HomeMy WebLinkAbout04-23-2012 CHPC MINUTESCALDWELL HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MINUTES
Meeting of April 23, 2012 @ 6:00 P.M. X�7
ED
Caldwell Public Library — Idaho Room
I. Call to order. Chairperson Randolph called the meeting to ordw at approximately
6:00 P.M.
11. Roll Call
Members Present. Chuck Randolph, Elaine Carpenter, Elaine Leppert, Eileen
Davidson, Jan Boles, Lorene Oates, Megan Dixon.
Members Absent. Anita Shore, Gina Lujack, Steve Maughan.
Others Present. Brian Billingsley, Planning & Zoning Director; April Cabello,
Planning Technician.
Others Absent. Rob Hopper, City Council Liaison.
III. Approval of Minutes.
MOTION TO APPROVE THE MINUTES OF MARCH 26, 2012.
MOTION: Elaine C., SECOND: Elaine L., MOTION PASSED.
IV. Certificate of Appropriateness Interviews.
A. CA- 160 -12 —1904 Blaine Street.
Chairman Randolph reviewed the Certificate of Appropriateness application with
the commission and gave some history of the home. Chairman Randolph asked
the applicant to explain the proposed future deck and wondered if it is going to be
a first -floor deck or a second -floor deck.
Dean Gunderson, 711 N. 21 St., Boise, ID 83702, applicant's representative,
testified in favor of the application. Mr. Gunderson stated the reason for the
Certificate of Appropriateness application was to remove a non- conforming metal
awning and related non - compliant cast -in -place concrete stoop, and replace it
with the new construction of a wood - framed awning and cast -in -place stair /stoop
assembly that is architecturally compatible with the historically conforming
aspects of the principal dwelling. Additionally, the owner will be removing the
damaged portions of the existing rear sidewalk/patio adjacent to the new stoop
and replacing it in -kind. The applicant also provided plans for a potential future
freestanding deck in a desire to secure comments and suggestions.
Mr. Gunderson responded to Chairman Randolph that the cedar deck is a 1Oft x
14ft one - step -up above finished grade about 18 inches out from the back of the
house. They will use a foursquare column that is detailed similarly to the more
arch itectu ra I ly4rue column that is completely in framed.
CHPC Meeting, April 23, 2012 Page 1
Chairman Randolph asked Mr. Gunderson to outline for the commission the
gable framework drawing.
Mr. Gunderson referred the commission to sheet A -1, which shows the existing
rear door and glass screen door off the back of the house and explained there
will be a larger stoop made to be code compliant and showed the placement of
the columns, which will match the same height as the columns on the front of the
home. Mr. Gunderson further explained there will be small wing walls off the
house to the back of the column. The new rear wing walls will be detailed the
same as the front wing walls having bead board on the interior and the same
siding as the home on the exterior. The proposed rear awning /cover will have the
same pitch as the addition off the kitchen and the materials used will be the same
as the rest of the home.
Chairman Randolph asked the commission if there were any questions or
comments.
Elaine C. stated it was nice to have plans come in that were thorough and well
thought out and that kept the integrity of the home. This is wnat the commission
has been striving for in the district - maintaining the integrity of the homes in the
district. This is a lovely addition to the house.
The members of the commission and staff echoed Elaine C.'s comment.
Chairman Randolph stated he would like to handle a couple of things separately;
he would like to call for a motion on this Certificate of Appropriateness before any
comment is made about the proposed future deck so there is no confusion.
The commission and the Gundersons held a conversation about the history of
the home and past residents.
Chairperson Randolph asked for a motion.
Jan B. made the motion to approve the Certificate of Appropriateness.
MOTION: Jan B., SECOND: Elaine L & Eileen D., MOTION PASSED.
Mr. Gunderson wondered if there were any comments about the proposed future
wood deck and stated when they are ready to submit for this future deck they
would like to have a discussion about an arborvitae shrub that has a growth
hormone problem and should be removed and replaced with a shade tree.
Chairman Randolph responded that the position the commission is moving
towards is not to comment on future plans /proposals until the Certificate of
Appropriateness application is submitted, but based on the proposed plans the
deck should not be an obstacle. Per the current ordinance, the arborvitae shrub
is not part of the commission's jurisdiction.
Gene Gunderson, 1904 Blaine Street, applicant, stated several years ago they
wanted to put in two large maples in front of the house and three large maples
along 19` but there seemed to be confusion as to who they needed to speak with
and if they needed a Certificate of Appropriateness for the trees. Per the forester,
he needed a permit and so he went to the city to pick up the permit and the city
CHPC Meeting, April 23, 2012 Page 2
said he had to go to the commission for approval. Mr. Gunderson stated that
Blaine Street is not his property and if the city wanted trees along Blaine Street
the city could plant the trees and he gave up at that point. He would, however,
like to bring the canopy trees back to Blaine Street,
Chairperson Randolph asked staff about the process to remove or place a tree in
the public right -of -way and wondered if the city forester was still involved.
Staff responded that the property owner would need to contact the city forester
for a permit.
