HomeMy WebLinkAbout05-13-2013 CHPC MINUTESCALDWELL HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MINUTES
Meeting of May 13, 2013 @ 6.00 P.M.
Caldwell Public Library — Idaho Roomr'�'�w
I. Call to order. Chairperson Maughan called the meeting to order at approximately
6:05 p.m.
ll. Roll Call
Members Present. Chuck Randolph, Elaine Carpenter, Gina Lujack, Lorene Oates,
Megan Dixon and Steve Maughan.
Members Absent. Elaine Leppert.
Others Present. Brian Billingsley, Planning & Zoning Director; Anne Marie Skinner,
Senior Planner; April Cabello, Planning Technician; and Rob Hopper, City Council
Liaison.
Others Absent. None.
III. Approval of Minutes.
MOTION TO APPROVE THE MINUTES OF APRIL 22, 2013.
MOTION: Megan D., SECOND: Elaine C. MOTION PASSED.
IV. Certificate of Appropriateness Interviews.
A. CA- 175 -13 A request by Debbie Holmes to replace fencing. The site is
located at 1408 Dearborn Street.
Testimony:
Anne Marie Skinner, Senior Planner /Development Team Leader, 621
Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell, ID 83605, presented the written staff report
and stated that the fence is visible from the street, which necessitates
the requirement for issuance of a Certificate of Appropriateness. Ms.
Skinner further explained the broken cedar fence is approximately 5ft
tall and was painted white but is faded and chipping. The request is to
replace the 5ft tall wood fence with a 6ft tali dog -eared wood fence
that would not be painted white. Ms. Skinner stated that the house to
the west, has a 6ft high dog -eared cedar fence, the house to the east
has a 311 high picket vinyl fence and the house across the street has a
Eft high dog -eared cedar fence. Ms. Skinner explained the three items
that the Historic Preservation Commission needs to find at least one
of them to be true:
CHPC Meeting, May 13, 2013 Page 1
A. That the request supports the City of Caldwell's
Comprehensive Plan goals, policies, and recommendations
contained within Section 11, Special Sites /Historic Areas, of
said plan. The Comprehensive Plan states that the
Steunenberg Residential Historic District has great
architectural significance, as well as added historical value as
many of the early teachers at the College of Idaho and
community business leaders lived within its boundaries.
• Goal 1 of Special Sites/Historic Areas is to harmonize new
development to blend into a historically sensitive property.
In this case, there is no new development. The broken
fence is existing and will be replaced with new fencing.
• Goal 2 of Special Sites/Historic Areas is to protect and
enhance the historical resources that represent elements
of the City's cultural and architectural history.
Staff finds this finding to be TRUE.
B. That the request will be congruous with the historical,
architectural, archeological, education, or cultural significance
of the local district. Staff finds this finding to be TRUE.
C. There will be no significant effect on the exterior of the site.
Staff finds this finding to be TRUE.
Commissioner Carpenter wondered if the 6ft height is an allowable
height.
Ms. Skinner responded it is allowed because the fence is setback far
enough from the front property line.
Commissioner Randolph wondered about the procedure and
confirmed the only reason why staff could not approve the Certificate
of Appropriateness is that the fencing material is not one of the
approved materials.
Ms. Skinner responded that because this home is contributing to the
neighborhood staff could not approve it.
Debbie Holmes, applicant, 1408 Dearborn Street, Caldwell, testified in
favor of the application and stated that the fence needs to be replaced
because it is old, ugly and broken because a tree fell on it. Ms.
Holmes stated she did not feel this new cedar fencing would deter
from the rest of the neighborhood fencing. Ms. Holmes expressed to
the commission if they do not approve the request her only solution
would be to have her handy man put back the old dilapidated fence.
MOTION TO CLOSE TESTIMONY: Chairman Maughan SECOND:
Commissioner Oates Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Evidence List for Case Number OA-175-13 - Consisted of the case file;
sign -up sheet; staff report; testimony
MOTION: Commissioner Oates SECOND: Commissioner Dixion Passed:
Unanimous roll call vote.
CHPC Meeting, May 13, 2013 Page 2
Findings of Fact for Case Number CA -175 -13
MOTION: Commissioner Carpenter SECOND: Commissioner Lujack
Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Conclusions of Law for Case Number CA- 175 -13
MOTION: Commissioner Dixion SECOND: Commissioner Carpenter
Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Order of Decision for Case Number CA- 175 -13
MOTION: Commissioner Randolph SECOND: Commissioner Lujcak. The
motion for Approval was approved with unanimous roll call vote and the
following condition: New fencing to be placed in the same location.
V. Audience Participation.
None.
VI. Actions Since Last Meeting.
April C. reported that Case Number CA- 164 -13. Applicant: Chris & Elsje Taggart.
Address: 1808 Everett Street. Certificate of Appropriateness was issued for a Re-
Roof 1 Architectural style 1 Staff Level Approval. Building Permit BR -13 -00155
was issued on 5/3/2013 for the re -roof.
Anne Marie S. reported that the City Attorney spoke with Livvy Albizo of Olive
Tree and Donald Esteppe and came to an understanding of what is allowed thus
the application for the rezone, special use and comprehensive plan map change
has been withdrawn.
VII. Old Business.
Commissioner Randolph reported that he saw the Streets Department drilling
holes for the downtown signage and suspects the signs will be up by the
weekend.
Commissioner Randolph reported that Brian B. applied on behalf of the Historical
Society for 501 C3.
Commissioner Randolph reported he had a proposal for the Historical Society to
think about is that the Van Slyke Museum in the park, has no advocacy and
suggested the Historical Society take the Museum on as a project. Commissioner
Randolph shared pictures removed from the cabins for restoration.
Brian B. wondered about the possible Memorial Day walking tour that the
commission had discussed at a previous meeting. Brian B. asked the
commission if they wished to have a walking tour on Memorial Day and July 4
Commissioner Randolph suggested postponing the Memorial Day, Downtown
walking tour until the signs have been placed, and then launch the Downtown
walking tour with a lot of publicity.
VIII. New Business.
CHPC Meeting, May 13, 2013 Page 3
April C. reported that she mailed a letter to SHPO requesting to expedite the
notification process regarding the National Register of Historic Places nomination
for Washington & Idaho Avenues Historic District.
For detailed minutes, please request a copy of the digital recording.
IX. Meeting adjourned at approximately 7.00 p.m.
Respectfully submitted by April Cabello,
MINUTES APPROVEITAND SIGNED BELOW BY CHAIRPERSON STEVE MAUGHAN
ON THE DATE NOTED BELOW.
Chairperson Maughan
ATTEST: Brian Billingsley, P & Z Director
2#
Date
Date
CHPC Meeting, May 13, 2013 Page 4