HomeMy WebLinkAbout09-24-2012 CHPC MINUTESCALDWELL HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MINUTES
Meeting of September 24, 2012 @ 6:00 P.M.
Caldwell Public Library - Idaho Room
I. Call to order. Chairperson Randolph called the meeting to order at approximately
6:00 p.m.
II. Roll Call
Members Present. Chuck Randolph, Anita Shore, Elaine Carpenter, Gina Lujack,
Lorene Oates, Megan Dixon.
Members Absent. Elaine Leppert, Eileen Davidson, Steve Maughan.
Others Present. Brian Billingsley, Planning & Zoning Director: Anne Marie Skinner,
Senior Planner; April Cabello, Planning Technician: Rob Hopper, City Council
Liaison.
Others Absent. None.
III. Approval of Minutes.
MOTION TO APPROVE THE MINUTES OF AUGUST 27, 2012 WITH
CORRECTIONS.
MOTION: Anita S., SECOND: Gina L. MOTION PASSED.
IV. Certificate of Appropriateness Interviews.
A. Case No. CA- 167 -12. Applicant: Roger & Kristy Baumchen. Address: 1716
Everett St. A request for Certificate of Appropriateness to replace windows,
replace the front door, remove existing accent roof on front of house, build a
covered porch and relocate the chain link fence to behind the front of the house.
April C. explained to the commission that this application was received prior to
the adoption of CHPC Ordinance 2905 and will be heard under CHPC Ordinance
2724.
Roger & Kristy Baumchen, the applicants, presented their case before the
commission and explained the renovation plans. The Baumchens shared with the
commission their intentions of increasing the value of the home by bringing the
home to the standard of the historic neighborhood. Mr. & Mrs. Baumchen stated
they will replace the front door, upstairs window, remove existing accent roof,
build a covered porch and move the chain link fence. They had not yet decided
on the type of replacement windows for the first -floor front windows.
CHPC Meeting, September 24, 2012 Page 1
Elaine C. stated that the applicant must know what type of replacement window
they are going to use for the first -floor windows or the commission cannot
approve the Certificate of Appropriateness.
Chairman Randolph stated that the commission could approve the Certificate of
Appropriateness for all the work except for the first -floor windows and the
homeowner would apply for a separate Certificate of Appropriateness when they
were ready to replace the first -floor windows.
Elaine C. made the motion to accept and approve the Certificate of
Appropriateness application with the exception of the first -floor windows. The
homeowner, when ready to replace the first -floor windows, will apply for a
separate Certificate of Appropriateness.
MOTION: Elaine C., SECOND: Anita S. MOTION PASSED.
V. Audience Participation.
A. None.
VI. Actions Since Last Meeting.
A. None.
VII. Old Business.
A. CHPC Ordinance Amendment, Anne Marie Skinner reported that the amended
ordinance was approved by City Council and is now effective. Ms. Skinner
reviewed the Ordinance and the Historic Preservation Decision Matrix with the
commission. Ms. Skinner asked for a motion to adopt Resolution No. 01 -12, the
Historic Preservation Decision Matrix.
Motion was made to adopt Resolution No. 01 -12 Historic Preservation Decision
Matrix with the addition of "unpainted stucco, unpainted brick" to page 2, number
8 of the DO NOT require certificate of appropriateness matrix.
MOTION: Elaine C., SECOND: Lorene O. MOTION PASSED.
The commission discussed the wording and definitions of "Contributing" and
"Non- Contributing ".
B. Continued discussion of the Historic Homes on the CHPC Website.
Chairperson Randolph explained to the commission the reason why he would
like to have a sign placed in front of 1402 Cleveland Blvd and place it on the
Historic Preservation Website. Chairman Randolph volunteered to write the
narrative for the sign and webpage.
C. 2012 CLG Grant Update. April C. gave an update and reported that TAG would
give a presentation of the final product at the October 22 CHPC meeting. April
C. explained she had to move the presentation by TAG to October because of
the full September agenda.
CHPC Meeting, September 24, 2012 "' Page 2
D. Future Signage. Brian B. explained why a sign would be placed at 1402
Cleveland. Brian B. stated that Chairman Randolph had done a wonderful job
helping with the walking, trolley tours of the Steunenberg Historic District, and
asked Chairman Randolph if he would like a small stipend for his work, but he
declined payment. Instead, Chairman Randolph stated that he was happy to
donate his time but would rather have the city put up a new sign in the
Steunenberg Historic District. Brian B. stated that he agreed to put up the sign
but still wanted to give Chairman Randolph something as a "Thank You" for all
his hard work and presented him with a gift certificate to his favorite restaurant.
Brian B. continued with the discussion of future signage and explained that the
Canyon County Commissioners are spreading $90,000 of their Historic
Preservation funding around to other agencies throughout Canyon County. Brian
B. stated that he asked the Mayor, Chairman Randolph and Rob Hopper if the
City should apply for some of the funding and the response was YES. Brian B.
stated he submitted a proposal to the County Commissioners asking for
$2,700.00 to place 15 signs in the Caldwell Historic District. The County
Commissioners approved the request but Brian B. was not sure of the amount
awarded. Brian B. further stated that to receive the funding, a Non - Profit
Historical Society was formed and called the Caldwell Historical Society.
Volunteers that will serve on the Society are Chuck R., Elaine C. and Megan D.
VIII. New Business.
A. 2013 CI_G Grant. April C_ reported that the application deadline for the 2013
CLG Grant was very near and that she would submit the application to SHPO on
Tuesday, September 25, 2012. April C. further stated she emailed the application
to all the commission members asking for any changes, deletions or corrections.
Chairman Randolph asked the commission to email April C. with any changes by
12:00pm on Tuesday, September 25"'.
IX. Meeting adjourned at approximately 8:15 p.m.
Respectfully submitted by April Cabello,
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BELOW BY CHAIRPERSON CHUCK RANDOLPH
ON THE DATE NOTED BELOW.
Chairperson Randolph bate
_r g Z ] 2
o Z_
ATTEST: Brian Billingsley, P & Z Director Date
CHPC Meeting, September 24, 2012 PagEF 3