A. CA- 161 -12 —1406 Everett Street.
Chairman Randolph reviewed the Certificate of Appropriateness application for a
home occupation with the commission and asked Brian B. to clarify the home
occupation process.
Brian B. referred the question to April C.
April C. responded that the first step for a homeowner in the district is to obtain a
Certificate of Appropriateness and then they can apply for a home occupation
permit through the city. April C. explained the process of the home occupation
application to the commission.
Jim Brown, 1406 Everett Street, applicant, stated he has been operating a
business out of Nampa and operating it out of the Nampa Airport, Caldwell
Airport, and houses in the county enclave in Nampa. Economic conditions have
been such that they are not operating two business offices at the airports
anymore but operating primarily out of the houses in Nampa. For ease of use, he
would like to operate out of his own home. All he needs is a computer, printer
and two file cabinets located in the small room just off the entry. The business is
a transportation company that transports inmates and mental patients for
counties and state and federal agencies. The transportation vehicles are stored
off site at the Nampa address and the Nampa airport. This application does not
change the home; the only change is the use of the small room.
Chairman Randolph asked Mr. Brown about signage and simultaneously stated
there will be no signage on the outside of the property regarding the home
occupation and confirmed with the applicant that he makes the transportation
arrangements electronically and actual transferring /transporting takes place off
site.
Mr. Brown responded the office would be strictly for billing and receipting via fax
and email. Inmate transfers are done at secure facilities with no advertising. It is
strictly work for government agencies. The home occupation would not use any
additional parking, no signage or anything that would change the view or use of
the home other than the office space.
Chairman Randolph confirmed with Mr. Brown he will reside in the home.
Mr. Brown confirmed.
Lorene O. wondered if any other employees would use this space.
CHPC Meeting, April 23, 2012 Page 3
Mr. Brown responded no other employees would work from his house.
Elaine C. confirmed only Mr. Brown would use this space.
Mr. Brown confirmed.
Brian B. confirmed no customers or delivery vehicles.
Mr. Brown responded there would be no customers or delivery vehicles.
Elaine C. asked staff what the City ordinance says about home occupations.
Brian B. responded there are several provisions as stated before. The home
occupation can use no more than 25% of the home's square footage and
signage can only be a nameplate on the home, but this applicant will not have
signage.
Elaine C. asked if the Historic Preservation ordinance has stipulations about no
signage on the homes.
April C. responded no.
Chairman Randolph confirmed with staff that the application meets all
requirements for the home occupation.
April C. confirmed.
Chairperson Randolph asked for a motion.
Elaine L. made the motion to approve the Certificate of Appropriateness.
MOTION: Elaine L., SECOND: Megan D., MOTION PASSED.
V. Audience Participation.
A. None.
VI. Actions Since Last Meeting.
A. None.
VII. Old Business
A. 2011 -2012 Signage Project Update — Brian B. reported that he had four signs to
review with the commission tonight and would like a consensus on the language.
He stated he needed to get the signs to the sign company and place the signs in
the district before the walking tour. Brian B. reviewed with the commission the
location and narrative of the four pending signs:
• Boone Church — 1323 Dearborn Street — Jan B. provided the photograph
and April C. researched and verified the address as 1323 Dearborn St.,
not 14` Ave. Brian B. stated he added the name of the architectural firm
and contractor to the narrative which is up to 108 words and he might
CHPC Meeting, April 23, 2012 Page 4
reduce the font size to better accommodate the sign. Brian B. worked with
the commission on shortening the narrative so the font can be enlarged
rather than reduced.
1824 Everett Street — Jones /Simplot House — Brian B. provided the
picture and Jan B. helped with converting it to a drawing. Lorene O. read
a letter and passed around photos to the commission, given to her by
Dawnette, Leon Jones's daughter. Brian B. read the narrative and made
changes to the narrative as directed by the commission.
519 S. 14 Avenue — Geroge Crookham's house — Brian B. stated Bill
Crookham wrote the narrative for this sign. Brian B. further stated he
made some corrections and sent the corrected narrative to Bill and
George Crookham, but only George responded that he was okay with the
changes. Bill did not respond. Brian B. read the finished narrative to the
commission.
1515 Everett Street — Frank Crookham's home — Brian B. informed the
commission that the Crookham Company provided paintings of big
George and Frank. Jan B. converted the paintings into pictures for the
signs. Brian B. stated he received a call from Carl Crookham who
provided the text for the sign. The commission reviewed the text and gave
suggestions to Brian B. for text changes. Brian will call Carl with the
suggestions made by the commission.
B. 2012 CLG Grant Update — April C. reported she submitted the mid- project report
to SHPO and TAG will be conducting additional research and scheduling field
work (to take the required photographs) later this month. TAG is on schedule and
will have the finished product by the agreed timeline.
C. 2012 Certified Local Government Evaluation project - April C. requested
status from Chuck R. on the resumes requested by Ann Swanson of SHPO.
Chuck R. responded he would submit his resume to Ann Swanson as soon as
possible.
