HomeMy WebLinkAbout08-14-2012 P&Z MINUTESCALDWELL PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION
MINUTES
August 14, 2012
Call to Order — Vice - Chairperson Doty - Pomoransky called the meeting to order for the public hearing at
7:00 p.m.
II. Roll Call —
Members Present: Ed Doty - Pomoransky, Dana Vance, Roger Page, Arvid Salisbury
Disclosures and Conflicts of Interest: None
Members Absent: Ken Scholz
Staff Present: Anne Marie Skinner (Senior Planner /Development Team Leader); April Cabello (Planning Technician),
Ricardo Calderon (Associate City Engineer)
Staff Absent: Brian Billingsley (Planning and Zoning Director)
Review of Proceeding — Vice - Chairperson Doty- Pomoransky announeed the procedures for the public hearing.
III. Old Business
A. Approve minutes of June 12, 2012 regular meeting.
MOTION: Commissioner Vance SECOND: Commissioner Page Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
IV. New Business
A. Case Number SUP - 353 -12 a request by Josh White and Tay's Inc. for special use permit approval to operate
a brewery at the northwest corner of Grant Street and 10` Avenue addressed as 923 Grant Street.
Testimony:
1) Anne Marie Skinner, 621 Clevetand Blvd., Caldwell, ID 53605, Senior Planner/Development
Team Leader, presented the written staff report as written and submitted an aerial map of the
site labeled as PZ -1000.
2) Ms. Skinner reported that the subject property is in the process of being purchased by the
applicant, Josh White, Tay's Inc., who is asking for special use approval for this nanobrewery.
3) Ms. Skinner referred to the aerial photo PZ -1000 and stated the subject property is located on
the northwest corner of Grant Street and I O' Avenue in the C -C City Center zoning district,
which is a mixed use - zoning district and allows for this use with special use approval.
4) Ms. Skinner reported on the uses surrounding the site. The subject property is surrounded by
C -C City Center zone with the exception of the golf course and the Odd Fellows building with
R -2 zoning. To the east of the subject property it is zoned C -C City Center being residential in
use and to the north is zoned C -C City Center with a mix of commercial and residential, to the
west it is zoned C -C City Center with different forms of residences and further to the west is
commercial use.
P &Z Minutes
8/14/2012
5) Ms. Skinner explained the nanobrewery will produce beers on site and those beer will be
available to tasting, as well as purchase by the glass or keg. No food will be served. No liquor
will be served. No alcohol other than what is produced on site will be served. This site will not
function as a bar, pub, or restaurant, but people will be allowed to bring in food.
6) Ms. Skinner staled lasting room hours would be Wednesdays and Thursdays from 3:00 p.m. to
8:00 p.m.; Fridays and Saturdays froin 12:00 p.m. to 10.00 p.m.; and Sunday afternoons.
7) Ms. Skinner also stated a neighborhood meeting was held on August 6, 2012 regarding this
request.
8) Ms. Skinner gave some background on the site stating it was originally a single- family
dwelling that was converted to a commercial use of a chiropractic office and a salon/spa. The
salon /spa closed and the chiropractic office moved to another location leaving the structure
vacanl.
9) Ms. Skinner stated the applicable public agencies were notified but no public agency
comments were received.
10) Ms. Skinner noted that all landscaping and parking requirements have already been met.
1 1) Ms. Skinner recommended approval with restrictive conditions and stood for questions.
12) Josh White, applicant, 13930 Pecota Dr, Caldwell, ID 83607 acknowledged he had been
sworn in and gave supporting testimony.
13) Mr. White stated that Ms. Skinner explained most of the request so he will elaborate on why
he chose Caldwell and this location. Mr. While stated he has been a brewer for 10 years and
has been involved in the profession with friends and many acquaintances that are in the
brewery profession and has been working with business consultants for the last few years
trying to bring something to Caldwell that will work and that is craft beer.
14) Mr. While informed the commission that he has no intent of having a bar or being a
bartenderlbarkeep and wanted to give an analogy and explanation of the craft brewing
industry. Canyon County has a great winery industry and part of that where people go taste
wines where the wines are produced and it is an experience. It is an Idaho product and it
brings people into Idaho. This is the same for craft beer; it will bring people in to have
different items made on site in a craft setting, not a place to get cheap alcohol. Compare this to
wine tasting. People come in and taste and can purchase 2 liters to take home or a pint to have
on site.
15) Mr. White stated he wants the brewery to be a great place and a great experience for people in
Caldwell. He wants to have great ambiance and they have that with the fireplace, places to sit,
couches, coffee tables, and will have abrewing library available and accessible for people in
the western end of the Treasure Valley. This site is wonderful, ready to go with a great patio
and again it comes down to the experience of tasting handcrafted beer with friends. They also
have plans to distribute beer to places outside like Boise, Meridian, and beer markets. That
way when people taste the beer and like it, they can go locally to purchase the beer. They also
encourage people to bring in food from local restaurants or eateries such as Orphan Annie's,
11amburger Connection, and pizza places and sit by fire during the spring or autumn time. Mr.
