HomeMy WebLinkAbout3-21-1996 P&Z MINUTES . y .
� �
PLANNING AND ZONiNG DEPARTMENT
' The City of �aldwell
� � NANCY HUFF
Pianning & Zoning Director
621 CLEVELAND BLVD.
CALDWELL ID 83605
TELEPHONE 455-3021
♦ FAX 455-3003
Revised
MINUTES OF THE PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION
Meeting of March 21,1996
ROLL CALL:
Present: Madeline Buckendorf, Sonia Huyck, Bettie Pilote, William Roos, Mike Nachtigall,
and
Bill Gilbert
Absent: Ron Reed
Staff: Nancy Huff, Ed Christopher, Debra Pendleton and Gordon Law, City Engineer
The regular meeting of the Planning and Zoning Commission was called to order by Chairperson Betty
Pilote, at 7:15 p.m., in the Caldwell City Hall Council Chambers.
MINUTES:
The first item of business was approval of the minutes for the previous meeting of March 7, 1996.
A motion was made by Commissioner Buckendorf that the March 7, 1996, minutes be approved.
The motion was seconded by Commissioner Nachtigall.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: Madeline Buckendorf; Sonia Huyck, William Roos, Mike Nachtigall, Bill Gilbert
No: None
Motion passed.
PUBLIC H�ARINGS:
The public hearing portion of the agenda then followed. Chairperson Pilote explained the procedure
for public hearings.
OLD BUSINESS
The first item of Old Business was Case # 96-03--SUB/Rezone Baycrest Village. Chairperson Pilote
stated that this case would not be heard tonight. As it had b�en tabled until April 18, 1996.
MINUTES P&Z 3/21/96
Page 1
NEW BUSINESS
Chairperson Pilote suggested that the Commission consider hearing the second item on the agenda first
tonight.
A motion was made by Commissioner Huyck that Case #96-08-SUP be moved to first on the
agenda. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Nachtigall. The Chairperson called for a
voice vote. All commissioners voted "aye". The motion passed.
The first hearing was Case # 96-08-SUP-- A request to allow a mobile office to continue at Chica�o
Street and Twentv-first Avenue for the Idaho State Brand Office. The applicant was Gary Penny, a
representative of the Idaho Staxe Brand Office.
Ed Christopher presented the staff report. All legal requirements were met. The applicant requested a
new Special Use Permit for the operation of the State Brand Office. He stated that the Branding Office
had not had enough demand tc warrant a new permanent office. He reminded the Commissioners that
the original Special Use Permit was approved on April 1, 1993. One of the original conditions of that
permit was that the unit had to be removed within three years. Approval of this permit allowed the
applicant the option of extending their Special Use Permit to provide for this use as long as it is viable.
Staff had received no negative neighbor responses.
Commissioner Gilbert asked if the temporary unit was hooked into the city water and sewer. Mr.
Christopher stated that it was. Commissioner Gilbert inquired about the landscaping. Mr. Christopher
stated that landscaping was not a requirement of the original Special Use Permit. However, the applicant
was willing to do some landscaping if required to do so.
Commissioner Roos inquired about the length of time requested in the permit. Mr. Christopher related
that the applicant hoped to have a permanent building sometime in the future. The Special Use Permit
can be approved for an indefinite time or on an annual review. The annual review would be done by the
Planning and Zoning Director or by the-Plann.ing and Zoning Commission.
Gary Penny was representing the applicant. He gave his residence as 1102 E. Robinson, Nampa, Idaho.
He stated that right now it would be a hardship for the Brand office if they had to relocate. He further
stated that he would provide landscaping and be sure that the weeds and tall grass around the building
area were cut down.
Commissioner Huyck asked T�Ir. Penny if he would like to have the stipulation of a yearly review. He
stated that he would. It woulc: help the Brand Office keep their expenses down. '
Chairperson Pilote closed the public hearing. Discussion within the Commission ensued. Commissioner
Huyck stated that it was an appropriate use of the land.
MINUTES P8Z 3/21/96
Page 2
A motion was made by Commissioner Buckendorf that the Special Use Permit be approved. It
was seconded by Commissioner Huyck.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: Madeline Buckendorf, Soria Huyck, William Roos, Mike Nachtigall, Bill Gilbert
No: None
Motion passed.
Anyone interested in filing an appeal may contact the Planning and Zoning Department.
The second hearing was Case # 96 04 ANN A request to chan�e the Comprehensive Plan and to
chan�e the Zone in connection with the annexation reQUest further known as the Flvin� J Travel Plaza.
The applicant was CFJ Properties.
Nancy HufF presented the staff report. The applicant requested annexation of a 33.67 acre parcel and
a re-zone to C-4 for the entire area. The applicant proposed a Flying J Travel Plaza on 18.07 acres. The
remainder of the site did not have a submittal at this time.
N1r. Craig Call represented the applicant. He gave his residence as 2424 N. 4500 W., Plain City, Utah
8�404. Mr. Call shared a video with the Commission and the public present. The video gave an
overview in reference to the Flying J's and what they have to offer the community and the Caldwell area.