D. CA- 159 -12 — 304 S. 17 Ave. - Shed. — Update — Chuck R. reported that he
had not been in contact with Mr. Loon. Chuck R. stated he would call Mr. Loon to
schedule an appointment to pick out a color for the shed and review the legal
form with Mr. Loon that he will need to have notarized. Chuck R. will give an
updated report at the next meeting.
E. Discussion of some changes to the CHPC ordinance, tips on running the
meetings and a 5 -year comprehensive plan. — Brian B. stated at the previous
meeting he handed out a 5 -year comprehensive plan and will review the plan
with Mayor Nancolas on Thursday, April 26 and then he will take it to City
Council for their stamp of approval.
Brian B. reviewed tips on meetings and what has been covered in the past few
months. Brian B. also asked the commission during the meetings to keep items
of discussion related to historic preservation as sometimes the meetings go off
topic. Brian B. stated that he and April C. would be available for the commission
after the meeting to discuss something that is not on the agenda and is not
related to historic preservation. The commission may email or call staff with code
violations or questions and concerns other than historic preservation.
CHPC Meeting, April 23, 2012 Page 5
Brian B. informed the commission the CHPC Ordinance Amendment will go
before Planning & Zoning in June. April C. reminded the commission to review
the amendment and to contact Anne Marie via email or phone with suggestions
of any changes or corrections. Elaine C. wondered about the term limits. Brian B.
stated he would speak to the Mayor about term limits when he meets with him on
Thursday and this ordinance amendment is legislative and the commission may
contact the Mayor and City Council regarding any of the items in the amendment.
F. Brian B. stated at the previous meeting the commission decided to have the
Steunenberg Residential walking tour on May 19 but Jan B. was not at that
meeting. Jan B. contacted Brian B. after the meeting and offered the use of the
C of I archives as part of the tour and Brian B. thought it could be a good place to
take a 15- minute break. Jan B. responded they are welcome to the archives, but
he had informed Brian B. that he would not be in town on May 19 Brian B.
stated the walking tour needed to be moved back to May 26 which is Memorial
Day weekend so we may not get everyone to come. However, if the walking tour
cannot be done Memorial Day weekend it will need to be pushed back to the fall.
Chuck R. noted that if they wait until the fall they run into Taste of the Harvest at
College of Idaho and Boise State football. Brian B. said, per Jan B., one of the
advantages of having the walking tour on May 26th is the campus is closed so the
walking tour will not interfere with any school functions. Lorene O. asked Brian B.
how many people need to attend the walk to deem it a success. Brian B.
responded around 25 people attended last year's North Caldwell Historic District
Walk and it was successful. Lorene O. felt this May date would also be a great
time to inspire people to do nice things to their yards. Brian B. stated last year for
the North Caldwell Historic District Walk, he mailed invitations to all property
owners within the district and he plans on doing the same with the Steunenberg
District. He also placed a one -time advertisement in the Press Tribune about a
week before the event to let people know. Lorene O. suggested posting the
Steunenberg walking tour on Face Book. Brian B. asked the commission if the
May 26 date will work for the walking tour and what time to hold the walk or do
they want to wait until the fall. The commission held a discussion and decided on
May 26 at 10am. Brian B. reviewed the route of the walking tour and the
commission discussed the best way to handle the tour. Depending on how many
people show up for the walking tour, the guides will determine if they break up
into groups.
Vlll. Now Business.
A. Preservation Idaho /Orchids and Onions. Elaine C. reported we have another
Orchid for "The Hat" and to make your reservation with Preservation Idaho if you
would like to attend. Jan B. stated the awards are at 1lam and lunch follows.
"The Hat" receives two free tickets, but he will be out of town so someone else
from the commission needs to be at the ceremony to accept the award. Chuck R.
asked Jan B. if there was someone be appropriate aside from Jan B. from the
college to accept the award. Jan B. responded that he thought so. Lorene O.
stated she will attend, not as the recipient but will attend. Jan B. responded she
was entitled to a ticket. Chuck R. stated he would attend and wondered if a C of
representative will attend. Lorene O. suggested Chuck R. or Elaine C. should
accept the award on behalf of the commission. Jan B. suggested someone
should speak with Steve M. and Chuck R. stated he would speak with Steve M.
CHPC Meeting, April 23, 2012 Page 6
IX. Commission 1 Staff Reports:
A. April C. stated she received a request from a homeowner within the district, 1323
Cleveland Blvd., who would like specific wording changes for the description of
his house as it is listed on the Caldwell webpage. The homeowner would like to
remove the portion about a meeting room and the glass doors. The commission
felt this subject should be placed on the May 21 agenda for further discussion.
X. Meeting adjourned at approximately 7 :53 p.m.
Respectfully submitted by April Cabello,
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BELOW BY CHAIRPERSON CHUCK RANDOLPH
ON THE DATE NOTED BELOW.
Chairperson Randolph
Date
ATTEST: Brian Billingsley, P & Z Director Date
CHPC Meeting, April 23, 2012 Page 7