White fi r(her stated lie has a neighbor that works at the College of Idaho who is excited to
have a place to hold meetings in the upstairs. He is excited to bring; this type of experience to
Caldwell. as there are no breweries between Meridian acid Baker City.
16) Mr. White reiterated this is not a bar and for the commission to think about it more like a
winery but instead of tasting wine you are tasting beer and hanging out with friends while
having a great experience.
17) Mr. White stood for questions.
18) Commissioner Salisbury wondered about Mr. White's experience handling the public when
they are drinking. Commissioner Salisbury stated his concerns are the brewery being on a
major street, Mr. While not being ready to handle people who have been drinking, and being a
good neighbor.
19) Commissioner Salisbury also asked how many people Mr. White could handle in this building
at one time.
20) Mr. White clarified Commissioner Salisbury's question was about the occupancy load.
21) Mr. While stated that the occupancy load on the first level is 70 people but he does not have a
need to pack that many people in at one time unless (hey have a special event for Christmas or
Saint Patrick's Day. That m,uiy people would ruin the experience. You would not be able to sit
down and talk nor hear if someone was playing the acoustic guitar.
22) Mr. White also stated he has had conversations with Matt Ganz of Salmon River Brewing in
McCall about handling the publie and discussed what issues they have run into as a brewery
and how to handle those issues. Mr. White informed (lie commission he currently works with
the public and sometimes irate or unreasonable customers and he does have background and
experience handling irate or unreasonable customers.
23) Mr. White responded to the commission's question about being a good neighbor and lie stated
that the neighbor next to the subject property attended the neighborhood meeting and
expressed some very well - founded concerts. They discussed putting up signs oil the walls
2
P &Z Minutes
8/14/2012
with an adinoniiion to patrons to respect the neighbors and maybe extending the lattice on the
fencing. Mr. White stated the neighbor thanked Mr. While for being so cordial and appreciated
they held the neighborhood meeting,
24) Commissioner Vance wondered if music would be outside.
25) Mr. White responded the intention is to have the music in the northeast corner of the main
room but if it would not be a problem with the neighbors it would be nice to have an acoustic
guitar outside on the patio, but the intention was not to have music outside.
26) Commissioner Page voiced his concern about safety measures and hoNv the process of
manufacturing workings in a residential area.
27) Mr. While responded it is an electric brew system and the only concern would be the steam
coming off the boil kettle but will install a hood chat vents outside. This is a two - barrel small -
scale electric system.
28) Vice -Chair Doty - Pomoransky stated that no one else signed up in favor, opposition or neutral
and asked if there was anyone else who did not sign up that wanted to speak.
29) No one responded.
30) Vice -Chair Doty- Pomoransky asked for a motion to close public (estimony.
31) Commissioner Vance made the motion to close public testimony.
MOTION TO CLOSE TESTIMONY: Commissioner Vance SECOND: Commissioner Salisbury Passed:
Unanimous roll call vole.
Evidence List for Case Number SUP - 353 -12 - Consisted of the case file, the written and verbal staff reports, and the
sign -up sheet. Commissioner Vance SECOND: Commissioner Page Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for Case Number SUP- 353 -12 — MOTION: Commissioner Page SECOND:
Commissioner Vance Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Findings of Fact for Case Number SUP - 353 -12 - MOTION: Commissioner Vance SECOND: Commissioner Page
Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Conclusions of Law for Case Number SUP - 353 -12 — MOTION: Commissioner Salisbury SECOND: Commissioner
Page Passed: Unanimous roil call vote.
Order of Decision on Case Number SUP - 353 -12 — MOTION: Commissioner Page SI.COND: Commissioner Vance.
The Commission voted unanimously to Approve with the following conditions:
• Items 8.2 through 8.10
B. Case Number SUB- 207 (PF) -12 a request by Byron Nelson, Autozone Development Corp., and JUB
Engineers for short plat approval of Nelson /Knipe Development, consisting of 5.94 acres to be
subdivided into two lots in a C -3 Service Commercial zone addressed as 5615 Cleveland Blvd. and
identified as Tax IDPR32451,
Testimony:
1)Anne Marie Skinner, 621 Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell, ID 83605, Senior Planner/Development Team
Leader, explained to the commission this is the first short plat application the commission has heard
and gave a brief explanation of platting.
2) Ms. Skinner presented the written staff report as written and submitted an aerial map of the site
Iabeted as PZ -1000.
