be required to
change back to R -1.
15. Mr. Mapp discussed with staff the number of attendants at the site within a
24 -hour period and the parking requirements.
16. Mr. Wagoner stated per his calculations he came up with 6 required parking
spaces by combining the single family residence with the assisted living facility
requirements.
17. Mr. Mapp asked staff if Planning & Zoning had received any complaints when it
was being used as an assisted living facility.
18. Mr. Wagoner responded, NO.
19. Stacy Gunnerson, applicant representative, 6051 North Echo Summit Lane,
Star, ID 83607, testified in favor of the application and stated she has been
working with Jarom Wagoner trying to get this straightened out. They
purchased the property the week of Thanksgiving with the understanding that
it was licensed for 12 beds but was currently vacant. After working with the city
to get all the sign offs from the Building Department, Fire Department and
Zoning Department they found out it was not approved by the city to have
more than 8 beds. Ms. Gunnerson further shared that she is the Vice President
of Operations for Ashley Manor and they would like to license this facility for
13 beds, the additional beds will help the financial viability. The last 2 owners
of the facility went out of business due to financial constraints. In order to
make the business viable, make a profit to keep it open they need more than 8
beds, especially if they take Medicaid. The facility will be licensed to take
Medicaid and the typical Medicaid payment for Idaho is half of what they
would get from a private paying client. In order to service the clients they will
have to take more clients.
20. Ms. Gunnerson explained they have made improvements to the front of the
property and will continue with landscaping this spring. They will also work
with City Engineers to get ADA compliance side walk and ramps.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing on March 11, 2014 P a ' 14
21. Mr. Mapp asked how many attendants will work within a 24 hour period and
will the attendants reside on the site.
22. Ms. Gunnerson responded that staff does not live on site, during the day there
will be 3 staff and overnight there will be 1 staff. If the care changes for a client
then more staff would be required.
23. Mr. Mapp wondered about the neighborhood meeting.
24. Ms. Gunnerson responded the feedback from the neighborhood meeting was
good. Concerns about staffing but ended on a positive note.
25. Mr. Mapp asked who on the government side is responsible for monitoring this
facility.
26. Ms. Gunnerson answered Health and Welfare will monitor the facility.
27. Sharla Wilson, applicant representative, 5314 Crimson Ave, Caldwell, ID 83607,
testified in favor of the application and stated she agrees with everything that
Ms. Gunnerson has stated and would like to point out in the letter that Mr.
Aldridge submitted, he had stated the need for this type of service and type of
care in this area. It is not represented well in this area especially considering
the need for Medicaid beds. Ashley Manor wants to help and improve
community by offering assistance.
28. Janet Santiago, 304 East Spruce Street, Caldwell, ID 83605, testified in neutral
of the application and expressed her concern of property value, staff / patron
parking, and current construction vehicles blocking the view of traffic. Also
wanted clarification about the correction to the existing right -of -way that
encroaches on the site which directly affects her.
29. Mr. Mapp stated one of the requirements is 6 parking spots on the property
and that anyone can park on the street.
30. Liz Michaelides, 3121 Arlington Ave., Caldwell, ID 83605, testified in opposition
of the application and expressed her concerns not objections but concerns. She
does not object to the assisted living facility because it has been that way since
she moved there. The main concern is that the living space inside and out is not
adequate for the proposed number (13) of the dementia /Alzheimer's clients;
also she is concerned about the limited number of staff to take care of the
clients.
31. Joyce Prestwick, 312 East Spruce, Caldwell, ID 83605, testified in opposition of
the application and stated that she agrees with Liz Michaelides testimony.
32. Grace Yamamot, 3115 Arlington, Caldwell, ID 83605, testified in opposition of
the application and stated that she agrees with Liz and Joyce's testimony.
33. Majarie Bratton, 3108 Arlington Ave., Caldwell, ID 83605, singed in opposition
of the application but did not wish to speak.
34. Mr. Mapp stated that he felt the citizens should have protection in regards to
the R -2 zone and will have the applicant answer the questions about Health
and Welfare. Mr. Mapp further stated that Jarom is speaking with Ms. Santiago
about the correction of the R -O -W.
35. Ms. Gunnerson provided rebuttal testimony. Ms. Gunnerson agreed that the
backyard seems small and that this spring they are redoing the backyard. They
are putting in a sidewalk that will loop around into a full circle and in the
middle of the circle will have a gardening area for the residences and will utilize
the side yard for outdoor space. The interior has been remodeled adding
another large bedroom which added 2 more beds. As per the rules and
regulations, Health and Welfare has measured and determined they meet the
160 sq ft requirement to have 2 people reside in each bedroom.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing on March 11, 2014 P a g e Is
36. Ms. Gunnerson addressed the concerns about the construction trucks and
stated that the construction should be complete in a week and she will address
with her workers about the parking of construction vehicles.
37. Mr. Mapp asked Ms. Gunnerson to address the Health and Welfare concerns.
38. Ms. Gunnerson explained that they are strictly regulated by all divisions of
Health and Welfare and the Life Safety Department has already approved them
and the Licensing Department will come out make sure they are giving good
care and observe the environment to make sure it is safe. Health and Welfare
will monitor the books and medications to make sure they are assisting with
medication properly. Health and Welfare may come out every 3 months if they
feel there is a need.
39. Mr. Mapp suggested after tonight's meeting that Ms. Gunnerson and the ladies
that signed up to speak, meet and discuss the concerns and exchange phone
numbers.
40. Ms. Gunnerson stated that she had given all the ladies her business card that
has her cell phone and they are welcome to contact her at any time.
41. Mr. Mapp expressed that he did not like the idea of spot zoning but this is a
unique situation because as code is written to apply for more patients the zone
has to be changed.