He stated that the Flying J Travel Plaza with its restaurant, convenience store and hoteUmotel would
provide several new jobs to the area. The aesthetics would be pleasing to the community. He stated that
they had found that by upgrading the facilities and landscaping the areas, their business increased. They
found that they catered to automobiles and RV's, as well as the �arger trucks. This increase in a variety
of travelers also brought increased business and revenues to the surrounding communities. He stated
thax they were community oriented and would work together to help support and promote the City of
Caldwell.
He stated to the Commission that the issue tonight was whether or not to annex the property and whether
or not it is appropriate for this use.
Commissioner Gilbert asked if the zoning request fit the needs of the applicant. The applicant would
prefer the total area be zoned C-4. However, he was agreeable to the difference in the zoning.
Chairperson Pilote clarified that this zone was an A� Overlay.
The first public speaker was Ms. Regina Broadbent. She gave her residence as 1606 Andy Lane. She
asked it the east border of the property line was a section line. Gordon Law, the City Engineer,
responded that it was. She also inquired about the possible building of a two lane road. Mr. Law
responded that the applicant will dedicate a right of way for it. She further asked if she would be
required to hook in to city services. Mr. Law responded that lines may be run for city services if
development occurs.
MINIJTES P&Z 3/21/96
Page 3
The second public speaker was Ms. Jean Huffecker. She gave her residence as 1321 Andy Lane. She
was concerned about the type of people that may stop there. She was also concerned about the 24 hour
service and the noise.
The third public speaker was Ms. Cazole Gillespie. She gave her residence as 1419 Andy Lane. She
expressed concem over Andy Lane finally being paved and she wanted to see some kind of assurance
of control over the truck traffic on the little road. She was also concerned about security at the truck
stop.
Mr. Gordon Law responded that they did not need to worry about Andy Lane. It was not part of the
development. The trucks would not be using it.
The fourth public speaker was Mr. Donald Lane. He gave his residence as 1218 Smith, Nampa, Idaho.
He owned a shop near the proposed development property that is to be annexed. He stated that he
received paperwork from staff that if he was interested in being annexed also that he should submit an
application. He is in favor of the development and wo�zld like to see his portion zoned for commercial
use too. The Commission informed him that since his property is in the county, he would have to apply
for annexation on his own behalf.
That concluded all of the public speakers. Chairperson Pilote asked Mr. Call if he would like to give
rebuttal. Mr. Ca11 stated in rebuttal that he thought the concern over Andy Lane was settled. In reference
to the types of customers, Mr. Call stated that they cannot control who stops and why. However, he said
that management will help to provide security . He said that management strives to provide safety and
security for it's employees and customers. They have never had a robbery at a Flying J Store. He stated
in reference to the noise level that studies have proved that most of the noise comes from the interstate.
This had been proven with decibel studies. Commissioner Nachtigall clarified for Ms. Huffaker that
from his drawing, it appeared to h im that the distance between the Flying J and Ms. Huffaker is farther
than the distance between her and the interstate. Therefore there should be no more noise. Mr. Call
further stated that the property being in the Airport Overlay was new to him. It was not in the staff
report. Therefore, he would have to take a look at that and report back to the Commission and City
Council at a later time.
Chairperson Pilote then closed the public hearings. Discussion from the Commission followed.
Commissioner Huyck inquired as to whether or not the city could handle the water and sewer. Mr. Law
responded that it could. Commissioner Gilbert stated that he felt this would be a good thing for
Caldwell. He suggested that the Commission recommend that the whole area be rezoned C-4. He felt
that this would better fill the needs of the applicant. Chairperson Pilote asked for an explanation from
staff. Ms. Huff replied staff based their recommenda� �on around the Comprehensive Plan and standard
zoning practices. The Commission did not agree with having several zones in this particular area, based
on the configuration of the property. Chairperson Pilote clarified to the Commissioners that they were
looking at two issues. The first being whether or not to annex the property . The second was what zone
to recommend to the City Council.
MINUTES P&Z 3/21/96
Page 4
.
Commissioner Roos made a motion that the property described under #96-01-ANN be
recommended to the City Council for annexation. Commissioner Nachtigall seconded it.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: William Roos, Mike Nachtigall, Bill Gilbert, Madeline Buckendorf, Sonia Huyck
No: None
Motion passed.
A motion was made by Commissioner Roos that the zoning of C-4AP be recommended to the City
Council in regards to the property described under #96-01-ANN. It was seconded by
Commissioner Nachtigall.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: William Roos, Mike Nachtigall, Bill Gilbert, Madeline Buckendorf, Sonia Huyck
No: None
Motion passed.
Anyone interested in filing an appeal may contact the Planning and Zoning Department.
Chairperson Pilote stated that this concluded the public hearing portion of the agenda.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 9:00 p.m.
MINUTES P8Z 3/21/96
Page 5