3) Ms. Skinner reported the subject property is zoned C -3 Service Commercial with a Commercial
designation on the Comprehensive Plan Map and is currently bare ground. Ms. Skinner further
reported that the surrounding land uses, zones and comprehensive plan map designations are M -1
to the north of the subject property, R -2 to the south, C -3 to the east and C -3 to the west.
4) Ms. Skinner stated the site has an existing approach from Cleveland Boulevard. The project
proposes to eliminate this approach and replace it with a new approach, built to City standards and
specifications, and spaced according to Idaho Transportation Department requirements. No more
than one approach is being proposed. Perpetual cross - connectivity and emergency access easement
is provided from the north side of Lot I to the north side of Lot 2 and from west to east across Lot
2.
P &Z Minutes
8/14/2012
5) Ms. Skinner slated the applicable public agencies were notified of the request. Those that
responded are exhibits PA -1 letter from ITD, PA -2 letter from Pioneer Irrigation and PA -3 memo
from the City Engineer.
6) Ms. Skinner further stated that the landscaping buffer requirement was met through the existence of
Notus Canal.
7) Ms, Skinner reported there are no future Parks / Recreation sites, no future Public Facilities on the
site, no Pathways or Bike routes, and no over lay zones with the exception of the property being
located in Zone X, so any building will have to follow the requirements for the Zone X
construction.
8) Ms. Skinner further reported that the Planning & Zoning Department and the Engineering
Department have reviewed the preliminary and final plat. All items on the plat meet all the
conditions of the subdivision ordinance, and as per the subdivision ordinance, if all conditions are
met they are bound to approve the plat.
9) Ms. Skinner referred to the conditions of approval noted in section 8 and read into the record two
conditions of approval that were added to the staff report:
• 8.12 Asper Idaho Power, existing overhead power lines will remain in place as overhead
power lines and do not have to be relocated underground. Installation of new power lines shall
take place underground when possible.
• 8.13 Looping of water shall not take place with development of the subdivision plat nor with
new construction on Lot 1. Rather, looping of water shall be coordinated with any new
construction on Lot 2.
10) Ms. Skinner recommended approval of the application and stood for questions.
11) Dean Cardwell, applicant's representative, 12854 W. Fiddlelenf Drive, Boise, ID 83713
acknowledged he had been sworn in and gave supporting testimony.
12) Mr. Cardwell stated the subject property as explained is a 2 -lot subdivision. 1 {e is representing
Auto Zone as the developer who is proposing to build on Lot l and stood for questions.
13) Vice- Chair Doty asked the commission if they had any questions for the applicant. The commission
had no questions,
14) Vice -Chair Doty - Pomoransky stated there was no one signed up in opposition or neutral on the
case and asked for a motion to close public testimony.
15) Commissioner Salisbury made the motion to close public testimony.
MOTION TO CLOSE TESTIMONY: Commissioner Salisbury SECOND: Commissioner Vance Passed:
Unanimous roll call vote.
Evidence List for Case Number SUB- 207(PF) -12 - Consisted ofthe. case tile, the written and verbal staff reports, and
the sign -up sheel. Commissioner Vance SECOND: Commissioner Salisbury Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for Case Number SUB- 207(PF) -12 — MOTION: Commissioner Page SECOND:
Commissioner Vance Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
bindings of Fact for Case Number SUB- 207(PF) -12 - MOTION: Commissioner Vance SECOND: Commissioner
Salisbury Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Conclusions of Law for Case Number SUB- 207(PF) -12— MOTION: Commissioner Salisbury SECOND:
Commissioner Page Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Recommendation on Case Number SUB-207(PF)-12 — MOTION: Commissioner Vance SECOND: Commissioner
Page. The Commission voted unanimously to recommend Approval.
C. Case Number SUP - 352 -12 a request by Caldwell YMCA and the City of Caldwell for special use
permit approval to construct a park located west of the existing Caldwell YMCA, approximately 550
feet west of Indiana Avenue, more or less, and approximately 700 feet, more or less, north of Ustick
Road
Testimony:
1) Anne Marie Skinner, 621 Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell, ID 83605, Senior Planner/Development
Team Leader, presented the staff report as written and submitted an aerial map of the site
labeled as PZ -1000.
4
P &Z Minutes
8/14/2012
2) Ms. Skinner reported the subject property is partially undeveloped bare ground to the west and
a developed and existing parking lot to the east, owned by the YMCA. The YMCA has an
existing recreational facility immediately adjacent to the subject property. The development of
the bare portion of the subject property into a park has always been a part of the YMCA's
master plan for its property.
3) Ms. Skinner reported that the subject property is zoned C -1 Neighborhood Commercial and
has to the north Ag use, to the west R -1 and R -3 as school and residential, to the east C -1 and
county as public being the YMCA and a house, and to the south in the county as Ag use.