42. Mr. Mapp stated that he will recommend to staff to change the code allowing
more than 8 beds with a special use in an R -1 zone instead of having to rezone
to R -2 and apply for a special use.
MR. MAPP CLOSED THE PUBLIC TESTIMONY.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for SUP -03 -14 (Special Use): Mr. Mapp accepted the comprehensive
plan analysis as listed in the staff report.
Findings of Fact for SUP -03 -14 (Special Use): The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as
outlined in the staff report, public testimony, and the evidence list.
Conclusions of Law for SUP -03 -14 (Special Use): The Hearing Examiner accepted the Conclusions of
Law as outlined in the staff report.
ORDER OF DECISION FOR SUP -03 -14 (Special Use Permit): The Hearing Examiner ORDERED that
Case Number SUP- 03 -141S APPROVED with conditions:
12.2 —12.8 as written.
12.9 — R -2 classification will go with the use, assisted living facility of 13 beds.
12.10 — When the zoning ordinance is amended to allow this use in the R -1 zone with or
without the special use that this zoning classification R -2 through a public hearing process will
go back to R -1 at no cost to the applicant.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for ZON -01 -14 (Rezone): Mr. Mapp accepted the comprehensive plan
analysis as listed in the staff report.
Findings of Fact for ZON -01 -14 (Rezone): The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as
outlined in the staff report, public testimony, and the evidence list.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing on March 11, 2014 P a - 2 16
Conclusions of Law for ZON -01 -14 (Rezone): The Hearing Examiner accepted the Conclusions of Law
as outlined in the staff report.
RECOMMENDATION FOR ZON -01 -14 (Rezone): The Hearing Examiner RECOMMENDS that Case
Number ZON -01 -14 BE APPROVED with conditions:
8.1 as written.
D. Case Number SUB- 01(P) -14 a request by East Chicago LLC and Lance Warnick for preliminary
plat approval of East Chicago Business Park Subdivision, consisting of 3.12 acres to be
subdivided into 6 lots in an M -1 Light Industrial zone. The subject property is located on the
south side of Chicago Street approximately 750 feet east of 21" Avenue in Caldwell, Idaho.
Testimony:
1. Jarom Wagoner, Senior Planner /Development Team Leader, 621 Cleveland
Blvd., Caldwell, ID 83605, presented the staff report as written. The subject
property is identified as Tax Parcel #: R35369 -010D and R35369 -010E in said
application.
2. Mr. Wagoner further noted that the subject property is zoned M -1 Light
Industrial with industrial designation on the Comprehensive Plan Map and is
bare ground. The preliminary plat calls for 6 industrial lots ranging in size from
0.36 acres to 0.79 acres. There are no common lots.
3. Mr. Wagoner further noted that the applicant is proposing a 20 -foot wide
landscape buffer along Chicago Street with vegetative ground cover, 8 trees,
and 42 shrubs. The applicant's proposal meets the city's landscape buffer
requirements and should be approved, as proposed (see Exhibit A -12). The
applicant is not proposing any landscaping within the proposed parking lot. In
accordance with city code, the applicant should be required to plant a
minimum of one Class 1 or Class 2 tree within the 2 proposed planter islands.
4. Mr. Wagoner stated as per Chapter 11 of City Code, the preliminary plat shall
be completed within two years of the date of the Order of Decision. Chapter
11- 02- 03 -(1)F of City Code states that one time extension of up to twelve (12)
months may be authorized and that commercial and industrial preliminary
plats may be allowed up to three (3) time extensions at the discretion of the
city council.
5. Mr. Wagoner stated that staff recommends approval with conditions as
outlined in the staff report.
6. Lance Warnick, applicant representative, PO BOX 205, Kuna, ID 83634, testified
in favor of the application and stated he was presenting this case on behalf of
the owner East Chicago LLC and asking for City approval of East Chicago
Business Park Preliminary Plat consisting of 6 industrial lots. They have been
working closely with staff on the plat and the plan will be to close one of the
three driveways along Chicago.
7. Mr. Mapp asked about the design structures and how high the ceilings will be.
8. Mr. Warnick responded 16 to 20 ft high.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing on March 11, 2014 P a g e 17
9. Penelope Riley, applicant representative, PO Box 405, Boise, ID 83701, testified
in favor of the application and stated the project is ideally located in Caldwell
for an industrial subdivision with excellent access to transportation corridors.
Ms. Riley reviewed review vehicle trips generated by this development per day.
The potential for this subdivision to provide locations for small businesses will
be an asset to the City of Caldwell.
10. Ms. Riley respectfully requested approval of the East Chicago Business Park.
MR. MAPP CLOSED THE PUBLIC TESTIMONY.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for SUB- 01(P) -14: Mr. Mapp accepted the comprehensive plan analysis
as listed in the staff report.
Findings of Fact for SUB- 01(P) -14: The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as outlined in
the staff report, public testimony, and the evidence list.
Conclusions of Law for SUB- 01(P) -14: The Hearing Examiner accepted the Conclusions of Law as
outlined in the staff report.
RECOMMENDATION FOR SUB- 01(P) -14: The Hearing Examiner RECOMMENDS that Case Number
SUB- 01(P) -14 BE APPROVED with conditions:
8.2 - 8.6 as written.
V. Planning Issues — None.
VI. Adjournment
The Hearing Examiner adjourned the meeting at approximately 8:00 p.m.
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BY THE HEARING EXAMINER, M. JEROME MAPP, ON THE DATE NOTED
BELOW:
Jarom Wagoner, Senior Planner / Development Team Leader
ATTEST:
Date
For detailed minutes, please request a copy of the digital recording.
Hearing Examiner Minutes
Hearing on March 11, 2014 P a d I 8