Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout04-01-2008 DESIGN REVIEW COMMISSION � � * . . ,- - . � z � �� _ �_��� `,,,� T�ac T nrzarrrc of tlae Ucrlley � � ° ��� Memo to: Mayor Nancolas and City Council . � .. From: Brian K. Billingsley, AICP �� r-�. Date: April 1, 2008 � '` °�'' RE: Indian Creek Landscaping Plan #�� �� � ��� �g�: . , ! � �: s,.,;- � ��� �,�,$ � Please be advised that the Landscape Plan Design Review Committee has reviewed the >. �� landscaping plans for the Indian Creek corridor project. We found that the plan meets or exceeds code requirements in most instances. We want to bring to your attention one tree species that might pose a problem. The "black cottonwood" is a tree that will do well near a stream, but it probably belongs in a city park rather than in downtown 5� _- Caldwell. This tree is susceptible to losing many branches. Black cottonwoods can �_�?- ���� .._ also reach up to 50 meters in height, which would tower well above our tallest buildings � � _ � � � -s in downtown. �..� . . _ _� �� �,�� ���� The City does not have a City Forester on staf£ We consulted with a landscape _���� ; architect who highly recommended every tree listed on the landscaping plan, except for __ � the black cottonwood. �� � T � The landscaping plan calls for fifteen (15} black cottonwoods; four trees would be �� �� �'� located on the south side of the stream near the 7 Avenue footbridge, seven trees �� __ �� �� would be located on both sides of the stream near the 6 Avenue footbridge, and the " �� �� �� � remaining four trees would be on the north side of the stream near the weir. , � � ��� =Y ������ � If you want us to remove this tree from the tree list and substitute it with another �� ������ � _ variety, then please take the approval of the landscaping committee minutes off of the ��� � � � ���� � agenda. The landscape architect s comments are attached to this memo. �� � � ��� _ � ***It should be noted that the information in this memo was made available to me after we held our landscaping meeting*** � � . . W" � QR ESER�� '� . 100BES COMMUNITIES ��o � .TRE6CITYUSP AMERICA City Hall • 411 f3lc�ine St. • P.O. f3ox 1179 • Cc�ldwell, Id�ho 83606 •(208) 455 3000 • fRX: (208) 455-3003 • w w w. c i t4 o Fcc� I cJ ui e I I. co m Page 1 of 1 w "� �L Brian Billingsley � � _ _ _ __ _ _ From: Jed Wyatt [jedw@landmark-ep.com] Sent: Tuesday, April 01, 2008 9:40 AM To: Brian Billingsley Subject: Google Image Result for http://www.for.gov.bc.ca/hfd/library/documents/treebooWblackcottonwood.jpg Brian, Below is a link to a web page telling about the Black Cottonwood. It is certainly a tree that would grow and do well along Indian Creek. My concerns are with its size, and it will be a dirty tree dropping a lot of branches and dead wood in wind storms. It would probably be a better used in a more natural or park setting than downtown. Jed ht�_://ima im�url=ht�:1/www,for..�ov_bc.caJhfd/library_/documcnts/treebook/blackcottonwood ' 3Fq%o3Dblack%2Bcottonwaoci%o2Btrees%2Bhardiness%26�;b_v%3D2%26h1%3Den°/o26sa� o3DX � • 4/1/2008