4) Ms. Skinner explained parking facilities for the proposed park will take access from the
existing YMCA facility and no new streets or approaches are proposed or needed for the
proposal. A park requires a minimum of three parking spaces per acre and a maximum of
eight parking spaces per acre. The park consists of 7.37 acres as per the submitted site plan.
This equates to a minimum of 21 and a maximum of 56 parking spaces. The provided site plan
shows an addition of 72 parking spaces to the existing parking lot for the YMCA. However,
the sixteen parking spaces that exceed the maximum allowed for the park are being added for
the use of the YMCA recreational facility, which needs additional parking. For every 25
parking spaces added, one ADA parking space will need to be provided. There should be three
ADA parking spaces and the site plan shows four spaces. A detailed parking plan giving
dimensions of drive aisles and parking spaces will need to be included with the certificate of
compliance application.
5) Ms. Skinner further explained the general areas of landscaping are shown on the site plan,
including the parking lot landscape planter islands. A detailed landscaping plan will be
submitted with the certificate of compliance application.
6) Ms. Skinner stated the applicable public agencies were notified of the request the only agency
to respond was Pioneer Irrigation labeled as exhibit PA -I.
7) Ms. Skinner also informed the commission she included in the packet some copies of items
from the Parks and Recreation Master Plan, which is part of the overall Caldwell
Comprehensive Plan. Part of the implementation plan for the 2030 Comprehensive Plan calls
for implementation of the Parks and Recreation Plan and Table 7 of the Parks and Recreation
Master Plan calls for a new park called Values Park, which is the subject park located next to
the YMCA. Table 8, which is the Implementation Schedule of the Parks and Recreation
Master Plan, also calls for the Values Park. Based upon these items being consistent with the
Comprehensive Plan and the Parks and Recreation Plan, staff is recommending approval of the
special use request.
8) Ms. Skinner stood for questions.
9) Commissioner Vance confirmed with slatTthe City held a neighborhood meeting which no
one attended.
10) Ms. Skinner confirmed.
11) Commissioner Salisbury voiced his concern for appropriate fencing along the southwest
lateral irrigation canal.
12) Ms. Skinner responded that will all be included in [lie detailed plan that is submitted Nvith the
Certificate of Compliance application.
13) Commissioner Salisbury wondered if the City would take care of the maintenance of the park.
t4) Ms_ Skinner responded the City would maintain the park.
15) Commission Salisbury clarified that City would absorb the cost and YMCA funds would
develop the park.
16) Ms. Skinner referred the question to the Ricardo Calderon, one of the City Engineers who is
acting as the applicanCs representative.
t7) Ricardo Calderon, applicant's representative, 621 Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell, ID 83605
acknowledged he had been sworn in and gave supporting testimony.
18) Mr. Calderon restated Commissioner Salisbury's questions regarding fencing, maintenance
and funding of the park, Mr. Calderon stated this is a multi -phase project funded through the
YMCA and the City. The City has 95k available to spend on Phase 1 and the YMCA will fund
the next phase. Mr. Calderon further stated the Parks Department would maintain the park and
that the City has plans to enhance the fencing along the Lowline Canal and Dixie Drain.
19) Mr. Calderon also stated a planned future bike lane will connect the existing bike lane to Lake
Lowell and will connect the existing bike like by the YMCA through the park crossing the
Dixie Drain connecting it to the Heritage Charter School.
20) Vice -Chair Doty Pomoransky stated that Deanne Gatfield, signed in favor of the application
but did not wish to speak.
21) Vice -Chair Doty- Pomoransky asked for a motion to close public testimony.
22) Commissioner Salisbury made the motion to close public testimony.
MOTION TO CLOSE TESTIMONY: Commissioner Salisbury SECOND: Commissioner Page Passed: Unanimous
roll call vote.
P &Z Minutes
8/14/2012
Evidence List for Case Number SUP - 352 -12 - Consisted of the case file, the written and verbal staff reports, and the
sign -up sheet. Vance SECOND: Commissioner Salisbury Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis for Case Number SUP - 352 -12— MOTION: Commissioner Vance SECOND:
Commissioner Page Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Findings of Fact for Case Number SUP- 352 -12 - MOTION: Commissioner Salisbury SECOND: Commissioner
PAGE Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Conclusions of Law for Case Number SUP - 352 -12 — MOTION: Commissioner Page SECOND: Commissioner
Vance Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Order of Decision on Case Number SUP - 352 -12 — MOTION: Commissioner Salisbury SECOND: Commissioner
Page. The Commission voted unanimously to Approve with the following conditions:
• Items 8.2 through 8.13
V. Planning Issues —
A. The next regularly scheduled Planning and Zoning Commission h=ing is October 9, 2012.
VI. Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned at approximately 8:00 p.m.
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BY VICE - CHAIRPERSON ED DOTY- POMORANSKY ON THE DATE
P &Z Minutes
8/14/2012
31